Wikipedia

Victims of the Night of the Long Knives

(Redirected from Victims of The Night of the Long Knives)

The Night of the Long Knives (German: Nacht der langen Messer) was a purge in which Adolf Hitler and the regime of Nazi Germany targeted members of the Sturmabteilung (SA), the paramilitary wing of the Nazi Party, as well as past opponents of the party. At least 85 people were murdered in the purge, which took place between June 30 and July 2, 1934.

Adolf Hitler, Gregor Strasser, Ernst Röhm and Hermann Göring in 1932; Röhm and Strasser would be killed in the Night of the Long Knives, which in large part was provoked by evidence fabricated by Göring and Heinrich Himmler purporting to show that Röhm was planning a coup.

Although most of those killed during the Night of the Long Knives were members of the SA, other victims included close associates of Vice Chancellor Franz von Papen, several Reichswehr (German Army) members – one of whom, General Kurt von Schleicher, was formerly Chancellor of Germany – and their associates; Gregor Strasser, Hitler's former competitor for control of the Nazi Party; at least one person killed in a case of mistaken identity; and several victims killed because they "knew too much".

The total number of victims is heavily disputed between historians; some estimates put the number in the hundreds.

Debate over number of victims

edit

The precise number of victims is disputed and will probably never be known with certainty. During the Purge itself official radio and newspaper reports only gave the names of ten people killed: the six SA-leaders executed in Stadelheim Prison on June 30; Kurt von Schleicher, a German general and a former Chancellor of the Weimar Republic, and his wife; Karl Ernst, who was wrongly reported to have been shot in Stadelheim, whereas in fact he was shot in the barracks of Hitler's Personal Guard Unit in Berlin Lichterfelde; and Ernst Röhm.

While the German newspapers avoided disclosing the names of further victims of the purge, in the weeks and months to follow, the international press would set out to detail a more comprehensive account of how many people had been killed between June 30 to July 2. They managed to present about 100 names of people allegedly killed, although a number of those eventually turned out to have survived, such as the former SA chief of Berlin Wolf-Heinrich Graf von Helldorf (who was actually one of the organizers of the purge – e.g. he warned Werner von Alvensleben, Schleicher's go-between to Hitler – but not Schleicher – to spend the fateful weekend at his hunting lodge; and was himself only killed after participating in the fateful 20th of July 1944 coup attempt) and Adolf Morsbach, the head of the cosmopolitan-minded Akademischer Austauschdienst (Academic Exchange Programme), who had instead been sent to a Nazi concentration camp.

Official list of those killed

edit

Immediately after the events of the purge the Gestapo compiled an official list of those killed at the order of Hitler who wished to gain an overall view on the number and identity of those killed in order to prepare the Reichstag speech in which he intended to present his interpretation of the occurrences of June 30 to July 2 to the German public and the world in general, and which he finally delivered on July 13. This "Gestapo List" comprised a total of 77 names.

In his Reichstag speech Hitler sub-divided those into 61 persons who had been shot during "the action"; allegedly 13 had died resisting arrest while three committed suicide. In his speech Hitler revealed the names of 11 of those 77 (Ferdinand von Bredow, Georg von Detten, Karl Ernst, Hans Hayn, Edmund Heines, Peter von Heydebreck, Ernst Röhm, Kurt von Schleicher, Gregor Strasser, and Julius Uhl).

 
Gregor Strasser, Hitler's former competitor for control of the Nazi Party (1928)
 
Gustav von Kahr (1920)

However, the list of 77 was far from being complete: Hitler admitted that some excesses had taken place and stated that he had handed over the cases of several people who had been killed as part of unauthorized actions by subordinate organs to the authorities, who were supposed to implement a regular prosecution of the perpetrators. Among those cases who were at first subject to regular investigation and prosecution by the locally responsible Attorney Offices were those of the city clerk Kuno Kamphausen who was murdered at the order of an SS officer who bore a grudge against him for refusing to give a construction permission to his brother and the cases of four Jews and two Communists who were killed without permission from Berlin in the course of arbitrary actions by lower SS echelons in the province of Silesia. In September 1934, Heinrich Himmler – eager to shield his SS men from legal prosecution – managed to convince Hitler to change his mind on the latter six people, whose names as a consequence, were subsequently added to the official list whose killing was to be considered rightful and which now encompassed 83 names.

