Philip Joseph Shiner (born 25 December 1956) is a British former human rights solicitor. He was struck off the roll of solicitors in England and Wales in 2017 over misconduct relating to false abuse claims against British troops. He was Head of Strategic Litigation at Public Interest Lawyers (International) from 2014 until the firm's closure on 31 August 2016. He had previously been Principal at Public Interest Lawyers Ltd from 1999 to 2014.[1][2]
Philip Joseph Shiner | |
|---|---|
| Born | 25 December 1956 |
| Nationality | British |
| Alma mater | |
| Known for | Iraq Historic Allegations Team |
| Children | 5 |
Early life and career
editShiner was brought up in Coventry, where he was educated at a Catholic comprehensive school.[3] He later attended the University of Birmingham (LLB, 1978) and the University of Warwick (LLM, 1985).[4] He was an honorary research fellow at the University of Warwick from 1999 to 2004, an honorary professor of law at London Metropolitan University from 2005 to 2013, and a visiting fellow at the London School of Economics from 2005 to 2013. In July 2012, the University of Kent awarded him an honorary doctorate of law,[5] which the university revoked in November 2017 following the findings of misconduct against him.[6]
Shiner was named human rights lawyer of the year in 2004, an award given jointly by the human rights organisations Liberty and JUSTICE, for "his tremendous skill, tenacity and dedication to fighting for justice".[7] In 2007, he was named the Law Society's solicitor of the year.[7] From 2004 to 2014 he was a regular contributor to The Guardian newspaper.[8] In 2024, Shiner's honours and awards were rescinded.
Misconduct findings
editBackground
editShiner had "led the pursuit of legal claims against British troops for their treatment of Iraqi detainees after the 2003 invasion".[9] The law firm Public Interest Lawyers (PIL), of which he was the only director and the owner of 100% of its shares (and which subsequently closed down in August 2016), was "instrumental in passing on about 65% of the 3,392 allegations received by" the Iraq Historic Allegations Team (Ihat).[9]
Early courtroom successes for him in the Baha Mousa case were followed by controversy about other allegations, "the most serious of which turned out to be wholly untrue".[9] He claimed that "UK soldiers had captured, tortured and murdered innocent Iraqi civilians after the Battle of Danny Boy near Amara in 2004".[9] In 2014, a report by the Al-Sweady Inquiry showed that the dead "had been members of the Mahdi army militia, who ambushed a British patrol and were killed in exchanges of gunfire. Shiner subsequently admitted paying an Iraqi middleman to find claimants, a practice that is in breach of professional standards".[9]
Admissions and defence
editShiner was charged before the Solicitors Disciplinary Tribunal but did not attend its two-day hearing, after telling it in writing that "he was unwell and could not afford to pay for a defence lawyer".[9] He "admitted eight allegations of acting without integrity, including that he made 'unsolicited direct approaches' to potential clients",[9] and he also admitted "another allegation of acting recklessly".[9] Andrew Tabachnik, prosecuting for the Solicitors Regulation Authority, said that "Shiner's defence to the dishonesty charges ... was effectively: 'I was not in full control of my mental faculties at this time and I didn't know right from wrong and what I am doing.'"[9]
Findings against him
editThe tribunal found him "guilty of multiple professional misconduct charges, including dishonesty and lack of integrity".[9] Twenty-two "misconduct charges ... were proved to the criminal standard of beyond reasonable doubt. Two other charges were left to lie on the file."[9]
By February 2017, the Solicitors Disciplinary Tribunal struck him off the Roll of Solicitors and also ordered him to "pay for the full costs of the prosecution, starting with an interim downpayment of £250,000".[9][10]
Criminal charges
editIn June 2022, Shiner was charged with three counts of fraud and entered a plea of Not Guilty. The charges related to claims made against British soldiers in Iraq. Shiner was alleged to have failed to disclose to the Legal Aid Agency that he had engaged in cold-calling to solicit cases and had paid referral fees to agents in Iraq. It was also alleged that he committed fraud by false representation by providing an ‘untrue and misleading’ response to a question from the Solicitors Regulation Authority.[11] Shiner's trial was set for September 2024.[12]
