Talk:Top Model (Scandinavian TV series)

(Redirected from Talk:Top Model (Scandinavia))
Latest comment: 8 years ago by Tigraan in topic Which table should be used in the article?

Comments

edit

The majority of information in this post is incorrect. —Preceding unsigned comment added by 66.65.42.15 (talkcontribs) 2006-11-23

Could you state what, specifically, is wrong? --Oldak Quill 23:14, 22 November 2007 (UTC)Reply


There is a mistake in the judges section, it sais Mariana Herkerk, but her name is Mariana Verkerk, I dont know if she changed her (Dutch) name to make it easyer to pronounce... Juudt (talk) 17:28, 15 September 2009 (UTC)Reply

Which table should be used in the article?

edit

The following discussion is closed. Please do not modify it. Subsequent comments should be made on the appropriate discussion page. No further edits should be made to this discussion.


I'm trying to reach consensus over which table should be used in the main article. The first, smaller table, includes only the finalists of the merged version. The second includes finalists from the merged version as well as the national finalists of each branch during the cycle. It would be very appreciated if other users would put their imput into this discussion. For the record, I choose Table B. My logic is that while I agree that tables should be kept consistent to each other, the format of this show itself was vastly different from most other versions. That in itself demands that information be presented differently for a better understanding of the show. It's a bit more information yes, but the presentation of the table (airtade, cycle, winner, runner-up, contestants, number of contestants, destination) is exactly the same. The addition of all the contestants in no way takes away from the validity or accuracy of the information.

2601:241:0:EA46:78D4:88EE:F3A6:47A1 (talk) 18:37, 1 May 2016 (UTC)Reply

This is Table A

edit
Cycle Premiere date Winner Runners-up Other contestants in order of elimination Number of contestants Destination
1   February 15, 2005 (2005-02-15)
  February 16, 2005 (2005-02-16)
  February 17, 2005 (2005-02-17)
 
Kine Bakke
 
Elina Herbeck
 
Nanna Schultz Christensen

Stine Mangaard Hansen, Madelene Lund & Kristin Rem Trehjørningen, Maja Ekberg & Henriette Stenbeck & Cecilie Madsen

9  
New York
2   September 5, 2005 (2005-09-05)
  September 6, 2005 (2005-09-06)
  September 14, 2005 (2005-09-14)
 
Frøydis Elvenes
 
Anna Nørgaard
 
Arwen Bergström

Mikaela Källgren & Louise Falkenblad & Karin Santini, Tine Holm Riis & Kristine Øverby & Janni Juntunen

9  
Paris
3   February 14, 2006 (2006-02-14)
  February 27, 2006 (2006-02-27)
  March 8, 2006 (2006-03-08)
 
Freja Kjellberg Borchies
 
Anna Brændstrup
 
Therese Haugsnes

Sara Olsen & Cathrine Wenger, Florina Weisz, Sabina Karlsson & Mira Aanes Wolden & Camilla Schønberg