The list of 77 or 83 names respectively was kept in several copies – which were stored under lock and key – in the Ministry of Justice and the Gestapo Headquarters. After a law entitled "Gesetz über Maßnahmen der Staatsnotwehr" ("Law pertaining to the Measures of Self-Defense of the State") had been passed by the Reich Cabinet on July 3, which declared: "Die zur Niederschlagung hoch- und landesverräterischer Angriffe am 30. Juni, 1. und 2. Juli 1934 vollzogenen Maßnahmen sind als Staatsnotwehr rechtens" ("The measures taken to clamp down on the treasonous attacks of June 30th, July 1st and 2nd are rightful, due to having been acts of self-defense of the State.")[1] it was decided that the killing of everybody on that list was to be considered lawful and that therefore the police and Attorney Offices were prohibited from investigating and prosecuting anyone for those killings. The lists thus were used by the Ministry and the Gestapo as a referential tool which could be consulted to decide, whether requests of relatives and friends of those killed to be given information on the circumstances of death of their beloved ones, or requests to prosecute those responsible for their killing would be answered in the affirmative (people killed and not mentioned on the Gestapo list) or in the negative (people whose names were to be found on the list). The same applied to requests of other state authorities (especially police departments and Attorney Offices) who inquired at the Ministry of Justice or the Gestapo headquarters whether they should open and or continue investigation of a specific killing that had taken place on the three days from June 30 to July 2.

The official list of those killed was first published in 1964 by Heinrich Bennecke (1902–1972) in the appendix of his book Die Reichswehr und der "Röhm-Putsch".

 
Ernst Röhm, Chief of Staff of the Sturmabteilung (SA), one of the primary targets of the purge (1933)
 
Kurt von Schleicher, former Chancellor of Germany (1932)

Estimates of people killed in addition to those on the official list

edit

Later research by historians has shown that in addition to those listed by the Gestapo a number of others also had been killed. Heinrich Bennecke complemented the names of the city clerk Kuno Kamphausen from Waldenburg and the music critic Willi Schmid to his reprint of the official Gestapo list, whereupon he concluded that at least 85 people were killed during the purge. Later, Hans Günther Richardi, in his study on the Dachau concentration camp, added the names of four inmates of Dachau (lawyer Julius Adler (1882–1934), worker Erich Gans (1908–1934), Walter Häbich and worker Adam Hereth (1897-1934)), claiming they were murdered by the SS during the purge. In 1993 Otto Gritschneder published a book on the post–World War II prosecution of those involved in the killings which lists 90 names of people killed (adding the doctor and Röhm associate Karl Günther Heimsoth to the list).[2]

Richard J. Evans states that at least 85 people were killed and more than 1000 were arrested.[3] Ian Kershaw also cites the number of deaths at 85. Kershaw notes that "some estimates...put the total number killed at between 150 and 200."[4] William L. Shirer writes in his Rise and Fall of the Third Reich, that "The White Book of the Purge, published by émigrés in Paris claims 401 deaths, but lists only 116 of them. At the 1957 trial in Munich the figure 'more than 1,000' was used."[5] Both of those figures are much higher than the ones most historians of the period rely on, and that Shirer himself was not necessarily citing the figures as accurate, but was simply relaying them in his book. The most recent study on the matter lists by name 89 people who were definitely killed, as well as two other cases of whom it is unclear whether they were murdered during the events or slightly earlier or later.[6]

