Wikipedia

Murder of Marie Wilks

(Redirected from The Murder of Marie Wilks)

Marie Patricia Wilks (30 March 1966 – 18 June 1988) was a 22-year-old seven-months-pregnant woman who was abducted from the hard shoulder of the M50 motorway and murdered on 18 June 1988. Her body was found two days later dumped three miles up the road, after a witness described having seen a silver-grey Renault 25 car parked there. In 1989, Eddie Browning, who had been driving a silver-grey Renault 25 that day, was found guilty of the murder at trial by a unanimous jury decision. A violent man with previous convictions for assault and having only recently been released from prison for aggravated burglary, Browning had stormed out of his home that day after a violent row with his seven-months-pregnant wife, declaring he was driving to Scotland – a route that would have naturally taken him along the M50. Dozens of witnesses reported seeing a blond man in a silver-grey C-registered Renault 25 parking by Wilks and then driving off erratically and both the descriptions of the man and the car matched Browning and his vehicle. Several of Browning's friends and associates called in to report Browning as matching the artist's impression of the suspect and he was the only driver of C-registered silver-grey Renault 25s nationwide who could not be eliminated as a suspect, indicating that only he could be responsible. A tyre expert also testified at trial that a skid mark at the place the body was found matched a wheel on Browning's car.

Murder of Marie Wilks
The M50 in 2016. The emergency telephone, where Wilks was attacked and abducted, was by the trees on the right-hand side of the image, near the blue lorry.
Date18 June 1988
TimeApprox. 7:40 pm
LocationEmergency telephone 2076B, M50 motorway, near Longdon, Worcestershire
Marie Wilks
Wilks, c. 1988
Born30 March 1966
Disappeared18 June 1988
Emergency telephone 2706B, hard shoulder of the M50 motorway52°01′04″N 2°13′35″W / 52.017643°N 2.226348°W / 52.017643; -2.226348
StatusFound murdered on 20 June 1988
Died18 June 1988 (aged 22)
Cause of deathStab wounds to the neck
Body discoveredEmbankment on the side of the eastbound carriageway of the M50 motorway, slightly east of Junction 1 52°02′11″N 2°09′37″W / 52.036436°N 2.160195°W / 52.036436; -2.160195
Known forAbduction from the side of a busy motorway within sight of traffic and subsequent murder

Having failed in an initial appeal in which he complained that the trial judge had prevented the jury from convicting him of manslaughter and not murder (i.e. that he killed Wilks but that he did not intend to do so), Browning was controversially released in 1994 on a technicality. A police officer who had felt guilty at having driven past the scene despite apparently seeing the killer turn and park next to Wilks had undergone hypnosis to try to remember more of the car's numberplate, but the video of this had not been disclosed to either the prosecution or defence. It was determined that this 'irregularity' affected the conviction as he had given a numberplate different to Browning's, even though he still maintained it was a C-registered vehicle. The prosecution maintained the video had only not been disclosed as the man's claims were unreliable and he had unintentionally made up the evidence in an effort to be helpful, highlighting how he had immediately apologised and told police to ignore it. It was argued that there still remained sufficient evidence and witness sightings even without the officer's evidence to convict Browning but the judges ruled they could not be certain the jury would still have convicted Browning had they also seen the video and so ordered his release, although did not declare him innocent.

Browning was given compensation, although at that time all individuals freed on appeal were automatically given compensation no matter whether evidence existed to prove them innocent or not. In the years after being freed Browning was twice convicted of carrying a knife in public (the same believed used in the murder) and also for drunk driving and attempting to evade arrest, whilst also being arrested on two other occasions for allegedly attacking his wife with a chainsaw and for causing a car accident. In 2000, one of the friends and colleagues who had called police saying he matched the artist's impression in the Wilks case testified on oath at a trial that Browning had admitted to murdering the woman the day before he was arrested. Re-investigations of the case failed to identify any suspects other than Browning. He died in 2018 aged 63; police said there were no suspicious circumstances.

Background

edit

Marie Wilks was pregnant[1] and heading home to Worcester after visiting her husband Adrian at a Territorial Army camp. She was driving accompanied by her 11-year-old sister, Georgina Gough, and her 13-month-old son Mark.[2] She was attacked while calling for assistance after her car had broken down, and her body was later found on the side of the M50 motorway.[1]

Search and discovery

edit
 
Wilks was found dead beside the eastbound carriageway on the right of this image (this picture is taken from the westbound carriageway approaching Junction 1). Several witnesses reported seeing a Renault 25 parked inside the crash barrier on the edge of the road, and when police went to the spot they found Wilks' body.

By 8.10 pm, a police helicopter had been scrambled to search with heat-seeking imagery; however, it was unsuccessful due to the hot June weather. At 8.20pm, tracker dogs began to aid the large police search. At dawn, the following day, some blood was discovered around the emergency phone area. A witness came forward to report seeing a silver Renault 25 parked three miles further up the road in a reversed position behind the crash barrier at the side of the road, and when this witness led police to the spot on 20 June, the body of Wilks was discovered at the bottom of the embankment,[3][4] near the Bushley area in Hereford and Worcester.[5] Wilks had been stabbed in the side of her neck, severing her carotid artery, and struck on the side of the head.[6] It was later disclosed that Wilks had tried to use her Red Cross training to stem the blood from her punctured artery with her hand, which had successfully helped reduce her blood loss and might have saved her, before the killer had punched her three or four times in the face and broken her jaw, knocking her out and finally killing her.[3] The attack, murder and dumping of Wilks' body would only have taken about 10 minutes in total.[7]

Further evidence was found at the site that a car had been reversed behind the crash barrier.[6]

