Talk:List of World War II military equipment of Poland

MISTAKES

lots of mistakes in River Fleet.

for example armament of monitors

SHOLD BE: Warszawa (Warsaw), Horodyszcze, Pińsk, Toruń

• since 1920 - 105 mm (5 cm) Cannons (2xI),5 MG
• since 1930 - 100 mm howitzer, 75 mm Cannons (2xI), 4 MG
• since 1938 - 75 mm Guns (1xII and 1xI), 4 MG

Supermatthew 19:20, 19 September 2006 (UTC)

Few questions

1. What is purpose of this list?
2. Why there is no external links, references or even no internal links?
3. Why there is so much mess, like list of early 1920s aircraft when this should be list of 1939-1945 equipment?

Piotr Mikołajski 19:27, 23 May 2007 (UTC)

The reason for this list!

1. The reason for this list is to list polish army equipment
2. I cant explain the age but maybe it was still in service in 1939
3. Im adding links now

Several problems with this list

Lack of sourcing and several mistakes:

Polish army didn't used Mosin-Nagant Rifle but Kbk. wz.91/98/26 which used 7.92mm ammo

Springfield, Garand, and M1 Carbine wasn't issued to polish troops on the West, they were equipped by British forces

French weaponry is a total mess, there's no proof that polish troops received semi-automatic weapon. Also lack of FM24/29, MAS-36, Hotchkiss gun and Ruby Pistol.

Soviet weaponry for forces on the East. PPD 34/38 wasn't used by Polish troops. PPD 40 could be used but it's not confirmed and needs citation. Lack of DP-27 and SVT-40. WWIIEnjoyer (talk) 20:23, 22 September 2023 (UTC)

Lack of proper sourcing and references

This list to justify it's own existence needs sourcing and references. Without it will be vandalized. State of this list is very poor WWIIEnjoyer (talk) 01:26, 24 February 2024 (UTC)