Template talk:Romeo editnotice
(Redirected from Template talk:Romeo notice/doc)
Latest comment: 15 years ago by Cenarium in topic Rewrite
This template was considered for deletion on 2008 November 17. The result of the discussion was "no consensus". |
Uses
editI list here the different uses so that we can see their relevance, if they need more specific notices or no notice at all.
- Significant other low levels of vandalism, I don't think an editnotice is justified
- Sexual attraction same
- Marriage is indefinitely semi-protected, so it doesn't require this kind of editnotice, but still one for other reasons
- Soulmate attracts this kind of vandalism
- Romance (love) same
- Girlfriend same
- Engagement a little
- Proposal of marriage very low levels of vandalism, I don't think an editnotice is justified
- Cuteness attracts a lot of this kind of vandalism
- Lovely a disambiguation page with low levels of editing and vandalism, probably not needed there
- Physical attractiveness attracts this kind of vandalism
- Gorgeous also
- Pretty too
- Beautiful is indefinitely semi-protected, making the editnotice largely unneeded
- Beauty same as above
- Love is indefinitely semi-protected, making the editnotice largely unneeded
- Femininity has low level of vandalism, I don't think an editnotice is needed.
- Cleavage (breasts) doesn't attract this kind of vandalism
Rewrite
editI have rewritten the template in a more professional way. Even if our goal is to reach a certain population, we should appear in a professional light, especially in mainspace system messages, and have consideration for other users. The template was addressed to romeos/sweethearts, but all editors can see it, so this should say 'notice to editors', also keeping in line with AGF. Cenarium (Talk) 03:27, 27 December 2008 (UTC)