The 2012 West Texas A&M Buffaloes football team represented West Texas A&M University in the 2012 NCAA Division II football season as a member of the Lone Star Conference .[ 1] The Buffaloes ended the regular season with 9–2 record (7–1 in the LSC) which was enough to claim a share of the Lone Star Conference title and to qualify for the NCAA tournament as a six seed in region 4.[ 2] West Texas A&M went on to win the NCAA Super Region Four Tournament but ended the season with a loss to Winston-Salem State in the National semi-final. With the 57–20 win over Western State on September 8, eighth-year head coach Don Carthel tied former head coach Joe Kerbel for the most wins in school history with 68,[ 3] passing him a week later with win over Texas A&M–Kingsville.[ 4] The Buffaloes had multiple shutouts for first time since 2008 .[ 5]
West Texas A&M was ranked No. 24 the initial AFCA poll of the season.[ 6]
Dismissal of Don Carthel and NCAA investigation
edit
This was Dan Carthel's final season as the Buffaloes head coach as he was fired by the university on August 22, 2013. According to the university's press release, Carthel misled university officials about buying tickets to a Texas Rangers game for two players on the football team and instructed the players to lie about who bought the tickets.[ 7] The NCAA launched an investigation that lasted for almost two-and-a-half years; the investigation found other infractions, such as defensive coordinator Colby Carthel providing impermissible benefits to a student-athlete and an academic fraud violation that occurred during the 2014 season . As punishment, the program was placed on probation from March 23, 2016 to March 22, 2019, had to vacate four wins from the 2014 season, and was fined $5,000.[ 8]
Date Time Opponent Rank Site TV Result Attendance August 30 7:00 pm at No. 6 CSU Pueblo * No. 24 KCIT L 34–446,457[ 9]
September 8 6:00 pm Western State (CO) * W 57–208,432[ 10]
September 15 8:00 pm vs. No. 14 Texas A&M–Kingsville KAMR W 40–1019,143[ 11]
September 22 7:00 pm at Incarnate Word No. 25 KAMR W 24–04,755[ 12]
September 29 6:00 pm Tarleton State No. 23 Kimbrough Memorial Canyon, TX W 41–247,825[ 13]
October 6 6:00 pm at Angelo State No. 21 KCPN /KAMRW 35–94,822[ 14]
October 13 6:00 pm Abilene Christian No. 20 Kimbrough Memorial Canyon, TX FSSW.com W 36–013,019[ 15]
October 20 6:00 pm at Eastern New Mexico No. 17 KAMR W 44–212,759[ 16]
October 27 7:00 pm at West Georgia * No. 14 KAMR/CSSW W 44–212,886[ 17]
November 3 6:00 pm No. 10 Midwestern State No. 12 Kimbrough Memorial Canyon, TX L 48–5212,238[ 18]
November 10 2:00 pm at Texas A&M–Commerce No. 17 KAMR W 45–141,521[ 19]
November 17 2:00 pm at No. 20 Chadron State * No. 16 KCIT W 38–301,490[ 20]
November 24 10:00 am at No. 4 Ashland * No. 16 Jack Miller Stadium Ashhland, OH (NCAA Division II Second Round)KAMR W 33–282,842[ 21]
December 1 5:30 pm at No. 1 CSU Pueblo* No. 16 KCIT W 34–1310,217[ 22]
December 8 5:30 pm at No. 2 Winston-Salem State * No. 16 L 18–418,612[ 23] [ 24]
*Non-conference game HomecomingRankings from AFCA Poll released prior to the game
Ranking movementsLegend: ██ Increase in ranking ██ Decrease in ranking RV = Received votes Week Poll Pre 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 Final AFCA 24 RV RV 25 23 21 20 17 14 12 17 16 4
1
2
3
4
Total
No. 24 Buffaloes
14
0
6
14
34
No. 6 Thunderwolves
14
10
6
14
44
Statistics
WTAMU
CSUP
First downs
25
27
Total yards
541
487
