Wikipedia

Stripped Classicism

(Redirected from Starved Classical)
For the Art Deco style sometimes called “stripped classical”, see Greco Deco.

Stripped Classicism (or "Starved Classicism" or "Grecian Moderne")[1] is primarily a 20th-century classicist architectural style stripped of most or all ornamentation, frequently employed by governments while designing official buildings. It was adopted by both totalitarian and democratic regimes.[A] The style embraces a "simplified but recognizable" classicism in its overall massing and scale while eliminating traditional decorative detailing.[3][4][5][6] The orders of architecture are only hinted at or are indirectly implicated in the form and structure.[B]

The German Imperial Embassy (designed 1911–12) on Saint Isaac's Square in Saint Petersburg is considered the key template for Stripped Classicism. It was stripped still further when the large statues originally placed on the plinth on the roof were removed during World War I
Victoria Palace, Bucharest, Romania, 1937–1944, by Duiliu Marcu

Despite its etymological similarity, Stripped Classicism is sometimes distinguished from "Starved Classicism", the latter "displaying little feeling for rules, proportions, details, and finesse, and lacking all verve and élan".[5][7] At other times the terms "stripped" and "starved" are used interchangeably.[8][9]

Stripped Classicism was a materialistic manifestation of 'political' modernism. Recent historiography has explicitly linked this architectural style – and its relationship with modernist thinking – to political projects arising in the 1920–1930s, which utilised artistic dexterity to articulate – in built form – a powerful political ethos orientated towards the future.[10]

Other writers have noted the need to read the impact of avant-garde movements such as the Italian Futurists, who extolled the innumerable possibilities of the modern world, on this unique style (and the futurism it espoused).[11] It was popularised by the French-born Paul Philippe Cret, among others, and employed in Nazi Germany, Fascist Italy, the Soviet Union and New Deal America.

Description and history

edit

Though the term is usually reserved for the more thorough style that forms part of 20th-century rational architecture,[5] characteristics of Stripped Classicism are embodied in works of some progressive late 18th- and early 19th-century neoclassical architects, such as Étienne-Louis Boullée, Claude Nicolas Ledoux, Friedrich Gilly, Peter Speeth, Sir John Soane and Karl Friedrich Schinkel.[5]

Between the World Wars, a stripped-down classicism became the de facto standard for many monumental and institutional governmental buildings all over the world.[2] Governments used this architectural méthode to straddle modernism and classicism, an ideal political response to a modernizing world.[12] In part, this movement was said to have origins in the need to save money in governmental works by eschewing the expense of hand-worked classical detail.[6]

 
Albert Speer's Zeppelinfeld outside Nuremberg, in 1934
 
Folger Shakespeare Library in Washington, D.C.

In Europe, examples as early as the Embassy of Germany, Saint Petersburg, designed by Peter Behrens and completed in 1912, "established models for the classical purity aspired to by high modernists like Mies van der Rohe but also for the oversized, Stripped Classicism of Hitler's, Stalin's and Ulbricht's architects and perhaps of American, British and French official buildings in the 1930s as well".[13] The style later found adherents in the Fascist regimes of Germany[14] and Italy as well as in the Soviet Union during Stalin's regime.[15] Albert Speer's Zeppelinfeld and other parts of the Nazi party rally grounds complex outside Nuremberg were perhaps the most famous examples in Germany, using classical elements such as columns and altars alongside modern technology such as spotlights. The Casa del Fascio in Como has also been aligned with the movement. In the USSR some of the proposals for the unbuilt Palace of the Soviets also had characteristics of the style.[2]

Among American architects, the work of Paul Philippe Cret exemplifies the style. His Château-Thierry American Monument built in 1928 has been identified as an early example.[16] Among his other works identified with the style are the exterior of the 1933 Folger Shakespeare Library in Washington, D.C. (though not the Tudor Revival library interior), the 1937 University of Texas at Austin's Main Tower, the 1937 Federal Reserve Building in Washington, D.C., and the 1939 Bethesda Naval Hospital tower.[16][17][18]

It is sometimes evident in buildings that were constructed by the Works Projects Administration during the Great Depression, albeit with a mix of Art Deco architecture or its elements. Related styles have been described as PWA Moderne and Greco Deco.[19][20]