Partial list of victims

edit
Name Place of death Personal details Circumstances Image
Otto Ballerstedt Dachau Concentration Camp Former Chief of the "Bayernbund", a secessionist political group in Bavaria. Hitler was imprisoned for a month in 1922 after he had physically attacked Ballerstedt at a rally. Ballerstedt was arrested on the evening of 30 June 1934 by armed SS men in his Munich apartment, a day before going on a planned trip to Austria. He was killed in or near Dachau concentration camp. His body found on the morning of 1 July in the forest near Gündinger Neuhimmelreich. The autopsy revealed he had died by a shot to the back of the head.[7]
—
Fritz Beck Gündinger Forest near Dachau Director of the Munich Students' Welfare Fund.[8] Killed either for his contacts to Röhm who was honorary president of his student association or for Beck’s opposition to Nazi policy.  
Herbert von Bose Borsig Palace, Berlin Press chief in the Prussian State Ministry and senior government councillor. Associate of Franz von Papen.[4] Part of the catholic conservative opposition centered around Edgar Jung. Initially reported as "suicide" then revised to "shot while resisting search of the Chancellery".[8][9]  
Ferdinand von Bredow Berlin Chief of the Abwehr and general major of the Reichswehr. Close associate of Kurt von Schleicher,[4] famed militarist and Junker. Shot when answering his door at Spichernstrasse 15 in Berlin's Wilmersdorf,[10] or perhaps executed the following Monday by firing squad.[8]  
Georg von Detten Lichterfelde SS barracks Member of the Reichstag, SA-Gruppenführer, and head of the Political Office in the Supreme SA-Leadership. Arrested at Munich train station and transferred to Stadelheim Prison. Together with his staff leader Hans-Joachim von Falkenhausen, Karl Schreyer and Fritz Ritter von Kraußer, he was flown to Berlin. The four men were held at Columbia concentration camp prior to execution at Lichterfelde SS barracks.  
Karl Ernst Lichterfelde, SS barracks[8] Member of the Reichstag, SA-Gruppenführer, and commander of the SA in Berlin. Ernst was arrested in Bremerhaven together with his wife about to board a ship to travel to their honeymoon. He was handed over in Bonn to an SS unit led by Kurt Gildisch for interrogation. He was flown to Berlin, taken to the Leibstandarte Adolf Hitler barracks. He was shot by firing squad on June 30, one of 14 people shot there.[11]  
Hans Joachim von Falkenhausen Lichterfelde SS barracks SA-Oberführer, and Chief of staff of Georg von Detten. Brother of General Alexander von Falkenhausen, head of the military government in Belgium in 1940–44 during its German occupation. He was arrested in Munich on June 30, 1934. The next day he was flown to Berlin with Georg von Detten, Fritz von Krausser and Karl Schreyer. They were temporarily held in the Columbia concentration camp at Tempelhof. Falkenhausen was taken to Lichterfelde SS barracks and shot at 2 a.m. on July 2.  
Fritz Gerlich Dachau Concentration Camp Newspaper journalist, editor of Munich's Catholic weekly (Der Gerade Weg) and publisher, Catholic Action.[8] Had been arrested already on 9 March 1933 and was in detention in Dachau KZ prior to his execution.  
Alexander Glaser Maxvorstadt, Munich Lawyer,[8] associate of Gregor Strasser. Shot from behind outside his apartment on Amalienstrasse in Munich. He succumbed to his injuries a few days later, on July 5 at Schwabing Hospital.  
Hans Hayn Stadelheim Prison, Munich Member of the Reichstag, SA-group leader of Sachsen. On June 30, 1934, Hayn was arrested and taken to Stadelheim Prison in Munich. There he was shot by the SS Leibstandarte under Sepp Dietrich in the afternoon, along with Edmund Heines, Peter von Heydebreck, Wilhelm Schmid, August Schneidhuber and Hans Erwin von Spreti-Weilbach.
—
Edmund Heines Stadelheim Prison, Munich SA-Obergruppenführer and former deputy to Röhm. Leader of SA Obergruppe VIII (Silesia), Chief of Police of Breslau. Arrested at Bad Wiessee having been found in bed with Erich Schiewek,[4][failed verification] transferred to Stadelheim Prison where he was shot by an SS firing squad convened by Sepp Dietrich. In 1957, Dietrich was convicted of being an accessory to manslaughter by a West German court and sentenced to 18 months in prison.  
Oskar Heines In a field near Groß Heidau SA-Sturmbannführer and younger brother of Edmund Heines.
—
