Inverse trigonometric functions

(Redirected from Arctan (trigonometry))

In mathematics, the inverse trigonometric functions (occasionally also called antitrigonometric,[1] cyclometric,[2] or arcus functions[3]) are the inverse functions of the trigonometric functions, under suitably restricted domains. Specifically, they are the inverses of the sine, cosine, tangent, cotangent, secant, and cosecant functions,[4] and are used to obtain an angle from any of the angle's trigonometric ratios. Inverse trigonometric functions are widely used in engineering, navigation, physics, and geometry.

Notation

edit
 
For a circle of radius 1, arcsin and arccos are the lengths of actual arcs determined by the quantities in question.

Several notations for the inverse trigonometric functions exist. The most common convention is to name inverse trigonometric functions using an arc- prefix: arcsin(x), arccos(x), arctan(x), etc.[1] (This convention is used throughout this article.) This notation arises from the following geometric relationships:[citation needed] when measuring in radians, an angle of θ radians will correspond to an arc whose length is , where r is the radius of the circle. Thus in the unit circle, the cosine of x function is both the arc and the angle, because the arc of a circle of radius 1 is the same as the angle. Or, "the arc whose cosine is x" is the same as "the angle whose cosine is x", because the length of the arc of the circle in radii is the same as the measurement of the angle in radians.[5] In computer programming languages, the inverse trigonometric functions are often called by the abbreviated forms asin, acos, atan.[6]

The notations sin−1(x), cos−1(x), tan−1(x), etc., as introduced by John Herschel in 1813,[7][8] are often used as well in English-language sources,[1] much more than the also established sin[−1](x), cos[−1](x), tan[−1](x) – conventions consistent with the notation of an inverse function, that is useful (for example) to define the multivalued version of each inverse trigonometric function:   However, this might appear to conflict logically with the common semantics for expressions such as sin2(x) (although only sin2 x, without parentheses, is the really common use), which refer to numeric power rather than function composition, and therefore may result in confusion between notation for the reciprocal (multiplicative inverse) and inverse function.[9]

The confusion is somewhat mitigated by the fact that each of the reciprocal trigonometric functions has its own name — for example, (cos(x))−1 = sec(x). Nevertheless, certain authors advise against using it, since it is ambiguous.[1][10] Another precarious convention used by a small number of authors is to use an uppercase first letter, along with a “−1” superscript: Sin−1(x), Cos−1(x), Tan−1(x), etc.[11] Although it is intended to avoid confusion with the reciprocal, which should be represented by sin−1(x), cos−1(x), etc., or, better, by sin−1 x, cos−1 x, etc., it in turn creates yet another major source of ambiguity, especially since many popular high-level programming languages (e.g. Mathematica and MAGMA) use those very same capitalised representations for the standard trig functions, whereas others (Python, SymPy, NumPy, Matlab, MAPLE, etc.) use lower-case.

Hence, since 2009, the ISO 80000-2 standard has specified solely the "arc" prefix for the inverse functions.

Basic concepts

edit
 
The points labelled 1, Sec(θ), Csc(θ) represent the length of the line segment from the origin to that point. Sin(θ), Tan(θ), and 1 are the heights to the line starting from the x-axis, while Cos(θ), 1, and Cot(θ) are lengths along the x-axis starting from the origin.

Principal values

edit

Since none of the six trigonometric functions are one-to-one, they must be restricted in order to have inverse functions. Therefore, the result ranges of the inverse functions are proper (i.e. strict) subsets of the domains of the original functions.

For example, using function in the sense of multivalued functions, just as the square root function   could be defined from   the function   is defined so that   For a given real number   with   there are multiple (in fact, countably infinitely many) numbers   such that  ; for example,   but also     etc. When only one value is desired, the function may be restricted to its principal branch. With this restriction, for each   in the domain, the expression   will evaluate only to a single value, called its principal value. These properties apply to all the inverse trigonometric functions.

The principal inverses are listed in the following table.

Name Usual notation Definition Domain of   for real result Range of usual principal value
(radians)
Range of usual principal value
(degrees)
arcsine   x = sin(y)      
arccosine   x = cos(y)      
arctangent   x = tan(y) all real numbers    
arccotangent   x = cot(y) all real numbers    
arcsecant   x = sec(y)      
arccosecant   x = csc(y)      

Note: Some authors [citation needed] define the range of arcsecant to be  , because the tangent function is nonnegative on this domain. This makes some computations more consistent. For example, using this range,   whereas with the range  , we would have to write   since tangent is nonnegative on   but nonpositive on   For a similar reason, the same authors define the range of arccosecant to be   or  

Domains

edit

If   is allowed to be a complex number, then the range of   applies only to its real part.