The movement was widespread, and transcended national boundaries. Architects who at least notably experimented in Stripped Classicism included John James Burnet, Giorgio Grassi, Léon Krier, Aldo Rossi, Albert Speer, Robert A. M. Stern and Paul Troost.[C][5]

Despite its popularity with totalitarian regimes, it has been adapted by many English-speaking democratic governments, including during the New Deal in the United States.[2] In any event, presumed "fascist" underpinnings have hampered acceptance into mainstream architectural thought.[2] There is no evidence that architects who favored this style had a particular right-wing political disposition. Nevertheless, both Adolf Hitler and Benito Mussolini were fans.[21][22] On the other hand, Stripped Classicism was favored by Joseph Stalin and various regional Communist regimes.[15]

After the defeat of Nazi Germany and end of World War II, the style fell out of favor. However, it was somewhat revived in designs in the 1960s.[6] Included was Philip Johnson's New York Lincoln Center for the Performing Arts,[6] evidencing "a revival in the Stripped Classical style". Likewise, Canberra, Australia saw the Law Courts of the Australian Capital Territory (1961) and the National Library of Australia (1968) resurrect grand Stripped Classical designs.[6][23] See Australian non-residential architectural styles.

The paradoxical embrace of old and new

edit

The use of culture and 'myth' was a shared peculiarity of totalitarian political programmes during the 1920–30s, including Nazism in Germany and Soviet Communism in Russia. Cultural incentives launched by these states, and all their various intricacies, evoked currents of modernist thought.

Through architecture, they strove to invoke the power of modernity in their physical landscapes (especially in their capital cities) and, simultaneously, reinvent the past (as symbolised by Stripped Classicism's restrained classical features) by ransacking its archetypal 'healthy' elements to inaugurate a reforged, rejuvenated, futural, open-ended and monumental future.

It is this curious dichotomy between old and new, an inexorable feature of Stripped Classicism, which historian Roger Griffin has encapsulated in his conceptual framework of 'rooted modernism' (which he discusses in relation to fascist buildings).[24]

The modernism in Stripped Classical buildings can be seen through their stylistic components (mute apertures, blank walls and the absence of ornament) and through their pure functionality. Adolf Loos, an Austrian theorist of modern architecture, and his essay "Ornament and Crime" can be seen as just one of the many philosophers/theorists/architects who foreshadowed some of the stylistic elements of Stripped Classicism.

Avant-garde movements such as Futurism also foreshadowed a form of building which is as much extravagant as it is streamlined, as much multi-functional as it is fit for the multi-faceted modern future vis-a-vis high-speed travel, technologically advanced means of communication, hydraulic engineering etc... "all in time for the most mechanised war in history", as Samuel Patterson writes.[25]

The Stripped Classical style was also embraced by Franklin D. Roosevelt, who yearned for an architecture symbolising a 'new beginning' under New Dealism (which was fighting to ameliorate the ramifications of the Great Depression), and concomitantly, archetypal American genius. A discussion of the Roosevelt administration, its reinvention of the past (centred on Jeffersonianism) and its uses of architecture in the 1930s can be found in Patterson's 'Problem-Solvers' thesis.[25]