Hans Peter von Heydebreck Stadelheim Prison, Munich Member of the Reichstag, SA-Gruppenführer. Arrested on his way to Bad Weissee and transferred to Stadelheim Prison. He was shot by an SS-Leibstandarte firing squad convened along with Hans Hayn, Edmund Heines, Wilhelm Schmid, August Schneidhuber and Hans Erwin von Spreti-Weilbach in the early evening of the same day. In 1957, Sepp Dietrich, who convened the firing squad which executed the men, was convicted of being an accessory to manslaughter by a West German court and sentenced to 18 months in prison.
—
Anton von Hohberg und Buchwald Dulzen, East Prussia SS-Obersturmführer, one of only five SS victims.[12] Shot by two SS men at his home on the orders of Obergruppenführer Erich von dem Bach-Zelewski. On January 16, 1961, von dem Bach Zelewski was convicted of manslaughter by a West German court and sentenced to 4+1⁄2 years imprisonment
—
Edgar Julius Jung Uncertain, possibly Berlin Lawyer, Catholic Action worker. Authored Vice-Chancellor Franz Franz von Papen's "Marburg speech", critical of the Nazi Party. In 'protective custody' since late June. Found dead in a ditch near Oranienburg on 1 July,[4] or executed the following Monday by firing squad.[8]  
Gustav Ritter von Kahr Dachau concentration camp Former prime minister of Bavaria, member of Triumvirate that ruled Bavaria during the Beer Hall Putsch. Shot at the Dachau concentration camp.[13][14][15] Story that his body was later found hacked with pickaxes largely discredited by later historians.  
Dr. Kuno Kamphausen Waldenburg Architect, member of the Zentrum political party Three SS officers were convicted of his manslaughter in 1934 and sentenced to 1, 2, and 5 years in prison. However, they were all released from prison within a year, under pressure by Himmler.  
Eugen von Kessel Tiergartenstrasse, Berlin Former officer and police captain Shot dead in his Berlin office on June 30, 1934.
—
Erich Klausener Wilhelmstrasse 80, Berlin Catholic Professor, former leader of the police department in the Prussian ministry of internal affairs and president of Berlin's Catholic Action group. Close associate of Vice-Chancellor Franz von Papen and contributed to the Marburg speech. Shot in his office at the Ministry of Transport in Berlin. The assassination was ordered by Reinhard Heydrich, and carried out by Kurt Gildisch. After the war, Gildisch convicted of his murder, having been promoted by the SS in rank after the killing, and sentenced to 15 years in prison. He was released from prison on health grounds shortly before his death in 1956.[16][4][8]  
Hans-Karl Koch Lichterfelde SS barracks Member of the Reichstag, SA-Brigadeführer in the group of Westmark
—
Fritz Ritter von Kraußer Lichterfelde SS barracks Member of the Reichstag, SA-Obergruppenfuhrer. Chief of Department I (Organization) in the Supreme SA Leadership. Arrested on 30 June 1934, and sent to Stadelheim prison. Transferred from Munich to Berlin where he was executed at Lichterfelde SS barracks on 2 July.  
Adalbert Probst Unknown National director of the Catholic Youth Sports Association (German:Deutsche Jugendkraft-Sportverbands) Probst was abducted and later found dead, allegedly "shot while trying to escape".[17]  
Hans Ramshorn Woods near Obernigk and Breslau-Deutsch-Lissa Member of the Reichstag, SA-Brigadeführer in Oberschlesien and chief of police of Gleiwitz Udo von Woyrsch was convicted of manslaughter for this killing amongst others in 1957 and sentenced to 10 years imprisonment.[18]
—
Ernst Röhm Stadelheim prison, Munich SA-chief of staff Arrested at Bad Wiessee, transferred to Stadelheim Prison. Executed in his cell after being given a gun with one bullet and asked to commit suicide.[4][8]  
Paul Röhrbein Dachau concentration camp SA-captain, leader of the first SA of Berlin In protective custody in various prisons in Munich and in the Dachau concentration camp since July 5, 1933. Shot along with Fritz Gerlich.
—
Martin Schätzl Dachau Concentration Camp SA-Obertruppführer adjutant to Röhm Arrested at Bad Wiessee, transferred to Stadelheim Prison, taken to Dachau KZ where he was shot by the SS.  
Erich Schiewek Dachau concentration camp SA-Obertruppführer from Breslau, accompanied Edmund Heines to Bad Wiessee as substitute adjutant Arrested in bed with Heines. After incarceration in Stadelheim Prison, he was transferred to Dachau KZ where he was shot by the SS alongside Max Vogel.
—
General Kurt von Schleicher Babelsberg, Potsdam Former Chancellor of Germany. Shot at home with his wife, reported as "resisting arrest".[4][8][10]  
