A variety of behaviors whereby people are highly selective in what they eat and do not eat are known as picky eating or selective eating. Selective eating is common in younger children[1] and can also sometimes be seen in adults.[2]
There is no generally accepted definition of selective eating,[3][4] which can make it difficult to study this behavior.[5] Selective eating can be conceptualised as two separate constructs: picky eating and food neophobia.[4] Picky eaters reject both novel and familiar food whereas food neophobic people are thought to reject unfamiliar foods specifically.[6] Selective eating can be associated with rejecting mixed or lumpy foods.[7] It can also be associated with sensory sensitivity.[8]
Estimates of the prevalence of selective eating vary due to measurement instrument, age of sample, population sample etc.[5] However, studies suggest that feeding problems occur in about 80% of children with intellectual and development disabilities, and in about 25-45% of typically developing children.[9] Consequently, a proportion of selective eaters continue into adulthood with similar eating patterns as during childhood.[10]
Selective eating in children is a common concern for parents, as it may lead to nutritional inadequacies and mealtime struggles.[3] While many cases of selective eating tend to diminish with age,[4] some individuals continue to exhibit discerning eating habits into adulthood, which can impact their overall health and well-being.
There is debate as to whether picky eating represents an eating disorder or is related to eating disorders.[11] Some extreme forms of picky eating are recognised as psychological disorders, like avoidant/restrictive food intake disorder, or have been proposed as psychological disorders, as with orthorexia nervosa.
Causes and contributing factors
editThe etiology of selective eating is not well understood[9] but can be broadly explained through nature and nurture. Nature typically refers to genetic predispositions, which play a significant role in the development of selective eating behaviors. The ability to taste certain bitter thiourea compounds, such as 6-n-propylthiouracil (PROP) and phenylthiocarbamide (PTC), is genetically determined. PROP tasters tend to have more food dislikes due to heightened sensitivity to bitter compounds. As a result, they’re at higher risk of developing selective eating patterns.[12] Additionally, several studies provide evidence that food neophobia is highly heritable. A study conducted on over 5000 twin pairs and their parents found a neophobia heritability estimate of 0.78, although about 25% of phenotypic variation was accounted for by environmental factors.[3]
Environmental influences during early life also shape selective eating behaviors. The impact of early experiences with flavor, both in utero and via breastfeeding, plays a crucial role in shaping food preferences later in life. Fetuses are exposed to the flavors present in the mother's diet through the amniotic fluid, leading to heightened preferences for those flavors postnatally. Breastfeeding further influences flavor preferences, as flavors from the mother's diet are transmitted through breast milk. Infants exposed to various flavors through breastfeeding demonstrate increased acceptance of those flavors during weaning. During weaning, the timing and variety of foods introduced influence children's readiness to consume new and varied foods.[12] Parenting style and feeding practices further influence children's food behaviors. Cole et al’s (2017) systematic review cites several studies indicating that negative, non-responsive feeding styles are positively associated with selective eating. Across these studies, high warmth authoritative parenting was reported as being the most beneficial for implementing healthy eating habits.[13] Lastly, the food environment at home, encompassing food availability and exposure to novel foods, significantly influences children’s food preferences and behaviors. Children exposed to a greater variety of foods at home tend to consume more fruits and vegetables. However, it’s important to note that some families will struggle to provide their children with varied healthy food options due to socioeconomic restrictions or food insecurity.[14]
Ultimately, various factors interact to shape each child’s eating behaviours and food preferences. Early experiences including exposure to flavors in utero and via breastmilk, interact with genetic differences in flavor perception to establish food preferences. Nurture elements such as exposure to different tastes and parental feeding practices can modify feeding behaviors. Conversely, a child's innate preferences, behaviors, and temperament can influence nurture elements. Research indicates that children who are sensitive to sensory stimuli may be less likely to model their parents' fruit and vegetable consumption, highlighting the bidirectional nature of picky eating. Further research is needed to fully understand the intricate interactions between these factors and their relation to selective eating.[12]
Implications of selective eating
editFamily conflict
editSelective eating often causes conflict within the family.[10] Studies have reported impairment in family functioning with both moderate and severe selective eating.[15] Parents of selective eaters commonly report that their children consume a restricted range of foods; require food prepared in particular ways; express strong preferences and aversions towards food and throw tantrums when these are denied. This often leads parents to providing meals for their children that are different from the rest of the family. Selective eating may also be a significant source of concern for parents as it may prompt physician visits and potentially spark conflict between parents regarding how to manage their child's eating behavior.[16]
