Jesse Steven Koochin (April 15, 1998 – November 19, 2004)[1] was a 6-year-old American boy who became the center of a legal battle between his parents, Steve and Gayle Koochin, and Primary Children's Medical Center in Salt Lake City.
Biography
editJesse Koochin was born in Dunedin, Florida[1] the youngest of four children born to Steve and Gayle Koochin, and resided in Clearwater. His parents were Scientologists. His mother worked as a graphic designer and his father as an engineer.[2]
Cancer diagnosis and treatment
editShortly after his sixth birthday, Jesse was diagnosed with an "inoperable and incurable" brain tumor— medulloblastoma with metastasis to the brain and spine—on April 19, 2004.[3] His parents sought holistic treatment in three states, including Georgia, where they agreed to try standard radiation treatment as his condition worsened. However, Jesse's condition was determined to be too advanced for radiation or chemotherapy, so his parents took him to another alternative clinic in Mexico for treatment. His parents claimed he improved in Mexico from the alternative treatment. The Mexican treatment included "injecting him with live cells from the embryo of a blue shark and placing an ointment on his head, which his father described as killing and pulling out the tumors."[4][2]
The Koochins then sought more holistic treatment at the Modern Health Clinic in Bountiful, Utah, but the clinic determined he was too ill for treatment. On September 15, 2004, Jesse developed respiratory problems and was taken to Primary Children's Medical Center in Salt Lake City and placed on a ventilator.[2] On October 8, "his tumor pushed his brain stem down through his skull," and he was in an unresponsive coma. Subsequently, two physicians independently examined him on October 11 and 12 and determined that the child was brain dead. The hospital informed his parents that they would order life support removed within 24 hours.[3]
Legal fight
editHowever, the Koochins rejected the hospital's definition of death. Instead, relying on traditional notions of cardiopulmonary death, they filed for an immediate restraining order to keep Koochin on a ventilator and to receive other treatment. They declared that he had been in a "similar coma" from May 23, 2004 to July 11, 2004 and had successfully awakened, and also claimed that the hospital staff did not perform an EEG exam or cerebral perfusion study to test for brain activity. The Utah judge granted the restraining order on October 13 and ruled that the hospital would not be allowed to declare him brain dead without performing the two tests.[3]
On October 15, the parents removed the brain-dead child from the hospital and put him under hospice care at their temporary home in Salt Lake City.[2][5] Koochin's heart ultimately stopped beating on November 19, 2004.[6]
The landmark case was the first documented instance in the United States in which parents attempted to opt out of legally accepted standards of death.[7]
See also
editReferences
edit- ^ a b Social Security Death Index, 1935-2014. Social Security Administration.
- ^ a b c d Hamilton, Casey (October 15, 2004). "Brain-dead 6-year-old may be transferred to hospice care today". The Salt Lake Tribune. Archived from the original on 18 January 2014. Retrieved August 4, 2017.
- ^ a b c "Ex parte temporary restraining order, in re Jesse Steven Koochin" (PDF). Third District Court of Utah. October 13, 2004. Retrieved August 4, 2017.
- ^ "Jesse Koochin Passes Away". KSL. Associated Press. November 19, 2004. Retrieved August 4, 2017.
- ^ Appel, Jacob M. (2005). "Defining Death: When Physicians and Families Differ". Journal of Medical Ethics. 31 (11): 641–2, discussion 642–4. doi:10.1136/jme.2005.011718. PMC 1734056. PMID 16269560.
- ^ Collins, Lois M.; Thomson, Linda (2004-11-19). "Jesse loses his battle with brain tumor". Deseret News. Archived from the original on December 8, 2008.
- ^ Belluck, Pam (2005-03-27). "Even as Doctors Say Enough, Families Fight to Prolong Life". The New York Times.