Elisabeth von Schleicher Babelsberg Wife of Kurt von Schleicher.[4][8] Shot alongside her husband, died on the way to hospital  
Wilhelm Eduard Schmid Dachau Concentration Camp Music critic for the Münchener Neueste Nachrichten, a Munich newspaper. Killed by SS in a case of mistaken identity, believing him to be either SA-Gruppenführer Wilhelm Schmid[19] or Dr. Ludwig Schmitt, sympathizer of Otto Strasser.[4]  
Wilhelm Schmid Stadelheim Prison, Munich SA-Gruppenfuhrer, commander of SA-Gruppe Hochland in Munich, member of the Reichstag Arrested in Munich and sent to Stadelheim prison. He was executed by the Leibstandarte along with SA leaders Hans Hayn, Edmund Heines, Peter von Heydebreck, August Schneidhuber and Hans Erwin von Spreti-Weilbach. In 1957, Sepp Dietrich, who convened the firing squad which executed the men, was convicted of being an accessory to manslaughter by a West German court and sentenced to 18 months in prison.
August Schneidhuber Stadelheim Prison, Munich SA-Obergruppenfuhrer, commander of SA-Obergruppe VII (Munich), chief of police in Munich, member of the Reichstag Arrested by Hitler in Munich and sent to Stadelheim prison. He was executed by the Leibstandarte along with SA leaders Hans Hayn, Peter von Heydebreck, Wilhelm Schmid, Hans Erwin von Spreti-Weilbach and Edmund Heines. In 1957, Sepp Dietrich, who convened the firing squad which executed the men, was convicted of being an accessory to manslaughter by a West German court and sentenced to 18 months in prison.  
Johann Konrad Schragmüller Lichterfelde SS barracks SA-Gruppenführer, Member of the Reichstag, chief of police of Magdeburg Arrested in Bad Wiessee. Transferred to Lichterfelde SS barracks where he was shot.
—
Hans Schweighart Dachau Concentration Camp SA-Standartenfuhrer - Adjutant to Ernst Röhm Arrested on June 30, 1934, in Bad Wiessee and taken to Stadelheim Prison. Shot in Dachau KZ on July 1, 1934.  
Emil Sembach Riesengebirge Member of the Reichstag, ex-SS-Oberführer Udo von Woyrsch was convicted of manslaughter for this killing amongst others in 1957 and sentenced to 10 years imprisonment.  
Hans Erwin von Spreti-Weilbach [de] Stadelheim Prison, Munich Close associate of Röhm, SA-Standartenfuhrer Arrested at Bad Wiessee, transferred to Stadelheim Prison where he was executed by the Leibstandarte on 30 June along with Hans Hayn, Edmund Heines, Peter von Heydebreck, Wilhelm Schmid and August Schneidhuber. In 1957, Sepp Dietrich, who convened the firing squad which executed the men, was convicted of being an accessory to manslaughter by a West German court and sentenced to 18 months in prison.  
Father Bernhard Stempfle Munich Defrocked priest, former co-prisoner of Hitler in Landsberg, Bavaria, and one of the editors of Mein Kampf No known motive.[4]  
Gregor Strasser Prinz-Albrecht-Strasse, Berlin Former high-ranking Nazi Party member. Hitler was godfather to his children. Shot in a cell in the Gestapo HQ.[4] Reported as a suicide.[8]  
Julius Uhl Dachau concentration camp SA-Standartenfuhrer, Hitler named him in the Reichstag as the man who would've killed him Arrested at Bad Weissee on June 30 then transferred to Stadelheim Prison. Along with Martin Schätzl and Johann König he was transferred to Dachau Concentration Camp and shot on July 2.  
Maximilian "Max" Vogel Dachau concentration camp SA-Obersturmfuhrer Ernst Röhm's chauffeur Arrested in Bad Wiessee. After incarceration in Stadelheim Prison, he was transferred to Dachau KZ where he was shot by the SS together with Erich Schiewek.[20]
—
Gerd Voß Lichterfelde SS barracks SA-Sturmfuhrer Lawyer - SA Legal adviser to Karl Ernst
—
Karl Zehnter Road from Dachau to Augsburg near Längenmoos Zum Bratwurstglöckl proprietor The Zum Bratwurstglöckl in Munich was Röhm's favorite tavern, where Goebbels met secretly with Röhm prior to the purge. Although not involved politically, it was deemed that he 'knew too much'.[21][22][8]
—
Alexander Zweig Near Hirschberg Jewish doctor from Hirschberg
—
Jeanette Zweig Near Hirschberg Wife of Alexander Zweig (contrary to some accounts, she herself was not Jewish by birth)
—
Ernestine Zoref Dachau concentration camp Partner of arrested journalist Paul Edmund von Hahn a suspected Soviet spy. After imprisonment at Dachau KZ, Zoref was released only to be rearrested on June 30, 1934. She was brought back to Dachau and immediately shot.
—