9  
Milan
4 TBA TBA TBA TBA TBA TBA

This is Table B

edit
Cycle Premiere Winner Runners-up Other contestants in order of elimination Number of
contestants
Destination
National finalists   Denmark   Norway   Sweden
1   February 15, 2005 (2005-02-15)
  February 16, 2005 (2005-02-16)
  February 17, 2005 (2005-02-17)
  Kine Bakke   Elina Herbeck
  Nanna Schultz Christensen
  Stine Mangaard Hansen
  Madelene Lund &
  Kristin Rem Trehjørningen
  Maja Ekberg &
  Henriette Stenbeck &
  Cecilie Madsen
Malene von der Maase
Amirah Hamed Alsarrag
Sophie Tine Schandorff
Helga Rose
Anne Baunbæk Pedersen
Stéphanie Juana Rasmussen
Anne Hauge
Amila Vuckic
Warsan Adam
Anna Kolaczkowska
Tina Nordby
Marna Haugen
Paula Quiroga
Maria Öhrstrand (quit)
Heléne Melin
Maria Lager
Kumba M'bye
Louise Willenheimer
Julia Krischel
28  
New York
2   September 5, 2005 (2005-09-05)
  September 6, 2005 (2005-09-06)
  September 14, 2005 (2005-09-14)
  Frøydis Elvenes   Anna Nørgaard
  Arwen Bergström
  Mikaela Källgren &
  Louise Falkenblad &
  Karin Santini
  Tine Holm Riis &
  Kristine Øverby &
  Janni Juntunen
Mikaela K. Ibsen
Tanja Johnsen
Line Bang
Sofie Thrane
Heidi Helm Larsen
Lise M. Andersen
Nazila Shirindel
Annette Kjær
Nora Møller
Elise Måge
Sarah Mohamud
Sandra Otteraaen
Fahrie Berisha
Charlotte Treschow
Anna Maria Moström
Jazzmine Berger
Maria Lindgren
Emelie Törnqvist
27  
Paris
3   February 14, 2006 (2006-02-14)
  February 27, 2006 (2006-02-27)
  March 8, 2006 (2006-03-08)
  Freja Kjellberg Borchies   Anna Brændstrup
  Therese Haugsnes
  Sara Olsen &
  Cathrine Wenger
  Florina Weisz
  Sabina Karlsson &
  Mira Aanes Wolden &
  Camilla Schønberg
Mira Pelle
Cecilia Kristensen
Stine Palle
Nana Bach Nielsen
Line Vanggaard Nielsen
Christina Anaya Mortensen
Signe Cecilie Nørgaard
Ingrid Janne Sæberg
Rikke Kalsveen
Helene Sletten Vangen
Ellen Caroline Brenger (quit)
Kira Hellsten
Camilla Abry
Sandra Nilsson
Joanna Häggblom
Ebba Söderström
Emma Johansson
Julia Agapova
Sofia Eriksson
Kristina Svensson
29  
Milan
4 TBA TBA TBA TBA TBA TBA
A is more consistent with the format of the other tables, and it includes only the finalists, while B includes the contestants of the individual competitions, which are classified as semi-finalists. Also, B disrupts the page format, as it stretches it a lot, and I feel it could be hard to manage when the new cycle begins, as we don't know whether it will follow the same format as cycles 1–3 or not. Linguist 111talk 18:45, 1 May 2016 (UTC)Reply
That is why the new cycle section for new contestants has been ammended to cover for that. If that were the case, if the show were to follow a more standard format (like Asia's Next Top Model) the new table would look like this, and the difference would be explained in the format section of the article. 2601:241:0:EA46:78D4:88EE:F3A6:47A1 (talk) 18:49, 1 May 2016 (UTC)Reply
Cycle Premiere Winner Runners-up Other contestants in order of elimination Number of
contestants
Destination
National finalists   Denmark   Norway   Sweden
1   February 15, 2005 (2005-02-15)
  February 16, 2005 (2005-02-16)
  February 17, 2005 (2005-02-17)
  Kine Bakke   Elina Herbeck
  Nanna Schultz Christensen
  Stine Mangaard Hansen
  Madelene Lund &
  Kristin Rem Trehjørningen
  Maja Ekberg &
  Henriette Stenbeck &
  Cecilie Madsen
Malene von der Maase
Amirah Hamed Alsarrag
Sophie Tine Schandorff
Helga Rose
Anne Baunbæk Pedersen
Stéphanie Juana Rasmussen
Anne Hauge
Amila Vuckic
Warsan Adam
Anna Kolaczkowska
Tina Nordby
Marna Haugen
Paula Quiroga
Maria Öhrstrand (quit)
Heléne Melin
Maria Lager
Kumba M'bye
Louise Willenheimer
Julia Krischel
28  
New York
2   September 5, 2005 (2005-09-05)
  September 6, 2005 (2005-09-06)
  September 14, 2005 (2005-09-14)
  Frøydis Elvenes   Anna Nørgaard
  Arwen Bergström
  Mikaela Källgren &
  Louise Falkenblad &
  Karin Santini
  Tine Holm Riis &
  Kristine Øverby &
  Janni Juntunen
Mikaela K. Ibsen
Tanja Johnsen
Line Bang
Sofie Thrane
Heidi Helm Larsen
Lise M. Andersen
Nazila Shirindel
Annette Kjær
Nora Møller
Elise Måge
Sarah Mohamud
Sandra Otteraaen
Fahrie Berisha
Charlotte Treschow
Anna Maria Moström
Jazzmine Berger
Maria Lindgren
Emelie Törnqvist
27  
Paris
3   February 14, 2006 (2006-02-14)
  February 27, 2006 (2006-02-27)
  March 8, 2006 (2006-03-08)
  Freja Kjellberg Borchies   Anna Brændstrup
  Therese Haugsnes
  Sara Olsen &
  Cathrine Wenger
  Florina Weisz
  Sabina Karlsson &
  Mira Aanes Wolden &
  Camilla Schønberg
Mira Pelle
Cecilia Kristensen
Stine Palle
Nana Bach Nielsen
Line Vanggaard Nielsen
Christina Anaya Mortensen
Signe Cecilie Nørgaard
Ingrid Janne Sæberg
Rikke Kalsveen
Helene Sletten Vangen
Ellen Caroline Brenger (quit)
Kira Hellsten
Camilla Abry
Sandra Nilsson
Joanna Häggblom
Ebba Söderström
Emma Johansson
Julia Agapova
Sofia Eriksson
Kristina Svensson
29  
Milan
1 September 22, 2010   Caroline Bader   Brinette Odgaard Sofia Sakko, Astrid Bech Augustinussen, Serina Jensen, Emma Penthien, Nanna Jo Borgersen,
Elise Lou Dubois, Rochel Rasmusen, Laila McFarlan, Isabella Kaufmann, Stephanie Strarup & Karen Ziefeldt
13  
Paris
 