Investigation and arrest

edit

West Mercia police set up interview areas in nearby service stations and also detained motorists in their search for witnesses. On 24 June, an artist's impression of a possible suspect was released, with further witness descriptions of a blond man seen at the crime scene. He was described as "of young appearances, in his 20s", blond crew cut hair, with possible yellow or orange highlights. He had pale skin and a long sharp nose. This man had been seen driving his silver-grey car onto the hard shoulder next to Wilks's car, and a similarly-described man had been seen by witnesses near Wilks at the emergency telephone.[8] Several witnesses corroborated the sighting.[8]

Experts attempted to examine an automatic tape machine[clarification needed] by the site of the phone box, believing that it may have recorded the attack.[9] On 25 June, a reconstruction was filmed on the M50, with WPC Taryn Green dressed in a similar pink and white maternity dress to the one Marie had worn. On 28 June, following an identity parade, Edward Owen Browning was charged with the abduction and murder of Marie Wilks.[10]

Evidence against Eddie Browning

edit
 
 
The artist's impression of the suspect in the Wilks' case, compared to Eddie Browning. Browning was later found to have been wearing a blue and white striped shirt on the day of the murder, as the suspect was described and depicted in the artist's impression.
 
Several witnesses saw a silver-grey Renault 25 both at the murder scene and parked where the body was found. Browning was driving a silver-grey Renault 25 that day.

"Eddie" Browning was a former Welsh Guardsman who had been rejected by the SAS and who worked as a night club bouncer in a South Wales social club.[11][12] He lived in Cwmparc, in the Rhondda Valley area of South Wales, and was said to live off his 'hard man' reputation as a bouncer.[13] He was married, and expecting a baby with his wife, Julie, although he was also cheating on her at the time.[12] This was his second marriage, with his first marriage notably having broken up because of Browning's violence.[14] He had a reputation for mindless, random violence and had a criminal record, including two convictions for assault.[11][12] He had only recently been released from prison in 1986, having served a seven-year sentence for aggravated burglary.[11] At the time, police had found a revolver he used to threaten victims buried in his garden.[13] He had also once chased two policemen with a samurai sword.[15] He was considerably stressed at the time of the murder because he had recently developed the life-changing condition diabetes.[14]

Police had become interested in Browning after several calls identifying him from the artist's impression, which bore a remarkable likeness to him.[16][13][17] One of the 14 calls identifying Browning had come from Browning's own close friend and fellow night club bouncer Kenneth Latten, who said he matched the description and also reported that he became edgy and unstable as soon as the artist's impression came on TV while they were at a club together.[11][10][18][19] On the day of the murder he left his house to drive to Scotland after a violent row with his wife, who, like Wilks, was seven months pregnant at the time.[11] The row had begun after Browning insisted his wife make breakfast for him, which she did not want to do as she had just returned from work.[11][14] For some hours he went out to several clubs and pubs and drank a considerable amount, and witnesses recounted him being in a foul and reckless mood.[14][20] Browning then came home, only to soon storm out again after his wife became angered at him ignoring her and a violent argument ensued about his womanizing; he had indeed been cheating with a mistress at the time.[12][11][21] His first wife would later tell the press that Browning was a violent and unfaithful man who cheated on her constantly, even on the day before their wedding, and also used to hit her when she complained, including when she was pregnant.[22] It later materialised that Browning's second wife had herself been cheating behind her husband's back at the time of the murder; it is not known if Browning knew about this, but the man who the wife was having an affair with told the press that Browning "would kill us if he found out" since he was "a maniac and would gladly kill any man who went with his wife".[23] It was said that Browning had on multiple occasions assaulted local men he thought had been having affairs with his wife.[23]

Browning declared that he was going to drive away to a friend's house in Scotland after the second row, with his wife not knowing how long he would be away.[11] After the murder, it was revealed, Browning had called his mistress to tell her about the violent row with his wife, saying: "Bev, I had to go then because if I had stayed I would have killed her".[12] It was later argued that this showed he had "murder on his mind".[24] When Browning's wife heard that he had been arrested for the murder she reportedly collapsed.[25] Three "vital" calls were received by police from an anonymous man in Scotland; it was not known if this evidence was related to the friend in Scotland Browning drove to see on the day of the murder.[26][27]

It was believed that Browning had seen the vulnerable Wilks at the side of the motorway on his journey and, still filled with rage, had stopped to attack her.[11] When he had seen that she was heavily pregnant, it may have reminded him of the tempestuous relationship he had with his own heavily pregnant wife and reignited his anger which led to him stabbing her.[11] The amount he had drunk likely would have also worsened his state of mind.[14]

Witnesses had seen a silver Renault 25 car parked at the spot where the body was later found dumped, and dozens of witnesses had come forward to report seeing this silver-grey C-registered Renault driving erratically on the stretch of the motorway near the murder site, with the blond-haired driver speeding at speeds of up to 120 miles per hour.[13][28][3][29][30] Browning had been driving a C-registered silver-grey Renault 25 that day.[13] An off-duty police officer had seen Browning park his silver-grey car by Wilks as she was on the emergency telephone, but assumed that he was offering to help her and so drove on.[11] Several witnesses corroborated this account, reporting that they had seen the silver Renault perform a U-turn across the central reservation before parking up next to Wilks.[3] One woman reported seeing the man getting out and touching Wilks.[3] All these witnesses reported the man who had parked near Wilks and got out to speak to her as being blond.[31] Another officer also saw Browning's car parked by the embankment where Wilks was dumped, but did not know at that early stage that it was connected to Wilks' murder.[11] Crucially, a motorist had also identified the first two letters of the car's numberplate, which matched Browning's numberplate.[32] Police were able to eliminate all the 479 other drivers of silver/grey Renault cars in the country with the same first two letters on their numberplates, meaning Browning was further incriminated by a process of elimination and indicating only he could have been responsible.[32][21][33][20] The only driver of such a vehicle across the country whose movements could not be accounted for on the day of the murder was Browning.[20] Police later said that even if his name had not been given to the police by tip-offs they would have eventually interviewed Browning anyway because of these descriptions of the type of Renault car which Browning was driving and the numberplate, with his car one of the 480 in the country that matched the descriptions.[21][20]