References

edit

Inline citations

edit
  1. ^ wikisource
  2. ^ de:Otto Gritschneder: Der Führer hat sie zum Tode verurteilt, Munich 1993, ISBN 3-406-37651-7.
  3. ^ Evans, Richard (2005). The Third Reich in Power. Penguin Group. p. 39. At least eighty-five people are known to have been summarily killed without any formal legal proceedings being taken against them. Göring alone had over a thousand people arrested.
  4. ^ a b c d e f g h i j k l Kershaw, Ian (1999). Hitler: 1889–1936 Hubris. W. W. Norton & Company. p. 517. ISBN 9780393046717.
  5. ^ Shirer, William J. (1960). The Rise and Fall of the Third Reich. Simon and Schuster. pp. 221–222.
  6. ^ Rainer Orth: Der SD-Mann Johannes Schmidt. Der Mörder des Reichskanzlers Kurt von Schleicher?, Marburg 2011, pp. 102–112. ISBN 978-3828828728
  7. ^ (Kimmel: KZ Dachau, S. 366;) Garg: Justice in the Third Reich, p. 439 in combination with international Dachau Committee: Dachau notebooks, vol. 8-9, p. 222
  8. ^ a b c d e f g h i j k l m United Press (July 5, 1934). "Hitler Issues Anti-Jewish Decree". The Pittsburgh Press. p. 1. Retrieved February 12, 2013.
  9. ^ Speer, Albert (1970). Inside the Third Reich. The MacMillan Company. p. 53. ISBN 0-684-82949-5.
  10. ^ a b Wheeler, John (1967). The Nemesis of Power the German Army in Politics 1918-1945. The MacMillan Company.
  11. ^ Federal Archive NS 23/45.
  12. ^ Hamburger Abendblatt 4 August 1962
  13. ^ Richardi, Hans-Günther (1995). Schule der Gewalt: das Konzentrationslager Dachau [School of Violence: the Dachau Concentration Camp] (in German). Munich: Piper. p. 235. ISBN 9783492120579.
  14. ^ Gritschneder, Otto (1993). Der Führer hat Sie zum Tode verurteilt … [The Führer Has Sentenced You to Death ...] (in German). Munich: C.H. Beck. p. 136. ISBN 9783406376511.
  15. ^ Tuchel, Johannes (1991). Konzentrationslager: Organisationsgeschichte und Funktion der "Inspektion der Konzentrationslager" 1934–1938 [Concentration Camps: Organizational History and Function of the "Inspection of Concentration Camps" 1934–1938] (in German). Boppard am Rhein: H. Boldt. p. 179. ISBN 9783764619022.
  16. ^ "Night of the Long Knives | Summary & Facts". May 9, 2024.
  17. ^ John S. Conway; The Nazi Persecution of the Churches, 1933-1945; p. 92
  18. ^ Gritschneder, Otto (1993). he Führer sentenced you to death. Hitler's "Röhm Putsch" murders in court. Munich. p. 1105. ISBN 3406376517.{{cite book}}: CS1 maint: location missing publisher (link)
  19. ^ Shirer, William J. (1960). The Rise and Fall of the Third Reich. Simon and Schuster. pp. 223–224.
  20. ^ Lothar Gruchmann : Justice in the Third Reich 1933-1940: Adaptation and submission in the Gürtner era , p. 437.
  21. ^ Bullock, Alan (1962), Hitler: A Study in Tyranny, London: Pelican, p. 297
  22. ^ Manvell, Roger; Fraenkel, Heinrich (2010), Doctor Goebbels: His Life and Death, New York: Skyhorse Publishing, p. 134

General references

edit
edit
 
Wikimedia Commons has media related to Victims of the Night of the Long Knives.
Retrieved from "https://en.wikipedia.org/w/index.php?title=Victims_of_the_Night_of_the_Long_Knives&oldid=1253862465"