London
A I think it's good like it is now. Table B is to big and stretched. To much squeezed in one Table. DDKay (talk) —Preceding undated comment added 19:12, 1 May 2016 (UTC)Reply
  • Table B I like B because it contains more information. I always consider more information to be better inasmuch as people looking up such information have everything they need presented to them with fewer clicks. No point in making people scroll or click when you can present them with the information they want right there. Damotclese (talk) 15:40, 2 May 2016 (UTC)Reply
  • Leaning towards B (Summoned by feedback request service) Yes, it looks huge & unwieldy, but it doesn't seem to me that every possible contestant along the way is crufty information or too much detail. I suppose this is just the lesser of two evils; I might prefer something else if another alternative were presented. Zeke, the Mad Horrorist (Speak quickly) (Follow my trail) 20:46, 6 May 2016 (UTC)Reply
  • Then may I propose this This last table has all of the information of the larger table (B), but the subsection is collapsible so that it does not take up as much room. This way, the table in place remains intact, but the rest of information is still made available. I've left the new table on the main page so we can get a better understanding of how much space it would take up. 2601:241:0:EA46:112:272F:30F2:AA0D (talk) 22:52, 8 May 2016 (UTC)Reply
Cycle Premiere date Winner Runners-up Other contestants in order of elimination National finalists Number of contestants Destination
1   February 15, 2005 (2005-02-15)
  February 16, 2005 (2005-02-16)
  February 17, 2005 (2005-02-17)
 
Kine Bakke
 
Elina Herbeck
 
Nanna Schultz Christensen
Stine Mangaard Hansen, Madelene Lund & Kristin Rem Trehjørningen, Maja Ekberg & Henriette Stenbeck & Cecilie Madsen
  Denmark   Norway   Sweden
Malene von der Maase
Amirah Hamed Alsarrag
Sophie Tine Schandorff
Helga Rose
Anne Baunbæk Pedersen
Stéphanie Juana Rasmussen
Anne Hauge
Amila Vuckic
Warsan Adam
Anna Kolaczkowska
Tina Nordby
Marna Haugen
Paula Quiroga
Maria Öhrstrand (quit)
Heléne Melin
Maria Lager
Kumba M'bye
Louise Willenheimer
Julia Krischel
28  
New York
2   September 5, 2005 (2005-09-05)
  September 6, 2005 (2005-09-06)
  September 14, 2005 (2005-09-14)
 
Frøydis Elvenes
 
Anna Nørgaard
 
Arwen Bergström
Mikaela Källgren & Louise Falkenblad & Karin Santini, Tine Holm Riis & Kristine Øverby & Janni Juntunen
  Denmark   Norway   Sweden
Mikaela K. Ibsen
Tanja Johnsen
Line Bang
Sofie Thrane
Heidi Helm Larsen
Lise M. Andersen
Nazila Shirindel
Annette Kjær
Nora Møller
Elise Måge
Sarah Mohamud
Sandra Otteraaen
Fahrie Berisha
Charlotte Treschow
Anna Maria Moström
Jazzmine Berger
Maria Lindgren
Emelie Törnqvist
27  
Paris
3   February 14, 2006 (2006-02-14)
  February 27, 2006 (2006-02-27)
  March 8, 2006 (2006-03-08)
 
Freja Kjellberg Borchies
 
Anna Brændstrup
 
Therese Haugsnes
Sara Olsen & Cathrine Wenger, Florina Weisz, Sabina Karlsson & Mira Aanes Wolden & Camilla Schønberg
  Denmark   Norway   Sweden
Mira Pelle
Cecilia Kristensen
Stine Palle
Nana Bach Nielsen
Line Vanggaard Nielsen
Christina Anaya Mortensen
Signe Cecilie Nørgaard
Ingrid Janne Sæberg
Rikke Kalsveen
Helene Sletten Vangen
Ellen Caroline Brenger (quit)
Kira Hellsten
Camilla Abry
Sandra Nilsson
Joanna Häggblom
Ebba Söderström
Emma Johansson
Julia Agapova
Sofia Eriksson
Kristina Svensson
29  
Milan
4 TBA TBA TBA TBA TBA TBA
Looks good! It's fine by me. Linguist 111talk 12:24, 12 May 2016 (UTC)Reply
The discussion above is closed. Please do not modify it. Subsequent comments should be made on the appropriate discussion page. No further edits should be made to this discussion.