Wikipedia

Lost Cosmonauts

(Redirected from Conspiracy theories about Gagarin being not the first human in space)

The Lost Cosmonauts or Phantom Cosmonauts are subjects of a conspiracy theory, which alleges that Soviet and Russian space authorities have concealed the deaths of some cosmonauts in outer space. Proponents of the Lost Cosmonauts theory argue that the Soviet Union attempted to launch human spaceflights before Yuri Gagarin's first spaceflight, and that cosmonauts onboard died in those attempts. Soviet military pilot Vladimir Ilyushin was alleged to have landed off course and been held by the Chinese government. The Government of the Soviet Union supposedly suppressed this information, to prevent bad publicity during the height of the Cold War.

The evidence cited to support Lost Cosmonaut theories is generally regarded as inconclusive, and several cases have been confirmed as hoaxes. In the 1980s, American journalist James Oberg researched space-related disasters in the Soviet Union, but found no evidence of these Lost Cosmonauts.[1] Since the fall of the Soviet Union in the early 1990s, much previously restricted information has been made available, including information on Valentin Bondarenko, a would-be cosmonaut, whose death during training on Earth was covered up by the Soviet government. Even with the availability of published Soviet archival material and memoirs of Russian space pioneers, no evidence has emerged to support the Lost Cosmonaut theories. Ilyushin, who died in 2010, also never gave any support to conspiracy theories.

Allegations

edit

Purported Czechoslovakian information leak

edit

In December 1959, an alleged high-ranking Czechoslovakian Communist leaked information about many purported unofficial space shots. Alexei Ledovsky was mentioned as being launched inside a converted R-5A rocket. Three more names of alleged cosmonauts claimed to have perished under similar circumstances were Andrei Mitkov, Sergei Shiborin and Maria Gromova.[2] In December 1959, the Italian news agency Continentale repeated the claims that a series of cosmonaut deaths on suborbital flights had been revealed by a high-ranking Czechoslovakian communist. Continentale identified the cosmonauts as Alexei Ledowsky, Serenty Schriborin, Andrei Mitkow, and Maria Gromova.[3] No other evidence of Soviet sub-orbital crewed flights ever came to light.[2]

High-altitude equipment tests

edit

A 1959 edition of Ogoniok published an article and photos of three high-altitude parachutists: Colonel Pyotr Dolgov, Ivan Kachur, and Alexey Grachov. Official records state that Dolgov was killed on November 1, 1962, while carrying out a high-altitude parachute jump from a Volga balloon gondola. Dolgov jumped at an altitude of 28,640 metres (93,960 ft). The helmet visor of Dolgov's Sokol space suit hit part of the gondola as he exited, depressurizing the suit and killing him.[4] Kachur is known to have disappeared around this time; his name has become linked to this equipment.[4] Grachov is thought to have been involved, with Dolgov and Kachur, in testing the high-altitude equipment. Russian journalist Yaroslav Golovanov suggested that high-altitude testing was exaggerated into a story that those parachutists died on a space flight.[4] In late 1959, Ogoniok carried pictures of a man identified as Gennady Zavadovsky testing high-altitude equipment (perhaps with Grachov and others). Zavadovsky would later appear on lists of dead cosmonauts, without a date of death or accident description.[4]

Yaroslav Golovanov, who researched the lost cosmonaut claims in his book, Cosmonaut #1, found and interviewed the real Alexey Timofeyevich Belokonov, a retired high-altitude parachutist. In this interview, Belokonov revealed more about his colleagues Dolgov, Kachur, Mikhailov,[specify] Grachov, Zavadovsky and Ilyushin, and confirmed they never flew to space. According to Belokonov, in 1963, after New York Journal American published an article on lost cosmonauts, listing the parachutists among them, Soviet newspapers Izvestia and Krasnaya Zvezda published a refutation that included testimonies and photographs of the actual parachutists Belokonov, Kachur, Grachov and Zavadovsky. The parachutists also wrote an angry letter to New York Journal American editor William Randolph Hearst, Jr., which he ignored.[4]