The table below displays names and domains of the inverse trigonometric functions along with the range of their usual principal values in radians.

Name
Symbol Domain Image/Range Inverse
function
Domain Image of
principal values
sine                    
cosine                    
tangent                    
cotangent                    
secant                    
cosecant                    

The symbol   denotes the set of all real numbers and   denotes the set of all integers. The set of all integer multiples of   is denoted by

 

The symbol   denotes set subtraction so that, for instance,   is the set of points in   (that is, real numbers) that are not in the interval  

The Minkowski sum notation   and   that is used above to concisely write the domains of   is now explained.

Domain of cotangent   and cosecant  : The domains of   and   are the same. They are the set of all angles   at which   i.e. all real numbers that are not of the form   for some integer  

 

Domain of tangent   and secant  : The domains of   and   are the same. They are the set of all angles   at which  

 

Solutions to elementary trigonometric equations

edit

Each of the trigonometric functions is periodic in the real part of its argument, running through all its values twice in each interval of  

  • Sine and cosecant begin their period at   (where   is an integer), finish it at   and then reverse themselves over   to  
  • Cosine and secant begin their period at   finish it at   and then reverse themselves over   to  
  • Tangent begins its period at   finishes it at   and then repeats it (forward) over   to  
  • Cotangent begins its period at   finishes it at   and then repeats it (forward) over   to  

This periodicity is reflected in the general inverses, where   is some integer.

The following table shows how inverse trigonometric functions may be used to solve equalities involving the six standard trigonometric functions. It is assumed that the given values         and   all lie within appropriate ranges so that the relevant expressions below are well-defined. Note that "for some  " is just another way of saying "for some integer  "

The symbol   is logical equality and indicates that if the left hand side is true then so is the right hand side and, conversely, if the right hand side is true then so is the left hand side (see this footnote[note 1] for more details and an example illustrating this concept).

Equation if and only if Solution
              for some  
              for some  
                for some  
                for some  
            for some  
            for some  

where the first four solutions can be written in expanded form as:

Equation if and only if Solution
     
          or
 
for some  
     
          or
 
for some  
     
         or
 
for some  
     
         or
 
for some  

For example, if   then   for some   While if   then   for some   where   will be even if   and it will be odd if   The equations   and   have the same solutions as   and   respectively. In all equations above except for those just solved (i.e. except for  /  and  / ), the integer   in the solution's formula is uniquely determined by   (for fixed   and  ).

With the help of integer parity   it is possible to write a solution to   that doesn't involve the "plus or minus"   symbol:

  if and only if   for some  

And similarly for the secant function,

  if and only if   for some  

where   equals   when the integer   is even, and equals   when it's odd.

Detailed example and explanation of the "plus or minus" symbol ±

edit

The solutions to   and   involve the "plus or minus" symbol   whose meaning is now clarified. Only the solution to   will be discussed since the discussion for   is the same. We are given   between   and we know that there is an angle   in some interval that satisfies   We want to find this   The table above indicates that the solution is   which is a shorthand way of saying that (at least) one of the following statement is true:

  1.   for some integer  
    or
  2.   for some integer  

As mentioned above, if   (which by definition only happens when  ) then both statements (1) and (2) hold, although with different values for the integer  : if   is the integer from statement (1), meaning that   holds, then the integer   for statement (2) is   (because  ). However, if   then the integer   is unique and completely determined by   If   (which by definition only happens when  ) then   (because   and   so in both cases   is equal to  ) and so the statements (1) and (2) happen to be identical in this particular case (and so both hold). Having considered the cases   and   we now focus on the case where   and   So assume this from now on. The solution to   is still   which as before is shorthand for saying that one of statements (1) and (2) is true. However this time, because   and   statements (1) and (2) are different and furthermore, exactly one of the two equalities holds (not both). Additional information about   is needed to determine which one holds. For example, suppose that   and that all that is known about   is that   (and nothing more is known). Then   and moreover, in this particular case   (for both the   case and the   case) and so consequently,   This means that   could be either   or   Without additional information it is not possible to determine which of these values   has. An example of some additional information that could determine the value of   would be knowing that the angle is above the  -axis (in which case  ) or alternatively, knowing that it is below the  -axis (in which case  ).