Rushing yards
75
265
Passing yards
466
222
Turnovers
2
1
Time of possession
25:45
34:15
Team
Category
Player
Statistics
West Texas A&M
Passing
Dustin Vaughan
30/47, 398 yards, 3 TD, INT
Rushing
Aaron Harris
9 rushes, 28 yards, TD
Receiving
Torrence Allen
9 receptions, 164 yards, TD
CSU Pueblo
Passing
Ross Dausin
20/24, 222 yards, 2 TD
Rushing
J. B. Matthews
23 rushes, 153 yards, TD
Receiving
J. B. Matthews
4 receptions, 78 yards, TD
1
2
3
4
Total
Mountaineers
0
0
6
14
20
Buffaloes
21
13
14
9
57
Statistics
WSCU
WTAMU
First downs
16
29
Total yards
278
677
Rushing yards
65
170
Passing yards
213
507
Turnovers
2
0
Time of possession
30:38
29:22
Team
Category
Player
Statistics
Western State
Passing
Brian Duboski
15/30, 213 yards, 2 TD, INT
Rushing
Germaine Daniels
19 rushes, 48 yards
Receiving
Lukas Adams
4 receptions, 59 yards, 2 TD
West Texas A&M
Passing
Dustin Vaughan
22/32, 409 yards, 5 TD
Rushing
Geremy Aldridge
11 rushes, 102 yards
Receiving
Nate Slaughter
6 receptions, 132 yards, TD
Vs. No. 14 Texas A&M–Kingsville
edit
1
2
3
4
Total
No. 14 Javelinas
3
0
0
7
10
Buffaloes
7
3
14
16
40
Statistics
TAMUK
WTAMU
First downs
19
18
Total yards
285
368
Rushing yards
88
112
Passing yards
197
256
Turnovers
3
1
Time of possession
34:14
25:46
Team
Category
Player
Statistics
Texas A&M–Kingsville
Passing
Nate Poppell
19/32, 188 yards, TD, INT
Rushing
Randall Toney
10 rushes, 42 yards
Receiving
Sherman Batiste
6 receptions, 86 yards, TD
West Texas A&M
Passing
Dustin Vaughan
19/29, 250 yards, 3 TD
Rushing
Khiry Robinson
17 rushes, 110 yards, TD
Receiving
Lance Ratliff
3 receptions, 76 yards, 2 TD
1
2
3
4
Total
No. 25 Buffaloes
0
10
14
0
24
Cardinals
0
0
0
0
0
Statistics
WTAMU
UIW
First downs
18
10
Total yards
361
146
Rushing yards
105
15
Passing yards
256
131
Turnovers
3
1
Time of possession
24:43
35:17
Team
Category
Player
Statistics
West Texas A&M
Passing
Dustin Vaughan
19/32, 243 yards, 2 TD, INT
Rushing
Khiry Robinson
13 rushes, 58 yards
Receiving
Torrence Allen
9 receptions, 86 yards
Incarnate Word
Passing
Taylor Woods
14/26, 123 yards, INT
Rushing
Trent Rios
14 rushes, 66 yards
Receiving
Trent Rios
6 receptions, 67 yards
1
2
3
4
Total
Texans
7
0
14
0
21
No. 23 Buffaloes
7
17
10
7
41
Statistics
TSU
WTAMU
First downs
23
27
Total yards
389
502
Rushing yards
193
171
Passing yards
196
331
Turnovers
1
1
Time of possession
32:06
27:54
Team
Category
Player
Statistics
Tarleton State
Passing
Aaron Doyle
15/27, 196 yards, TD
Rushing
Vaughn Smith
24 rushes, 134 yards, TD
Receiving
Arthur Buckingham
4 receptions, 69 yards, TD
West Texas A&M
Passing
Dustin Vaughan
23/37, 331 yards, 4 TD
Rushing
Khiry Robinson
18 rushes, 125 yards
Receiving
Torrence Allen
5 receptions, 104 yards, 2 TD
1
2
3
4
Total
No. 21 Buffaloes
8
10
10
7
35
Rams
3
0
0
6
9
Statistics
WTAMU
ASU
First downs
17
23
Total yards
398
332
Rushing yards
154
49
Passing yards
244
283
Turnovers
2
3
Time of possession
29:23
30:37
Team
Category
Player
Statistics
West Texas A&M
Passing
Dustin Vaughan
17/32, 241 yards, 3 TD, INT
Rushing
Khiry Robinson
17 rushes, 143 yards
Receiving
Alphonse Coleman
3 receptions, 75 yards
Angelo State
Passing
Blake Hamblin
23/50, 264 yards, TD, 2 INT
Rushing
Donovan Roberts
7 rushes, 41 yards
Receiving
C. J. Akins
7 receptions, 70 yards
1
2
3
4
Total
Wildcats
0
0
0
0
0
No. 20 Buffaloes
7
6
16
7
36
Statistics
ACU
WTAMU
First downs
15
26
Total yards
210
475
Rushing yards
3
92
Passing yards
207
383
Turnovers
2
0
Time of possession
28:59
31:01
