- Green indicates clinched playoff berth
- Purple indicates division champion
- Grey indicates best regular season record
| Quarterfinals
| | | Semifinals
| | | ArenaBowl XI
| |
| | | | | | | | | | | | | | |
| 1
| Arizona
| 46
| | | |
|
| 8
| Milwaukee
| 29
| |
| | 1
| Arizona (OT)
| 49
| |
|
| |
| | | 6
| Tampa Bay
| 46
| |
| 3
| Nashville
| 49
| |
| |
| 6
| Tampa Bay
| 52
| |
| | 1
| Arizona
| 55
| |
|
| |
| | | 2
| Iowa
| 33
| |
| 2
| Iowa
| 68
| | |
| |
| 7
| San Jose
| 59
| |
| | 2
| Iowa
| 52
| |
|
| |
| | | 4
| Orlando
| 34
| |
| 4
| Orlando
| 45
| |
| |
| 5
| New Jersey
| 37
| |
Source:[1]
Position
|
First team
|
Second team
|
Quarterback
|
Kurt Warner, Iowa
|
Sherdrick Bonner, Arizona
|
Fullback/Linebacker
|
Chad Dukes, Albany
|
Paul McGowan, Orlando
|
Wide receiver/Defensive back
|
Barry Wagner, Orlando Randy Gatewood, Arizona
|
Alvin Ashley, New Jersey Carlos James, Iowa
|
Wide receiver/Linebacker
|
Cory Fleming, Nashville
|
Hunkie Cooper, Arizona
|
Offensive specialist
|
Calvin Schexnayder, Arizona
|
Lamart Cooper, Iowa
|
Offensive lineman/Defensive lineman
|
Carlos Fowler, Texas James Baron, Nashville Willie Wyatt, Tampa Bay
|
Al Noga, San Jose Victor Hall, Orlando Robert Stewart, New Jersey
|
Defensive specialist
|
Tracey Perkins, Tampa Bay Chris Barber, Orlando
|
Rodney Mazion, Anaheim Jamie Coleman, Nashville
|
Kicker
|
Steve Videtich, New Jersey
|
Daron Alcorn, Portland
|