E-referrals or electronic referrals or electronic consultation is an electronic platform that enables the seamless transfer of patient information from a primary to a secondary treating practitioner's client management system.[1][2] E-referrals have fast become the best replacement of paper-based referrals, and hold great potential toward the ultimate goal of seamless communication and information sharing between practitioners.[3]
Benefits
editElectronic referrals can result in considerable benefits for service providers. Firstly at the patient level, e-referrals ensure significant improvements to follow-up care coordination[4] by the creation of accurate and timely referrals. Medical decisions are enhanced as each provider involved has the full patient information available to them.[5] Duplicate tests are eliminated as patient information is being shared from one provider to another.[6] The speed of communication is improved by removing delays related to paper-based transmission, ensuring a faster response rate. Also transmission of referral information is secured, upholding Consumer privacy.
Benefits can also be seen beyond the patient level, e-referrals can improve practice productivity. Documentation quality is improved by removing the use of illegible handwriting as well as poor quality faxed documentation. E-referrals create a logical and standardised referral template. Auto-population of clinical information ensures referrals are more clinically complete. There are also significant long term operational cost savings between electronic and paper based referrals.[7]
Barriers
editA variety of barriers exist that inhibit the electronic General practitioner referral pathway to secondary care. These include the high start-up costs such as that of hardware, software and training needed to produce, process, send and receive each electronic referral.[8] Difficulties faced when integrating different information systems to allow technology interface. As well as a slow response due to a deep rooted resistance to change and new technologies.[9]
Architecture framework
editClinical Document Architecture (CDA) is an international standard developed by the organisation Health Level 7 International,[10] outlining the unvarying structure and presentation for clinical documents like that of e-referrals. The CDA:
- Provides a consistent structure for e-referral clinical information
- Guarantees receiving systems can understand and interpret e-referral information
- Allows the automation process of forwarding e-referrals to the correct department.[11]
International review
editThe e-referral initiative has been acknowledged globally, with many countries having successfully adopted the system. Including Finland who implemented the e-referral in 1990, Denmark in 1995,[12] Norway in 1996, Netherlands in 2001, New Zealand in 2007.[13] and Australia in 2009.[14]
| Country Adopting E-referral System | Start Date (Approx) | Number of GPs | No. of e-referrals per year |
|---|---|---|---|
| Finland (Helsinki) | 1990 | 200 | 67,000 (by 2002) |
| Finland (Oulu) | 1991 | 10 | 2,000 (by 2002) |
| Denmark (MedCom-EDI*) | 1995 | 2024 | 41% (by 2004) |
| Denmark | 1995 | 2024 | 63% (by Nov 2008) |
| Norway (ELIN**) | 1996 | N/A | <25% (by Jan 2009) |
| Netherlands (ZorgDomai) | 2001 | 100 | 5,000 (by Dec 2004) |
| Netherlands | 2001 | 2,000 (by 2008) | N/A |
| UK | 2015:06:15 | N/A | |
| New Zealand (Hutt Valley) | 2007 | 34 | >90% (by Jan 2009) |
| Australia | Jun 2009 | 30 | N/A |
* EDI - Electronic Data Interchange ** ELIN - Electronic Information Exchange[3]
Finland
editFinland was the first country to implement an e-referral system, introduced in the capital city of Helsinki in 1990. The e-referral project was put in place to allow for a more cost-effective way of treating a bigger number of patients, increase productivity and to improve access to healthcare. There were two hundred general practitioner practices and one million residents originally involved in the project. It took twelve years but by 2002, a total of sixty-seven thousand e-referrals had been sent.[3][15]
Denmark
editDenmark was the second country to introduce an electronic referral system. This was done so through a nationwide MedCom project implemented in 1995 entitled The Danish Health Care Data Network. This TeleMed project aimed to expand the electronic communication between health service parties, and e-referrals were a part of this.[16] By 2004, forty-one percent of all referrals sent were electronic. Causing a "significant improvement in access to care, quality of care, efficiency and productivity of the health sector".[3][12]
Norway
editThe use of e-referrals began in Norway in 1996, and has been much slower than that of other countries. By January 2009, less than twenty-five percent of all referrals were sent electronically. Remarkably lower than that of Denmark or Finland.[3][14]
Netherlands
editThe development of e-referrals in the Netherlands began in 2001. With one hundred GP's initially involved, by December 2004 five thousand e-referrals had been sent.[3][14]
New Zealand
editThe e-referral project was launched within New Zealand Hutt District in 2007. The project aimed to "provide complete and relevant referral information electronically and make it available to practitioners involved in the patient's care to allow prompt and appropriate clinical decision-making."[17] By 2009, ninety percent of all referrals were electronic. The Hutt Valley District has been acknowledge as the leading district in electronic referrals in New Zealand by the Ministry of Health (New Zealand).[3][13]
Australia
editMost recent to initiate an e-referral system was Australia in June 2009. Approximately thirty General practitioners from the Australian Capital Territory used the electronic system to refer to sixty outpatient service specialists. With many plans underway to increase and expand to other nearby areas of Australia[3][14]
References
edit- ^ eReferral, National E-Health Transition Authority (NEHTA).