Equal identical trigonometric functions

edit

The table below shows how two angles   and   must be related if their values under a given trigonometric function are equal or negatives of each other.

Equation if and only if Solution (for some  ) Also a solution to
       
       
       
       
       
       
       

The vertical double arrow   in the last row indicates that   and   satisfy   if and only if they satisfy  

Set of all solutions to elementary trigonometric equations

Thus given a single solution   to an elementary trigonometric equation (  is such an equation, for instance, and because   always holds,   is always a solution), the set of all solutions to it are:

If   solves then Set of all solutions (in terms of  )
  then              
  then              
  then            
  then            
  then        
  then        

Transforming equations

edit

The equations above can be transformed by using the reflection and shift identities:[12]

Transforming equations by shifts and reflections
Argument:            
 
           
           
           
           
           
           

These formulas imply, in particular, that the following hold:

 

where swapping   swapping   and swapping   gives the analogous equations for   respectively.

So for example, by using the equality   the equation   can be transformed into   which allows for the solution to the equation   (where  ) to be used; that solution being:   which becomes:   where using the fact that   and substituting   proves that another solution to   is:   The substitution   may be used express the right hand side of the above formula in terms of   instead of  

Relationships between trigonometric functions and inverse trigonometric functions

edit

Trigonometric functions of inverse trigonometric functions are tabulated below. A quick way to derive them is by considering the geometry of a right-angled triangle, with one side of length 1 and another side of length   then applying the Pythagorean theorem and definitions of the trigonometric ratios. It is worth noting that for arcsecant and arccosecant, the diagram assumes that   is positive, and thus the result has to be corrected through the use of absolute values and the signum (sgn) operation.

        Diagram
         
         
         
         
         
         

Relationships among the inverse trigonometric functions

edit
 
The usual principal values of the arcsin(x) (red) and arccos(x) (blue) functions graphed on the cartesian plane.
 
The usual principal values of the arctan(x) and arccot(x) functions graphed on the cartesian plane.
 
Principal values of the arcsec(x) and arccsc(x) functions graphed on the cartesian plane.

Complementary angles:

 

Negative arguments:

 

Reciprocal arguments:

 

The identities above can be used with (and derived from) the fact that   and   are reciprocals (i.e.  ), as are   and   and   and  

Useful identities if one only has a fragment of a sine table:

 

Whenever the square root of a complex number is used here, we choose the root with the positive real part (or positive imaginary part if the square was negative real).

A useful form that follows directly from the table above is

 .

It is obtained by recognizing that  .

From the half-angle formula,  , we get:

 

Arctangent addition formula

edit
 

This is derived from the tangent addition formula

 

by letting

 

In calculus

edit

Derivatives of inverse trigonometric functions

edit

The derivatives for complex values of z are as follows:

 

Only for real values of x:

 

These formulas can be derived in terms of the derivatives of trigonometric functions. For example, if  , then   so

 

Expression as definite integrals

edit

Integrating the derivative and fixing the value at one point gives an expression for the inverse trigonometric function as a definite integral:

 

When x equals 1, the integrals with limited domains are improper integrals, but still well-defined.

Infinite series

edit

Similar to the sine and cosine functions, the inverse trigonometric functions can also be calculated using power series, as follows. For arcsine, the series can be derived by expanding its derivative,  , as a binomial series, and integrating term by term (using the integral definition as above). The series for arctangent can similarly be derived by expanding its derivative   in a geometric series, and applying the integral definition above (see Leibniz series).

 
 

Series for the other inverse trigonometric functions can be given in terms of these according to the relationships given above. For example,  ,  , and so on. Another series is given by:[13]

 

Leonhard Euler found a series for the arctangent that converges more quickly than its Taylor series:

 [14]

(The term in the sum for n = 0 is the empty product, so is 1.)

Alternatively, this can be expressed as

 

Another series for the arctangent function is given by

 

where   is the imaginary unit.[15]

Continued fractions for arctangent

edit

Two alternatives to the power series for arctangent are these generalized continued fractions:

 

The second of these is valid in the cut complex plane. There are two cuts, from −i to the point at infinity, going down the imaginary axis, and from i to the point at infinity, going up the same axis. It works best for real numbers running from −1 to 1. The partial denominators are the odd natural numbers, and the partial numerators (after the first) are just (nz)2, with each perfect square appearing once. The first was developed by Leonhard Euler; the second by Carl Friedrich Gauss utilizing the Gaussian hypergeometric series.