Robert Heinlein's speculation

edit

In 1960, the science fiction author Robert A. Heinlein wrote in his article Pravda means 'Truth' (reprinted in Expanded Universe) that on May 15, 1960, while traveling in Vilnius, in Soviet Lithuania, he was told by Red Army cadets that the Soviet Union had launched a human into orbit that day, but later the same day, it was denied by officials. Heinlein speculated that Korabl-Sputnik 1 was an orbital launch, later said to be uncrewed, and that the retro-rockets had fired in the wrong attitude, making recovery efforts unsuccessful.[5]

According to Gagarin's biography, these rumours were likely started as a result of two Vostok missions equipped with dummies (including a mannequin known as Ivan Ivanovich) and human voice tape recordings (to test if the radio worked) that were made just prior to Gagarin's flight.[6]

In a U.S. press conference on February 23, 1962, Colonel Barney Oldfield revealed that an uncrewed space capsule had indeed been orbiting the Earth since 1960, as it had become jammed into its booster rocket.[7] According to the NASA NSSDC Master Catalog, Korabl Sputnik 1, designated at the time 1KP or Vostok 1P, did launch on May 15, 1960 (one year before Gagarin).[8] It was a prototype of the later Zenit and Vostok launch vehicles. The onboard TDU (Braking Engine Unit) had ordered the retrorockets to fire to recover, but due to a malfunction of the attitude control system, the spacecraft was oriented upside-down, and the firing put the craft into a higher orbit. The re-entry capsule lacked a heat shield as there were no plans to recover it. Engineers had planned to use the vessel's telemetry data to determine if the guidance system had functioned correctly, so recovery was unnecessary.[9]

The Torre Bert recordings

edit
This section is an excerpt from Judica-Cordiglia brothers.[edit]
 
The two brothers
 
The brothers reported that they had recorded messages from secret missions during the Soviet Vostok program in the early 1960s.
The Judica-Cordiglia brothers are two Italian former amateur radio operators who made audio recordings which allegedly support the conspiracy theory that the Soviet space program covered up cosmonaut deaths in the 1960s.[10] The pair claimed to have recorded several failed secret Soviet space missions. These recordings have been the center of public interest for more than 50 years.[11][12]

Vladimir Ilyushin

edit
This section is an excerpt from Vladimir Ilyushin.[edit]
Vladimir Sergeyevich Ilyushin (Russian: Владимир Серге́евич Ильюшин; 31 March 1927 – 1 March 2010) was a Russian military officer and a test pilot in the former Soviet space program.[13] Ilyushin was a son of the famous aviation designer Sergey Ilyushin, and whose career was mostly as a test pilot for the Sukhoi OKB (a rival of Ilyushin OKB). After retiring from the space program, Ilyushin became a sports administrator and was inducted into the World Rugby Hall of Fame (then known as the IRB Hall of Fame) in 2013.[14]

Two days before Gagarin's launch on 12 April 1961, Dennis Ogden wrote in the Western Communist newspaper the Daily Worker that the Soviet Union's announcement that Ilyushin had been involved in a serious car crash was really a cover story for a 7 April 1961 orbital spaceflight gone wrong.[15] A similar story was told by French broadcaster Eduard Bobrovsky, but his version had the launch occurring in March, resulting in Ilyushin slipping into a coma.[15] NORAD tracking stations, however, had no record of any such launch.[15] Later that year, U.S. News & World Report transmitted the rumor by claiming that Gagarin had never flown, and was merely a stand-in for the sickened Ilyushin.[16] The 1999 film The Cosmonaut Cover-Up takes the position that Ilyushin was the first man in space and discusses the alleged cover-up in detail. They claim, "According to recently declassified documents, Ilyushin was placed in a capsule named Rossiya, and the secret flight took place in the early hours of the morning, on Friday April 7th 1961". After a guidance malfunction, the cosmonaut is reported to have made an unguided crash landing in China, too critically injured to announce the mission a complete success.[17] The 2009 film Fallen Idol: The Yuri Gagarin Conspiracy also takes the same position and further discusses US efforts to continue the allegation, even citing national security not to release information under the Freedom of Information Act. The data sought was from the CIA tracking station at Tern Island that supposedly covered and recorded Iluyshin's failed mission.