It was known by witnesses that Browning owned a butterfly knife whose blade matched the one used in the murder, and which he carried with him.[11][21] Several people had seen him practicing opening it.[21] He was a martial arts enthusiast and had boasted about his speed with a knife.[12]

Trial

edit
 
Wilks was dumped beside the road a few hundred yards (metres) up the road from this spot, near Junction 1 of the M50.

The trial of Eddie Browning took place at Shrewsbury Crown Court, beginning on 3 October 1989, and ending on 10 November 1989. The evidence was presented by Mr Anthony Palmer, QC for the prosecution. A notable moment in the trial was when Browning openly admitted that, in his duties as a bouncer, he could punch someone hard enough to break their jaw.[14] Wilks had been found with a broken jaw when she was discovered murdered.[14] Some years previously, Browning had broken a police officer's jaw at a South Wales police station but had been cleared by a court after claiming self-defence.[13] The jury were not told this information, nor did they know about Browning's prior convictions for assault or aggravated burglary, since laws at the time prevented prior criminal convictions being disclosed in court.[13] With his wife and mistress in court attending, Browning admitted he could be "insensitive" to women, but denied that he could be "callous".[12] By the time of the trial Browning's pregnant wife had given birth to a baby daughter who he then met in prison, which had delighted him.[34][35] Both of the psychologists appointed by the court to inspect Browning agreed that there might have been a serious disturbance in Browning's past which had left him with his unstable personality.[12] However, both concluded that he had killed out of anger.[12]

Mr John Griffiths Williams QC, for the defence, argued that Browning had not been on the M50 on 18 June 1989. Browning himself said that he had crossed the Severn Bridge on his journey to Scotland and had not travelled on the M50 that day. However, Mr Palmer of the prosecution pointed out that security cameras on the Severn Bridge did not pick up Browning's car that day, indicating that Browning's story was a lie.[36][13] Browning's own father also testified against his son for the prosecution and said that Eddie had called in to ask him the best route to Scotland from south Wales that day, and he told him to go via the M50, before Browning promptly left and started his journey.[20] Browning was found to have a written route which included the M50, and the trial judge asked the jury to consider why Browning had therefore dubiously claimed he had not used the M50, when he was accused of a murder on the M50.[37] The prosecution pointed out that Browning had claimed he had got rid of his butterfly knife three weeks before the murder, yet witnesses had reported him showing them it two days before the murder, indicating he was lying and still had it at the time of the killing.[38]

Defence QC Williams said that Browning had only "acted impulsively" said there was nothing to suggest any sexual motive.[14] The defence argued that Browning only bore a superficial resemblance to the artist's impression, especially in regards to hair cut and age. However, the tyre expert revealed at the trial that the skid mark made near the spot Wilks' body was found was made by Browning's Renault 25 car, saying that he was certain it came from his front nearside wheel.[39] The front nearside wheel on Browning's car had a braking fault that matched the peculiar mark one of the skid marks had left, and also was heavily worn and without tread just like the mark.[19][40] Browning's friend also testified that there was a thick smudge of blood on the car when he arrived in Scotland, with Browning saying it must have come from "an animal he had hit on the journey" before cleaning it off.[41][13] The friend, however, saw that the blood was thick and not like thin animal blood.[28] Browning then asked the friend for a bucket of water and cloth to clean it off before asking if he could then keep the cloth, the friend testified.[38][28] The friend's housemate also corroborated this story, and both said that Browning had arrived wearing a blue and white striped shirt, two of seven witnesses who said so.[42][43] Browning's friend also said that he was wearing blue jeans.[44] These were exactly the type of clothes witnesses had described the suspect at the scene of the murder as wearing, as depicted in the artist's impression.[36]

Browning's own brother also testified that Browning said had spoken of burning his Renault 25 car for an insurance claim.[13] Forensic experts had in fact found a smear of human blood in Browning's car, but it was too small a sample to tell the blood group (forensic science at that time could only tell what blood group a bloodstain was, not whose blood it was).[45] It was believed that Browning had used his knowledge from his prior criminal experiences to hide more evidence.[43]

The jury did not believe Eddie Browning's version of events and they found him unanimously guilty of murder after five and a half hours deliberation.[11][14] He was sentenced to life in prison to serve a minimum of 25 years.[14] In his sentencing remarks, the trial judge said Browning had showed himself to be "vain and arrogant" in the dock[14] and said he "wholeheartedly" agreed with the verdict of the jury.[33] He told Browning:

On June 18, 1988, you had plainly had a fierce disagreement with your wife, arising in part out of your selfish demand that she, heavily pregnant, should get your breakfast. Following that, you spent six hours in pubs and clubs in the Upper Rhondda and on your return ignored your wife, which led to a violent disagreement. You set out for Scotland, without your wife knowing how long you would be away. You saw the solitary figure of a pregnant woman on the motorway. Whether out of spite or rage or any other reason, you determined to wreak violence on that person. It is plain you intended to take it out on her because she was defenceless and because she was pregnant.[11]

