Khlysts

The Khlysts or Khlysty (Russian: Хлысты, IPA: [xlɨˈstɨ], lit. "whips") were an underground Spiritual Christian sect which emerged in Russia in the 17th century.

The sect is traditionally said to have been founded in 1645 by Danilo Filippovich, although there is no written evidence to support this claim. The beliefs and practices of its members included ecstatic rituals, worship of charismatic leaders, and a rejection of the priesthood and holy books. They believed in direct communication with the Holy Spirit and practiced the ritual of radenie [ru] ("rejoicing"), which was characterized by dancing, speaking in tongues, and prophesying.

Throughout their history, the Khlysts were pursued by accusations of sexual immorality and faced persecution from other religious groups and from the government. In the 18th century, doctrinal changes led to schisms, and by the 1970s, only a few isolated groups remained. The Khlysts had a significant influence on other Russian sectarian movements, such as the Skoptsy, Dukhobors and Molokans. Russian mystic Grigori Rasputin was associated with the Khlysts in popular rumor, but the consensus among historians is that he was not a member of the sect.

Name

The members of the sect referred to themselves by various names, including "God's People" (liudi bozh'i), "followers of Christ's faith" (Khristovovery),^[1] or simply "Christs" (Khristy).^[2] The appellation "Khlysty" is a derogatory term applied by critics of the sect. The origin of the term is disputed. It is probably a corruption of the group's aforementioned self-designation of Khristy, but may also allude to the sect's practice of ritual self-flagellation; the Russian word khlyst means a "whip" or "thin rod".^[1]^[3]

It is also possible that the word is related to the Greek word khiliaste (meaning "chiliast" or "millennialist").^[4]

Origins

According to its own oral tradition, the sect was founded in 1645 by Danilo Filippov (or Daniil Filippovich), a peasant of Kostroma and a runaway soldier. He was said to have become a "living god" after the Lord of Hosts descended upon him on Gorodino Hill, Vladimir Oblast. He delivered twelve commandments to his disciples, which forbade (among other things) sexual intercourse, drinking and swearing. He later named as his successor Ivan Suslov, a peasant of Murom. Suslov, transformed by Filippov into a "new Christ", acquired a following of twelve apostles, along with a woman who was given the title of "Mother of God". The tradition relates that Suslov was crucified twice by the Russian authorities, but rose from the dead each time.^[1]^[5]^[6]

There is no written evidence to support this story, or to confirm the existence of Filippov. The first historical references to the Khlysty are found in the writings of the Old Believers, a Christian community which resisted the 17th-century reforms of the Russian State Church. The Old Believers condemned the Khlysty as heretics, and warnings about them can be found in letters dating from around the 1670s. The Orthodox Church also attacked the Khlysty; Dimitry of Rostov wrote against them in An Investigation of the Schismatic Faith (c. 1709).^[7]

Suslov died around 1716, at which time Prokofii Lupkin became the new "Christ". The oral tradition claims that Lupkin was the son of Filippov, but this is unlikely to be true.^[8]

Lupkin was a trader, and made use of his frequent journeys to places such as Uglich and Venev to organise secret assemblies for his followers. He encouraged his followers to worship in the manner of the Old Believers, such as by making the sign of the cross with two fingers instead of three,^[9] but he also instructed them to attend the State Church and take communion. Many Khlysty, including Lupkin's wife and son, even took monastic vows. Lupkin also made large donations to the Church, which helped to protect the sect from persecution.^[10]

Beliefs and practices

The Khlysty renounced priesthood, holy books and veneration of the saints (excluding the Theotokos). They believed in the possibility of direct communication with the Holy Spirit and of its embodiment in living people.^[5] Each of their leaders was a "living god", and each congregation (or "ark") had its own "Christ" and "Mother of God", appointed by the overall leader of the sect.^[3]^[11] Furthermore, they believed that the Holy Spirit could descend upon any one of them during the state of ecstasy which they attained during the ritual of radenie ("rejoicing").

This ritual, which formed the focus of their worship, took place on holy feast days. The congregation would gather during the evening at a prearranged location, such as a member's house. They would remove their outer clothing, and enter the sacred space dressed only in an undershirt. After a period of singing or chanting the Jesus Prayer ("Lord Jesus Christ, Son of God, have mercy on me, a sinner"), some of the worshippers would feel the Holy Spirit come upon them, and would begin dancing wildly, prophesying in unintelligible language. This would continue for half an hour or more, until the dancers collapsed with exhaustion. Finally, they would share a sacramental meal of nuts, bread, pastry and kvass.^[12]

The Khlysty practiced an extreme asceticism, in order to prepare themselves for the reception of the Holy Spirit into their bodies. They abstained from alcohol, and often fasted for days or weeks at a time. Although marriage was permitted for practical purposes, "because the help of a wife was indispensable for a peasant", it was a sin to engage in sexual intercourse, even with one's own wife.^[13] Connected with this mortification of the flesh was the practice of self-flagellation which often accompanied the radenie rite.

