The examples and perspective in this article may not represent a worldwide view of the subject. (May 2019) |
An essay mill (also term paper mill) is a business that allows customers to commission an original piece of writing on a particular topic so that they may commit academic fraud. Customers provide the company with specific information about the essay, including number of pages, general topic, and a time frame to work within. The customer is charged a certain amount per page.[1] A similar concept is the essay bank, a company from which students can purchase prewritten but less expensive essays on various topics, at higher risk of being caught. Both forms of business are under varying legal restraints in some jurisdictions.
History
The idea behind term paper mills can be dated back to the mid-nineteenth century, when "paper reservoirs" were located in the basements of fraternity houses. Otherwise known as "fraternity files," these were used by students who shared term papers and submitted work that had been done by other students.[2][clarification needed] These essay banks inspired the commercialization of ghostwritten essay-writing practices. As early as the 1950s, advertisements circulating on college campuses described services that included ghostwritten work for dissertations, theses, and term papers.[2]
In conjunction with this practice, the changing attitudes of students in the 1960s and 1970s started to stray away from diligent and engaged coursework because they saw an emphasis on the benefits of community involvement. A new focus on activities outside of the classroom took away from time to focus on classwork, thus promoting these writing services throughout college campuses.[2]
Later, actual businesses located near college campuses charged students for custom-written essays.[3] One could walk into a building and peruse pricing pamphlets, speak to someone directly to place an order, or possibly make a selection from a vault of recycled research papers stored in the basement of these businesses.[2]
Products and services
"Essay mill" companies hire university students, graduates, and professional writers to ghostwrite essays and term papers, and use advertising targeting students. Until the early 1990s, most essay mill companies were 'bricks and mortar' businesses offering their services by mail order or from offices in university or college towns.[3] By the 2000s, most essay mill businesses had switched to an e-commerce business model, soliciting business and selling essays on the Internet. Companies often provide free sample essays on popular topics to attract Internet searches.
To obtain an essay, a customer usually submits a form that describes the assignment that he or she wants completed, how many pages it needs to be, and when it needs to be completed. An employee searches through requests until he or she finds something that looks interesting that he or she can write quickly and that will satisfy the page requirement. It does not matter if the writer has previous knowledge about the subject; if it is easy to research, he or she will get the job done.[1]
Depending on how much a student pays an essay mill, a student can receive a number of different products. The most expensive of these products are full written essays or even dissertations. Requested papers can follow specific guidelines laid out by the student, including the use of a certain number of sources, a preselected topic, and the receiving of specific grade by the student. Some students may request to receive a high mark on a purchased essay in order to boost their grade point average (GPA), while some may deliberately order an essay that will give them a "C" in order to reduce suspicion of academic fraud. Cheaper options include detailed outlines of information to be included in essays that students write themselves. Due to the minimalist nature of this type of transaction, it can be very difficult for schools to catch this type of paid academic assistance.
Similar to essay mills, essay banks sell students prewritten essays. Due to the nature of essay bank essays, students are more likely to be caught committing academic dishonesty. Because of this, essay bank essays in general may cost less than those from essay mills.
Legal status
The first major legal battle against an essay mill came in 1972 in the case of State of New York v. Saksniit.[4] This case involved the state challenging an essay mill's business with reference to the New York Education Law. The law "condemns the obtaining of a degree by fraudulent means or 'aiding and abetting' another to do the same."[5] The state claimed that the students were using the term papers they purchased for credit and even though the company stated that the essays they wrote were for research purposes only, their advertising scheme encouraged otherwise by boasting about grades.[4] The court determined that the disclaimers did not sufficiently protect the company because their encouragement of cheating and plagiarism hurt the educational system. The ruling called for the company to cease business in the State of New York.[5] Several other legal battles have been fought since and have largely resulted in the punishment of the term paper writers rather than the students purchasing them.
California Education Code Section 66400 "penalizes the preparation or sale of term papers, theses, or dissertations for compensation ...." The law is applicable when the preparer/seller knew or should have known that the recipient would submit the paper for academic credit. State residents or academic institutions "acting for the interest of itself, its students, or the general public" can file suit against offenders for "any relief as is necessary."[6][unreliable source][dead link] This law differs from that of New York in various ways, including holding the vendor responsible even if it claims that the paper was not intended to be turned in for credit, if the court concludes that it should have known that it would, or if the claim is not credible. For example, while some essay mills state that their products are not intended to be submitted for credit, they may also boast of the high grades that their papers have received.
