Metro Manila Transit Corporation

(Redirected from Draft:Love Bus)

The Metropolitan Manila Transit Corporation (MMTC) was a government-owned transport company in Metro Manila, the Philippines.

Metro Manila Transit Corporation
ParentMetro Manila Council (1975–1979)
Ministry of Transportation and Communications (1979–1997)[1]
Founded1974; 50 years ago (1974) (as the Manila Transit Corporation)
Commenced operation1975; 49 years ago (1975)
Ceased operation1995; 29 years ago (1995)[2]
Defunct1997; 27 years ago (1997)[2]
HeadquartersNorth Avenue corner Mindanao Avenue, Diliman, Quezon City
Service areaMetro Manila
Service typeBus service
OperatorGovernment of the Philippines

At its peak, the MMTC operated several bus routes in Metro Manila. It was most well known for its Love Bus and double-decker bus routes.

History

edit

After World War II, the pre-war tranvía streetcar system in Manila was left destroyed, leaving a gap in the city's public transport infrastructure that was subsequently filled by buses and jeepneys. Loose regulations, however, resulted in a fragmented public transportation system in Manila and its suburbs dominated by independent transport operators who competed against each another, resulting in inadequate services.[3][4]

During the martial law period under Ferdinand Marcos, efforts were made to address the problem, as Marcos issued Presidential Decree No. 492 on June 27, 1974, which established a government-owned and controlled corporation called the Manila Transit Corporation (MTC). The MTC would serve the role of integrating all public transportation operations in the region under a single corporate entity, thereby streamlining services and eliminating the issues caused by the proliferation of independent transport operators. It was created with a capital stock of ₱10 million (equivalent to ₱282,419,326 in 2021) divided into 3 million shares. Of these shares, one million shares may be sold to individuals or entities operating public transport vehicles in Metro Manila.[4]

On November 7, 1975, Marcos issued Presidential Decree No. 824, establishing Metro Manila and the Metropolitan Manila Commission.[5] Following this, on December 25, 1975, the MTC was renamed as the Metropolitan Manila Transit Corporation (MMTC) and its focus was expanded to cover the newly-created metropolitan area through the issuance of Presidential Decree No. 860. The decree also exempted the MMTC from regulation under the Public Service Act.[6]

On January 26, 1976, the Love Bus was launched by the MMTC.[7]: 182  It was popularized as the first air-conditioned bus service in the country, as well as its strict observance of timetables.[3] By May 1977, the Love Bus had carried over 5.34 million passengers, with a study in February 1976 stating that 19 percent of its passengers used to commute by car.[8]: 62, 64 

On June 27, 1977, Marcos issued Presidential Decree No. 1168, increasing MMTC's corporate stock to ₱25 million (equivalent to ₱706,048,315 in 2021) divided into 6 million shares.[9] The number of shares was then increased to 26 million shares through the issuance of Presidential Decree No. 1465 on June 11, 1978.[10] Around this time, the MMTC reportedly had over 2,500 bus drivers and conductresses and 491 employees in its administration and maintenance departments.[11]: 38 

On July 23, 1979, Marcos issued Executive Order No. 546, creating the Ministry of Transportation and Communications (MOTC) and designating the MMTC as an attached agency of the MOTC.[1]

By 1980, the MMTC shifted from its original role in monopolizing all public transport operations in Metro Manila to supporting private operators through integrating fewer but larger bus consortiums, acting as a government tool for achieving broader social and developmental goals, such as pioneering new services and routes.[12]: 38-39 [3]

In 1982, the MMTC reported its first profitable year. This would be the only year it generated a profit during its first ten years of operation.[12]: 39 

On March 20, 1985, Marcos issued Executive Order No. 1011, creating the Land Transportation Commission (LTC) as an attached agency of the MOTC. The order removed MMTC's exemption from regulation, placing it under the authority of the LTC.[13]

At some point in the 1990s, the Love Bus was discontinued due to significant losses incurred by MMTC.[citation needed]

Privatization and dissolution

edit

Following the People Power Revolution, which led to Marcos' resignation, the subsequent Aquino administration shifted the government's focus towards deregulating and privatizing the transport sector and disposing of state-owned bus operations, particularly those of MMTC.[14]

During the Ramos administration, a study group was created in 1994 to formulate a plan to privatize the MMTC.[15] After multiple unsuccessful attempts to liquidate MMTC, the company was eventually sold to its blue-collar employees on April 10, 1995. Its remaining 155 buses were then acquired and operated by four groups formed by the former employees:[16][2]: 7-3[17]

