Wikipedia

Same-sex marriage in Montana

(Redirected from Recognition of same-sex unions in Montana)

Same-sex marriage has been recognized in Montana since a federal district court ruled the state's ban on same-sex marriage unconstitutional on November 19, 2014. Montana had previously denied marriage rights to same-sex couples by statute since 1997 and in its State Constitution since 2004. The state appealed the ruling to the Ninth Circuit Court of Appeals, but before that court could hear the case, the U.S. Supreme Court struck down all same-sex marriage bans in the country in Obergefell v. Hodges, mooting any remaining appeals.

edit

Statute

edit

In 1997, the Montana Legislature passed a ban on same-sex marriage and any "contractual relationship entered into for the purpose of achieving a civil relationship".[1][2][3]

Constitution

edit

On November 2, 2004, Montana voters approved Initiative 96, a state-initiated constitutional amendment that prohibited the recognition of same-sex marriage, as well as anything "identical or substantially similar to marital status" in the state of Montana.[4]

Lawsuits

edit

Rolando v. Fox

edit

Four same-sex couples represented by the American Civil Liberties Union (ACLU) and local attorneys filed a lawsuit in federal district court in Great Falls on May 21, 2014, challenging the Montana Constitution's definition of marriage as the "union of one man and one woman" and related statutes. The plaintiffs in the suit, Rolando v. Fox, were three couples (Shauna and Nicole Goubeaux, Ben Milano and Chase Weinhandl, and Sue Hawthorne and Adel Johnson) who had married in Hawaii, Iowa, and Washington, respectively. A fourth couple, Angela and Tonya Rolando, were denied a marriage license by the Cascade County Clerk of Court. Governor Steve Bullock expressed support for the plaintiffs. Attorney General Tim Fox defended the state.[5] On October 15, citing the recent decision of the Ninth Circuit Court of Appeals in Latta v. Otter and Sevcik v. Sandoval, which ended bans on same-sex marriage in Idaho and Nevada, the plaintiffs asked the court for summary judgment. Their brief compared the texts of Montana's ban with those of Idaho and Nevada and used the Latta decision to counter the state's arguments.[6] U.S. District Court Judge Brian Morris ruled for the plaintiffs on November 19, 2014, and his injunction against the state's enforcement of its ban on same-sex marriage took effect immediately. Among the first couples to marry were Tonya and Angela Rolando, plaintiffs in Rolando, who filed marriage paperwork and were married at the Cascade County Courthouse on Thursday morning, November 20.[7] Leslie Burgess and Serena Early were the first couple to be issued a marriage license in Missoula County.[8] Former Supreme Court Judge James C. Nelson officiated at the wedding of Linda Gryczan and Constance Enzweiler, a couple for 31 years, who were the first to marry in Helena, the state capital, on November 20.[9]

Governor Bullock welcomed the court ruling, saying, "Today's decision ensures we are closer to fulfilling our promise of freedom, dignity, and equality for all Montanans. It is a day to celebrate our progress, while recognizing the qualities that bind us as Montanans: a desire to make a good life for ourselves and our families, while providing greater opportunities to the next generation. I have instructed my administration to quickly take all appropriate steps to ensure that we are recognizing and affording the same rights and responsibilities to legally married same-sex couples that all married Montanans have long enjoyed." Senator John Walsh said, "Today's overdue court ruling reflects our Montana values of individual freedom, fairness and equality. I believe every Montanan – our sons, daughters, friends and family – should live free of discrimination", and Senator Jon Tester also welcomed the court decision, saying, "I applaud today's ruling. It aligns our laws with our values and is a big step forward for our state. Denying same-sex couples the right to marry denies them happiness and equal protection under the law." Representative Steve Daines said he was "disappointed that an unelected federal judge ha[d] ignored Montanans' voice".[10]

Attorney General Fox announced plans to appeal the decision to the Ninth Circuit.[11] At the request of all parties, the Ninth Circuit suspended proceedings in the state's appeal on February 9, 2015, pending action by the Supreme Court in Obergefell v. Hodges.[12] On June 26, 2015, the Supreme Court ruled in Obergefell that laws depriving same-sex couples of the rights of marriage violate the Due Process and Equal Protection clauses of the Fourteenth Amendment, striking down all same-sex marriage bans in the country and mooting the state's appeal to the Ninth Circuit.