Team
Category
Player
Statistics
Abilene Christian
Passing
Mitchell Gale
17/29, 207 yards, 2 INT
Rushing
Charcandrick West
6 rushes, 17 yards
Receiving
Darian Hogg
2 receptions, 75 yards
West Texas A&M
Passing
Dustin Vaughan
32/46, 359 yards, 3 TD
Rushing
Khiry Robinson
15 rushes, 102 yards, TD
Receiving
Jarrian Rhone
9 receptions, 106 yards, TD
At Eastern New Mexico
edit
1
2
3
4
Total
No. 17 Buffaloes
14
7
14
9
44
Greyhounds
0
14
0
7
21
Statistics
WTAMU
ENMU
First downs
18
19
Total yards
454
391
Rushing yards
123
205
Passing yards
331
186
Turnovers
2
1
Time of possession
21:56
38:04
Team
Category
Player
Statistics
West Texas A&M
Passing
Dustin Vaughan
20/33, 321 yards, 2 TD, 2 INT
Rushing
Khiry Robinson
16 rushes, 131 yards, 4 TD
Receiving
Nate Slaughter
7 receptions, 133 yards, TD
Eastern New Mexico
Passing
Wesley Wood
15/31, 188 yards, 2 TD
Rushing
Wesley Wood
15 rushes, 79 yards, TD
Receiving
Chase Kyser
7 receptions, 92 yards, 2 TD
1
2
3
4
Total
No. 14 Buffaloes
7
24
7
14
52
Wolves
14
0
14
0
28
Statistics
WTAMU
UWG
First downs
19
21
Total yards
463
267
Rushing yards
119
151
Passing yards
344
116
Turnovers
1
1
Time of possession
24:52
35:08
Team
Category
Player
Statistics
West Texas A&M
Passing
Dustin Vaughan
28/37, 331 yards, 5 TD
Rushing
Khiry Robinson
15 rushes, 89 yards
Receiving
Torrence Allen
4 receptions, 97 yards, TD
West Georgia
Passing
Dallas Dickey
7/10, 112 yards, 2 TD
Rushing
David Bailey
17 rushes, 70 yards, TD
Receiving
Joey Eliezer
2 receptions, 45 yards, TD
No. 10 Midwestern State
edit
1
2
3
4
Total
No. 10 Mustangs
14
14
3
21
52
No. 12 Buffaloes
10
21
10
7
48
Statistics
MSU
WTAMU
First downs
24
30
Total yards
565
525
Rushing yards
317
134
Passing yards
248
391
Turnovers
2
3
Time of possession
29:52
30:08
Team
Category
Player
Statistics
Midwestern State
Passing
Brandon Kelsey
14/22, 248 yards, TD
Rushing
Keidrick Jackson
20 rushes, 133 yards, 2 TD
Receiving
Keivin Swanson
6 receptions, 91 yards
West Texas A&M
Passing
Dustin Vaughan
30/47, 391 yards, 3 TD, INT
Rushing
Khiry Robinson
23 rushes, 147 yards, 3 TD
Receiving
Lance Ratliff
11 receptions, 180 yards, TD
At Texas A&M–Commerce
edit
1
2
3
4
Total
No. 17 Buffaloes
14
7
14
10
45
Lions
0
7
7
0
14
Statistics
WTAMU
TAMUC
First downs
28
16
Total yards
510
328
Rushing yards
199
111
Passing yards
311
217
Turnovers
1
1
Time of possession
27:35
32:25
Team
Category
Player
Statistics
West Texas A&M
Passing
Dustin Vaughan
20/29, 278 yards, 2 TD
Rushing
Khiry Robinson
16 rushes, 110 yards, 2 TD
Receiving
Torrence Allen
5 receptions, 113 yards, TD
Texas A&M–Commerce
Passing
Kevin Vye
15/31, 217 yards
Rushing
Jamar Mosley
12 rushes, 72 yards, TD
Receiving
Tyler Rawlings
4 receptions, 81 yards
At No. 20 Chadron State (NCAA Division II First Round)
edit
1
2
3
4
Total
No. 16 Buffaloes
0
17
7
14
38
No. 20 Eagles
14
0
6
10
30
Statistics
WTAMU
CSC
First downs
25
27
Total yards
580
455
Rushing yards
311
72
Passing yards
269
383
Turnovers
2
0
Time of possession
29:38
30:22
Team
Category
Player
Statistics
West Texas A&M
Passing
Dustin Vaughan
19/31, 269 yards, 2 TD, 2 INT
Rushing
Khiry Robinson
30 rushes, 235 yards, 3 TD
Receiving
Torrence Allen
7 receptions, 142 yards
Chadron State
Passing
John McLain
32/49, 331 yards, 2 TD
Rushing
Michael Madkins
11 rushes, 54 yards
Receiving
Nathan Ross
8 receptions, 76 yards, TD
At No. 4 Ashland (NCAA Division II Second Round)
edit
1
2
3
4
Total
No. 16 Buffaloes
10
9
14
0
33
Eagles
0
21
7
0
28
Statistics
WTAMU