There were cheers and applause from the public gallery when the guilty verdict was announced, and Wilks' sobbing husband Adrian rushed to thank Anthony Palmer of the prosecution.[11][33] After the trial, he stated: "I never had any doubts that Browning killed Marie".[14] Wilks' father also broke down after the verdict, exclaiming "brilliant".[11] Browning showed no reaction when found guilty, staring straight ahead.[11]

After the trial, the friend who Browning had travelled to see on the day of the murder said he believed Browning had indeed killed Wilks, saying: "My feeling is that Eddie just snapped. In his mind's eye he was killing his own pregnant wife. She is lucky to be alive".[24] Browning's first wife also commented: "It doesn't surprise me Eddie could kill a pregnant woman. Sometimes I thought he would murder me. It didn't matter to Eddie who he hit, policemen, women, anybody. If he got in a rage you couldn't stop him".[22] She added: "He beat me and then denied it. Eddie was the sort of man who would lie about everything. No wonder he insisted he was innocent at the trial - he doesn't know what the truth is".[22]

Praise for investigation

edit

The judge praised the prosecution and its preparation, and commended Detective Chief Superintendent David Cole, who led the investigation.[33] He said that the detectives who worked on the case deserved "the highest commendations".[32]

The lead detective on the case, David Cole, was a highly-regarded detective who up until then had only ever failed to solve one out of the 88 murders he investigated.[46] He was celebrated in particular for bringing Geoffrey Prime to justice.[46]

Appeals

edit

Browning lost an appeal against his conviction in 1991.[21] He had complained about the nature of the evidence against him, but the Court of Appeal stated that the evidence had been properly admitted as the jury had been correctly directed on it.[21] He had also complained that the judge had prevented the jury from coming to a manslaughter verdict against him (i.e. that he had indeed killed her but accidentally), but this was rejected.[21][47] He said that the evidence about him appearing similar to the E-fit was faulty, but the trial judge pointed out that the prosecution's case was only that the witness sightings were not inconsistent with Browning's appearance, and never claimed they were identical.[48] When the judges rejected the appeal and ordered Browning to be taken down, Browning shouted out "I have done nothing to be ashamed of".[47] Wilks' family spoke of their relief at the decision to reject Browning's appeal.[49]

Eddie Browning's new QC, Michael Mansfield, launched a new appeal in 1994. He introduced new evidence to the court, that West Mercia Police has withheld witness evidence and statements. In particular, the evidence obtained under hypnosis of off-duty police Inspector Peter Clarke.[50] He had seen a grey/silver car pulling over onto the hard shoulder at the crime scene. During his hypnotic state, Inspector Clarke gave the car registration number as C856HFK; Browning's car registration was C754VAD. There were other differences in make of car and type of hubcaps. Another witness was "encouraged", according to Mr Mansfield, to say that he had seen a C reg car when in actuality, he could not be sure. However, while the hypnosis video had not been disclosed to the defence, it had also not been disclosed to the prosecution.[51] Additionally, Mr Clarke insisted that the registration number he mentioned during hypnosis was not certain and told police at the time that they "shouldn't spend too much time on it".[29] The police insisted that Clarke had unintentionally made up the evidence "in an effort to be helpful".[52] Clarke had been criticised for having driven on despite having seen a man, presumably the killer, having turned and stopped by Wilks while she was at the emergency phone, with Clarke notably saying that "I have to live with that on my conscience, that a young woman and her child lost their lives because I made a fatal error of judgement".[29] After making the video in an attempt to make up for this error and the fact he had been unable to remember the numberplate other than it starting with a C, Clarke was extremely apologetic and wished for the details from the hypnosis session to be dismissed, saying he could only be sure of the details in his original statement.[53] He insisted that the only thing he could remember for sure was that the car's numberplate started with a C – as Browning's indeed did.[53]

Defending the conviction at the appeal, the prosecution said that the video had not been handed to any of the lawyers because it was considered unreliable, that it was a marginal part of the inquiry, and because the "sham" hypnosis video had in any case been made without the authorisation of the lead detective.[53] The detectives who managed the investigation had already been cleared of misconduct in not disclosing the video tape.[54] The Crown argued that, although the video should have been disclosed, it would not have been of any value anyway, as Clarke had been in a "hyper-suggestive" state and the overly-keen-to-help man was clearly being coaxed by the hypnotist in the video.[55] The court also heard that even without the evidence of Clarke, there remained enough evidence to convict Browning, and that it was an "entirely safe conviction".[53][51] Dozens of other witnesses had also reported seeing a blond man who looked similar to Browning driving this same car, and one had been able to identify the first two letters of the numberplate being "C7", which matched Browning's numberplate of C754VAD.[29] Browning's car was still the only C7-registered Renault 25 car out of the nearly 500 known to be in the country that could have been in the vicinity of the murder that day.[28] Clarke had continued to maintain that the car was a C-registered vehicle with C as the first letter on the numberplate, which partly corroborated the other witness's sighting of the numberplate starting C7.[29]

Lord Chief Justice Taylor gave opinion that if the hypnosis evidence had been included in the original trial, he could not be certain that the verdict would have remained the same. The appeal was therefore narrowly granted and, in May 1994, Browning was freed, although he was not declared innocent.[56] The judges also did not find that there was any bad faith in relation to any officer of the West Mercia Police.[57] West Mercia Police said they were "surprised and disappointed" by the Court of Appeal's decision, and added that there were no new lines of inquiry which pointed to anyone other than Browning having committed the crime.[57][58] Wilks's widower remarked that he was "totally gutted" by the decision and said it was "the second worst day of my life".[58]