Donaldson v. State of Montana

edit

In July 2010, seven same-sex couples in Montana filed a lawsuit against the state. The suit contended that even with the ban on same-sex marriage, the State Constitution's guarantees of privacy, dignity, and the pursuit of life's basic necessities and its guarantees of equal protection and due process require the state to offer same-sex couples the same rights and protections it offers to different-sex couples through marriage.[13] A state district court heard oral arguments in January 2011 in the case, Donaldson v. State of Montana.[14] The city of Bozeman backed their suit.[15] The court ruled against the plaintiffs on April 19, 2011,[16] and the plaintiffs, represented by the ACLU, appealed that decision to the Montana Supreme Court on August 4, arguing that the marriage amendment does not preclude providing rights other than the name "marriage" to same-sex couples.[17] On December 17, 2012, that court in a 4–3 decision denied the plaintiffs' request to find Montana's entire "statutory scheme" unconstitutional, but invited them to renew their suit in district court by specifying the statutes they were challenging.[18]

Native American nations

edit

The Law and Order Code of the Blackfeet Nation specifies that state law and state jurisdiction govern marriage relations and that neither common-law marriages nor marriages performed under native customs are valid within the Blackfeet Reservation.[19] In 2006, a traditional Blackfoot marriage ceremony was held in Seeley Lake for a two-spirit (Blackfoot: ááwowáakii,[20] ᖳᖶᖷᖽ, pronounced [áːwowâːki]) couple.[21] As same-sex marriage is legal under state law, same-sex couples can also marry on the Blackfeet Reservation. The Crow Tribe of Montana's Law and Order Code provides that marriage is a consensual relationship between "a man and a woman" arising out of a civil contract. However, the code also states that marriages which are validly contracted under the laws of the place where they occurred are recognized as valid within the Crow Indian Reservation.[22] Likewise, the Tribal Code of the Northern Cheyenne Tribe defines marriage as "a personal relationship between a man and a woman", but states that marriages validly performed under the laws of the jurisdiction where performed are valid in its reservation.[23] Similar language is found in the codes of the Assiniboine and Sioux Tribes,[24] and the Gros Ventre and Assiniboine Tribes.[25] The laws of the Confederated Salish and Kootenai Tribes are silent on who can marry; "The Code is silent on defining who can marry. If the Tribal Code is silent, then we rely on federal law first and then state law", said a tribal member during a meeting of the Tribal Council on December 20, 2016.[26]

While there are no records of same-sex marriages as understood from a Western perspective being performed in Native American cultures, there is evidence for identities and behaviours that may be placed on the LGBT spectrum. Many of these cultures recognized two-spirit individuals who were born male but wore women's clothing and performed everyday household work and artistic handiwork which were regarded as belonging to the feminine sphere.[27] Marriages between two-spirit people and cisgender men or women have been historically performed in these tribes. In Cheyenne culture, two-spirit people are known as he'émáné'e (pronounced [hɛ̀ʔɛ́mánɛ́ʔɛ̥]),[28] and filled an important role in Cheyenne society as a third gender. They were revered as warriors, directed the traditional scalp dances, were believed to be able to talk to coyotes, and were known for their skills in matchmaking, particularly for young, unmarried men who sought to impress young women. The he'émáné'e often served as a second wife in a married man's polygynous household.[29] Among the Assiniboine, two-spirit people, known as wįktą (pronounced [ˈwĩktã]), would marry men,[27] whereas the Crow batée (pronounced [bə̀ˈtêː])[30] would marry either women or men. Osh-Tisch, a famous Crow batée, adorned women's clothing and married a woman.[27] In the Gros Ventre language, two-spirit individuals are known as níí3ʼa bíitéinɔh,[31] and in Montana Salish as sncˀew̓s snx̣péw̓s, meaning "twin-spirit".[32][33] The Kutenai refer to two-spirit people who were born female but wore men's clothing and performed men's activities as titqatʼiʔtik (pronounced [tɪtqaˈtʼɪʔtɪk]). One famous Kutenai two-spirit person was Kaúxuma Núpika, who, after leaving his White fur trader husband, returned to his people and adopted men's clothing and weapons, and took a wife. Kaúxuma was one of the "principal leaders" of the tribe and supernatural powers were attributed to him. He "is remembered among the Kutenai as a respected shamanic healer", a masculine occupation.[34] The two-spirit status thus allowed for marriages between two biological males or two biological females to be performed in these tribes.

Demographics and statistics

edit

Data from the 2000 U.S. census showed that 1,218 same-sex couples were living in Montana. By 2005, this had increased to 1,662 couples, likely attributed to same-sex couples' growing willingness to disclose their partnerships on government surveys. Same-sex couples lived in all counties of the state, except Liberty County, and constituted 0.6% of coupled households and 0.3% of all households in the state. Most couples lived in Missoula, Yellowstone and Cascade counties, but the counties with the highest percentage of same-sex couples were Big Horn (0.82% of all county households), Garfield (0.75%) and Jefferson (0.67%). Same-sex partners in Montana were on average younger than opposite-sex partners, and more likely to be employed. However, the average and median household incomes of same-sex couples were lower than different-sex couples, and same-sex couples were also far less likely to own a home than opposite-sex partners. 35% of same-sex couples in Montana were raising children under the age of 18, with an estimated 762 children living in households headed by same-sex couples in 2005.[35]

