Talk:No Help/GA1

GA Review

The following discussion is closed. Please do not modify it. Subsequent comments should be made on the appropriate discussion page. No further edits should be made to this discussion.

---

Article (edit | visual edit | history) · Article talk (edit | history) · Watch

Reviewer: Lirim.Z (talk · contribs) 05:17, 13 November 2018 (UTC)

Infobox

• Add the music video to the infobox with Template:External music video

 Done

• Non-free media information and use rationale: Link the given source and its "Global Records" not "Gobal Records"

 Done

• the cover needs a description

 Done

• Format: add streaming audio Music is mostly consumed through streaming nowadays

 Done

• Who produced the song? Lyrics?

Sadly, this information was not revealed (yet). "No Help" also won't be included on Inna's upcoming album Yo', so I'm sure we'll have to wait for this information.

Lead

• "No Help" is a song by Romanian singer Inna. It was released for digital download on 6 September 2018 by Global Records. This could be one sentence. Again add streaming audio.

 Done

• Musically, "No Help" is a pop and oriental-influenced dance and tropical house song. During the lyrics, Inna discusses confidence, independence and self-help. Again could be one sentence. For e.x. Musically, "No Help" is a pop and oriental-influenced dance and tropical house song, whose lyrics discuss confidence, independence and self-help.

 Done

• Commercially, "No Help" peaked at number 65 on the Romanian Airplay 100 chart. The track received minor commercial success in Romania and France.

 Done

Background and reception

• The section needs a sample of the song

 Done Merged the sample in the infobox though, to avoid WP:SANDWICH

• the release of a single on social media On all social media platforms she uses or only on one specific? There are a lot of social media services.

She released this news on all of her social media simultaneously, so I think this is okay as it stands now.

• Are there more reviews for this song?

Sadly, no! This song has not that much of a media coverage.

• Who produced the song? Lyrics? Maybe the studio it was recorded?

Again, this is sadly unknown. It would be fine to have that information, but it isn't the case here (at least for now).

• and ascended to number 65 the next week. Is the song still in the charts?

The song is still in the Romanian chart, but it isn't climbing up anymore. I've corrected the wording to make this clear.

Music video

• A screenshot from the music video?

 Done

• Shes nit just performing in a desert.

 Done Indeed, she's also shortly seen in a blue-toned forest all alone.

Track listing / Charts

• no issues

Thanks!

Release history

• add streaming audio

 Done

References

• Ref 3: what language is that?

 Done French

• Ref 7: Needs a translation

 Done

• Ref 9: in Romanan in Romanian

 Done

Other stuff

• 0% Really good.
• No dead links.

Thanks!!

Outcome

• ✗ Fail This article is not bad, but it's too short. It is missing basic information about the composition of the song. It's not mentioned once who wrote or produced the song. Some sentences in this article are in my opinion obsolete. A large part of the article is based on one CelebMix source. The music video section could be bigger. And what about a personal section? I still did the entire review, to help you out.--Lirim | Talk 05:17, 13 November 2018 (UTC)

@Lirim.Z: Hi! Thank you for the review! Maybe you could wait a few days before closing it all together since I would want to work on your comments? Best regards; Cartoon network freak (talk) 05:37, 13 November 2018 (UTC)

@Cartoon network freak: Forgot to mention that. I think seven days is fair enough. Thank you for me reminding me.--Lirim | Talk 05:44, 13 November 2018 (UTC)

@Lirim.Z: Hi again! I've worked on all your points now and commented back on some. Personally, I think just because the article is short, it doesn't mean that it isn't suitable for GA. It is well-sourced and now (hopefully) well-written; the fact that the CelebMix ref is used multiple times isn't necessarily a bad thing since we also have other sources out there. Sadly, information on the song itself (writer, producer...) is not known yet, and doing a Personnel section with just a few credits from the music video seems odd to me. Do you agree with me? Best regards and thanks again for your time. Cartoon network freak (talk) 21:55, 13 November 2018 (UTC)

Let's take a direct look at the good article criteria

1. Well written: ✓
2. Verifiable with no original research: ✓
3. Broad in its coverage: If you are not lying to me, which you would obviously never do, its somewhat weird that there is no information about the production of the song etc. From my own research, I can confirm that there not many sources for this song (I only found the CelebMix one). So you get a ✓ from me.
4. Neutral: ✓
5. Stable: ✓
6. Illustrated: ✓

Lirim | Talk 22:56, 14 November 2018 (UTC)

@Lirim.Z: Hi! Are there any further changes to be made in the article? Cartoon network freak (talk) 05:23, 15 November 2018 (UTC)

I am passing this article. Not really my kind of music, but still a good article. If information about the production is released, please add it.--Lirim | Talk 05:38, 15 November 2018 (UTC)

The discussion above is closed. Please do not modify it. Subsequent comments should be made on the appropriate discussion page. No further edits should be made to this discussion.