- ^ "Electronic referral (E-referral)". Victorian Government Health Information. Archived from the original on 22 February 2014. Retrieved 4 November 2013.
- ^ a b c d e f g h Li Tian, healthAlliance (2011-04-01). "Health Informatics New Zealand". Hinz.org.nz. Archived from the original on 2012-11-16. Retrieved 2013-09-08.
- ^ Hysong, Sylvia J.; Adol Esquivel; Dean F. Sittig; Lindsey A. Paul; Donna Espadas; Simran Singh; Hardeep Singh (2011). "Towards successful coordination of electronic health record based-referrals: a qualitative analysis" (PDF). Implementation Science. 6 (84). Retrieved 4 November 2013.
- ^ Kim, Y; Chen, AH; Keith, E; Yee, HF Jr; Kushel, MB (2009). "Not perfect, but better: primary care providers' experiences with electronic referrals in a safety net health system". Journal of General Internal Medicine. 24 (5): 614–9. doi:10.1007/s11606-009-0955-3. PMC 2669877.
- ^ "Reaping the Benefits of Electronic Patient Referral". Physiciansmoneydigest.com. 2011-03-07. Archived from the original on 2012-11-24. Retrieved 2013-09-08.
- ^ "The cost benefit of electronic patient referrals in Denmark summary report" (PDF). ACCA and MedCom. Retrieved 4 November 2013.[permanent dead link]
- ^ Kim-Hwang, Judy E.; Chen, Alice Hm; Bell, Douglas S.; Guzman, David; Yee, Hal F. Jr.; Kushel, Margot B. (2010). "Evaluating Electronic Referrals for Specialty Care at a Public Hospital" (PDF). Journal of General Internal Medicine. 25 (10): 1123–8. doi:10.1007/s11606-010-1402-1. PMC 2955477.
- ^ "Victorian State-wide Forum on Electronic Referral" (PDF). Department of Human Services. April 2004. Archived from the original (PDF) on 12 August 2008. Retrieved 4 November 2013.
- ^ "What is Clinical Document Architecture (CDA)? - Definition from WhatIs.com". Searchhealthit.techtarget.com. Retrieved 2013-09-08.
- ^ "eReferrals and discharges". Medicare Local: Inner East Melbourne. Archived from the original on 2013-05-03. Retrieved 2013-09-08.
- ^ a b Cannaby, S.; Wanscher CE; Pedersen CD; Voss H. (2005). The Cost Benefit of Electronic Patient Referrals in Denmark. London: MedCom / ACCA.
- ^ a b New guidelines to test e-referrals
- ^ a b c d Heimly V. Electronic Referrals in Healthcare: A Review. Journal of Telemedicine and Telecare 2009; 5:327-331
- ^ Wootton R, Harno K and Reponen J. Organisational Aspects of e-Referrals. Journal of Telemedicine and Telecare 2003; 9 (Suppl 2): 76-79
- ^ "TeleMed" (PDF). MedCom-the Danish Health Care Data Network. December 1999. Archived from the original (PDF) on 5 March 2014. Retrieved 4 November 2013.
- ^ Health Information Strategy Action Committee, Action Zone 8 - eReferrals Preliminary Scope and Approach; 2007 [cited 1 Nov 2009] Archived June 1, 2010, at the Wayback Machine