According to Mark Wade, editor of the space history web site Encyclopedia Astronautica, "The entire early history of the Soviet manned space program has been declassified and we have piles of memoirs of cosmonauts, engineers, etc., who participated. We know who was in the original cosmonaut team, who never flew, was dismissed, or was killed in ground tests. Ilyushin is not one of them."[18]

Moon-shot allegations

edit

The Soviet Union lost the crewed Moon-landing phase of the Space Race to the United States. However, some sources claim that just before the historic Apollo 11 flight to the Moon, the Soviets undertook a hasty attempt to beat the Americans. Despite the unsuccessful first test launch of the new Soviet N1 rocket on 20 January 1969, it is alleged that a decision was made to send a crewed Soyuz 7K-L3 craft to the Moon using an N1. This attempt is alleged to have occurred on 3 July 1969, when it ended in an explosion, destroying the launch pad and killing the cosmonauts on board.[citation needed] Official sources state that the L3 was not ready for crewed missions. Its lunar lander, the LK, had been tested a few times but its orbiter, the 7K-LOK, had not been successfully tested by the closing of the Moon-landing program at the end of 1974. The closing of the program was officially denied and maintained top secret until 1990 when the government allowed them to be published under the policy of glasnost.

This claim correlates with the late hoax about the unsuccessful Moon-shot flight of Andrei Mikoyan. In reality, the second launch, like the first, was a test of the booster and was therefore uncrewed. Even if cosmonauts had been on board, they would have been rescued by its launch escape system, which carried the dummy payload to safety 2 km (1.2 mi) from the pad.[19]

Other allegations

edit

In 1959, pioneering space theoretician Hermann Oberth claimed that a pilot had been killed on a sub-orbital ballistic flight from Kapustin Yar in early 1958. He provided no source for the story.[3]

Confirmed hoaxes

edit

Ivan Istochnikov

edit

Officially Soyuz 2 was an uncrewed spacecraft that was the docking target for Soyuz 3. However, Mike Arena, an American journalist, allegedly found in 1993 that an 'Ivan Istochnikov' and his dog 'Kloka', who were manning Soyuz 2, disappeared on October 26, 1968, with signs of having been hit by a meteorite. They had been "erased" from history by the Soviet authorities, who could not tolerate such a failure.[20]

The entire story was found to be a hoax perpetrated by Joan Fontcuberta[21] as a 'modern art exercise' that included falsified mission artifacts, various digitally manipulated images, and immensely detailed feature-length biographies that turned out to be riddled with hundreds of historical as well as technical errors. The exhibit was shown in Madrid in 1997 and the National Museum of Catalan Art in 1998. Brown University later purchased several articles, and put them on display themselves.

Mexico's Luna Cornea magazine however, failed to notice this, and ran issue number 14 (January/April 1998) with photos, and a story explaining the "truth".[22]

Several lines of evidence available since the first exhibition of "Sputnik" in 1997 in Madrid suggested that the story and artifacts form an elaborate hoax:

  • The name "Ivan Istochnikov" is a Russian translation of Joan Fontcuberta's name; in specific, "Joan" and "Ivan" both translate to "John"[23][24] and "Fontcuberta" and "Istochnikov" both mean "hidden fountain".
  • The photographs of Istochnikov show Fontcuberta's face.
  • Pages of the official website of the Madrid exhibition contain the words "PURE FICTION" toward the top of each page in light red text on a dark red background [25] or light pink text on a white background.[26]
  • The front and rear endpapers of the catalog accompanying the Madrid exhibition have the words "it's all fiction" in Russian and Spanish printed on them using glow-in-the-dark ink.[27]
  • At the website of Spanish newspaper El Mundo, the third of three pages concerning the Madrid exhibition states that "the report which we published on the previous pages is a product of his [Fontcuberta's] imagination".[28]

