50+1 rule is an informal term used to refer to a clause in the regulations of the Deutsche Fußball-Liga (German Football League). The clause states that, in order to obtain a license to compete in the Bundesliga and 2. Bundesliga, a club must either wholly- or majority-own its association football team. In case of majority ownership, the football team is operated as a separate company, of which 50% of the votes plus one vote must belong to the parent club, while the rest of votes belong to the investors. The rule is designed to ensure that the club's members retain overall control via owning at least 50% + 1 of the club's shares, protecting them from the influence of external investors.
Background
editPrior to 1998, football clubs in Germany were owned exclusively by members' associations.[1] This meant that clubs were run as not-for-profit organisations, and private ownership was not allowed under any circumstances.[2] This changed following a ruling by the German Football Association (DFB) in October 1998, which allowed clubs to convert their football teams into public or private limited companies. However, the "50+1 rule" requires the parent club to own at least 50% plus one additional share of the football company, ensuring that the club's members still hold a majority of voting rights.[3]
Exceptions
editIn cases where a person or company has substantially funded a club for a continuous period of 20 years, it is possible for that person or company to own a controlling stake in the club.[4] This exception most notably applies to Bayer 04 Leverkusen (owned by pharmaceuticals company Bayer), and VfL Wolfsburg (owned by automobile manufacturer Volkswagen), because they have been owned by their parent companies since their inception predating the Bundesliga, and has more recently allowed SAP co-founder Dietmar Hopp to gain control of his former youth club of 1899 Hoffenheim. This was later reverted with the club returning to the 50+1 rule in November 2023 after Hopp transferred his majority voting rights back to the club's members.[5]
Criticism
editThe rule has been criticised on a number of occasions. One of the rule's most vocal opponents is Hannover 96 president Martin Kind, who argued that the rule could be in breach of EU competition law.[6] In 2009, Hannover put forward a motion to change the 50+1 rule, but this was overwhelmingly rejected, with 32 out of 36 clubs voting against the proposal.[7]
The effectiveness of the rule has also been brought into question following the rise of RB Leipzig. Although it is theoretically possible to become a voting member in the association, RB Leipzig reserves the right to reject any membership application without citing a reason. As a result, RB Leipzig had only a handful of members as of 2014, most of whom were Red Bull GmbH agents. Critics also noted that the annual membership fee was relatively expensive compared to other clubs.[8]
Other countries
editIn Sweden, the "51-per cent rule" says that only non-profit clubs can play in the Swedish league systems, and if the club owns a company handling economic activities, the club must own at least 51% of that company. This rule is decided by the Swedish Sports Confederation and is valid for all sports.[9][10] In individual sports, all Swedish elite participants must be members of a non-profit club which they represent in normal national competitions (and the club can have a 51% owned company), but individuals are allowed to have their own company or (in many sports) take part in company competitions such as for example Ski Classics or Ironman and then represent a company team.
References
edit- ^ Schaerlaeckens, Leander (21 October 2010). "The best league in the world?". ESPN. Retrieved 8 March 2015.
- ^ Müller, Christian (21 February 2011). "Football Governance". parliament.uk. Retrieved 8 March 2015.
- ^ Honigstein, Raphael (10 February 2009). "League crack down on lewd shirt numbers to concentrate on 50+1". The Guardian. Retrieved 8 March 2015.
- ^ Hesse, Uli (30 December 2014). "Issues looming for Germany's footballing landscape". ESPN. Retrieved 3 May 2021.
- ^ "TSG Hoffenheim once again a "50+1" regulation club". TSG Hoffenheim. 29 November 2023. Retrieved 30 November 2023.
- ^ Amies, Nick (19 November 2009). "For better or worse, Bundesliga clubs to keep ownership rule". Deutsche Welle. Retrieved 8 March 2015.
- ^ Conn, David (13 November 2009). "Bundesliga votes to keep clubs owned by members". The Guardian. Retrieved 8 March 2015.
- ^ Oltermann, Philip (6 March 2014). "Why RB Leipzig are sending shockwaves through German football". The Guardian. Retrieved 8 March 2015.
- ^ "Fakta: 51-procentsregeln" [Facts: 51 percent rule] (in Swedish). SVT. 22 May 2013. Retrieved 4 March 2022.
- ^ "RF:s Stadgar (→ 11 kap)" [RF statutes] (PDF) (in Swedish). Riksidrottsförbundet (RF). 1 January 2020. Archived from the original (PDF) on 4 March 2022. Retrieved 4 March 2022.
External links
edit- Statuten DFL - bundesliga.de - die offizielle Webseite der Bundesliga Archived 9 June 2017 at the Wayback Machine (in German)