  • United Workers Transport Corporation
  • Drivers, Conductors, Mechanics (DCOMMP) Multi-Purpose Transport Service Cooperative
  • Filcomtrans
  • Fastrans

MMTC retained a skeletal workforce of 12 employees and focused on asset liquidation, auditing the four groups operating its former buses, and collecting outstanding payments from prior obligations.[2]: 7-3

After the company had completely ceased operations, its northern terminal and garage on the corner of North Avenue and Mindanao Avenue in Quezon City was demolished and returned to the National Housing Authority (NHA).[2]: 7-3. The area of that property was then developed in a joint venture between Ayala Land and the NHA into Vertis North.

Its 3,593-square-meter (0.3593 ha) southern terminal in Taguig[11]: 62, 64  was demolished and returned to Food Terminal Inc. (FTI), which leased the lot and much of the area to the Shoppers Paradise FTI Corporation in the 2000s,[18] then sold most of the area to Ayala Land in 2012, developing most of the area into Arca South.[19]

Fares

edit

In 1984, both ordinary buses and double-decker buses had a fare of ₱0.80 (equivalent to ₱8 in 2021) for the first 4 kilometers (2.5 mi) and ₱0.21 (equivalent to ₱2 in 2021) for each succeeding kilometer. Limited buses operated on a flat rate system with a fare of ₱0.70 (equivalent to ₱7 in 2021) per zone with a special fare of ₱1.85 (equivalent to ₱18 in 2021) per zone.[20]: 6-2

The Love Bus also similarly operated on a flat rate system. In 1979, the fare was set at ₱2.50 (equivalent to ₱56 in 2021).[21] By 1984, this amount had increased to ₱5.50 (equivalent to ₱52 in 2021).[20]: 6-2 By 1990, it had risen to ₱8.50 (equivalent to ₱44 in 2021).[22]: 88

Routes

edit

In 1984, MMTC operated 54 ordinary bus routes, 28 air-conditioned bus (Love Bus) routes, five limited bus routes, and three double-decker bus routes.[23]: 78-82

List of MMTC limited bus routes in 1984[20]: 33[24]: 1-38[23]: 78-82, 92-93
Route Terminals Route Structure Service area Length Notes
1 U.P. Campus - Ayala U.P. Campus
UP Diliman
Makati CBD
Ayala Avenue
18.4 km (11.4 mi)
2 U.P. Campus - Quiapo U.P. Campus
UP Diliman
Quiapo
Quezon Boulevard
18.3 km (11.4 mi)
3 Sangandaan - Ayala Caloocan
A. Mabini Street
Makati CBD
Ayala Avenue
19.6 km (12.2 mi)
4 Monumento - Washington
via Ayala, Buendia
Caloocan
Monumento
Makati
Washington Street
19.1 km (11.9 mi)
5 FTI - Monumento Taguig
Food Terminal Inc.
Caloocan
Monumento
26.2 km (16.3 mi)
List of MMTC double-decker bus routes in 1984[20]: 33[24]: 1-38[23]: 78-82, 92-93
Route Terminals Route Structure Service area Length Notes
1 U.P. Campus - Ayala U.P. Campus
UP Diliman
Makati CBD
Ayala Avenue
19.5 km (12.1 mi)
2 Monumento - Leveriza Caloocan
Monumento
Malate
Leveriza Street
21.6 km (13.4 mi)
3 Monumento - Ayala Caloocan
Monumento
Makati CBD
Ayala Avenue
20.0 km (12.4 mi)

Love Bus routes

edit

In 1984, MMTC operated 28 Love Bus routes, where 27 routes were within Metro Manila limits while one route was between Metro Manila and Rizal.[25] The first Love Bus route was launched between Escolta and the Makati CBD in 1976 and was its most profitable route.[3]