Andrei Mikoyan

edit

Andrei Mikoyan was reportedly killed together with a second crew member in an attempt to reach the Moon ahead of the Americans in early 1969. Due to system malfunction, they failed to get into lunar orbit and shot past the Moon.[29]

This story, which circulated in 2000, may have been based on the plot of an episode of the television series The Cape. The episode "Buried in Peace" first aired on October 28, 1996. In it, a Space Shuttle crew on a mission to repair a communications satellite encounters a derelict Soviet spacecraft with a dead crew—the result of a secret attempt to beat the United States to the Moon in the 1960s. Tom Nowicki played Major Andrei Mikoyan, a Russian member of the Space Shuttle crew in the story.[29]

Later allusions

edit
  • While the 1964 U.S. edition of the Guinness Book of World Records credits Gagarin's Vostok 1 as "earliest successful manned satellite", a footnote names nine putative lost cosmonauts: eight mentioned above (Ledovsky, Schiborin, Mitkov, Belokonev, Kachur, Grachev, Dolgov, and Ilyushin) and Gennadiy Mikhailov (named by the Judica-Cordiglia brothers).[30]
  • Julius Epstein wrote several papers on "Soviet failures in Space", including allegations of lost cosmonauts, which were read into the Congressional Record in 1965[31] and 1971.[32]
  • In 1993, Sun, a U.S. supermarket tabloid, ran a story recounting multiple cosmonaut deaths and ensuing body recovery missions between 1968 and 1988.[33]
  • In 2010 the Canadian band Wolf Parade released a song titled "Yulia", which lead singer Dan Boeckner confirmed in an interview as recounting a lost cosmonaut.[34]