Browning advised the Wilks family to go back to West Mercia police, although he also stated that "over the years I have lost any sympathy for the Wilks family."[57][59] He also acknowledged that he had not managed to prove that he was an innocent man.[60] He was subsequently awarded £600,000 in damages, which Wilks's widower, Adrian, said made him "shocked and distressed".[6][61] At that time, every individual who requested compensation after being acquitted on appeal would, automatically, be given compensation even if, as in Browning's case, there was no evidence proving their innocence; this law was only changed in 2006, when it was ruled that compensation would only be given "if and only if the new or newly discovered fact shows beyond reasonable doubt that the person did not commit the offence".[62][63] Around this time, there began to be complaints in the press that people such as Browning had been awarded compensation, yet people who were apparently more likely to be innocent of the crimes they had been convicted of such as Angela Cannings had yet to be given any.[64] Worcester MP Mike Foster said he could not comment on Mr Browning's acquittal, that he did not know if he had been rightly acquitted or not, but said his sympathies were with Mrs Wilks's family.[61] Detective Chief Superintendent David Coles, head of CID, later said, "All I would say is that I was completely satisfied with the investigation".[17]

Upon his release, Browning moved back to Cwmparc, in Wales, where locals there gave him a less-than-warm reception, as many remained convinced he was guilty, with one commenting to the press: "There's a lot of people won't be rejoicing".[59] Even prior to the murder, he had a long-standing reputation in the village for being quick with his fists.[59] Due to the strength of feeling in the village, only a small celebratory reception was held by close friends when Browning returned home.[59] Soon after he was released, Browning moved from Cwmparc to Ceredigion.[65] Within only seven months of his release, Browning's wife, Julie, filed for divorce from him because of the "living hell" of living with him.[66] He also quickly spent all of his initial compensation money on luxury items and nights out drinking, saying that his release "hasn't made me any happier".[66] He later married for a third time to Merediel Tomson.[61]

Aftermath

edit

Police reinvestigations of the Wilks murder have not uncovered any suspects other than Browning and police continue to believe Browning was responsible.[57][65][17] In 1995, only one year after he was freed, Browning was arrested in a pub for possessing a knife in public.[67] Thirteen other people in the pub were arrested simultaneously for drug offences, and drugs such as heroin and cocaine were found.[67][68] Browning refused to accept that any drugs were found.[68] The knife was a butterfly knife, similar to the one used in the Wilks's murder, and he was convicted at court for possessing it and fined £150.[69] Afterwards Browning attempted to approach national newspapers to try and sell his story.[69]

In 1996, Browning made the news again after police issued a request for the public to help locate him so they could arrest him for allegedly threatening his estranged wife.[70] The wife had dialled 999 from their home and the emergency operators reportedly heard the sound of him attacking her with a chainsaw in the background.[71][72]

In 2000, Kenny Latten, the friend of Browning and fellow bouncer who had been one of those who had reported Browning matching the E-fit in the initial investigation, attacked Browning in his home in Rhondda.[10][73] At his subsequent trial for the attack, Latten testified, on oath, that Browning had admitted to killing Wilks the day before he was originally arrested and he said this to Browning during their fight.[73][10] Latten also said that he then told Browning's wife of his confession.[73] Despite this new evidence Browning could not be retried for the murder due to the double jeopardy laws in place at the time.[74] A jury only took less than an hour to clear Latten of wounding Browning.[10]

In 2002, Browning was arrested again and charged with failing to stop after a car accident.[75] He was also charged with failing to report the accident.[75]

In 2005, Browning was banned from driving for 28 months after being caught driving three times over the legal alcohol limit.[76] He initially claimed that he had only consumed alcohol due to 'his drink being spiked'.[76] His brown Land Rover had been spotted driving erratically from one side of the road to the other, and when police attempted to pull him over he refused to stop.[76] He was only stopped when another police officer used his car to block a junction and stop him from going any further.[76] When he was finally stopped, he was found to be carrying a lock knife in his pocket.[77] He was told at court that he was lucky to avoid prison for the offence.[76]

In 2008, the original pathologist in the investigation said that advances in forensic science could feasibly help solved Wilks's murder.[78] David Cole, the lead detective on the original case, who had always believed Browning was responsible, said of the possible forensic opportunities: "I would be very interested if West Mercia was to re-open the case and submit certain items of evidence to renewed examination."[17]

In 2016, Detective Chief Inspector, Steve Tonks, with his team, reopened the case to see if any new forensic evidence could be generated to solve the murder. No such evidence was found, and the case remains, officially, unsolved.[65]

In 2018, while police were conducting a reinvestigation of the murder,[5] Browning died aged 63.[65] He was found dead in his home in Lampeter, Wales.[65] Police said that it was a sudden death and that there were no suspicious circumstances.[65]

The murder of Marie Wilks produced outrage at the death of a young mother; fear in lone female motorists; embarrassment and frustration for the West Mercia Police force, whose tactics and procedures were found to be deficient; and brought attention to crimes against pregnant women.

Issues raised by the murder

edit

Safety

edit

The fate of Marie Wilks was still being discussed in relation to driver safety years later.[79] Other similar incidents, involving serious attacks on lone female drivers who had broken down,[80] and the continued fears of women revealed in surveys that showed that eight out of ten women felt "some degree" of anxiety in driving alone.[81] In 1988, the only safety option opened to motorists was the emergency phone. There was conflicting advice given to women who broke down. These women, on being interviewed, described being abandoned by police or even being fined for helping other stranded women. In 2021, police are still advising the use of the emergency phone while also recommending to get into your car if another person approaches you and you feel in danger.[82] There does not seem to be any new thinking on the subject of the safety of solo female motorists.

