Keith number

This article is about the mathematics concept. For the political concept, see Countdown with Keith Olbermann.

In recreational mathematics, a Keith number or repfigit number (short for repetitive Fibonacci-like digit) is a natural number $n$ in a given number base $b$ with $k$ digits such that when a sequence is created such that the first $k$ terms are the $k$ digits of $n$ and each subsequent term is the sum of the previous $k$ terms, $n$ is part of the sequence. Keith numbers were introduced by Mike Keith in 1987. They are computationally very challenging to find, with only about 100 known.

Definition

Let $n$ be a natural number, let $k=\lfloor \log _{b}{n}\rfloor +1$ be the number of digits of $n$ in base $b$, and let

$d_{i}={\frac {n{\bmod {b}}^{i+1}-n{\bmod {b}}^{i}}{b^{i}}}$

be the value of each digit of $n$.

We define the sequence $S(i)$ by a linear recurrence relation. For $0\leq i<k$,

$S(i)=d_{k-i-1}$

and for $i\geq k$

$S(i)=\sum _{j=0}^{k}S(i-k+j)$

If there exists an $i$ such that $S(i)=n$, then $n$ is said to be a Keith number.

For example, 88 is a Keith number in base 6, as

$S(0)=d_{3-0-1}=d_{2}={\frac {88{\bmod {6}}^{2+1}-88{\bmod {6}}^{2}}{6^{2}}}={\frac {88{\bmod {2}}16-88{\bmod {3}}6}{36}}={\frac {88-16}{36}}={\frac {72}{36}}=2$

$S(1)=d_{3-1-1}=d_{1}={\frac {88{\bmod {6}}^{1+1}-88{\bmod {6}}^{1}}{6^{1}}}={\frac {88{\bmod {3}}6-88{\bmod {6}}}{6}}={\frac {16-4}{6}}={\frac {12}{6}}=2$

$S(2)=d_{3-2-1}=d_{0}={\frac {88{\bmod {6}}^{0+1}-88{\bmod {6}}^{0}}{6^{0}}}={\frac {88{\bmod {6}}-88{\bmod {1}}}{1}}={\frac {4-0}{1}}={\frac {4}{1}}=4$

and the entire sequence

$S(i)=\{2,2,4,8,14,26,48,88,162,\ldots \}$

and $S(7)=88$.

Finding Keith numbers

Whether or not there are infinitely many Keith numbers in a particular base $b$ is currently a matter of speculation. Keith numbers are rare and hard to find. They can be found by exhaustive search, and no more efficient algorithm is known. According to Keith, in base 10, on average $\textstyle {\frac {9}{10}}\log _{2}{10}\approx 2.99$ Keith numbers are expected between successive powers of 10. Known results seem to support this.

Examples

14, 19, 28, 47, 61, 75, 197, 742, 1104, 1537, 2208, 2580, 3684, 4788, 7385, 7647, 7909, 31331, 34285, 34348, 55604, 62662, 86935, 93993, 120284, 129106, 147640, 156146, 174680, 183186, 298320, 355419, 694280, 925993, 1084051, 7913837, 11436171, 33445755, 44121607, 129572008, 251133297, ...

Other bases

In base 2, there exists a method to construct all Keith numbers.

The Keith numbers in base 12, written in base 12, are

11, 15, 1Ɛ, 22, 2ᘔ, 31, 33, 44, 49, 55, 62, 66, 77, 88, 93, 99, ᘔᘔ, ƐƐ, 125, 215, 24ᘔ, 405, 42ᘔ, 654, 80ᘔ, 8ᘔ3, ᘔ59, 1022, 1662, 2044, 3066, 4088, 4ᘔ1ᘔ, 4ᘔƐ1, 50ᘔᘔ, 8538, Ɛ18Ɛ, 17256, 18671, 24ᘔ78, 4718Ɛ, 517Ɛᘔ, 157617, 1ᘔ265ᘔ, 5ᘔ4074, 5ᘔƐ140, 6Ɛ1449, 6Ɛ8515, ...

where ᘔ represents 10 and Ɛ represents 11.

Keith clusters

A Keith cluster is a related set of Keith numbers such that one is a multiple of another. For example, in base 10, $\{14,28\}$, $\{1104,2208\}$, and $\{31331,62662,93993\}$ are all Keith clusters. These are possibly the only three examples of a Keith cluster in base 10.

Programming example

The example below implements the sequence defined above in Python to determine if a number in a particular base is a Keith number:

def is_repfigit(x: int, b: int) -> bool:
    """Determine if a number in a particular base is a Keith number."""
    if x == 0:
        return True

    sequence = []
    y = x

    while y > 0:
        sequence.append(y % b)
        y = y // b

    digit_count = len(sequence)
    sequence.reverse()

    while sequence[len(sequence) - 1] < x:
        n = 0
        for i in range(0, digit_count):
            n = n + sequence[len(sequence) - digit_count + i]
        sequence.append(n)

    return sequence[len(sequence) - 1] == x

See also

• Arithmetic dynamics
• Fibonacci number
• Linear recurrence relation