Talk:Abdul-Karim al-Jundi

(Redirected from Talk:Abd al-Karim al-Jundi)
Latest comment: 12 years ago by Zozo2kx in topic 74.199.14.141 Edits

74.199.14.141 Edits

edit

I've reveted IP 74.199.14.141's edits to the article because they are a) not supported by sources, b) some of them actually contradict the cited sources.

  1. Al-Jundi family was not Sunni, they were certainly Ismaili, as attested by Hanna Batatu. Some of the family, including Abd al-Karim, later did convert to Sunni Islam, but that's beside the point.
  2. The family Abd al-Karim was born to, was a poor branch of the rich al-Jundi family. And even considering the overall family, their wealth would pale with regards to the real notable in Hama (those of al-Azm) and even in Masyaf (al-Mir).
  3. I have seen no source that claims that he was an Athiest. It's a probability, but, it's not our place to speculate on that matter.
  4. It's also a possibility that he was ordered dead by Hafez Assad, but most sources seem to agree that he actually killed himself when he felt cornered (Batatu, Moubayed, Seale). Yazan (talk) 07:52, 27 September 2012 (UTC)Reply