Thomas Dugdale, 1st Baron Crathorne

For other people named Thomas Dugdale, see Thomas Dugdale (disambiguation).

Thomas Lionel Dugdale, 1st Baron Crathorne, TD, PC (20 July 1897 – 26 March 1977), known as Sir Thomas Dugdale, 1st Baronet, from 1945 to 1959, was a British Conservative Party politician. He resigned as a government minister over the Crichel Down Affair, often quoted as a classic example of the convention of individual ministerial responsibility.

The Right Honourable The Lord Crathorne TD PC
Minister of Agriculture and Fisheries
In office 5 November 1951 – 28 July 1954
Prime Minister	Winston Churchill
Preceded by	Tom Williams
Succeeded by	Derick Heathcoat-Amory
Lord Commissioner of the Treasury
In office 28 May 1937 – 12 February 1940
Prime Minister	Neville Chamberlain
Preceded by	Sir Archibald Southby
Succeeded by	Patrick Munro
Member of the House of Lords
Lord Temporal
In office 9 October 1959 – 26 March 1977
Preceded by	Peerage created
Succeeded by	The 2nd Baron Crathorne
Member of Parliament for Richmond
In office 30 May 1929 – 18 September 1959
Preceded by	Sir Murrough John Wilson
Succeeded by	Timothy Kitson
Personal details
Born	(1897-07-20)20 July 1897
Died	26 March 1977(1977-03-26) (aged 79)
Political party	Conservative

Background and early life

Thomas Dugdale was the son of Captain James Lionel Dugdale, of Crathorne Hall near Yarm in Yorkshire. His grandfather John Dugdale (died 1881) was from a family of Lancashire cotton manufacturers, and had bought the Crathorne estate in 1844.

Dugdale was educated at Eton College and the Royal Military College, Sandhurst. He joined the Army in 1916, serving with the Scots Greys in the First World War and the Yorkshire Hussars in the Second World War.

Political career

In 1929, Dugdale was elected as Member of Parliament (MP) for Richmond, North Yorkshire, where he remained until 1959. He served as Parliamentary Private Secretary to several ministers, including Stanley Baldwin, and Deputy Chief Whip. He was later Chairman of the Conservative Party and Chairman of the Party's Agricultural Committee. He was created a baronet in the 1945 New Year Honours "for political and public services".

The Crichel Down affair

When the Conservatives won the 1951 election, Churchill made Dugdale his Minister of Agriculture and Fisheries.

Crichel Down was a piece of farmland in Dorset which had been bought compulsorily by the government for defence use. Commander George Marten, whose wife Mary was the only child and heiress of the original owner of the land, Lord Alington, wanted to buy the land back in the 1950s, because it was no longer used by the Ministry of Defence. However, the Ministry of Agriculture resisted, wanting to use the land for experimental farming in a time of rationing and agricultural development. Marten, a former equerry to the royal family, had very influential friends and stirred up considerable trouble in the local Conservative Party and on the government backbenches. There followed a public inquiry that criticised the department's decision and its civil servants, especially their methods, which were seen as an example of an over-powerful state.

In 1954, Dugdale announced that Marten could buy the land back, and told the House of Commons he was resigning, having been the responsible minister.

Resignation

Dugdale's resignation went down in history as an honourable, even heroic, one: a minister taking responsibility for civil servants' actions, which would lead to the perceived code of individual ministerial responsibility. However, in papers released thirty years after the affair it was found that Dugdale had known and approved of his civil servants' actions, and had to an extent passed the buck to them himself. It was also found that the inquiry was inaccurate and biased, having been led by a former Conservative candidate who was very opposed to civil servants and state interference.

Dugdale's junior minister, Lord Carrington, also tendered his resignation, but it was refused. He went on to be Foreign Secretary, resigning the post in 1982 over the Falklands War. Commander Marten received his land, but not a Conservative parliamentary seat, for which he had hoped.

In 1959, Dugdale himself was raised to the peerage as Baron Crathorne, of Crathorne in the North Riding of the County of York. Subsequently, he had a second political career in Europe, building links with parliamentarians in NATO and the Council of Europe.

Family

Dugdale married Nancy Gates (née Tennant; 1904–1969), daughter of Sir Charles Tennant, 1st Baronet, and his wife Marguerite (née Miles), in 1936. He died in March 1977, aged 79. His son James succeeded him in the barony.

Arms

Coat of arms of Thomas Dugdale, 1st Baron Crathorne

Crest A gryphon's head Ermine wings addorsed Erminois gorged with a collar Azure therefrom pendant a cross moline Gules. Escutcheon Ermine a cross moline Gules between four hurts. Supporters Dexter a crow Sable beaked and membered Or in the beak a sprig of blackthorn flowered Proper; sinister a stag also Sable attired unguled and gorged with a mural crown Gold charged on the shoulder with a thistle slipped and leaved also Proper. Motto Perseverando (By Persevering)

References

• Kidd, Charles, Williamson, David (editors). Debrett's Peerage and Baronetage (1990 edition). New York: St Martin's Press, 1990,

External links

• Hansard 1803–2005: contributions in Parliament by Thomas Dugdale