The 2011 Florida Statutes Section 877.17 states that it is a second degree misdemeanor to "sell, offer to sell, or advertise for sale" a "written, recorded, pictorial, artistic, or other assignment" to another for submission "unaltered to a substantial degree."[6] In the state of Florida, second degree misdemeanors are punishable by up to sixty days in prison.
In total, 17 US states have some form of legal regime prohibiting academic cheating services.[7]
Essay mills and similar academic cheating services are also illegal in England and Wales, Australia, Ireland, New Zealand and Austria, among other jurisdictions.[8] Scholars have indicated that these laws, many of which are drawn up without knowledge or intent requirements, may be so large in scope as to criminalise the provision and advertising of many general purpose, generative AI systems, such as online large language models.[8]
Criticism and controversy
The academic community has criticized essay mill companies for helping students to commit academic fraud.
Some essay mills have defended themselves against criticism by claiming that they are selling pre-written examples which students can use as guidelines and models for the student's own work. In 2002, a UK-based essay mill called Elizabeth Hall Associates required students purchasing essays to sign a disclaimer stating that "any material provided by Elizabeth Hall Associates [is] on the understanding that it is a guidance model only."[9] Other essay mills claim that they are "scholarly publishing houses" that provide students with essays that the student can then cite in the student's own work.
Students from different academic backgrounds have used essay mills. Many prestigious universities and colleges have caught their students turning in papers they bought from essay mills.[1] The University of California, San Diego caught 600 students cheating in one year. One of the forms of cheating was turning in papers bought from essay mills.[10]
Term paper mills bring up ethical controversies. Some people view them as unethical, others as completely moral. People view essay mills as ethical for different reasons. Some customers say they use essay mills as a form of proofreading. Essay mill writers will read their writing only to make comments and feedback about content and grammar mistakes. They also turn to essay mills to insure that all citations are correct.[1] Some customers claim they turn to essay mills because society has put too much pressure on students to achieve academic success. GPAs and grades are greatly stressed in schools which causes students to worry and make them feel like they cannot meet their deadlines.[11] Some students turn to paper mills to get a paper handed in on time. Essay mills have been compared to business situations. Some students view term paper mills as equivalent to companies outsourcing labor, a norm for businesses, insinuating that using term paper mills should be socially acceptable.[1]
Others view purchasing essays from essay mills as unethical: it is a form of cheating and plagiarism because one person is taking credit for another's work. Academic institutions are concerned about how essay mills affect learning. Students who use essay mills do not go through the process of gathering research, which is a learning experience in itself. Some professors, such as Dan Ariely, a professor of psychology and behavioral economics at Duke University and the author of The (Honest) Truth About Dishonesty, worry about the message that term paper mills send to students. He says the existence of essay mills encourages laziness to be seen as acceptable. Ariely found essay mills that use plagiarism-encouraging language on their websites.[12]
According to a study by Patrick Scanlon and David Neumann, 90% of students surveyed admitted that the practice is unethical. The same study showed that students believe around 20% of their peers frequently use these online services.[13]
Many customers believe that when they are ordering an essay online, that they are going to be receiving one from their own country; however, this is not always the case, as essay mill companies are hosted around the world.[1] Not only are many of the essay mill companies hosted overseas, but many of the writers for these companies do not have graduate[clarification needed (undergraduate or postgraduate?)] degrees, and have learned English as their second language.[1]
Having essay mills set up internationally allows for the owners of these companies to make high profits by paying wages in low-wage countries while selling the work of their employees in high-wage countries. A 2009 article in The Chronicle of Higher Education stated that overseas writers only get paid between $1 and $3 per page out of the $20 to $30 US-customers pay per page.[1] Compared to US-based writers that work for essay mills, this is a very low rate. Another article in The Chronicle of Higher Education from 2010 interviewed an American essay mill writer, who stated that he receives half of the money paid by a client for a paper.[14]
Within the US, the amount that writers are paid varies by up to a factor of five as of 2010[update]. Some US writers earn around $1,000 per month in their highest paying months, which, as of 2009[update], is a low wage.[1] Some of the better writers are able to earn up to $5,000 per month.[14]
Strategies for combating academic fraud
Universities and colleges have developed several strategies to combat this type of academic misconduct. Some professors require students to submit electronic versions of their term papers, so that the text of the essay can be compared by anti-plagiarism software (such as Turnitin) against databases of known "essay mill" term papers, and new software called Authorship Investigate, also by Turnitin, can look at a paper and compare it against a student's other writings to yield a probabilistic estimate of whether the student is the real author.