Notable examples

edit
Name Image Location Architect(s) Year completed Notes
Embassy of Germany, Saint Petersburg   Saint Petersburg, Russia Peter Behrens 1913
Provisional Parliament House   Canberra, Australia John Smith Murdoch 1927
Valley Life Sciences Building at UC Berkeley   Berkeley, California, U.S. George W. Kelham 1930
Polish Ministry of Education   Warsaw, Poland Zdzisław Mączeński 1930
Parliament House   Helsinki, Finland J. S. Sirén 1931 Also a key example of Nordic Classicism
William R. Cotter Federal Building   Hartford, Connecticut, U.S. Malmfeldt, Adams & Prentice 1931
Frist Center for the Visual Arts   Nashville, Tennessee, U.S. Marr & Holman 1932
Folger Shakespeare Library   Washington, D.C., U.S. Paul Philippe Cret 1933 John Gregory, architectural sculpture; Brenda Putnam, statue of Puck
Martin Luther King Jr. Federal Building   Atlanta, Georgia, U.S. A. Ten Eyck Brown 1933
Eccles Building (Federal Reserve) [26]   Washington, D.C., U.S. Paul Philippe Cret 1937 Sidney Waugh, architectural sculpture; Samuel Yellin, wrought iron; Ezra Winter, murals
San Francisco Mint   San Francisco, California, U.S. Gilbert Stanley Underwood 1937
Tennessee Supreme Court Building   Nashville, Tennessee, U.S. Marr & Holman 1937
Victoria Palace   Bucharest, Romania Duiliu Marcu 1937
Virginia Department of Highways Building   Richmond, Virginia, U.S. Carneal, Johnston & Wright 1937
Meštrović Pavilion   Zagreb, Croatia Ivan Meštrović 1938
Oregon State Capitol[1]   Salem, Oregon, U.S. Francis Keally and Trowbridge & Livingston 1938 Leo Friedlander and Ulric Ellerhusen, architectural sculpture; Frank Henry Schwarz and Barry Faulkner, murals
Patrick Henry Building   Richmond, Virginia, U.S. Carneal, Johnston and Wright 1938
Palace of Nations   Geneva, Switzerland Carlo Broggi, Julien Flegenheimer, Camille Lefèvre, Henri Paul Nénot, Joseph Vago 1938
Banovina Palace   Novi Sad, Serbia Dragiša Brašovan 1939 Reliefs were done by Karlo Baranji. The reliefs showcase Peter I of Serbia, Alexander I of Yugoslavia, Radomir Putnik, Petar Bojović, Živojin Mišić, and Stepa Stepanović.
PRIZAD Building   Belgrade, Serbia Bogdan Nestorović 1939
Houston City Hall[27]   Houston, Texas, U.S. Joseph Finger 1939
Harry S Truman Building (particularly the War Department Building) of the United States Department of State[28]   Washington, D.C., U.S. Underwood & Foster 1939
Justice Building   Raleigh, North Carolina, U.S. Northrup & O'Brien 1940
Waltham Forest Town Hall   London Borough of Waltham Forest, England Philip Hepworth 1941
Dauphin County Courthouse   Harrisburg, Pennsylvania, U.S. Lawrie and Green 1942
Esposizione Universale Roma (EUR)
(Colosseo Quadrato pictured) 		  Rome, Italy Marcello Piacentini 1942 Planned for the world's fair 1942, but unfinished due to the war.
Lisner Auditorium   Washington, D.C., U.S. Faulkner & Kingsbury 1943
Bernardo O'Higgins Military School   Santiago de Chile Juan Martínez Gutiérrez 1943
Jamuna Bhaban   Chittagong, Bangladesh 1952 Headquarters of Jamuna Oil Company
Anıtkabir   Ankara, Turkey Emin Halid Onat and Ahmet Orhan Arda 1953 Mausoleum of Mustafa Kemal Atatürk.
Lorenzo de Zavala State Archives and Library Building   Austin, Texas, U.S. Adams and Adams 1959
Çanakkale Martyrs' Memorial   Gallipoli, Turkey Feridun Kip, Doğan Erginbaş and İsmail Utkular 1960 War memorial for the Battle of Gallipoli
National Library of Australia   Canberra, Australia Walter Bunning, in association with T.E. O’Mahoney 1968 "... modern derivation in the spirit of ancient Greco-Roman architecture. It is unequivocally a twentieth century building, in the architectural style that is called Late Twentieth Century Stripped Classical".[29]
Ho Chi Minh Mausoleum   Hanoi, Vietnam Garol Isakovich 1975 Mausoleum of Vietnamese revolutionary leader and President Ho Chi Minh, based in part on Lenin's Mausoleum.

See also

edit

Notes

edit
  1. ^ "Stripped Classicism was a widely popular, international style of architecture during the inter-war period. It is best defined as a pared down version of classicism that blended the classical vocabulary with the ever-growing desire for abstraction... Due to its strong associations with totalitarian governments, it is often excluded from the canonic historical narrative of the modern movement. Recently a growing number of scholars have begun to question the traditional definition of modern architecture. If the discussion on modernism is expanding beyond the traditional canonical definition, a greater understanding of Stripped Classicism's place amongst the modern movement can be achieved."[2]
  2. ^ Thus, for example, cuts might be substituted for moldings.[5]
  3. ^ German architect and husband of architect Gerdy Troost[5]

