The 1886 Brooklyn Hills football team was an American football team that represented the Brooklyn Hill Football Club who had been playing football since at least the year prior,[ 1] [ 2] in the American Football Union during the 1886 football season . Coached and captained by William Halsey, notable halfback, captain, and secretary of the fledgling American Football Union, the Hills compiled a 3–5–3 (of games confirmed), and finished 0–1–2 in AFU play before resigning from the Union on November 16 due to a lack of league games scheduled for Saturday and an inability to complete the rest of their conference schedule.[ 3] The Brooklyn Hills were also not allowed to claim their forfeit win against the Unions of Columbia, as an AFU meeting on the same day confirmed. It is unclear whether or not Brooklyn Hill claimed a win on October 16 against the Crickets of Stevens Institute , with the referee deferring to the AFU, who either never resolved the issue or did so quietly.
Date Time Opponent Site Result Source October 10 Crickets of Stevens Institute * L 6–22[ 4]
October 15 Polytechnic Institute of Brooklyn * Parade Grounds, Prospect Park Brooklyn, NY T 0–0[ 5]
October 16 4:00 p.m. Crickets of Stevens Institute Parade Grounds, Prospect Park Brooklyn, NY L 6–8 (10–8 disputed)[ 6] [ 7]
October 23 Crescent Athletic Club * Crescent Athletic Club grounds Brooklyn, NY L 0–20[ 8] [ 9]
October 30 Staten Island Football Club T 6–6[ 10] [ 11] [ 12]
November 4 Polytechnic Institute of Brooklyn* W 28–0[ 13] [ 14]
November 6 Unions of Columbia * Crescent Athletic Club grounds Brooklyn, NY W (forfeit)[ 15]
November 6 3:40 p.m. Yale Freshmen * Crescent Athletic Club grounds Brooklyn, NY L 0–18[ 16]
November 11 at Hasbrouck Institute* W 14–0[ 17]
November 13 at Staten Island Football Club St. George Cricket Grounds Staten Island, NY T 0–0[ 18] [ 19] [ 20]
November 20 at Princeton Freshmen * Princeton, NJ L 11–66 or 11–68[ 21] [ 22] [ 23]
November 27 Amherst * Crescent Athletic Club grounds Brooklyn, NY Proposed [ 24] [ 25]
Yale Freshmen Proposed [ 26]
^ "Foot Ball on the Hill: A Lively Amateur Game Between the Brooklyns and Crescents" . The Brooklyn Daily Eagle . October 24, 1886. p. 1 – via Newspapers.com .
^ "A Foot Ball Game: The Crescent Athletic Club Whitewashes the Brooklyn Hills" . The Brooklyn Daily Eagle . October 24, 1886. p. 8 – via Newspapers.com .
^ "Sporting Notes" . The Brooklyn Union . November 18, 1886. p. 2. Retrieved August 11, 2020 .
^ "Two Football Games" . The New York Times . October 10, 1886. p. 7. Retrieved August 12, 2020 .
^ "City And Suburban News" . The New York Times . October 16, 1886. p. 8. Retrieved August 11, 2020 .
^ "Football Notes" . The Philadelphia Inquirer . October 18, 1886. p. 3. Retrieved August 11, 2020 .
^ "Football and Lacrosse" . The Brooklyn Daily Eagle . October 17, 1886. p. 3. Retrieved August 11, 2020 .
^ "Foot Ball on the Hill: A Lively Amateur Game Between the Brooklyns and Crescents" . The Brooklyn Daily Eagle . October 24, 1886. p. 1 – via Newspapers.com .
^ "A Foot Ball Game: The Crescent Athletic Club Whitewashes the Brooklyn Hills" . The Brooklyn Daily Eagle . October 24, 1886. p. 8 – via Newspapers.com .
^ "City and Suburban News" . The New York Times . October 30, 1886. p. 8. Retrieved August 11, 2020 .
^ "Kicking Football" . The New York Times . October 31, 1886. p. 14. Retrieved August 11, 2020 .
^ "Sports and Pastimes" . The Brooklyn Daily Eagle . October 31, 1886. p. 16. Retrieved August 11, 2020 .
^ "Football Notes" . The Brooklyn Daily Eagle . November 18, 1886. p. 1. Retrieved August 11, 2020 .
^ "Football" . The Brooklyn Union . November 5, 1886. p. 3. Retrieved August 11, 2020 .
^ "Football Notes" . The Brooklyn Daily Eagle . November 18, 1886. p. 1. Retrieved August 11, 2020 .
^ "Victors At Football" . The New York Times . November 7, 1886. p. 7. Retrieved August 11, 2020 .
^ "Football Notes" . The Brooklyn Daily Eagle . November 18, 1886. p. 1. Retrieved August 11, 2020 .
^ "Sporting Notes" . The Brooklyn Union . November 11, 1886. p. 7. Retrieved August 11, 2020 .
^ "Sporting Notes" . The Brooklyn Union . October 25, 1886. p. 2. Retrieved August 11, 2020 .
^ "Football On Staten Island" . The New York Times . November 14, 1886. p. 9. Retrieved August 11, 2020 .
^ "Football Notes" . The Brooklyn Daily Eagle . November 18, 1886. p. 1. Retrieved August 11, 2020 .
^ "The Brooklyn Hills Beaten" . The Brooklyn Daily Eagle . November 21, 1886. p. 16. Retrieved August 11, 2020 .
^ "Football at Princeton" . The Brooklyn Union . November 21, 1886. p. 8. Retrieved August 11, 2020 .
^ "Football Notes" . The Brooklyn Daily Eagle . November 18, 1886. p. 1. Retrieved August 11, 2020 .
^ "Sporting Notes" . The Brooklyn Union . November 24, 1886. p. 3. Retrieved August 11, 2020 .
^ "Football Notes" . The Brooklyn Daily Eagle . November 18, 1886. p. 1. Retrieved August 11, 2020 .