Russian author Edvard Radzinsky has described a radenie ritual which he witnessed on the island of Chechen in 1964:^[14]

In white flaxen shirts worn over naked bodies they went down into the cellar of a peasant lodge. There in the dry cellar they lit candles. They started to sing something sacred in the half-light – as was later explained, a verse from the Easter canon: "Seeing, we are gladdened, for Christ has risen." After that a little old man with joyful, light-coloured eyes – the local Christ – began to chant a Khlyst prayer in the flickering candlelight. And then with youthful energy he started to "rejoice", that is, to whirl wildly in place, crossing himself and continually whipping his body. The choir chanted prayers, their voices ever more savagely, ever more fervently and passionately praying, so that some of them were already screaming and sobbing. But at this point the old man stopped in his whirling and cried out wildly, "Brothers! Brothers! I feel it, the Holy Spirit! God is within me!" And he began to prophesy, shouting out incoherent sounds mixed into which were the words, "Oh, Spirit!" "Oh, God!" "Oh, Spirit Lord!" After that began the main communal rite of "rejoicing", or general whirling and dancing.

Radzinsky says that they referred to the whirling dance as "spiritual beer", on account of its intoxicating effect. He reports that after the dance had continued for some time, the worshippers fell to the floor: "And that was the end of it. But apparently only because I was present."^[14] Radzinsky claims that in some arks, the Khlysts would at this point engage in "group sinning" – a frenzied sexual orgy, which they believed would purify them from the lusts of the flesh.^[15] Similarly, C. L. Sulzberger, in his book The Fall of Eagles, writes that the Khlysty's "foremost idea was that salvation could be attained only by total repentance and that this became far more achievable for one who had truly transgressed. 'Sin in order that you may obtain forgiveness,' was the practical side of the Khlysty."^[16]

Other scholars have dismissed these rumours. Frederick Cornwallis Conybeare, referencing a study by Karl Konrad Grass, writes:^[17]

[The Khlysty] have been accused of ending their radenia or religious dances with wholesale debauchery, the lights being first put out. Grass examines the evidence very carefully and impartially, and rejects the story as calumny. The only thing that gives it colour is that often, when the ecstasies are over, the exhausted votaries drop down on the floor and sleep till dawn, the men on one side of the apartment, the women on the other. Their doing so, instead of going home at once, is a necessity dictated either by the climate or by fear of the Russian police, whose suspicions would be roused if they trooped home at a late hour.

Historian Joseph T. Fuhrmann claims that "splinter groups practiced 'holy intercourse,' but most khlysty were devout pentecostalists who condemned such behaviour."^[18]

Persecution

Accusations of sexual immorality pursued the sect from its earliest days, and provoked numerous government investigations.^[19]

In 1717, Lupkin and twenty other Khlysty were arrested in Uglich. They were held for five months, during which time they were interrogated and beaten. While some of his followers remained in custody, Lupkin managed to negotiate his own release, with the help of a 300-ruble bribe.^[20] Despite officially repenting, he continued to lead the movement until his death in 1732.^[21]

From 1733 to 1739, a specially-formed government commission arrested hundreds of suspected Khlyst members, charging them with participation in sexual orgies and ritual infanticide. These accusations were repeatedly denied, but the commission nevertheless convicted over three hundred people. They handed out sentences of hard labour, beatings, and mutilation of the nostrils and the tongue, and sent many of the prisoners into exile in Siberia or Orenburg.^[22]

However, the Khlysty were undeterred, and continued practising. Some of those who had been sent into exile began to spread the movement through Siberia. In 1745, therefore, a new commission was formed, this time using "far crueler methods of interrogation".^[23] This commission, although eliciting false confessions of sexual deviation and cannibalistic communion, and sending another 200 people into exile, likewise failed to stamp out the movement.^[23]

Later history

Around 1750, some doctrinal changes took place within the sect, and they became known as the Postniki ("Fasters"). The leaders of the sect were now seen as "personifications of Christ", rather than only playing host to his spirit. It was no longer considered possible for ordinary members to receive the Holy Spirit during radenie, although the ritual still held a central position in their worship.^[24]

In 1840, a new splinter sect broke away from the Postniki. Calling themselves Israelites, they shortly afterwards split again into Old Israel and New Israel. The beliefs of the latter group departed considerably from the traditional teachings of the Khlysts,^[24] and the sect still exists today in Uruguay.^[25]

These schisms weakened the movement, and their numbers began to decline. By the start of the twentieth century, estimates of the Khlysty's numbers ranged at around one hundred thousand.^[26] Prior to the outbreak of World War I, there were reported to be around 20,000 New Israelites, 15,000 Old Israelites and 3,000 Postniki in Russia. By the 1970s, there were only "a few isolated groups" remaining.^[24]

Influence

The Khlysty are said to have been "the root of all Russian sectarianism", having spawned sects such as the Skoptsy, the Dukhobors and the Molokans.^[27]