Indefinite integrals of inverse trigonometric functions

edit

For real and complex values of z:

 

For real x ≥ 1:

 

For all real x not between -1 and 1:

 

The absolute value is necessary to compensate for both negative and positive values of the arcsecant and arccosecant functions. The signum function is also necessary due to the absolute values in the derivatives of the two functions, which create two different solutions for positive and negative values of x. These can be further simplified using the logarithmic definitions of the inverse hyperbolic functions:

 

The absolute value in the argument of the arcosh function creates a negative half of its graph, making it identical to the signum logarithmic function shown above.

All of these antiderivatives can be derived using integration by parts and the simple derivative forms shown above.

Example

edit

Using   (i.e. integration by parts), set

 

Then

 

which by the simple substitution   yields the final result:

 

Extension to the complex plane

edit
 
A Riemann surface for the argument of the relation tan z = x. The orange sheet in the middle is the principal sheet representing arctan x. The blue sheet above and green sheet below are displaced by 2π and −2π respectively.

Since the inverse trigonometric functions are analytic functions, they can be extended from the real line to the complex plane. This results in functions with multiple sheets and branch points. One possible way of defining the extension is:

 

where the part of the imaginary axis which does not lie strictly between the branch points (−i and +i) is the branch cut between the principal sheet and other sheets. The path of the integral must not cross a branch cut. For z not on a branch cut, a straight line path from 0 to z is such a path. For z on a branch cut, the path must approach from Re[x] > 0 for the upper branch cut and from Re[x] < 0 for the lower branch cut.

The arcsine function may then be defined as:

 

where (the square-root function has its cut along the negative real axis and) the part of the real axis which does not lie strictly between −1 and +1 is the branch cut between the principal sheet of arcsin and other sheets;

 

which has the same cut as arcsin;

 

which has the same cut as arctan;

 

where the part of the real axis between −1 and +1 inclusive is the cut between the principal sheet of arcsec and other sheets;

 

which has the same cut as arcsec.

Logarithmic forms

edit

These functions may also be expressed using complex logarithms. This extends their domains to the complex plane in a natural fashion. The following identities for principal values of the functions hold everywhere that they are defined, even on their branch cuts.

 

Generalization

edit

Because all of the inverse trigonometric functions output an angle of a right triangle, they can be generalized by using Euler's formula to form a right triangle in the complex plane. Algebraically, this gives us:

 

or

 

where   is the adjacent side,   is the opposite side, and   is the hypotenuse. From here, we can solve for  .

 

or

 

Simply taking the imaginary part works for any real-valued   and  , but if   or   is complex-valued, we have to use the final equation so that the real part of the result isn't excluded. Since the length of the hypotenuse doesn't change the angle, ignoring the real part of   also removes   from the equation. In the final equation, we see that the angle of the triangle in the complex plane can be found by inputting the lengths of each side. By setting one of the three sides equal to 1 and one of the remaining sides equal to our input  , we obtain a formula for one of the inverse trig functions, for a total of six equations. Because the inverse trig functions require only one input, we must put the final side of the triangle in terms of the other two using the Pythagorean Theorem relation

 

The table below shows the values of a, b, and c for each of the inverse trig functions and the equivalent expressions for   that result from plugging the values into the equations   above and simplifying.

 

The particular form of the simplified expression can cause the output to differ from the usual principal branch of each of the inverse trig functions. The formulations given will output the usual principal branch when using the   and   principal branch for every function except arccotangent in the   column. Arccotangent in the   column will output on its usual principal branch by using the   and   convention.

In this sense, all of the inverse trig functions can be thought of as specific cases of the complex-valued log function. Since these definition work for any complex-valued  , the definitions allow for hyperbolic angles as outputs and can be used to further define the inverse hyperbolic functions. It's possible to algebraically prove these relations by starting with the exponential forms of the trigonometric functions and solving for the inverse function.

Example proof

edit
 

Using the exponential definition of sine[broken anchor], and letting  

 

(the positive branch is chosen)

 
Color wheel graphs of inverse trigonometric functions in the complex plane
     
     
     
     

Applications

edit

Finding the angle of a right triangle

edit
 
A right triangle with sides relative to an angle at the   point.