See also

edit

References

edit

Inline citations

edit
  1. ^ See Oberg's Uncovering Soviet Disasters (1988) ISBN 0-394-56095-7, 156–76
  2. ^ a b The first Soviet cosmonaut team: their lives, legacy, and historical impact Archived 29 April 2024 at the Wayback Machine, p. 226. Colin Burgess, Rex Hall. Springer. ISBN 978-0-387-84823-5 (2009)
  3. ^ a b "Oberth Believes Astronauts Lost". Gadsden Times – Associated Press. 10 December 1959. Archived from the original on 23 April 2020. Retrieved 16 March 2016.
  4. ^ a b c d e Yaroslav Golovanov Cosmonaut #1, Izvestia, 1986.
  5. ^ Heinlein, Robert A. "The Future Revisited". Firearmsrights.Com. Archived from the original on 22 May 2009. Retrieved 20 December 2014.
  6. ^ Bizony, Piers (1998). Starman: Truth Behind the Legend of Yuri Gagarin. Bloomsbury. ISBN 0-7475-3688-0.
  7. ^ "Soviets May Have Corpse in Orbit". Santa Cruz Sentinel. Vol. 106, no. 46. 23 February 1962. p. 20 col. 7. Archived from the original on 25 January 2018. Retrieved 25 January 2018 – via California Digital Newspaper Collection.
  8. ^ "Sputnik 4". National Space Science Data Center. NASA. Archived from the original on 20 April 2022. Retrieved 12 August 2009.
  9. ^ Asif Siddiqi, "Sputnik and the Soviet Space Challenge", 2000, p. 251
  10. ^ Ratcliff, J. D. (April 1965). "Reader's Digest April 1965". Reader's Digest. p. 110. Archived from the original on 17 February 2017. Retrieved 27 July 2022.{{cite news}}: CS1 maint: bot: original URL status unknown (link)
  11. ^ Hollington, Kris (July 2008). "Lost in Space". Fortean Times. Archived from the original on 3 April 2013. Retrieved 11 March 2022.
  12. ^ "These Brothers Were Eavesdropping on Space Transmissions When They Heard Cries for Help". www.vice.com. April 2020. Retrieved 27 July 2022.
  13. ^ Wade, Mark. "Ilyushin". Archived from the original on 9 January 2005.
  14. ^ "Ilyushin first Russian in IRB Hall of Fame" (Press release). International Rugby Board. 28 February 2013. Archived from the original on 16 May 2013. Retrieved 18 March 2013.
  15. ^ a b c Hall, Rex (2001). The Rocket Men: Vostok & Voskhod, the First Soviet Manned Spaceflights (illustrated ed.). Springer. p. 145. ISBN 1-85233-391-X. Retrieved 23 February 2009.
  16. ^ Политолог Вячеслав Никонов: «Дед признавал, что в 37-м дров наломал».
  17. ^ "The Cosmonaut Cover-Up". 5 August 1999 – via IMDb.
  18. ^ "Ilyushin Feedback". The My Hero Project. Archived from the original on 28 September 2013.
  19. ^ Siddiqi, Asif (2003). The Soviet Space Race with Apollo. University Press of Florida. pp. 688–91. ISBN 0-8130-2628-8. Archived from the original on 29 April 2024. Retrieved 16 March 2016.
  20. ^ Ivan Istochnikov: El cosmonauta fantasma Archived 27 September 2007 at the Wayback Machine, El Mundo Magazine, May 25, 1997. Following the links, we find the announcement Archived 27 September 2007 at the Wayback Machine of the Fontcuberta exposition.
  21. ^ Sputnik Foundation. Notice the "PURE FICTION" text in red text over a red background.
  22. ^ Istochnikov Archived 2008-05-15 at the Wayback Machine at the Encyclopedia Astronautica.
  23. ^ English Catalan Dictionary. Retrieved 1 July 2008
  24. ^ Online Etymology Dictionary: Ivan Retrieved 1 July 2008
  25. ^ Sputnik Foundation Archived 5 June 2008 at the Wayback Machine "From May 21st to July 20th, 1997" Retrieved 1 July 2008
  26. ^ Texts from the SPUTNIK catalog. Archived 21 August 2008 at the Wayback Machine Retrieved 1 July 2008
  27. ^ Kondakova, Olga, et al., Sputnik, Madrid: Fundación Arte y Tecnologia, 1997 ISBN 84-89884-00-5
  28. ^ Pérez de Albéniz, Javier, El cosmonauta fantasma El Mundo magazine, 25 May 1997, Retrieved 1 July 2008
  29. ^ a b Wade, Mark (2017). "Phantom Cosmonaut: Mikoyan, Andrei". Encyclopedia Astronautica. Archived from the original on 28 December 2016. Retrieved 7 January 2018.
  30. ^ McWhirter, Ross; McWhirter, Norris, eds. (1964). "Earliest successful manned satellite". Guinness Book of World Records. Sterling. p. 68.
  31. ^ "Open versus Secret Procedures in Space Programs". Congressional Record. 111 (14). U.S. Government Printing Office: 19541. 5 August 1965. Archived from the original on 29 April 2024. Retrieved 6 June 2022.
  32. ^ "Soviet failures in Space" (PDF). Congressional Record. 117 (6). U.S. Government Printing Office: 8269. 29 March 1971. Archived (PDF) from the original on 6 June 2022. Retrieved 6 June 2022.
  33. ^ Jones, Mike (21 September 1993). "Lost in Space". Sun. Boca Raton, Florida: American Media: 7.
  34. ^ "Matson on Music | Interview: Wolf Parade's Dan Boeckner explains "Yulia" from "Expo 86" | Seattle Times Newspaper". Seattletimes.com. 19 July 2010. Retrieved 18 June 2014.[dead link‍]

General references

edit
edit
Retrieved from "https://en.wikipedia.org/w/index.php?title=Lost_Cosmonauts&oldid=1247073001"