Physical health
editSelective eating is characterised by a restricted diet. Restricted diet can have a concerning impact on growth and development.[17] Studies show it is associated with poor physical health through nutritional deficiencies including low intakes of iron and zinc as these are associated with low intakes of fruit, vegetables and meat.[18] Also, lower intakes of vitamin C, vitamin E, folate and fibre which may lead to a weakened immune response and digestive problems.[19]
Studies have shown mixed findings regarding the relationship between selective eating and being at risk of being underweight or overweight. Timimi et al. (1997) studied a group of selective eaters (aged 4–14) and found that 'a significant minority has poor growth or weight gain'.[2] Yet, this observation could be attributed to their broadened interpretation of selective eating and the inclusion of much younger children. There remains little evidence for a consistent effect of being a selective eater on growth trajectories.[18] Further research is needed to investigate the effects of selective eating on brain development and metabolism.[17]
Psychosocial symptoms
editSelective eating is linked to eating psychopathology and psychosocial dysfunction.[7] This includes both internalizing (e.g. anxiety, depression) and externalizing (e.g. attention deficit hyperactivity disorder) psychopathology. Both moderate and severe levels of selective eating are associated with psychopathological symptoms, and the severity of these symptoms tends to worsen with more severe selective eating.[15]
Selective eaters tend to show social avoidance, although it's unclear whether this is a result of selective eating behavior or simply reflects a primary social skills deficit. The extent of social avoidance varies but one case study of a 9-year-old boy identifies the impact of selective eating specifically. He missed lunch at school so found it difficult to make friends. It affected how long he could stay at his friend's house. It prevented the whole family from going on visits and this family tension was exacerbated as his dad would get cross and go off with his brothers.[17]
Assessment and diagnosis
editAssessment of selective eating varies due to the lack of universal definition. Considering the complex etiology of selective eating, assessment (and later treatment) ideally should be carried out by an interdisciplinary team of professionals.[9]
One of the most common ways of measuring selective eating is using scales. Selective eating can be measured with a list heuristic, where the number of foods that the person rejects on a standard list is counted.[2] When investigating selective eating in children, parental report tends to be the most common tool of measurement. Two commonly used questionnaires include the Child Eating Behavior Questionnaire Food Fussiness subscale (CEBQ FF)[20] and the Food Neophobia Scale (FNS). These questionnaires have undergone validation against weight-for-age-z score or child body mass index z-score (BMIz), with greater selective eating being negatively correlated with BMIz or weight-for-age z-score. However, a limitation of such scales is that they either rely on individuals to self-identify as selective eaters[21] or rely on parental report which may be biased. Parents may struggle to accurately gauge the extent to which their child's eating habits differ from typical behavior for children, or they may find that their perception of their child's eating behavior is influenced by their own concerns regarding eating and feeding habits.[5]
Therefore, it can be helpful to validate selective eating scales against observational measures. There are a range of ways to conduct observational assessments of selective eating behavior. One study tested participants individually and told them that they were participating in a study of the relation between mood and taste perception. They were presented with various types of cookies and asked to rate them along various dimensions and told to eat as many as they wanted as fresh cookies would be baked for each participant. Following the taste test, participants completed a packet of surveys including dietary restraint scales as well as distractor scales (e.g. mood measures). Each of the plates was weighed before and after participant arrival to provide an unobtrusive measure of total caloric intake.[22]
Extreme forms of selective eating have been recognized as psychological disorders such as Avoidant/Restrictive Food Intake Disorder (ARFID). These should be assessed through diagnosis. The DSM-5 includes a ‘feeding and eating disorders’ section and covers several diagnoses that may be related to selective eating.[23]
See also
edit- Dietary conservatism, the prolonged reluctance to eat novel foods, a foraging strategy observed in animals
References
edit- ^ Walton, Kathryn; Kuczynski, Leon; Haycraft, Emma; Breen, Andrea; Haines, Jess (2017). "Time to re-think picky eating?: A relational approach to understanding picky eating". International Journal of Behavioral Nutrition and Physical Activity. 14 (1): 62. doi:10.1186/s12966-017-0520-0. PMC 5420103. PMID 28476160.