Violence against pregnant women

edit

A part of the circumstantial evidence against Eddie Browning was the fact of his angry row with his pregnant wife. There is some literature to evidence the vulnerability of pregnant women to attack.[83] Pregnant women are attacked and murdered for various reasons, with the desire to control the overriding one.[84] There is little academic study in the UK, and none about the murder of an expectant mother by a stranger. The exceptional murder of Marie Wilks shocked the British public, not only by its brutality but in its singularity. The United States has a crime of murder of the unborn child, with the "Unborn Victims of Violence Act", of 2004. The UK has no such laws. An unborn child is not a person in law in the UK, although there is a law of child destruction, which has been difficult to prove in most cases.[85] The murder of Marie Wilks also caused the death of her unborn child.

Bystander theory

edit

One of the most shocking aspects of the crime was that 11 year old Georgina Gough was seen walking down the hard shoulder, carrying her baby nephew, looking for her sister, and that no motorist stopped to help her. Latane and Darley found that sometimes apathy stops intervention.[86] People tend to use excuses, in this case, being in a car on a motorway. There are "strong situational factors" at play that stop a person acting in a critical situation. The term "bystander effect"[87] refers to the theory that the more witnesses there are, the fewer will help in crisis. Applying this to the M50 murder, it is possible to theorise that those people in cars imagined that "someone else" would do something, the "diffusion of responsibility" hypothesis.

Withholding of evidence by the police

edit

Detective Inspector Peter Clarke was off duty and driving on the M50 on 18 June 1988, when he spotted a man on the hard shoulder as well as a car. In court, he described what he had seen; a grey/silver car and a blond man. However, West Mercia police had not told the court that Inspector Clarke had agreed to undergo hypnotism in order to better recollect specific details. During hypnosis, however, Inspector Clarke gave the car registration number as C856HFK. Eddie Browning's car registration was C754VAD. The police also reserved other evidence from further witnesses. The successful 1994 appeal by Browning hinged on this abuse of process,[88] the non- disclosure of evidence and this led, along with other similar cases to the Criminal Procedure and Investigation Act of 1996.[89] Before this Act, defence barristers had access to all "unused material". In reality, the senior investigative officer decided what was shared. The conviction of Browning overturned on appeal was one of a series of cases where an appeal was upheld because of non-disclosure of possibly pertinent evidence. The Home Secretary, in 1996, took the decision of disclosure away from the police and gave it to the Crown Prosecution Service.[90] The CPS would then apply the test "does the unused material assist the defence or undermine the prosecution". Lord Chief Justice Taylor decided that if the new evidence had been included at the original trial, it was impossible to determine whether the verdict would still have been guilty.

Use of hypnosis in criminal investigations

edit

In 1977, the use of hypnosis in order to retrieve "hidden" evidence from a witness to a crime, was treated with some interest with studies concluding that it "may be a potential tool to get information".[91] The fact that Browning had got off on the hypnosis evidence even though the witness had only apparently invented the evidence to be helpful had apparently highlighted the pitfalls of hypnosis as evidence and its accuracy, and in 1995 the Court of Appeal which had previously freed Browning stated that "hypnosis... should not normally be considered in relation to witnesses who might be called to give material evidence".[52] In 2018, The Crown Prosecution Service concluded that the use of hypnosis may be subject to "cueing" or suggestion planting. A hypnosis subject should only be used as a witness in 'exceptional circumstances'.[92]

edit

Belinda Bauer has written a novel loosely based on the murder of Marie Wilks, called Snap.[93] The novel was long-listed for the Man Booker prize 2018.[94]