List of Love Bus routes in 1984[20]: 33[24]: 1-38[23]: 78-82, 92-93
Route Terminals Route Structure Service area Length Notes
1 Cubao - Escolta
via EDSA
Araneta Center
Ali Mall
Binondo
Escolta Street
16.5 km (10.3 mi)
2 U.P. - Ayala
via Cubao
U.P. Campus
UP Diliman
Makati CBD
Ayala Avenue
16.6 km (10.3 mi)
3 U.P. Campus - Ayala
via Escolta
U.P. Campus
UP Diliman
Makati CBD
Ayala Avenue
24.6 km (15.3 mi)
4 Ayala - Ali Mall, Cubao
via Quiapo
Makati CBD
Ayala Avenue
Araneta Center
Ali Mall
14.5 km (9.0 mi)
5 Ayala - Escolta - Philcoa Makati CBD
Ayala Avenue
Quezon City
Philcoa
10.6 km (6.6 mi)
6 New MIA - Ayala Pasay
Manila International Airport
Makati CBD
Ayala Avenue
7.5 km (4.7 mi)
7 New MIA - Sta. Cruz Pasay
Manila International Airport
Santa Cruz
Plaza Santa Cruz
12.0 km (7.5 mi)
8 FTI - Ayala (MCC) Western Bicutan
Food Terminal Inc.
Makati CBD
Ayala Avenue
13.8 km (8.6 mi)
9 Ayala - Cubao
via EDSA
Makati CBD
Ayala Avenue
Araneta Center
Ali Mall
10.8 km (6.7 mi)
10 Ayala - Escolta
via Mabini
Makati CBD
Ayala Avenue
Binondo
Escolta Street
10.0 km (6.2 mi)
11 Ayala - Marikina (MMC) Makati CBD
Ayala Avenue
Marikina
Shoe Avenue
19.1 km (11.9 mi)
12 Ayala - Sta. Cruz (MMC) Makati CBD
Ayala Avenue
Santa Cruz
Plaza Santa Cruz
9.9 km (6.2 mi)
13 Ayala - Quiapo (MCC) Makati CBD
Ayala Avenue
Quiapo
Quezon Boulevard
9.5 km (5.9 mi)
14 MIA - Cubao
via EDSA
Pasay
Manila International Airport
Araneta Center
Ali Mall
16.4 km (10.2 mi)
15 PNR Caloocan - Ayala Caloocan
Caloocan station
Makati CBD
Ayala Avenue
11.1 km (6.9 mi)
16 U.P. - Quiapo U.P. Campus
UP Diliman
Quiapo
Quezon Boulevard
24.7 km (15.3 mi)
17 Antipolo - Ayala
via EDSA, Crossing, Rosario
Antipolo
P. Oliveros Street
Makati CBD
Ayala Avenue
Antipolo, Cainta, Pasig, Quezon City, Mandaluyong, Makati 23.0 km (14.3 mi) Operated by EMBC.
18 Ayala - Greenhills Makati CBD
Ayala Avenue
Greenhills
Greenhills Shopping Center
8.6 km (5.3 mi)
19 Ayala - Quiapo Makati CBD
Ayala Avenue
Quiapo
Quezon Boulevard
9.5 km (5.9 mi)
20 Ayala - MIA Makati CBD
Ayala Avenue
Pasay
Manila International Airport
8.8 km (5.5 mi)
21 Ayala - Philtrade Makati CBD
Ayala Avenue
Pasay
PhilTrade
Makati, Pasay 5.3 km (3.3 mi)
22 Ayala - Muñoz Makati CBD
Ayala Avenue
Quezon City
Muñoz Market
15.7 km (9.8 mi)
23 Ayala - Philcoa Makati CBD
Ayala Avenue
Quezon City
Philcoa
14.1 km (8.8 mi)
24 Ayala - U.P. Campus Makati CBD
Ayala Avenue
U.P. Campus
UP Diliman
16.8 km (10.4 mi)
25 Ayala - Cubao
via Quiapo
Makati CBD
Ayala Avenue
Araneta Center
Ali Mall
23.0 km (14.3 mi)
26 U.E. Caloocan - Ayala
via DBP Buendia Crispa
Caloocan
UE Caloocan
Makati CBD
Ayala Avenue
21.1 km (13.1 mi)
27 U.E. Caloocan - Ayala Caloocan
UE Caloocan
Makati CBD
Ayala Avenue
20.9 km (13.0 mi)
28 Monumento - Buendia
via Ayala
Caloocan
Monumento
Pasay
Buendia Avenue
19.9 km (12.4 mi)

At some point, the Love Bus routes were complemented by Pag-Ibig Bus routes. By 1989, MMTC was only operating four Love Bus and Pag-Ibig Bus routes.[26]: 10, 20[27]: 6, 11

List of Love Bus and Pag-Ibig Bus routes in 1989[26]: 10, 20[27]: 6, 11
Route Terminals Route Structure Service area Length Notes
1 Ali Mall - Ayala - Escolta Araneta Center
Ali Mall
Binondo
Escolta Street
All trips:
Northbound trips:

Southbound trips:
Quezon City, San Juan, Mandaluyong, Makati, Pasay, Manila 33 km (21 mi) Loop route
2 PNR / UE - MIA Caloocan
Caloocan station
Pasay
Manila International Airport
Caloocan, Quezon City, San Juan, Mandaluyong, Makati, Pasay 34 km (21 mi)
3 Broadway - Ayala - Washington Broadway Centrum
Broadway Avenue
Makati
Washington Street
Quezon City, San Juan, Mandaluyong, Makati 27 km (17 mi)
4 Pansol - Ayala Pansol, Quezon City
Katipunan Avenue
Makati CBD
Ayala Avenue
Quezon City, San Juan, Mandaluyong, Makati 19 km (12 mi)

Fleet

edit

The MMTC operated several types of buses, each with varying specifications. The ordinary and limited buses were 2.5 m (8.2 ft) wide, 3.3 m (11 ft) high, and 11.0 m (36.1 ft) long. The ordinary buses had a seating capacity of 59, while the limited buses had 58 seats. The double-decker buses measured 2.5 m (8.2 ft) in width, 4.7 m (15 ft) in height, and 11.0 m (36.1 ft) in length, and had 100 seats. The Love Bus measured 2.5 m (8.2 ft) wide, 4.7 m (15 ft) high, and 10.0 m (32.8 ft) long, with a seating capacity of 54.[20]: 6-2

The Love Bus formerly ran on a fleet of air-conditioned buses that had a monocoque body design, which was considered a significant milestone at the time as before 1975, all buses in the Philippines were flatbed trucks mounted with wooden bodies. Its former fleet initially consisted of buses made by industry giants Hino, Mercedes-Benz, and Volvo, then expanded into then-lesser known brands such as Ford, Fiat, and four other companies. The Love Bus had also operated double-decker buses, being the first company to do so in the Philippines.[3]

In May 1977, the MMTC operated a fleet of 609 buses, consisting of 100 Hino Ordinary units, 50 Volvo B57 units, 162 Fiat 331A units, and 147 Ford B-1617 units. The fleet also included 60 Mercedez-Benz buses and 10 Berliet buses of unspecified models. The Love Bus service at the time was served by 100 Hino buses of an unidentified model.[11]: 44–45 

The 1984 JUMSUT report estimated that there were 40 double-decker bus units, 370 Love Bus units, and 100 limited bus units in operation as of February of that year.[20]: 6-2

The MMTC was also known for maintaining bus operations even during heavy rains or flood. During the curfew under the martial law period, the MetroCom would also direct the MMTC to deploy buses to rescue stranded commuters.[11]: 67 

Taxi operations

edit
 
MTC Harabas Taksi

In 1975, to address a shortage of taxis, the MTC ventured into taxi operations with an initial fleet of 50 Harabas Taksi taxicabs manufactured by the Francisco Motors Corporation. The Harabas Taksi was a four-door station wagon basic utility vehicle conceived as a derivative of the GM Harabas manufactured by General Motors as a result of the Progressive Car Manufacturing Program (PCMP) of the Marcos administration.[28]

Taxicab drivers were given a chance to own their vehicles through daily installments for a period of two years. Once the installments are paid in full, drivers are invited to join a semi-cooperative plan, where the driver could avail bulk purchases of spare parts and maintenance services from MTC.[8]: 21 

At its peak, the MMTC operated 248 taxicab units of various models. The MMTC eventually shut down its taxicab operations in 1982 and sold the units to private operators.[7]: 173 

Board of directors

edit

The MMTC was governed by a board of directors consisting of six ex-officio cabinet members. The board was chaired by the general manager or governor of Metro Manila, who also served as the MMTC chairman. The other board members included the Secretary of Transportation and Communications, who acted as Vice Chairman, the Secretary of National Defense, the Secretary of Industry, the Secretary of Finance, the Secretary of Public Highways, and one additional member appointed by the President of the Philippines, with a term limited to two years.[11]: 37, 40 [4]