- ^ a b c Potts, Henry W.W.; Wardle, Jane (1998). "The List Heuristic for Studying Personality Correlates of Food Choice Behaviour: A Review and Results from Two Samples". Appetite. 30 (1): 79–92. doi:10.1006/appe.1997.0087. PMID 9584064. S2CID 23389215.
- ^ a b c Taylor, Caroline M.; Emmett, Pauline M. (2019). "Picky eating in children: Causes and consequences". Proceedings of the Nutrition Society. 78 (2): 161–169. doi:10.1017/S0029665118002586. PMC 6398579. PMID 30392488.
- ^ a b c Cardona Cano, S.; Hoek, Hans W.; Bryant-Waugh, Rachel (2015). "Picky eating". Current Opinion in Psychiatry. 28 (6): 448–454. doi:10.1097/YCO.0000000000000194. PMID 26382157. S2CID 31066057.
- ^ a b c Fernandez, Carmen; DeJesus, Jasmine M.; Miller, Alison L.; Appugliese, Danielle P.; Rosenblum, Katherine L.; Lumeng, Julie C.; Pesch, Megan H. (August 2018). "Selective eating behaviors in children: An observational validation of parental report measures". Appetite. 127: 163–170. doi:10.1016/j.appet.2018.04.028. ISSN 0195-6663. PMC 5994375. PMID 29729326.
- ^ Dovey, Terence M.; Staples, Paul A.; Gibson, E. Leigh; Halford, Jason C.G. (August 2008). "Food neophobia and 'picky/fussy' eating in children: A review". Appetite. 50 (2–3): 181–193. doi:10.1016/j.appet.2007.09.009. ISSN 0195-6663. PMID 17997196.
- ^ a b Kauer, Jane; Pelchat, Marcia L.; Rozin, Paul; Zickgraf, Hana F. (2015). "Adult picky eating. Phenomenology, taste sensitivity, and psychological correlates". Appetite. 90: 219–228. doi:10.1016/j.appet.2015.03.001. PMC 8477986. PMID 25747855.
- ^ Wildes, Jennifer E.; Zucker, Nancy L.; Marcus, Marsha D. (2012). "Picky eating in adults: Results of a web-based survey". International Journal of Eating Disorders. 45 (4): 575–582. doi:10.1002/eat.20975. PMID 22331752.
- ^ a b c Volkert, Valerie M.; Patel, Meeta R.; Peterson, Kathryn M. (2016), "Food Refusal and Selective Eating", Evidence-Based Practices in Behavioral Health, Cham: Springer International Publishing, pp. 137–161, doi:10.1007/978-3-319-27297-9_7, ISBN 978-3-319-27295-5
- ^ a b Van Tine, Meredith L.; McNicholas, Fiona; Safer, Debra L.; Agras, W. Stewart (August 2017). "Follow-up of selective eaters from childhood to adulthood". Eating Behaviors. 26: 61–65. doi:10.1016/j.eatbeh.2017.01.003. ISSN 1471-0153. PMID 28152419.
- ^ Jacobi, Corinna; Schmitz, Gabriele; Agras, W. Stewart (2008). "Is picky eating an eating disorder?". International Journal of Eating Disorders. 41 (7): 626–634. doi:10.1002/eat.20545. PMID 18454484.