See also

edit

References

edit
  1. ^ a b "Man wrongly convicted of notorious Marie Wilks murder, has died". ITV News. 17 May 2018. Retrieved 18 May 2021.
  2. ^ "Murder beside motorway struck fear into women: Freed man tells family". The Independent. 23 October 2011. Archived from the original on 18 June 2022. Retrieved 18 May 2021.
  3. ^ a b c d e "Wilks case is stark reminder of vulnerability". The Independent. 9 November 1989.
  4. ^ Mills, Heather (4 October 1989). "Killer's voice may have been heard on M50 call". The Independent.
  5. ^ a b Walford, Jessica (23 September 2018). "Murdered as she rang for help on the M50: The mystery of Marie Wilks' death". WalesOnline. Retrieved 12 May 2021.
  6. ^ a b c BBC. "M50 murder - Timeline". BBC. Retrieved 12 May 2021.
  7. ^ Kirby, Terry (22 June 1988). "Police patrols may have driven past murder victim". The Independent.
  8. ^ a b c "Spiky-haired man sought over M50 killing". The Independent. 25 June 1988.
  9. ^ "Search for Killer Weapon". Nottingham Evening Post. 22 June 1988. p. 12.
  10. ^ a b c d e "Man cleared of assault on Eddie Browning". BBC News. 23 February 2000. Retrieved 18 September 2022.
  11. ^ a b c d e f g h i j k l m n o p q r Seton, Craig (9 November 1989). "Motorway murderer gets life sentence; Edward Browning". The Times.
  12. ^ a b c d e f g h i Mills, Heather (9 November 1989). "Random attack adds to list of grim statistics". The Independent.
  13. ^ a b c d e f g h i j "Former soldier who lived off hard-man reputation". The Guardian. 9 November 1989. p. 4.
  14. ^ a b c d e f g h i j k l Hoyland, Paul (9 November 1989). "M50 killer to serve 25 years, says judge". The Guardian. p. 9.
  15. ^ Smith, Sue (9 November 1989). "Life for the M50 killer". Birmingham Mail. p. 20.
  16. ^ "The M50 Murder: Marie Wilks". A.G.P STORIES. 30 July 2019. Retrieved 12 May 2021.
  17. ^ a b c d Pryce, Mike (19 February 2018). "Could DNA advances finally bring justice for Worcester mum who was murdered on the motorway?". Worcester News. Retrieved 18 September 2022.
  18. ^ Thomas, David (17 October 1989). "Bouncer tells of tip-off to detective on M50 murder". The Independent.
  19. ^ a b "Colleague's tip-off led police to Browning". Birmingham News. 17 October 1989. p. 5.
  20. ^ a b c d e "Suspect car last on murder list". The Guardian. 7 October 1989. p. 2.
  21. ^ a b c d e f g h "M-way murder appeal fails". The Guardian. 25 May 1991. p. 4.
  22. ^ a b c "Eddie Cheated Bride the Day before Wedding". Sunday Mirror. 12 November 1989.
  23. ^ a b Sounes, Howard; O'Hanlon, Terry (12 November 1989). "My Nights of Magic with the M50 Monster's Wife". Daily Mirror.
  24. ^ a b Cameron, Ian; Daniels, William; Hay, Gordon (9 November 1989). "Row with His Wife.. And Marie Was Doomed to Die". Daily Mirror.
  25. ^ Daniels, Williams (30 June 1988). "Angry Crowd Jeer M50 Murder Charge Man". Daily Mirror.
  26. ^ "Plea to mystery Scots witness in murder hunt". Dundee Courier. 24 June 1988. p. 15.
  27. ^ "N.E. twist to M50 death". Aberdeen Press and Journal. 28 June 1988. p. 27.
  28. ^ a b c d "M50 murder trial told of N.E. visit". Aberdeen Press and Journal. 4 October 1989. p. 8.
  29. ^ a b c d e Chaudhary, Vivek (14 May 1994). "Withheld evidence crucial in M-way murder case: Vivek Chaudhary looks at the tragic circumstances of the unsolved murder of a young pregnant mother, Marie Wilks". The Guardian. p. 12.
  30. ^ Perera, Shyama (25 June 1988). "Picture clue to M50 killer". The Guardian. p. 22.
  31. ^ a b c Thomas, David (9 November 1989). "Club bouncer gets life for killing woman on M50". The Independent.
  32. ^ a b c d O'Brian, James (9 November 1989). "Ex-Guardsman receives life term for motorway murder of Marie Wilks". The Telegraph.
  33. ^ "Baby for wife of M50 case man". Sunday Mirror. 17 July 1988.
  34. ^ "Brute cuddled baby in prison". Daily Mirror. 9 November 1989. p. 5.
  35. ^ a b BBC. "M50 murder - Timeline". BBC. Retrieved 18 May 2021.
  36. ^ "Verdict due on Marie murder". Sandwell Evening Mail. 8 November 1989. p. 2.
  37. ^ a b "M50 accused 'seen with lost knife'". The Independent. 12 October 1989.
  38. ^ "Skid mark 'made by M50 murder suspect's car'". The Daily Telegraph. 14 October 1989.
  39. ^ "Murder trial car to be inspected by the jury". Aberdeen Press and Journal. 14 October 1989. p. 5.
  40. ^ "'Blood on Car'". Daily Mirror. 11 October 1989.
  41. ^ "Marie jury told of cloth to clean car". Newcastle Journal. 12 October 1989. p. 2.
  42. ^ a b "Murderer who tried to cover his tracks". Birmingham Mail. 9 November 1989. p. 20.
  43. ^ Hay, Gordon; Cameron, Ian (9 November 1989). "The M-Way killer". Daily Record. p. 4.
  44. ^ "Blood found". Birmingham News. 26 October 1989. p. 5.
  45. ^ a b "'Spy catcher' to quit police". Sandwell Evening Mail. 3 March 1990. p. 4.
  46. ^ a b "M50 murderer fails in High Court appeal". The Independent. 25 May 1991.
  47. ^ "Conviction in Marie Wilks murder upheld". Dundee Courier. 25 May 1991. p. 3.
  48. ^ "Motorway killer loses appeal". Aberdeen Press and Journal. 25 May 1991. p. 5.
  49. ^ "Law Report: Non-disclosure of hypnosis tape was material irregularity". The Independent. 23 October 2011. Archived from the original on 18 June 2022. Retrieved 12 May 2021.
  50. ^ a b Foot, Paul (22 May 1992). "Strange case of the sleeping tape". Daily Mirror.