By November 19, 2015, one year after the ruling in Rolando, 436 same-sex couples had married in Montana. In Cascade County, containing the third-largest city in Montana, Great Falls, the "initial rush" of same-sex couples seeking marriage licenses had decreased by then; "It was busy at first [...] We [now] probably do a couple a month or a few more", said Cascade County Clerk of Court Faye McWilliams in November 2015.[36]

The 2020 U.S. census showed that there were 1,276 married same-sex couple households (482 male couples and 794 female couples) and 1,094 unmarried same-sex couple households in Montana.[37]

Domestic partnerships

edit

In 2004, the Montana Supreme Court ruled in Snetsinger v. Montana University System that the University of Montana's policy of denying insurance coverage to the same-sex domestic partners of its gay and lesbian employees violated the State Constitution's equal protection requirements.[38] Montana has provided benefits to same-sex partners of state employees since 2005.[39]

A domestic partnership bill was introduced to the Montana Legislature in 2009. It would have provided for basic rights such as hospital visitation access for one's partner and joint property ownership, but was swiftly killed in the Legislature.[40][41]

On April 3, 2003, Missoula County commissioners approved a domestic partnership registry for the county. It went into effect on July 1, 2003.[42] A similar domestic partnership registry went into force in Missoula on October 1, 2013.[43][44] The Missoula City Council voted to repeal the city's domestic partnership registry in October 2022, citing the legalization of same-sex marriage as a reason why "the registry was no longer needed".[45]

Public opinion

edit
Public opinion for same-sex marriage in Montana
Poll source Dates administered Sample size Margin of error Support Opposition Do not know / refused
Public Religion Research Institute March 9 – December 7, 2023 166 adults ? 63% 36% 1%
Public Religion Research Institute March 11 – December 14, 2022 ? ? 70% 29% 1%
Public Religion Research Institute March 8 – November 9, 2021 ? ? 62% 38% <0.5%
Public Religion Research Institute January 7 – December 20, 2020 254 adults ? 69% 30% 1%
Public Religion Research Institute April 5 – December 23, 2017 348 adults ? 57% 37% 6%
Public Religion Research Institute May 18, 2016 – January 10, 2017 524 adults ? 53% 36% 11%
Public Religion Research Institute April 29, 2015 – January 7, 2016 465 adults ? 49% 43% 8%
Public Religion Research Institute April 2, 2014 – January 4, 2015 256 adults ? 47% 43% 10%
New York Times/CBS News/YouGov September 20 – October 1, 2014 549 likely voters ± 4.5% 45% 41% 14%
MSU Billings October 2013 410 adults ± 5.0% 47% 43% 10%
Public Policy Polling June 21–23, 2013 807 registered voters ± 3.4% 42% 48% 10%
Public Policy Polling February 15–17, 2013 1,011 voters ± 3.1% 43% 49% 8%
Public Policy Polling April 26–29, 2012 934 voters ± 3.2% 41% 48% 11%
Public Policy Polling November 28–30, 2011 1,625 voters ± 2.4% 37% 51% 12%