- ^ a b c Patel, Meera D.; Donovan, Sharon M.; Lee, Soo-Yeun (2020-11-06). "Considering Nature and Nurture in the Etiology and Prevention of Picky Eating: A Narrative Review". Nutrients. 12 (11): 3409. doi:10.3390/nu12113409. ISSN 2072-6643. PMC 7694604. PMID 33171966.
- ^ Cole, Natasha Chong; An, Ruopeng; Lee, Soo-Yeun; Donovan, Sharon M (2017-05-23). "Correlates of picky eating and food neophobia in young children: a systematic review and meta-analysis". Nutrition Reviews. 75 (7): 516–532. doi:10.1093/nutrit/nux024. ISSN 0029-6643. PMID 28535257.
- ^ Best, Maisy; Papies, Esther K. (September 2019). "Lower socioeconomic status is associated with higher intended consumption from oversized portions of unhealthy food" (PDF). Appetite. 140: 255–268. doi:10.1016/j.appet.2019.05.009. ISSN 0195-6663. PMID 31082447.
- ^ a b "Psychological and Psychosocial Impairment in Preschoolers With Selective Eating". Pediatrics. 136 (3): X19. 2015-08-03. doi:10.1542/peds.2014-2386d. ISSN 0031-4005.
- ^ Mascola, Anthony J.; Bryson, Susan W.; Agras, W. Stewart (December 2010). "Picky eating during childhood: A longitudinal study to age 11years". Eating Behaviors. 11 (4): 253–257. doi:10.1016/j.eatbeh.2010.05.006. ISSN 1471-0153. PMC 2943861. PMID 20850060.
- ^ a b c Nicholls, Dasha; Christie, Deborah; Randall, Louise; Lask, Bryan (April 2001). "Selective Eating: Symptom, Disorder or Normal Variant". Clinical Child Psychology and Psychiatry. 6 (2): 257–270. doi:10.1177/1359104501006002007. ISSN 1359-1045.
- ^ a b Taylor, Caroline M.; Emmett, Pauline M. (2018-11-05). "Picky eating in children: causes and consequences". Proceedings of the Nutrition Society. 78 (2): 161–169. doi:10.1017/s0029665118002586. ISSN 0029-6651. PMC 6398579. PMID 30392488.
- ^ Wolstenholme, Hazel; Kelly, Colette; Hennessy, Marita; Heary, Caroline (2020-01-03). "Childhood fussy/picky eating behaviours: a systematic review and synthesis of qualitative studies". International Journal of Behavioral Nutrition and Physical Activity. 17 (1): 2. doi:10.1186/s12966-019-0899-x. ISSN 1479-5868. PMC 6942299. PMID 31900163.
- ^ Carnell, Susan; Wardle, Jane (January 2007). "Measuring behavioural susceptibility to obesity: Validation of the child eating behaviour questionnaire". Appetite. 48 (1): 104–113. doi:10.1016/j.appet.2006.07.075. ISSN 0195-6663. PMID 16962207.
- ^ Ellis, Jordan M.; Galloway, Amy T.; Webb, Rose Mary; Martz, Denise M. (August 2017). "Measuring adult picky eating: The development of a multidimensional self-report instrument". Psychological Assessment. 29 (8): 955–966. doi:10.1037/pas0000387. ISSN 1939-134X. PMID 27643793.
- ^ Stice, Eric; Fisher, Melissa; Lowe, Michael R. (2004). "Are Dietary Restraint Scales Valid Measures of Acute Dietary Restriction? Unobtrusive Observational Data Suggest Not". Psychological Assessment. 16 (1): 51–59. doi:10.1037/1040-3590.16.1.51. ISSN 1939-134X. PMID 15023092.
- ^ Zimmerman, Jacqueline; Fisher, Martin (April 2017). "Avoidant/Restrictive Food Intake Disorder (ARFID)". Current Problems in Pediatric and Adolescent Health Care. 47 (4): 95–103. doi:10.1016/j.cppeds.2017.02.005. ISSN 1538-5442. PMID 28532967.