Inverse trigonometric functions are useful when trying to determine the remaining two angles of a right triangle when the lengths of the sides of the triangle are known. Recalling the right-triangle definitions of sine and cosine, it follows that

 

Often, the hypotenuse is unknown and would need to be calculated before using arcsine or arccosine using the Pythagorean Theorem:   where   is the length of the hypotenuse. Arctangent comes in handy in this situation, as the length of the hypotenuse is not needed.

 

For example, suppose a roof drops 8 feet as it runs out 20 feet. The roof makes an angle θ with the horizontal, where θ may be computed as follows:

 

In computer science and engineering

edit

Two-argument variant of arctangent

edit

The two-argument atan2 function computes the arctangent of y / x given y and x, but with a range of (−ππ]. In other words, atan2(yx) is the angle between the positive x-axis of a plane and the point (xy) on it, with positive sign for counter-clockwise angles (upper half-plane, y > 0), and negative sign for clockwise angles (lower half-plane, y < 0). It was first introduced in many computer programming languages, but it is now also common in other fields of science and engineering.

In terms of the standard arctan function, that is with range of (−π/2, π/2), it can be expressed as follows:

 

It also equals the principal value of the argument of the complex number x + iy.

This limited version of the function above may also be defined using the tangent half-angle formulae as follows:

 

provided that either x > 0 or y ≠ 0. However this fails if given x ≤ 0 and y = 0 so the expression is unsuitable for computational use.

The above argument order (y, x) seems to be the most common, and in particular is used in ISO standards such as the C programming language, but a few authors may use the opposite convention (x, y) so some caution is warranted. These variations are detailed at atan2.

Arctangent function with location parameter

edit

In many applications[16] the solution   of the equation   is to come as close as possible to a given value  . The adequate solution is produced by the parameter modified arctangent function

 

The function   rounds to the nearest integer.

Numerical accuracy

edit

For angles near 0 and π, arccosine is ill-conditioned, and similarly with arcsine for angles near −π/2 and π/2. Computer applications thus need to consider the stability of inputs to these functions and the sensitivity of their calculations, or use alternate methods.[17]

See also

edit

Notes

edit
  1. ^ The expression "LHS   RHS" indicates that either (a) the left hand side (i.e. LHS) and right hand side (i.e. RHS) are both true, or else (b) the left hand side and right hand side are both false; there is no option (c) (e.g. it is not possible for the LHS statement to be true and also simultaneously for the RHS statement to be false), because otherwise "LHS   RHS" would not have been written.
    To clarify, suppose that it is written "LHS   RHS" where LHS (which abbreviates left hand side) and RHS are both statements that can individually be either be true or false. For example, if   and   are some given and fixed numbers and if the following is written:   then LHS is the statement " ". Depending on what specific values   and   have, this LHS statement can either be true or false. For instance, LHS is true if   and   (because in this case  ) but LHS is false if   and   (because in this case   which is not equal to  ); more generally, LHS is false if   and   Similarly, RHS is the statement "  for some  ". The RHS statement can also either true or false (as before, whether the RHS statement is true or false depends on what specific values   and   have). The logical equality symbol   means that (a) if the LHS statement is true then the RHS statement is also necessarily true, and moreover (b) if the LHS statement is false then the RHS statement is also necessarily false. Similarly,   also means that (c) if the RHS statement is true then the LHS statement is also necessarily true, and moreover (d) if the RHS statement is false then the LHS statement is also necessarily false.