See also

edit

References

edit
  1. ^ "XIII.7 Marriage". University of Montana. Retrieved October 11, 2022.
  2. ^ 40-1-103. Formalities.
  3. ^ 40-1-401. Prohibited marriages -- contracts.
  4. ^ CNN: Election 2004 - Ballot Measures, accessed April 7, 2011.
  5. ^ King, Jon (May 21, 2014). "Lawsuit Filed to End Montana Defenition of Marriage, Governor Bullock Applauds". KGVO. Retrieved October 15, 2014.
  6. ^ "Montana judge asked to decide on gay marriage". Billings Gazette. Associated Press. October 15, 2014. Retrieved October 15, 2014.
  7. ^ Fischer-Nitschke, Andrea (November 20, 2014). "Montana gay couples exchange vows after ban tossed". Great Falls Tribune.
  8. ^ Towle, Andy (November 20, 2014). "First Gay Couples Marry in Montana: PHOTOS". Towleroad.
  9. ^ "Gay couples exchange vows in Montana after ruling". The Seattle Times. November 21, 2014.
  10. ^ "Reaction on lifting of Montana's gay marriage ban". NBC Montana. Helena, Montana. November 20, 2014. Archived from the original on April 20, 2021.
  11. ^ Johnson, Chris (November 19, 2014). "Judge strikes down Montana ban on same-sex marriage". Washington Blade. Retrieved November 19, 2014.
  12. ^ "Motion to stay proceedings granted". Scribd.com. Ninth Circuit Court of Appeals. Retrieved February 9, 2015.
  13. ^ Garcia, Michelle (2010-07-22). "Gay Montana Couples Sue State". Advocate.com. Retrieved 2010-07-23.
  14. ^ Billings Gazette: "Gay couples argue for same rights as wedded people," January 25, 2011, accessed April 14, 2011
  15. ^ KTVM: "Bozeman Commission Backs Same-Sex Couples," September 27, 2010, accessed April 14, 2011
  16. ^ Independent Record (Helena): Matt Gouras, "Judge rules against gay couples seeking rights," April 21, 2011, accessed April 21, 2011
  17. ^ KTVM.com: Lauren Maschmedt, "ACLU Takes Same-Sex Case To State Supreme Court," August 4, 2011, accessed August 4, 2011
  18. ^ Geidner, Chris (December 17, 2012). "Montana Supreme Court Rejects Broad Equal Benefits Claim By Gay Couples". Buzz Feed. Retrieved December 17, 2012.
  19. ^ "Chapter 3, Blackfeet Tribe Law and Order Code" (PDF). narf.org. Retrieved January 28, 2022.
  20. ^ "Blackfoot dictionary". dictionary.blackfoot.atlas-ling.ca. Archived from the original on 4 April 2023. Retrieved 15 April 2024.
  21. ^ "A Spirit of Belonging, Inside and Out". The New York Times. October 8, 2006.
  22. ^ "Title 10 : Domestic Relations, Law and Order Code of the Crow Tribe of Montana" (PDF). indianlaw.mt.gov. Retrieved January 28, 2022.
  23. ^ "Title VIII : Domestic Relations, Tribal Code of the Northern Cheyenne Tribe" (PDF). www.narf.org.
  24. ^ "Section 202. Requirements. Title 10 – Family Code of the Assiniboine and Sioux Tribes" (PDF).
  25. ^ "The Laws of the Gros Ventre and Assiniboine Tribes" (PDF). indianlaw.mt.gov.
  26. ^ "Page 1 Tribal Council Meeting Minutes of the Confederated Salish and Kootenai Tribes of the Flathead Indian Nation, Montana" (PDF). Confederated Salish and Kootenai Tribes of the Flathead Reservation. Archived from the original (PDF) on February 23, 2019.
  27. ^ a b c Sabine Lang (1998). Men as women, women as men: changing gender in Native American cultures. University of Texas Press. ISBN 0-292-74701-2.
  28. ^ "Cheyenne Dictionary: he'émáné'e". Archived from the original on April 25, 2023. Retrieved August 16, 2022.
  29. ^ George Bird Grinnell (2008). The Cheyenne Indians: Their History and Lifeways: Edited and Illustrated. World Wisdom. ISBN 978-1933316604.
  30. ^ "Crow Dictionary: batée". Crow Language Consortium. Archived from the original on April 18, 2024. Retrieved June 1, 2024.
  31. ^ Cowell, Andrew (2012). English - Gros Ventre/White ClayStudent Dictionary. University of Colorado.
  32. ^ Turney-High, Harry Holbert (1937). The Flathead Indians of Montana. American Anthropological Association. p. 157. ISBN 0527005479.
  33. ^ "Seliš Translation, English to Salish Dictionary" (PDF). December 1, 2006. Archived from the original (PDF) on December 29, 2021. Retrieved June 2, 2024.
  34. ^ Schaeffer, Claude (1965). "The Kutenai Female Berdache". Duke University Press. 12 (3).
  35. ^ "Census Snapshot" (PDF). Williams Institute. Retrieved August 15, 2022.
  36. ^ Rosenbaum, Traci; Inbody, Kristen (November 19, 2015). "How many same-sex couples have married in Montana?". Great Falls Tribune.
  37. ^ "PCT1405 Couple Households, By Type". United States Census Bureau. Archived from the original on 9 June 2023. Retrieved 11 December 2023.
  38. ^ Justia.com: Snetsinger v. Montana University System, accessed April 25, 2011
  39. ^ National Conference of State Legislatures: "States offering benefits for same-sex partners of state employees", accessed April 16, 2011
  40. ^ HOUSE BILL NO. 590
  41. ^ HB 590
  42. ^ Missoula County, Montana approves health benefits for domestic partners
  43. ^ Missoula City Council Unanimously Approves Same-Sex – Domestic Partner Registration [AUDIO]
  44. ^ Missoula City Council passes domestic partnership registry resolution
  45. ^ "Missoula Repeals Domestic Partnership Registry; Keeps Tabs On Same-Sex Marriage At Supco". Missoula Current. October 12, 2022. Archived from the original on October 13, 2022.
edit
Retrieved from "https://en.wikipedia.org/w/index.php?title=Same-sex_marriage_in_Montana&oldid=1257144974"