German workers' and soldiers' councils 1918–1919
The German workers' and soldiers' councils of 1918–1919 (German: Arbeiter- und Soldatenräte) were short-lived revolutionary bodies that spread the German Revolution to cities across the German Empire during the final days of World War I. Meeting little to no resistance, they formed quickly, took over city governments and key buildings, caused most of the locally stationed military to flee and brought about the abdications of all of Germany's ruling monarchs, including Emperor Wilhelm II when they reached Berlin on 9 November 1918.
In spite of being patterned after the soviets of the Russian Revolution, few of the German workers' and soldiers' councils had any interest in establishing a system of council communism. Most members wanted an end to the war and to German militarism, and the establishment of a parliamentary republic dominated by the moderate Social Democratic Party (SPD). The interim national revolutionary government, the Council of the People's Deputies, was initially a coalition of the SPD and the more leftist Independent Social Democrats (USPD), but in it and the majority of the other councils, the SPD was able to keep the radical left wing on the sidelines. During the two large gatherings of the workers' and soldiers' councils, on 10 November and at the Reich Congress of Workers' and Soldiers' Councils that began on 16 December, most of the voting went the way the SPD leadership wished. An election for a national assembly that would allow all Germans, not just workers and soldiers, to determine Germany's future form of government was scheduled for 19 January 1919.
In the early months of 1919, there were a number of violent revolts by workers who thought that the revolution had been stopped too soon and wanted to carry it forward to establish a council republic. The government in Berlin, until 13 February still the Council of the People's Deputies, called on the army and the paramilitary Freikorps to suppress the uprisings, and there was considerable loss of life. The central councils in Berlin began turning their powers over to the Weimar National Assembly in early February. After the Weimar Republic was established on 14 August 1919, the last of the local councils disbanded late in the fall of 1919.
First councils
editWorkers' and soldiers' councils, for which the term "soviets" (German: Räte, singular Rat) was coined, were first set up during the Russian Revolution. The increasingly straitened living standards of German workers under the hardships of World War I made political parties such as the Independent Social Democrats (USPD), which opposed the war, more and more appealing. The USPD facilitated the creation of workers' councils, which, while not dedicated to revolutionary activity like their Russian counterparts, still promoted strikes and other popular agitation. The German workers' councils had their origins in the 1916 Auxiliary Services Act which allowed workers employed in companies with more than 50 people to create committees to negotiate wages and working conditions. Representatives from these committees as well as representatives from other formal and informal workers' groups joined the USPD-backed workers councils throughout Germany.[1] The USPD and its left wing, the Spartacus League, were responsible for calling the huge nationwide anti-war strike of January 1918.[2]
Kiel sailors' uprising
edit
After it became clear in the fall of 1918 that Germany would lose the war, revolutionary workers' and soldiers' councils formed the core of the early stages of the German Revolution that brought down the German Empire. The first council was formed on 4 November 1918 when sailors in Kiel mutinied against orders to sail out and attack the British fleet.[3] After sailors, soldiers and workers had brought public and military institutions in Kiel under their control, representatives of the sailors formed a council and issued a list of demands focussed mostly on loosening military discipline.[4] Revolutionary sailors spread out from Kiel in the following days, reaching Bremen and Hamburg on the sixth, Hanover and Cologne on the seventh, and all major cities in the west of Germany by the eighth. Everywhere they went, workers and soldiers joined them and set up councils similar to the one in Kiel. Soldiers by simple acclamation often elected their most respected comrades; workers generally chose members of the local executive committees of Germany's two main socialist parties, the Majority Social Democrats (generally referred to simply as the SPD) and the more radical USPD.[5]
There was little to no resistance to the establishment of the councils. With the support of local citizens, they freed political prisoners and occupied city halls, military facilities and train stations. The military authorities surrendered or fled, and civic officials accepted that they were under the control of the councils rather than the military and carried on with their work.[6] Little changed in the factories except for the removal of the military discipline that had prevailed during the war. Private property was not touched.[7] Princes and royals abdicated in the face of the revolution. All, including Emperor Wilhelm II, were gone without bloodshed by the end of November.[8]