References

edit
  • Abramowitz, Milton; Stegun, Irene A., eds. (1972). Handbook of Mathematical Functions with Formulas, Graphs, and Mathematical Tables. New York: Dover Publications. ISBN 978-0-486-61272-0.
  1. ^ a b c d Hall, Arthur Graham; Frink, Fred Goodrich (Jan 1909). "Chapter II. The Acute Angle [14] Inverse trigonometric functions". Written at Ann Arbor, Michigan, USA. Trigonometry. Vol. Part I: Plane Trigonometry. New York, USA: Henry Holt and Company / Norwood Press / J. S. Cushing Co. - Berwick & Smith Co., Norwood, Massachusetts, USA. p. 15. Retrieved 2017-08-12. […] α = arcsin m: It is frequently read "arc-sine m" or "anti-sine m," since two mutually inverse functions are said each to be the anti-function of the other. […] A similar symbolic relation holds for the other trigonometric functions. […] This notation is universally used in Europe and is fast gaining ground in this country. A less desirable symbol, α = sin-1m, is still found in English and American texts. The notation α = inv sin m is perhaps better still on account of its general applicability. […]
  2. ^ Klein, Felix (1924) [1902]. Elementarmathematik vom höheren Standpunkt aus: Arithmetik, Algebra, Analysis (in German). Vol. 1 (3rd ed.). Berlin: J. Springer. Translated as Elementary Mathematics from an Advanced Standpoint: Arithmetic, Algebra, Analysis. Translated by Hedrick, E. R.; Noble, C. A. Macmillan. 1932. ISBN 978-0-486-43480-3.
  3. ^ Hazewinkel, Michiel (1994) [1987]. Encyclopaedia of Mathematics (unabridged reprint ed.). Kluwer Academic Publishers / Springer Science & Business Media. ISBN 978-155608010-4.
    Bronshtein, I. N.; Semendyayev, K. A.; Musiol, Gerhard; Mühlig, Heiner. "Cyclometric or Inverse Trigonometric Functions". Handbook of Mathematics (6th ed.). Berlin: Springer. § 2.8, pp. 85–89. doi:10.1007/978-3-663-46221-8 (inactive 1 Nov 2024).{{cite book}}: CS1 maint: DOI inactive as of November 2024 (link)
    However, the term "arcus function" can also refer to the function giving the argument of a complex number, sometimes called the arcus.
  4. ^ Weisstein, Eric W. "Inverse Trigonometric Functions". mathworld.wolfram.com. Retrieved 2020-08-29.
  5. ^ Beach, Frederick Converse; Rines, George Edwin, eds. (1912). "Inverse trigonometric functions". The Americana: a universal reference library. Vol. 21.
  6. ^ Cook, John D. (11 Feb 2021). "Trig functions across programming languages". johndcook.com (blog). Retrieved 2021-03-10.
  7. ^ Cajori, Florian (1919). A History of Mathematics (2 ed.). New York, NY: The Macmillan Company. p. 272.
  8. ^ Herschel, John Frederick William (1813). "On a remarkable Application of Cotes's Theorem". Philosophical Transactions. 103 (1). Royal Society, London: 8. doi:10.1098/rstl.1813.0005.
  9. ^ "Inverse trigonometric functions". Wiki. Brilliant Math & Science (brilliant.org). Retrieved 2020-08-29.
  10. ^ Korn, Grandino Arthur; Korn, Theresa M. (2000) [1961]. "21.2.-4. Inverse Trigonometric Functions". Mathematical handbook for scientists and engineers: Definitions, theorems, and formulars for reference and review (3 ed.). Mineola, New York, USA: Dover Publications, Inc. p. 811. ISBN 978-0-486-41147-7.
  11. ^ Bhatti, Sanaullah; Nawab-ud-Din; Ahmed, Bashir; Yousuf, S. M.; Taheem, Allah Bukhsh (1999). "Differentiation of Trigonometric, Logarithmic and Exponential Functions". In Ellahi, Mohammad Maqbool; Dar, Karamat Hussain; Hussain, Faheem (eds.). Calculus and Analytic Geometry (1 ed.). Lahore: Punjab Textbook Board. p. 140.
  12. ^ Abramowitz & Stegun 1972, p. 73, 4.3.44
  13. ^ Borwein, Jonathan; Bailey, David; Gingersohn, Roland (2004). Experimentation in Mathematics: Computational Paths to Discovery (1 ed.). Wellesley, MA, USA: A. K. Peters. p. 51. ISBN 978-1-56881-136-9.
  14. ^ Hwang Chien-Lih (2005), "An elementary derivation of Euler's series for the arctangent function", The Mathematical Gazette, 89 (516): 469–470, doi:10.1017/S0025557200178404, S2CID 123395287
  15. ^ S. M. Abrarov and B. M. Quine (2018), "A formula for pi involving nested radicals", The Ramanujan Journal, 46 (3): 657–665, arXiv:1610.07713, doi:10.1007/s11139-018-9996-8, S2CID 119150623
  16. ^ when a time varying angle crossing   should be mapped by a smooth line instead of a saw toothed one (robotics, astromomy, angular movement in general)[citation needed]
  17. ^ Gade, Kenneth (2010). "A non-singular horizontal position representation" (PDF). The Journal of Navigation. 63 (3). Cambridge University Press: 395–417. Bibcode:2010JNav...63..395G. doi:10.1017/S0373463309990415.
edit