User talk:Palestine liberator/ban

Learn more about this page

I believe there is overwhelming evidence that this user is not interested in any way of contributing NPOV content to wikipedia but instead vandalising articles.

Examples

Inserting a picture of Ariel Sharon on the Penis page with the summary INSERTING PIC OF UGLY DICK SHARON

Inserting a picture of Sharon the the Feces page with the summary SHARON IS FECES

Inserting a picture of a penis on the Ariel Sharon page with the summary new pic looks more like him

replacing real headlines and texts in Israeli-Palestinian conflict with

ZIONIST TERROR

The Zionists are the REAL terrorists.

and

The Zionist entity, which the Zionists call "Israel" so that everyone forgets their crimes against the Arab nation of Palestine, is the world's biggest terrorist. Like Nazi Germany and bin Laden, this terrorist must be destroyed so that Palestine can strech from the river to the sea.

He summarised his changes as This site is crawling with Zionists

In Intifada he replaced a paragraph with the following

Both intifadas were originally characterized by civil disobedience by the Palestinians, which escalated into the use of honorable armed insurrection. Many Palestinians, including women and children, were martyred due to the Nazi-fascist brutality of the Zionists. The summary he gave was This site is crawling with Zionists.

redirected Israel to [[Zionist Entity]]. I deleted the page and restored it to its proper location, but he reinstated it, leading to a second deletion.

I do not have any problem with a pro-Palestinian viewpoint on wiki. Indeed I have been called pro-Arab and anti-semite by RK for seeking to stop his blatent pro-Israeli propagandising of some pages. Personally I do believe that wiki represents the what outside the US is seen as America's Israelophile sympathies. But it is crystal clear that this user is not trying to offer a balancing analysis of the Palestinian analysis of the Middle East problem. He is simply maliciously trying to vandalise articles. It is worth noting a similar user appeared on wiki some weeks ago propagandising articles supposedly from one viewpoint, yet whose contributions seemed nothing but vandalistic malicious nonsense, not a serious attempt at offering an alternative viewpoint. It might be worth someone checking this user's IP and comparing it to that user to see whether it is the same person. This user here clearly warrants a ban, not for his opinions but for his malicious vandalism of pages. FearÉIREANN 12:19, 4 Aug 2003 (UTC)

BTW 172 summed up this user's contributions with the following, which I concur with.

I can see that you're a mature and articulate advocate of your cause, laying out very convincing arguments involving poo poo and wee wees. 172 08:20, 4 Aug 2003 (UTC)

Since I started this page, Pl wrote on the talk page

I will stop messing with pages without permission. I will stop making rules on my page. However, I still want to be able to have others sign the list I'm starting agreeing that Zionism is racism.

I agree Zionism = racism

user Palestine liberator

After changes, that version was posted at 13:02, 4 Aug 2003. He then followed it up 8 minutes later, at 13:10, 4 Aug 2003 with

United States - some in the Palestinian movement and others regard America as a puppet of the Zionists.

So much for the promised neutrality and stopping messing. This guy is simply playing games. FearÉIREANN 12:19, 4 Aug 2003 (UTC)

Jimbo has just ruled on the mailing that this user should be banned. FearÉIREANN 15:19, 4 Aug 2003 (UTC)

Add topic