Berlin
edit
The revolution reached Berlin on Saturday 9 November. With the backing of the SPD, the Revolutionary Stewards and the Spartacus League – groups that favoured a soviet-style council republic – called a general strike. Workers and soldiers established councils and important buildings such as the police headquarters were occupied.[9] A massive demonstration march through the city drew in a large number of soldiers from their barracks. Many of the demonstrators carried placards calling for an end to the war and the authoritarian monarchical state. The SPD formed its own workers' and soldiers' council consisting of twelve factory representatives and the party leaders Friedrich Ebert, Otto Braun and Otto Wels. At midday, Reich Chancellor Max von Baden prematurely announced the abdication of the Emperor and, in formal breach of the Imperial Constitution, handed the chancellorship to Ebert. In the afternoon, Philipp Scheidemann of the SPD proclaimed a republic from the Reichstag building, while a few hours later Karl Liebknecht of the Spartacus League proclaimed the "Free Socialist Republic of Germany" at the Berlin Palace.[10]
Council vs. parliamentary republic
editIn an initial written exchange of ideas on 9 and 10 November about the future form of the government, the USPD stated that in order for it to join, political power would have to be in the hands of the workers' and soldiers' councils and an assembly of councils from across Germany. The response of the SPD, which wanted a national assembly to determine the type of government, was: "If this request means the dictatorship of a section of a class that is not backed by the majority of the people, then we must reject the demand because it contradicts our democratic principles."[11] For their part, the Spartacists wanted to abolish the Reichstag, all state parliaments and the existing Reich government; to have the Berlin workers' and soldiers' council take over the government until the establishment of a Reich workers' and soldiers' council; to elect workers' and soldiers' councils throughout Germany that would have full legislative and administrative authority; to have the workers' and soldiers' councils take over all military and civilian authorities and command posts, all weapons and ammunition stocks, as well as all armaments factories; and to control all means of transport.[11]
On the evening of the ninth, the Berlin workers' and soldiers' council, called together by the Revolutionary Stewards, decided to elect new councils the next morning and then to have them meet in the afternoon to elect a provisional government. In an attempt to put themselves in a position to control the newly elected councils, the SPD relented on its earlier stand and accepted the USPD's conditions for joining the government: the councils were to have political power, and a constitutional convention would be discussed only after the revolution was consolidated. Out of the agreement came the six-member Council of the People's Deputies (Rat der Volksbeauftragten) – the name was adopted at the insistence of the USPD – with three representatives from each party: Ebert, Scheidemann and Otto Landsberg for the SPD and Hugo Haase, Wilhelm Dittmann and Emil Barth for the USPD. Ebert and Haase were the co-chairmen. The Council of the People's Deputies was to derive its sovereignty from the workers' and soldiers' councils.[12]
Circus Busch meeting
editIn a rapidly executed plan to prepare the SPD for the new council elections, Otto Wels used the existing SPD party apparatus to bring the majority of the soldiers in Berlin over to the side of the SPD. He swore the 148 elected soldiers' representatives to the SPD platform, which called for equal representation of the SPD and USPD in the new government. In its 10 November edition, the party newspaper Vorwärts carried the same message of unity to the workers with the headline "No Civil War!"[13] The SPD's efforts gave them enough support to feel confident that at the afternoon's meeting they would have a majority of the delegates behind them and the Council of the People's Deputies.[14]
About 3,000 workers and soldiers gathered at Berlin's Circus Busch auditorium. A clear majority approved the six-member Council of the People's Deputies named earlier in the day. Emil Barth of the USPD, in a move that caught the SPD by surprise, then called for an action committee to oversee the Council and presented a list of radical leftists drawn up by the Revolutionary Stewards. Ebert thought the committee unnecessary and said that if it was established, it needed to have equal numbers of SPD and USPD members. When members of the Spartacus League threatened Ebert, he went for safety to the Reich Chancellery where he received the assurances of Prussian Minister of War Heinrich Scheuch that the Council of the People's Deputies would be protected.[15]
