Talk:List of famous Swiss people
Discussion moved to Talk:Swiss inventions
Merged or Subsumed or Subsuming ?
editHmm, yes, I understand the sentiment of wanting to merge the two lists. And at the moment, there's not exactly a strong focus on the inventions in this wiki - although I hoped that would develop once it was published.
I've also been rather cavalier about my use of the word "inventions" but I couldn't think of a better word at the time.
My feeling is that the function of the list of xxx people concept is very well established and very well defined. As a relative newbie to Wikipedia, and with not too much spare time on my hands, I didn't feel it would be possible to propose a Wikipedia-wide shift away from the "people" aspect and towards the "inventions" aspect.
What this list has, that the famous people list hasn't got, is a three-way categorisation -
- the Swiss and their inventions
- the anonymous (traditional) inventions
- the foreigners and residents (and their inventions)
Also, this addresses head on the annoying convention that Switzerland is boring. Belgium and Finland get that too, by the way.
So I won't be offended if the Consensus is to merge my contribution into the larger List of Swiss people, but perhaps it might be more useful to either broaden the remit on ALL the original lists?
IMHO the name of the older list is unnecessarily long; I would in any case prefer a shorter name, maybe Famous_Swiss.
OrangUtanUK - 2.June.2006 10:43 utc
Sorry, I overlooked your post here because I was only watching Swiss inventions. If you plan to work some more on Swiss inventions, then fair enough... but at the moment it is a very confused article that doesn't seem to have a focus. It also needs a good work over to sort out the tone, which isn't really suitable for an encyclopedia. Thanks. Addtional: it's just a suggestion, but the issue of the Swiss not being credited with inventions would surely be better addressed as a section of the main Switzerland article? - Motor (talk) 11:24, 3 June 2006 (UTC)