Citations

edit
  1. ^ a b Willingham, William F. (Spring 2013). "Architecture of the Oregon State Capitol". Oregon Historical Quarterly. 114 (1). Oregon Historical Society: 94–107. doi:10.5403/oregonhistq.114.1.0094. JSTOR 10.5403/oregonhistq.114.1.0094. S2CID 164151091. Jstor (subscription required)
  2. ^ a b c d e Bryant 2011.
  3. ^ Sennott, Stephen, ed. (2004). Encyclopedia of Twentieth Century Architecture. New York: Fitzroy Dearborn. p. 269. ISBN 1579582435.
  4. ^ "Stripped Classical 1900-1945". Essential Architecture. Retrieved December 5, 2014.
  5. ^ a b c d e f g h Curl, James Stevens (2000). "Stripped Classicism". A Dictionary of Architecture and Landscape Architecture. Encyclopedia.com. Retrieved December 6, 2014.
  6. ^ a b c d e "Post War Stripped Classical". Archipaedia-archive. Archipaedia world architecture. November 23, 2009. Retrieved December 6, 2014.
  7. ^ Cf, Curl, James Stevens (2000). "Starved Classicism". A Dictionary of Architecture and Landscape Architecture. Encyclopedia.com. Retrieved December 6, 2014.
  8. ^ "Return To Classicism". chicagotribune.com. June 9, 1985. Retrieved April 18, 2018.
  9. ^ "Frist Center for the Arts, former US Post Office in Nashville". wordpress.com. October 4, 2015. Retrieved April 18, 2018.
  10. ^ Patterson, Samuel, "'Problem-Solvers': The Modernist Ethos Behind Architecture in Stalinist Russia and New Deal America"[1], 2019.
  11. ^ Patterson,"'Problem-Solvers'"[2], 2019.
  12. ^ Bryant 2011, p. 5.
  13. ^ Ladd, Brian (June 27, 2004). The Companion Guide to Berlin. Woodbridge Rochester, NY: Companion Guides. p. 205. ISBN 1900639289. Retrieved December 5, 2014.
  14. ^ "Fascist Stripped Classical (German)". Essential Architecture. Retrieved December 5, 2014.
  15. ^ a b tjaaf (November 24, 2009). "Stalinist Architecture- Regional varieties". Archipaedia-archive. Archipaedia world architecture. Retrieved December 6, 2014.
  16. ^ a b Rybczynski, Witold (October 21, 2014). "The Late, Great Paul Cret". The New York Times. Retrieved December 5, 2014.
  17. ^ Moeller Jr., G. Martin (May 2, 2012). AIA Guide to the Architecture of Washington (Fifth ed.). Baltimore, MD: Johns Hopkins University Press. ISBN 978-1421402703.
  18. ^ Applewhite, E. J. (1993). Washington Itself: An Informal Guide to the Capital of the United States. Lanham, Md: Madison Books. p. 165. ISBN 1568330081.
  19. ^ Prosser, Daniel (1992). The New Deal Builds: Government Architecture during the New Deal. Vol. 9. pp. 40–54. {{cite book}}: |work= ignored (help)
  20. ^ Greif, Martin (1975). Depression Modern: The Thirties Style in America. New York: Universe Books. ISBN 9780876632574.
  21. ^ "Stripped Classical". Archipaedia-archive. Archipaedia world architecture. November 23, 2009. Retrieved December 6, 2014.
  22. ^ "Fascist Stripped Classical (German)". Archipaedia-archiv. Archipaedia world architecture. November 24, 2009. Retrieved December 6, 2014.
  23. ^ "Late twentieth century Stripped Classical". Retrieved December 6, 2014.
  24. ^ Griffin, Roger [3], 2018.
  25. ^ a b Patterson,[4], 2019.
  26. ^ Goley, Mary Anne. "Architecture of the Eccles Building". Federal Reserve Board. Archived from the original on June 12, 2002. Retrieved December 6, 2014.
  27. ^ "Front Matter". Journal of Public Administration Research and Theory. 11 (2). Oxford University Press on behalf of the Public Management Research Association: i-264. April 2001. JSTOR 3525687.
  28. ^ "Find a Building: Search". www.gsa.gov. Retrieved April 18, 2018.
  29. ^ Irving, Robert; Powell, Ron; Irving, Noel (2014). Sydney's hard rock story: the cultural heritage of trachyte. Leura, N.S.W.: Heritage Publishing. p. 137. ISBN 9781875891160.

Sources

edit
edit
 
Wikimedia Commons has media related to Stripped Classical architecture.
Retrieved from "https://en.wikipedia.org/w/index.php?title=Stripped_Classicism&oldid=1245121707"