Notable incidents

edit
  • On May 24, 1987, a MMTC bus was grounded and used as a barricade along EDSA during a rally organized by supporters and candidates of the Union for Peace and Progress (UPP) and Kilusang Bagong Lipunan (KBL) parties, who were protesting allegations of electoral fraud in the 1987 Philippine Senate election.[29]
  • On June 17, 1992, thousands of MMTC workers conducted a sitdown strike at multiple MMTC depots and terminals due to unpaid rice subsidies, delayed salaries, and alleged graft and corruption in a bus maintenance contract. The strike coincided with work slowdowns at other bus companies, leaving only 20 buses from over 300 buses in Metro Manila, leaving thousands of commuters stranded.[30] The next day, the Quezon City Regional Trial Court granted a petition filed by MMTC president and general manager Antonio Nery to order the workers to put an end to the strike and remove all barricades and picket lines. Nery alleged that the strike had resulted in daily losses amounting to about (equivalent to ₱397,082 in 2021) and denied the allegations of corruption. He further denounced the strike as "blackmail" and "sabotage" and vowed to press charges against the MMTC workers' union leaders who organized the strike.[31]

MMTC v. D.M. Consortium, Inc.

edit

In the aftermath of the 1989 Philippine coup attempt against the Aquino administration, bus operators JD Transit, Inc. and DM Consortium Inc. ceased operations, causing disruption to bus services. In response, President Corazon Aquino issued Memorandum Order No. 267 on December 7, 1989, directing the Department of Transportation and Communications to temporarily direct or take over the operations of the two transport companies.[32][33]

On December 9, 1989, MMTC repossessed DMCI's buses, occupied its offices, and attempted to auction off 228 repossessed buses that it was leasing from MMTC, alleging that DMCI had defaulted on its amortization payments. DMCI responded by filing for a temporary restraining order against the public auction, which was granted on April 11, 1990.[33]

MMTC filed a motion for reconsideration and a petition for certiorari, but these were denied by the courts. In 1995, the Regional Trial Court ruled in favor of DMCI, finding no legal basis for MMTC to repossess the buses or sell them at auction. Both MMTC and DMCI filed motions for reconsideration, with MMTC arguing it was justified to do so under a lease-purchase agreement, while DMCI argued that MMTC did not ensure just compensation as required by MO No. 267. DMCI also sought damages, claiming the buses had deteriorated during the prolonged legal battle.[33]

In 2001, the Court of Appeals upheld the decision against MMTC and ordered additional compensation, including ₱2 million for DMCI’s offices. MMTC appealed to the Supreme Court, contesting the ruling on the repossession and the ₱2 million compensation. The Supreme Court denied MMTC's appeal in 2007, affirming the Court of Appeals’ decision.[33]