Other universities have enacted rules allowing professors to give students oral examinations on papers which a professor believes to be ghostwritten; if the student is unfamiliar with the content of an essay that he or she has submitted, or its sources, then the student can be charged with academic fraud, a violation of the rules by which a student agrees to be bound when he or she enters a university or college program.
When a student is charged with academic fraud, his or her case is typically heard by a quasi-judicial administrative committee, which reviews the evidence. For students who are found guilty, the punishments range from a grade of zero on the specific assignment, to failure in the course in which the plagiarism occurred, to (in extreme or repeated cases) suspension or expulsion from the institution. In some cases, students who have committed academic fraud may also have academic honors, degrees, or awards revoked.
See also
References
- ^ a b c d e f g h i Bartlett, Thomas (March 2009). "Cheating Goes Global as Essay Mills Multiply". The Chronicle of Higher Education.
- ^ a b c d Stavisky, Leonard Price (1973). "Term Paper 'Mills', Academic Plagiarism, and State Regulation". Political Science Quarterly. 88 (3): 445–461. doi:10.2307/2148993. JSTOR 2148993.
- ^ a b Pemberton, Michael (March 1992). "Threshold of Desperation: Winning the Fight Against Term Paper Mills". Writing Instructor. 11 (3): 143–152.
- ^ a b Decision, State of New York v. Saksniit Archived March 4, 2016, at the Wayback Machine, 69 Misc.2d 554 (1972). New York State Supreme Court, Special Term, New York County. April 18, 1972. Via Leagle.com. Accessed: August 12, 2015.
- ^ a b Jeffes, Errin J.; Janosik, Steven M. (2002). "The Courts' Response to Student Cheating with the Help of Term Paper Mills: Implications for Student Affairs Administrators". College Student Affairs Journal. 21 (2): 68.
- ^ a b Mocello, Marie (13 November 2013). "Essay Mills 101: Selling College Term Papers Online May Be a Crime". Yahoo Contributor Network: Yahoo Voices.
- ^ "Term Paper Mills: Statutes and Legislative Information". Research Guides at Florida State University College of Law Research Center. Archived from the original on Sep 8, 2023. Retrieved 2023-09-08.
- ^ a b Gaumann, Noëlle; Veale, Michael (7 September 2023). "AI Providers as Criminal Essay Mills? Large Language Models meet Contract Cheating Law". SocArxiv. Faculty of Laws, University College London. doi:10.31235/osf.io/cpbfd. Retrieved 2023-09-08.
- ^ Major, Lee Elliot (8 January 2002). "Web of Deceit". The Guardian. Retrieved May 15, 2014.
- ^ Ruff, Bob; Costello, Carol. "Educating America: Cheating on Papers is a Booming Web Business". American Morning Blogs. CNN. Archived from the original on 2014-05-12. Retrieved 2014-05-09.
- ^ "Ethics in Computing". ethics.csc.ncsu.edu. North Carolina State University. Retrieved August 12, 2015.
- ^ Ariely, Dan (June 2012). "Essay Mills – A Coarse Lesson on Cheating". Los Angeles Times.
- ^ Scanlon, Patrick; Neumann, David (2002). "Internet Plagiarism among College Students". Journal of College Student Development. 43 (3): 374–386.
- ^ a b Dante, Ed (November 2010). "The Shadow Scholar". The Chronicle of Higher Education.
Further reading
- The Cheating Culture: Why More Americans Are Doing Wrong To Get Ahead. New York: Harcourt. 2004. ISBN 9780151010189.[full citation needed]
- Lathrop, Ann; Foss, Kathleen (2000). Student Cheating & Plagiarism to the Internet Era: A Wake-Up Call for Educators & Parents. New York: Libraries Unlimited.
- Page, James (2004). "Cyber-pseudepigraphy: A New Challenge for Higher Education Policy and Management" (PDF). Journal of Higher Education Policy and Management. 26 (3): 429–433. doi:10.1080/1360080042000290267. S2CID 216140181.