On September 30, 2024, Shiner pleaded guilty to three counts of fraud, and his sentencing was scheduled for December that year.[13]
Other consequences
editBy the time Shiner was struck off in February 2017, Ihat "had fewer than 250 active investigations".[9] About a week later Britain's Defence Secretary Michael Fallon announced that Ihat would soon be shut down, largely due to the exposing of Shiner's "dishonesty".[14]
When welcoming the decision to strike him off, the chief executive of the Solicitors Regulation Authority, Paul Philip, stated:
His misconduct has caused real distress to soldiers, their families and to the families of Iraqi people who thought that their loved ones had been murdered or tortured. More than £30m of public funds were spent on investigating what proved to be false and dishonest allegations.[9]
Shiner's disgrace also resulted in criticism by former army officers of Baroness Shami Chakrabarti, the Labour Party's shadow attorney general. Johnny Mercer MP, a retired Army captain, criticised her for "an almost child-like understanding of military operations" and for "trying to retrospectively apply European Human Rights Law to the battlefield". Richard Kemp a retired Army colonel accused Chakrabarti of being "one of [Shiner's] greatest supporters" before his downfall, and of "helping him lose his way" as a result of such support. She said that she had been saddened by Shiner's downfall and had said that, before apparently "losing his way", he had "given good service to the public" and "did some very good work that has been upheld by a judicial inquiry into, for example, the torture and killing of Baha Mousa in Iraq."[15]
Bankruptcy
editShiner declared himself bankrupt in March 2017, owing almost £7 million. In February 2018, the Insolvency Service (IS) found that Shiner had sold his own house to his family and put it into a trust that had allowed him to live there. He also sold two commercial properties for £550,000 each and transferred two £3,500 guitars into the family trust. The IS estimates they have recovered over £483,000 but must continue to work on locating another £6.5 million of Shiner's assets.[16]
In popular culture
editShiner was portrayed by Toby Jones in the 2021 BBC Two drama Danny Boy, which retold the story of the Al-Sweady Inquiry.[17]
References
edit- ^ "Iraq lawyer Phil Shiner struck off over misconduct". BBC News. 2 February 2017. Retrieved 2 February 2017.
- ^ Farmer, Ben (2 February 2017). "Disgraced Iraq human rights lawyer Phil Shiner struck off over false abuse claims against British troops". The Daily Telegraph. Retrieved 2 February 2017.
- ^ Rayment, Sean (2 October 2024). "He was the lawyer who helped the Left trash the Armed Forces – but his lies could put him in prison". The Telegraph.
- ^ "SHINER, Prof. Philip Joseph". Who's Who. 2017. Retrieved 17 March 2017.
- ^ "Phil Shiner". University of Kent. July 2012. Retrieved 2 February 2017.
- ^ 'Phil Shiner Stripped of Honorary Doctorate'. Inquire (2017-11-07). Retrieved 2018-05-01.
- ^ a b Bowcott, Owen (2 February 2017). "Lawyer ignored rules in claims against soldiers in Iraq, tribunal hears". The Guardian. Retrieved 2 February 2017.
- ^ "Phil Shiner". Journalisted. 2017. Retrieved 17 March 2017.
- ^ a b c d e f g h i j k l m n Bowcott, Owen (2 February 2017). "Phil Shiner: Iraq human rights lawyer struck off over misconduct". The Guardian. Retrieved 11 February 2017.
- ^ Rose, Neil (24 March 2017). "Shiner "let nothing get in the way" of securing high-profile and lucrative cases, says SDT". Legal Futures. Retrieved 2022-11-25.
- ^ Tobin, Sam (27 June 2022). "Phil Shiner pleads not guilty to fraud over Iraqi civilians claims". Law Gazette. Retrieved 2022-06-27.
- ^ Rose, Neil (21 November 2022). "Shiner faces two-year wait for trial on cold-calling fraud charges". Legal Futures. Retrieved 2022-11-25.
- ^ Rigley, Stephen (30 September 2024). "Disgraced human rights lawyer admits fraud linked to claims against Iraqi war veterans". LBC.
- ^ "Iraq war allegations probe to end". BBC News. 10 February 2017. Retrieved 11 February 2017.
- ^ Farmer, Ben (12 February 2017). "Disgraced Iraq lawyer Phil Shiner 'did good work, but lost his way' says Labour Baroness Chakrabarti". The Sunday Telegraph. Retrieved 15 February 2017.
- ^ Harley, Nicola; Mendick, Robert (26 February 2018). "Iraq lawyer's Deals to Move Guitars". The Telegraph. p. 11. ISSN 0307-1235.
- ^ "Is BBC's Danny Boy a true story? How a soldier was falsely accused of murder". Radio Times. Retrieved 13 May 2022.