At the Circus Busch, the Revolutionary Stewards backed down under pressure from both Hugo Haase (USPD) and the soldiers' representatives. The assembly then elected two 14-member action committees, one made up of seven members each from SPD and USPD and the other of soldiers, most of whom were politically independent. The two committees together formed the Executive Council of Workers' and Soldiers' Councils of Greater Berlin (Vollzugsrat des Arbeiter- und Soldatenrates Grossberlin) under the leadership of Richard Müller, the head of the Revolutionary Stewards.[15]
The workers' and soldiers' councils saw themselves as a provisional parliament to express the revolutionary will of the people. The goals they set were to be politically implemented by the Council of People's Deputies under the supervision of the Berlin Executive Council: "The bearers of political power are now workers' and soldiers' councils. Immediate peace is the slogan of the revolution. The rapid and consistent socialisation of the capitalist means of production is feasible without major upheaval, given Germany's social structure and the degree of maturity of its economic and political organisation. It is necessary in order to build a new economic order out of the blood-soaked ruins, to prevent the economic enslavement of the masses and the destruction of culture."[16]
SPD dominance
editIn its commitment to democracy, the SPD thought that the "revolutionary mandate" of the spontaneously elected workers' and soldiers' councils should not be used in advance of a national assembly.[17] In Ebert's words, the Council of the People's Deputies was simply the "bankruptcy trustee" of the Empire. Decisions on whether the government should be a council system or a parliamentary democracy and whether industries should be nationalised should not be made before the people had voted. The USPD members of the Council, on the other hand, wanted to wait until the revolution had been consolidated and then, in a manner to be determined later, link the councils to a national assembly.[18]
The Council of the People's Deputies relied on the expertise of the former Empire's state secretaries (equivalent to ministers), most of whom retained their positions. They generally preferred to work with the more moderate SPD on the councils rather than the USPD. This gave the SPD a distinct power advantage. The SPD also held the more important portfolios: Ebert had internal and military affairs, Landsberg finance and Scheidemann press and intelligence. The Berlin Executive Council issued laws and decrees affecting basic rights such as freedom of opinion and also in the area of social policy. The eight-hour working day, for example, was introduced on 26 November 1918.[19]
A network of revolutionary bodies stretching from the Council of the People's Deputies to the governments of the federal states and the local workers' and soldiers' councils, all dominated by the SPD, quickly covered Germany. The soldiers gave it armed power, while its economic and social power came from the workers' ability to strike and the people's to demonstrate. With this network, its own party and union structures, and cooperation with middle class Catholic and liberal parties at the local level, the SPD was able to keep the left wing radicals for the most part out of the councils.[18]
Reich Congress of Workers' and Soldiers' Councils
editThe Reich Congress of Workers' and Soldiers' Councils (Reichskongress der Arbeiter- und Soldatenräte or Reichsrätekongress) was called by the Greater Berlin Council and met from 16 to 20 December in the Prussian House of Representatives building.[20] Delegates were elected from across Germany, about one for every 200,000 civilians and one for every 100,000 soldiers.[18] Of the 514 delegates, 288 supported the SPD, 88 the USPD and 10 the Spartacus League.[21] Karl Liebknecht and Rosa Luxemburg, the Spartacus leaders, had not been elected to the Congress, and a proposal to let them sit in as guests in an advisory capacity was turned down.[20]
The central question that the Congress discussed continued to be whether Germany was to have a council or a parliamentary form of government. Ernst Däumig (USPD) spoke on behalf of a pure council system, with it to be the basis for the constitution of a socialist republic in which the workers' and soldiers' councils would have the highest law-giving and executive power in the state. Däumig called it the "death sentence of the revolution" when his proposal was voted down 344 to 98.[22] Richard Müller said later: "The Central Congress was Germany's first revolutionary tribunal, but there was no sign of any revolutionary breeze. I didn't set my expectations very high beforehand, but I hadn't believed that the Congress would turn into a political suicide club."[23]