AU
First downs
19
22
Total yards
451
366
Rushing yards
53
200
Passing yards
398
166
Turnovers
2
4
Time of possession
31:24
28:36
Team
Category
Player
Statistics
West Texas A&M
Passing
Dustin Vaughan
35/50, 398 yards, 4 TD, INT
Rushing
Khiry Robinson
21 rushes, 58 yards
Receiving
Torrence Allen
13 receptions, 185 yards, 3 TD
Ashland
Passing
Taylor Housewright
20/34, 166 yards, 2 TD, 3 INT
Rushing
Anthony Taylor
22 rushes, 156 yards, TD
Receiving
Logan Slavinski
7 receptions, 43 yards
At No. 1 CSU Pueblo (NCAA Division II Quarterfinal)
edit
1
2
3
4
Total
No. 16 Buffaloes
7
17
10
0
34
No. 1 ThunderWolves
0
3
3
7
13
Statistics
WTAMU
CSUP
First downs
24
17
Total yards
517
225
Rushing yards
193
32
Passing yards
324
193
Turnovers
2
2
Time of possession
31:09
28:51
Team
Category
Player
Statistics
West Texas A&M
Passing
Dustin Vaughan
24/38, 324 yards, 3 TD, INT
Rushing
Khiry Robinson
26 rushes, 176 yards
Receiving
Nate Slaughter
7 receptions, 170 yards, 2 TD
CSU Pueblo
Passing
Ross Dausin
22/33, 193 yards, TD, INT
Rushing
J. B. Matthews
16 rushes, 75 yards
Receiving
J. B. Matthews
6 receptions, 58 yards
At No. 2 Winston-Salem State (NCAA Division II Semifinal)
edit
1
2
3
4
Total
No. 16 Buffaloes
7
0
3
8
18
No. 2 Rams
6
14
7
14
41
Statistics
WTAMU
WSSU
First downs
19
28
Total yards
302
510
Rushing yards
133
261
Passing yards
169
249
Turnovers
2
0
Time of possession
27:02
32:58
Team
Category
Player
Statistics
West Texas A&M
Passing
Dustin Vaughan
21/35, 169 yards, TD, 2 INT
Rushing
Khiry Robinson
20 rushes, 137 yards, TD
Receiving
Torrence Allen
6 receptions, 74 yards
Winston-Salem State
Passing
Kameron Smith
15/23, 233 yards, 2 TD
Rushing
Maurice Lewis
21 rushes, 118 yards, 2 TD
Receiving
Jamal Williams
5 receptions, 99 yards, TD
West Texas A&M road games were brotcasted on KAMR-TV.[ 25]
^ "2012 Schedule and Results" .
^ "Nov. 12, 2012: LSC Football Weekly Release (Week 11)" . Lone Star Conference .
^ "Sept. 10, 2012: LSC Football Weekly Release (Week 2)" . Lone Star Conference .
^ "Sept. 17, 2012: LSC Football Weekly Release (Week 3)" . Lone Star Conference .
^ "Oct. 15, 2012: LSC Football Weekly Release (Week 7)" . Lone Star Conference .
^ "Buffs ranked No. 24 in poll" . Amarillo Globe-News .
^ "Don Carthel ousted as WT football coach" . Amarillo Globe-News . August 22, 2013. Retrieved August 22, 2013 .
^ Steed, Kale (March 23, 2016). "NCAA punishes WT football for conduct violations" . Amarillo Globe-News . Retrieved October 12, 2023 .
^ "West Texas A&M vs CSU-Pueblo (Aug 30, 2012)" .
^ "Western State vs West Texas A&M (Sep 08, 2012)" .
^ "Texas A&M-Kingsville vs West Texas A&M (Sep 15, 2012)" .
^ "West Texas A&M vs Incarnate Word (Sep 22, 2012)" .
^ "Tarleton vs West Texas A&M (Sep 29, 2012)" .
^ "West Texas A&M vs Angelo State (Oct 06, 2012)" .
^ "Abilene Christian vs West Texas A&M (Oct 13, 2012)" .
^ "West Texas A&M vs Eastern New Mexico (Oct 20, 2012)" .
^ "West Texas A&M vs West Georgia (10/27/12)" .
^ "Midwestern State vs West Texas A&M (Nov 03, 2012)" .
^ "West Texas A&M vs A&M-Commerce (Nov 10, 2012)" .
^ "West Texas A&M vs Chadron State (Nov 17, 2012)" .
^ "West Texas A&M vs Ashland University (Nov 24, 2012)" .
^ "West Texas A&M vs CSU-Pueblo (Dec 01, 2012)" .
^ "West Texas A&M falls in semis" . The Odessa American . December 9, 2012. Retrieved June 3, 2023 – via Newspapers.com .
^ "West Texas A&M vs Winston-Salem State (Dec 08, 2012)" .
^ "WT, KAMR-TV reach 2-year deal" . Amarillo Globe-News .