Connection to Rasputin

Grigori Rasputin was twice investigated (in 1903 and 1907) by the Tobolsk Theological Consistory, under charges of spreading Khlyst doctrine. Both investigations were closed without any evidence being found against him,^[28] but popular rumour continued to link Rasputin to the sect.^[29]

C. L. Sulzberger, in 1977, claimed that Rasputin "adopted the philosophy (if not proven membership)" of the Khlysts.^[16]

In The Man Behind the Myth, co-authored by Rasputin's daughter Maria, it is claimed that Rasputin attended several Khlyst gatherings in the years before his arrival in St. Petersberg, but ultimately became disillusioned with the sect.^[30] The factual accuracy of this book has been called into question,^[31] and according to Brian Moynahan, Maria's story is the only evidence that Rasputin had any Khlyst connections.^[32] The consensus of modern historians is that Rasputin was never a member of the sect.^[33]

References

Footnotes

^ ^a ^b ^c Gavrilyuk 2012, pp. 497–8
^ Etkind 2013, p. 568
^ ^a ^b Radzinsky 2000, p. 40
^ Brackney 2012, p. 173
^ ^a ^b Clay 1985, p. 70
^ Radzinsky 2000, p. 39
^ Clay 1985, pp. 71–2
^ Clay 1985, p. 85
^ Clay 1985, p. 92
^ Clay 2017, p. 128
^ Buss 2003, p. 74
^ Clay 1985, pp. 88–91
^ Buss 2003, pp. 74–75
^ ^a ^b Radzinsky 2000, p. 41
^ Radzinsky 2000, pp. 41–2
^ ^a ^b Sulzberger 1977, p. 214
^ Coneybeare 1921, p. 353
^ Fuhrmann 1990, p. 7
^ Clay 1985, pp. 72–3
^ Clay 1985, pp. 82–4
^ Clay 1985, p. 93
^ Clay 2017, p. 129
^ ^a ^b Clay 2017, pp. 130–1
^ ^a ^b ^c Lane 1978, pp. 92–3
^ Shubin 2004, p. 158
^ Etkind 2013, p. 570
^ Buss 2003, p. 73
^ Radzinsky 2000, pp. 45, 83–4, 183–4
^ Radzinsky 2000, pp. 101, 230–231
^ Rasputin & Barham 1977, pp. 100–108
^ Fuhrmann 2012, p. x
^ Moynahan 1997, p. 38
^ Smith 2017, p. 287

Sources

Brackney, William H. (2012). Historical Dictionary of Radical Christianity. Lanham, Md.: Scarecrow Press. p. 173. ISBN 978-0810871793.
Buss, Andreas (2003). The Russian-Orthodox Tradition and Modernity. Brill. ISBN 9789047402725.
Clay, J. Eugene (1985). "God's People in the early eighteenth century: The Uglich affair of 1717". Cahiers du Monde Russe. 26 (1): 69–124. doi:10.3406/cmr.1985.2034.
Clay, Eugene (2017). "The 'Quaker Heresy' in Siberia". Canadian-American Slavic Studies. 51 (1). Brill: 122–126. doi:10.1163/22102396-05101005.
Coneybeare, Frederick C. (1921). Russian Dissenters. Harvard University Press.
Etkind, Alexander (2013). "Whirling with the Other: Russian Populism and Religious Sects". The Russian Review. 62 (4): 565–588. doi:10.1111/1467-9434.00292. JSTOR 3664790.
Fuhrmann, Joseph T. (1990). Rasputin: A Life. Praeger. ISBN 0-275-93215-X.
Fuhrmann, Joseph T. (2012). Rasputin: The Untold Story. Wiley. ISBN 9781118226933.
Gavrilyuk, Paul L. (2012). "Nineteenth- to Twentieth-Century Russian Mysticism". In Lamm, Julia A. (ed.). The Wiley-Blackwell Companion to Christian Mysticism. Chichester, UK: John Wiley & Sons, Ltd. pp. 489–500. doi:10.1002/9781118232736.ch32. ISBN 9781118232736.
Lane, Christel (1978). Christian Religion in the Soviet Union. SUNY Press. ISBN 9780873953276.
Moynahan, Brian (1997). Rasputin: The Saint Who Sinned. Random House. ISBN 0-679-41930-6.
Radzinsky, Edvard (2000). The Rasputin File. Anchor. ISBN 0-385-48910-2.

Rasputin, Maria; Barham, Patte (1977). Rasputin: The Man Behind the Myth. Prentice-Hall. ISBN 0-446-82480-1.
Shubin, Daniel H. (2004). A History of Russian Christianity, Vol. III: The Synodal Era and the Sectarians – 1725 to 1894. Algora Publishing. ISBN 978-0-87586-426-6.
Smith, Douglas (2017). Rasputin. Pan Books. ISBN 978-1-4472-4585-8.
Sulzberger, C. L. (1977). The Fall of Eagles. New York: Crown Publishers. ISBN 0-517-52817-7.