Max Cohen for the SPD proposed to hold the election to the national assembly on 19 January 1919, almost a month earlier than the Council of the People's Deputies had agreed on in late November. That the Congress passed the resolution by an eight to one margin was a clear sign that the majority of the attendees were in favour of a parliamentary democracy. Against the radical Left's accusation that the SPD was trying to end the revolution, Cohen warned of possible unforeseen domestic and foreign consequences of a council system.[22]
The Congress then approved a proposal by the SPD to give the Council of the People's Deputies lawgiving and executive power until the national assembly made a final decision on the form of government. Oversight of the Council was switched from the Berlin Executive Council to a new Central Council of the German Socialist Republic (Zentralrat der Deutschen Sozialistischen Republik). After the Congress accepted the SPD's definition of parliamentary oversight, the USPD boycotted the election to the Central Council, with the result that it had only SPD members.[21] Its chairperson was Max Cohen. As a result of the establishment of the Central Council, the Executive Council faded in importance, with its influence limited to Berlin, where it played a role in the Berlin March Battles of 1919.[24] The remnants of the Council, by that time referred to as the "Red Council", was suppressed by the Reichswehr in November 1919.[25]
Two other votes at the Congress did not go as much to the liking of the SPD leadership. Delegates approved a proposal for the Council of the People's Deputies to move quickly to nationalise all industries that were "ripe" for it, especially mining. With the oversight of the Berlin Executive Council, the People's Deputies were also to exercise military command authority and to see to the ending of militarism and the abolition of blind obedience (Kadavergehorsam) in the military.[18] The Congress also voted unanimously for the democratisation of the military as laid out in the Hamburg Points: there were to be no more rank insignia and no carrying of weapons when not in service; soldiers were to elect officers; soldiers' councils were to be responsible for discipline; and the standing army was to be replaced by a people's army (Volkswehr). The Army Command strongly objected to the Hamburg Points, and no trace of them was left in the Weimar Constitution.[26]
The results of the Congress showed that the councils wanted to democratise the government and the military and did not see themselves as a substitute for a parliament. For its part, the SPD's leadership wanted to integrate itself into a parliamentarised government and co-govern within it.[27] In keeping with its support of a democracy that included all of German society and not just the workers and soldiers, it delayed the Congress' reform resolutions in order not to anticipate the national assembly's democratic choices. In doing so, it angered the radical Left and made itself increasingly reliant on the imperial powers that had not been abolished or thoroughly reformed, especially the military.[18]
The Central Council convened a second congress, the Reich Congress of Workers', Farmers' and Soldiers' Councils, on 8 April 1919. The weeklong Council, the last such at the national level, agreed among other things on new electoral regulations for workers' councils.[28]
1919 violence
edit
At the end of December 1918, the three USPD members of the Council of the People's Deputies resigned in protest over the SPD's use of the military against the People's Navy Division during the Christmas crisis. They were replaced by two new SPD representatives, Gustav Noske and Rudolf Wissell.[29] The popular discontent over the events of Christmas week led to the formation of a revolutionary committee by Georg Ledebour (USPD) and Karl Liebknecht of the newly established Communist Party of Germany (KPD) on 6 January 1919. With the goal of blocking the elections for a national assembly and setting up a council republic, they declared the Council of the People's Deputies deposed. In the violence that followed, an estimated 165 people lost their lives, mostly revolutionaries killed by the regular and Freikorps units brought in by the Council of the People's Deputies.[30]
An even bloodier uprising broke out in Berlin in March 1919. It was led by the KPD and attempted to gain recognition and guarantees for the workers' and soldiers' councils, set up a council republic and adopt the Hamburg Points democratising the military. The regular army and Freikorps again suppressed the revolt. The death toll was about 1,200. Additional worker unrest took place through early May 1919 in Hamburg, Bremen, Munich and the coal-mining regions of western and central Germany.[31][32]
Local councils
edit