See also

edit

Similar state-owned enterprises

References

edit
  1. ^ a b Executive Order No. 546 (July 23, 1979), Creating a Ministry of Public Works and a Ministry of Transportation and Communications
  2. ^ a b c d e "Technical Report No. 5 - Transportation Terminals". Metro Manila Urban Transportation Integration Study. Japan International Cooperation Agency. 1999.
  3. ^ a b c d e Santiago, Rene (December 2021). "The Rise and Fall of the Love Bus (and the Ghosts of Bus Reforms Past)" (PDF). Philippine Transportation Journal. 4 (1). National Center for Transportation Studies.
  4. ^ a b c Presidential Decree No. 492 (June 27, 1974), Creating The Manila Transit Corporation, Appropriating Funds Therefor And For Other Purposes
  5. ^ Presidential Decree No. 860 (November 7, 1975), Creating the Metropolitan Manila and the Metropolitan Manila Commission and for Other Purposes
  6. ^ Presidential Decree No. 860 (December 25, 1975), Amending the Title and Certain Sections of Presidential Decree Numbered Four Hundred Ninety Two, Entitled "Creating the Manila Transit Corporation, Appropriating the Funds Therefor and for Other Purposes"
  7. ^ a b Rimmer, Peter (1986). Rikisha to Rapid Transit: Urban Public Transport Systems and Policy in Southweast Asia. Pergamon Press.
  8. ^ a b Roxas, Victor Santos III (1977). An economic evaluation of the Metro Manila Transit Corporation (MMTC) in the context of its benefits to the public thru a more effecient and well organized commuter transport (AB-BSBA thesis). De La Salle University.
  9. ^ Presidential Decree No. 1168 (June 27, 1977), Amending Section Four of Presidential Decree No. 492, as Amended, Entitled "Creating the Metro Manila Transit Corporation, Appropriating the Funds Therefor and for Other Purposes".
  10. ^ Presidential Decree No. 1465 (June 11, 1978), Amending Presidential Decree No. 492, as Amended, Entitled "Creating the Metro Manila Transit Corporation, Appropriating the Funds Therefor and for Other Purposes".
  11. ^ a b c d e Sutadisastra, Effendi (1978). A critical study of Metro Manila Transit Corporation (MBA thesis). De La Salle University.
  12. ^ a b Pelkmans, Jacques; Wagner, Norbert, eds. (1990). Privatization and Deregulation in ASEAN and the EC: Making Markets More Effective. ISEAS – Yusof Ishak Institute. ISBN 9789813035652.
  13. ^ Executive Order No. 1011 (March 20, 1985), Establishing the Land Transportation Commission in the Ministry of Transportation and Communications, and for Other Purposes
  14. ^ Rimmer, Peter J. (May 1989). A Tale of Four Cities: Competition and Bus Ownership in Bangkok, Jakarta, Manila and Singapore (PDF). Thredbo – via Thredbo.
  15. ^ Memorandum Order No. 218 (July 13, 1994), Creating a Study Group to Prepare a Strategic Action Plan for the Privatization of the Metro Manila Transit Corporation (MMTC)
  16. ^ Juico, Philip Ella (August 3, 2022). "Fidel V. Ramos: A man dedicated to peace and his people". BusinessWorld. Retrieved September 25, 2024.
  17. ^ Rosales, A. (April 11, 1995). "Metro Manila Transit privatized". Manila Standard. Vol. 9, no. 59. Retrieved November 4, 2024.
  18. ^ G.R. No. 153925 (August 10, 2006), Food Terminal, Inc., et al. vs. Shoppers Paradise FTI Corporation
  19. ^ Burgonio, TJ (November 13, 2012). "Ayala buys FTI for P24.3B". Philippine Daily Inquirer. Archived from the original on November 15, 2012. Retrieved September 30, 2024.
  20. ^ a b c d e f g "Part II: Metro Manila Public Transportation". The Metro Manila Transportation Planning Study (JUMSUT) - Final Report - Main Text. Japan International Cooperation Agency. 1984.
  21. ^ Cal, Primitivo (1979). "Bus and Jeepney Operations in Metro Manila: Problems and Solutions" (PDF). Philippine Planning Journal. 10 (2). UP SURP.
  22. ^ Reyes, Elizabeth (1990). Manila. University of Michigan. ISBN 9789711341299.
  23. ^ a b c d "Supporting Document No. 5: Metro Manila Bus/Jeepney Route Inventory and Planning Data". The Metro Manila Transportation Planning Study (JUMSUT) - Final Report. Japan International Cooperation Agency. 1984.
  24. ^ a b c "Part II: Metro Manila Public Transportation". The Metro Manila Transportation Planning Study (JUMSUT) - Final Report - Main Text. Japan International Cooperation Agency. 1984.
  25. ^ Corpuz, Lynda (November 24, 2014). "Remember the Love Bus? Might be time to have it back". Rappler. Retrieved September 13, 2024.
  26. ^ a b フィリピン国 バス再活性化協力要請背景調査報告書 [Background Survey Report on the Philippines' Request for Cooperation in Bus Revitalization] (in Japanese). Japan International Cooperation Agency. May 1988.
  27. ^ a b フィリピン国 バス再活性化協力総合報告書 [Philippines Bus Revitalization Cooperation Comprehensive Report] (in Japanese). Japan International Cooperation Agency. January 1989.
  28. ^ Francisco, Elmer [@elmerbfrancisco] (January 2, 2024). "Francisco Motor Corporation's HARABAS Taksi" – via Instagram.
  29. ^ Torres, Radito; Soriano, A.F. (May 25, 1987). "20,000 rally anew on EDSA to protest election result". Manila Standard. Vol. 1, no. 104. Retrieved November 4, 2024.
  30. ^ Mahilum, Ed (June 18, 1992). "Thousands lose rides as MMTC workers strike". Manila Standard. Vol. 6, no. 127. Retrieved November 4, 2024.
  31. ^ Mahilum, Ed (June 20, 1992). "Thousands lose rides as MMTC workers strike". Manila Standard. Vol. 6, no. 129. Retrieved November 4, 2024.
  32. ^ Memorandum Order No. 267 (December 7, 1989), Directing the Temporary Take-Over or Direction of the Operations of JD Transit, Inc. and DM Consortium, Inc.
  33. ^ a b c d G.R. No. 147594 (March 7, 2007), Metro Manila Transit Corporation vs. D.M. Consortium, Inc.
edit