  51. ^ a b Rogers, Lois (24 April 1994). "An honest day's work; Lie detector". The Times. p. 23.
  52. ^ a b c d Chaudhary, Vivek (16 April 1994). "Hypnosis video 'marginal' to M50 murder inquiry". The Guardian. p. 5.
  53. ^ "M50 tecs cleared in probe". Sandwell Evening Mail. 21 April 1993. p. 10.
  54. ^ "Witness denies he withheld evidence". Dundee Courier. 16 April 1994. p. 7.
  55. ^ Magrath, Paul (17 May 1994). "Non-disclosure of hypnosis tape was material irregularity in trial". The Independent.
  56. ^ a b c d "Police knew I was not the M50 killer, freed man claims". HeraldScotland. 14 May 1994. Retrieved 12 May 2021.
  57. ^ a b Leigh, David (14 May 1994). "I'm Gutted Says Husband as Marie Case Man Is Freed". Daily Mirror.
  58. ^ a b c d Prestage, Michael (15 May 1994). "Acquitted 'M50 killer' gets a cold welcome in the valleys". The Observer. p. 7.
  59. ^ Darbyshire, Neil (22 September 1994). "£75,000 for man wrongly jailed over M50 murder". Daily Telegraph.
  60. ^ a b c "pounds 600,000 deal for cleared Wilks suspect; Fresh start: Eddie Browning with his new wife Merediel. He plans to buy a remote farmhouse with his compensation". Birmingham Post. 7 February 2000. Retrieved 18 September 2022.
  61. ^ "When the guilty go free". Sunday Tribune. 2 July 2000. p. 9.
  62. ^ "Miscarriages of justice: compensation schemes". UK Parliament. House of Commons Library. 6 March 2015. Retrieved 18 September 2022.
  63. ^ "But others are awarded huge sums". Daily Telegraph. 12 January 2005. p. 17.
  64. ^ a b c d e f "Marie Wilks murder: Wrongly convicted Eddie Browning dies". BBC News. 17 May 2018. Retrieved 18 September 2022.
  65. ^ a b Roberts, Joe (21 November 1994). "Jail cash blown". Daily Mirror.
  66. ^ a b Sutton, Ricky (16 July 1995). "Wilkes man 'had knife'". Sunday Mirror.
  67. ^ a b Edwards, Dave (20 July 1995). "Divorce for Eddie". Rhondda Leader. p. 2.
  68. ^ a b "Background: Doubts grew years after brutal killing". The Birmingham Post. 7 February 2000. p. 3.
  69. ^ "Husband sought; News in Brief". The Times. 8 May 1996. p. 6.
  70. ^ "Man sought". Aberdeen Press and Journal. 8 May 1996. p. 6.
  71. ^ "Suspect hunted". Reading Evening Post. 8 May 1996. p. 8.
  72. ^ a b c "'I DID MURDER M50 MARIE' Cleared man told pal, court hears". The Free Library. 23 May 2000. Retrieved 18 September 2022.
  73. ^ Gould, Peter (27 February 2003). "Still a suspect after 30 years". BBC News. Retrieved 24 May 2010.
  74. ^ a b "Browning accused again; ABERYSTWYTH: Bail granted as charges denied". Western Mail. 9 March 2002. p. 3.
  75. ^ a b c d e "Wrongly jailed man's two-year ban". BBC News. 5 August 2005. Retrieved 18 September 2022.
  76. ^ "Wrongly jailed man's driving case". BBC News. 19 January 2005. Retrieved 18 September 2022.
  77. ^ "Advances 'could help in M50 case'". BBC News. 15 May 2008. Retrieved 18 September 2022.
  78. ^ "TEN YEARS AGO: Warning to women". Lancashire Telegraph. 2 July 1998. Retrieved 16 May 2021.
  79. ^ "Sex attack on woman in A47 layby after car breaks down". BBC News. 27 November 2010. Retrieved 16 May 2021.
  80. ^ "Some women feel "some degree of fear" driving alone". www.its4women.ie. Retrieved 16 May 2021.
  81. ^ "Q593: What should I do if I break down on the motorway?". www.askthe.police.uk. Archived from the original on 16 May 2021. Retrieved 16 May 2021.
  82. ^ Shadigian, Elizabeth; Bauer, Samuel T. (March 2005). "Pregnancy-associated death: a qualitative systematic review of homicide and suicide". Obstetrical & Gynecological Survey. 60 (3): 183–190. doi:10.1097/01.ogx.0000155967.72418.6b. ISSN 0029-7828. PMID 16570396. S2CID 10061581.
  83. ^ "Why Pregnant Women Become Murder Victims". ABC News. Retrieved 16 May 2021.
  84. ^ ""Too hard to convict people of harming unborn babies"". BBC News. 17 April 2015. Retrieved 16 May 2021.
  85. ^ "Latane and Darley: Bystander Apathy". faculty.babson.edu. Retrieved 16 May 2021.
  86. ^ Fischer, Peter; Krueger, J.; Greitemeyer, Tobias; Vogrincic, C.; Kastenmüller, A.; Frey, D.; Heene, Moritz; Wicher, Magdalena; Kainbacher, Martina (2011). "The bystander-effect: a meta-analytic review on bystander intervention in dangerous and non-dangerous emergencies". Psychological Bulletin. 137 (4): 517–537. doi:10.1037/a0023304. PMID 21534650. S2CID 9855957.
  87. ^ "Abuse of Process | The Crown Prosecution Service". www.cps.gov.uk. Retrieved 16 May 2021.
  88. ^ Kelcey2018-07-20T10:35:00+01:00, Ian. "The disclosure debacle – a defence response?". Law Gazette. Retrieved 16 May 2021.{{cite web}}: CS1 maint: numeric names: authors list (link)
  89. ^ "Public Justice Offences incorporating the Charging Standard | The Crown Prosecution Service". www.cps.gov.uk. Retrieved 16 May 2021.
  90. ^ Kleinhauz, M.; Horowitz, I.; Tobin, Y. (1 April 1977). "The Use of Hypnosis in Police Investigation: A Preliminary Communication". Journal of the Forensic Science Society. 17 (2–3): 77–80. doi:10.1016/S0015-7368(77)71129-6. ISSN 0015-7368. PMID 632797.
  91. ^ "Hypnosis | The Crown Prosecution Service". www.cps.gov.uk. Retrieved 16 May 2021.
  92. ^ Bauer, Belinda (23 August 2018). Snap. www.penguin.co.uk. Retrieved 16 May 2021.
  93. ^ "Belinda Bauer, the crime author up for the Booker: "If it's tokenism, I don't care"". The Guardian. 10 August 2018. Retrieved 16 May 2021.
Retrieved from "https://en.wikipedia.org/w/index.php?title=Murder_of_Marie_Wilks&oldid=1248349102"