Hamburg's workers' and soldiers' councils can serve as an example of all that were set up in cities across Germany. On the night of 5/6 November, a group of sailors from Kiel reached the port of Hamburg, disarmed the torpedo boats there and won the crews over to their side. They occupied the main train station and union hall without resistance, but soldiers at an infantry barracks fought back and left a number of revolutionaries dead before they surrendered. The sailors established a provisional workers' and soldiers' council under USPD leadership on 6 November. After the council announced that it had political control of Hamburg, there was a mass march to the local military headquarters at Altona. Some shots were fired at them along the route, but when they reached the Altona headquarters, they found it deserted.[33] On 8 November, delegates were elected to choose the 30 members of the permanent workers' and soldiers' council. Eighteen were to represent the factories, with the remainder divided equally between USPD, SPD, the unions and the left-radicals.[34] The leaders of the new Council were the left-radical Heinrich Laufenberg and Wilhelm Heise. The USPD was the strongest group in the Council. It eliminated the Hamburg parliament on the 12th but had to restore it on the 18th because the city had lost its creditworthiness when the parliament was abolished. The Council, however, maintained a veto right over its actions. It announced the election of a new parliament, but as was the case at the national level, the SPD wanted the election to take place as soon as possible while the USPD stalled.[33]
In preparation for the December meeting in Berlin of the Reich Congress of Workers' and Soldiers' Councils, the Hamburg Council drew up the Hamburg Points that were adopted there.[33]
Hamburg's parliamentary election was held on 16 March 1919. The SPD won the largest share of the votes with 60%. The USPD had a mere 9% and the Communist Party of Germany (KPD) 7%.[34] On 26 March, the Hamburg Workers' and Soldiers' Council passed its power to the constituent parliament which wrote the city's new constitution.[33]
Some councils were far more radical than others. For instance, the workers' and soldiers' council of Neukölln controlled all local government departments, abolished the municipal authorities, took over the banks and declared housing to be communal property.[35] The soviet at Neukölln was repressed by the SPD when on the 16th of December 1918 it was invaded by armed supporters of the provisional government and forced it to postpone its plans for collectivisation of local property, let the SPD take up seats on local executive councils and to reintroduce the municipal authorities the council had abolished.[36]
End of the councils
editIn the election for the national assembly on 19 January, the SPD won 38% of the vote and the USPD 8%.[37] The SPD joined with the Centre Party and the German Democratic Party to form the ruling Weimar Coalition.[38]
On 4 February 1919, the Central Council transferred its powers to the Weimar National Assembly.[39] The Council of the People's Deputies ceased to exist on 13 February when it passed its authority to the government of Minister President Philipp Scheidemann, newly elected by the National Assembly.[40] The individual workers' and soldiers' councils across Germany lost their remaining legitimacy when the Weimar Constitution became effective on 14 August 1919. The last of them dissolved late in the autumn of that year.[41]
See also
editReferences
edit- ^ Patmore, Greg (2016). Worker Voice: Employee Representation in the Workplace in Australia, Canada, Germany, the UK and the US 1914-1939. Oxford University Press. p. 75-77. ISBN 978-1-78138-268-4. Retrieved 2023-12-28.
- ^ Kalmbach, Karena (10 June 2003). "Der Januarstreik 1918" [The January Strike 1918]. Deutsches Historisches Museum (in German). Retrieved 29 February 2024.
- ^ Scriba, Arnulf (15 August 2015). "Der Matrosenaufstand 1918" [The Sailors' Uprising 1918]. Deutsches Historisches Museum (in German). Retrieved 22 February 2024.
- ^ McElligott, Anthony (25 February 2021). Daniel, Ute; Gatrell, Peter; Janz, Oliver; Jones, Heather; Keene, Jennifer; Kramer, Alan; Nasson, Bill (eds.). "Workers' or Revolutionary Councils". 1914–1918-online. International Encyclopedia of the First World War. Freie Universität Berlin. Retrieved 22 February 2024.
- ^ Haffner, Sebastian (1991). Die deutsche Revolution 1918/19 (in German). Munich: Knaur. pp. 65–66. ISBN 978-3426038130.
- ^ Haffner 1991, p. 66.
- ^ Haffner 1991, p. 68.
- ^ Mommsen, Hans (1996). The Rise and Fall of Weimar Democracy. Translated by Forster, Elborg; Jones, Larry Eugene. Chapel Hill, NC: University of North Carolina Press. p. 22. ISBN 978-0807847213.
- ^ Sturm, Reinhard (23 December 2011). "Vom Kaiserreich zur Republik 1918/19: Revolution von unten" [From Empire to Republic 1918/19: Revolution from below]. Bundeszentrale für politische Bildung (in German). Retrieved 22 February 2024.
- ^ "9. November 1918: Ende der Monarchie – die Republik wird ausgerufen" [9 November 1918: End of the Monarchy – a Republic is Proclaimed]. Deutsche Bundestag (in German). 1918. Retrieved 22 February 2024.
- ^ a b Sturm, Reinhard (November 2011). "Weimarer Republik". Informationen zur Politischen Bildung (in German) (261): 9.
- ^ Mommsen 1996, pp. 27–29.
- ^ Winkler, Heinrich August (1993). Weimar 1918–1933. Die Geschichte der ersten deutschen Demokratie [Weimar 1918–1933. The History of the First German Democracy] (in German). Munich: C.H. Beck. p. 37. ISBN 3-406-37646-0.
- ^ Mommsen 1996, p. 28.
- ^ a b Winkler 1993, p. 37–38.
- ^ Piper, Ernst (2018). "Deutsche Revolution 1918/19". Informationen zur Politischen Bildung (in German) (33): 14.
- ^ Mommsen 1996, p. 30.
- ^ a b c d e Sturm, Reinhard (23 December 2011). "Vom Kaiserreich zur Republik 1918/19: Rätesystem oder Parlamentarismus?" [From Empire to Republic 1918/19: Council system or Parliament?]. Bundeszentrale für politische Bildung (in German). Retrieved 22 February 2024.
- ^ Piper 2018, p. 15.
- ^ a b Winkler 1993, p. 50.
- ^ a b Piper 2018, p. 17.
- ^ a b Winkler 1993, p. 51.
- ^ Hoffrogge, Ralf (2008). Richard Müller – Der Mann hinter der Novemberrevolution [Richard Müller – the Man Behind the Revolution] (in German). Berlin: Dietz. p. 94. ISBN 978-3320021481.
- ^ Weipert, Axel (2015). Die Zweite Revolution. Rätebewegung in Berlin 1919/1920. Berlin: Be.bra Wissenschaft Verlag. pp. 41–159. ISBN 978-3954100620.
- ^ Süss, Theodor (1921). Die Wirkungsgrenzen des Anerkenntnisses im deutschen Reichszivilprozessrecht [The limits of the effect of the confession in German civil law] (in German). Berlin: Ebering. p. 9.
- ^ Winkler 1993, p. 52.
- ^ Haffner 1991, p. 129.
- ^ "Zweiter Reichsrätekongress in Berlin" [Second Reich Congress of Councils in Berlin]. Bundesarchiv (in German). Retrieved 26 February 2024.
- ^ Altmann, Gerhard (11 April 2000). "Der Rat der Volksbeauftragten" [Council of the People's Deputies]. Deutsches Historisches Museum (in German). Retrieved 10 March 2024.
- ^ Scriba, Arnulf (1 September 2014). "Der Januaraufstand 1919" [The January Uprising 1919]. Deutsches Historisches Museum (in German). Retrieved 10 March 2024.
- ^ Scriba, Arnulf (1 September 2014). "Die Märzkämpfe 1919" [The March Battles 1919]. Deutsches Historisches Museum (in German). Retrieved 10 March 2024.
- ^ "Märzkämpfe 1919" [March Battles 1919]. Bundesarchiv (in German). Retrieved 10 March 2024.
- ^ a b c d Ewald, Christina. "Die Revolution 1918 in Hamburg". Hamburg Geschichtsbuch (in German). Retrieved 2 March 2024.
- ^ a b "Die Freie und Hansestadt Hamburg. Ereignisse 1918–1933" [The Free Hanse City of Hamburg. Events 1918–1933]. gonschior.de (in German). 1985. Retrieved 2 March 2024.
- ^ Gluckstein, Donny (1985). The Western Soviets. Bookmarks Publishing Co-operative. p. 133. ISBN 978-0-906-22422-9.
- ^ Gluckstein 1985, pp. 144–145.
- ^ "Wahl zur Nationalversammlung 1919" [Election to the National Assembly 1919]. gonschior.de (in German). Retrieved 10 March 2024.
- ^ "Weimarer Republik (1918 - 1933)". Deutscher Bundestag (in German). Retrieved 10 March 2024.
- ^ "Deutsche Revolution". Deutsche Geschichten (in German). p. 7. Retrieved 28 February 2024.
- ^ "Das Ende des Ersten Weltkrieges" [The End of the First World War]. Sächsische Landeszentrale für politische Bildung (in German). Retrieved 28 February 2024.
- ^ Scriba, Arnulf (15 August 2015). "Arbeiter- und Soldatenräte" [Workers' and Soldiers' Councils]. Deutsches Historisches Museum (in German). Retrieved 28 February 2024.