Barbara Arrowsmith Young (born November 28, 1951) is a Canadian author, entrepreneur and lecturer. She is the founder of the Arrowsmith School in Toronto and the controversial Arrowsmith Program[1] which forms the basis of the school's teaching method. In 2012 she published The Woman Who Changed Her Brain which combines an autobiographical account of her own severe learning disabilities and the method she developed to overcome them with case studies of learning disabled children who she claims overcame similar problems by using her method.
Barbara Arrowsmith Young | |
|---|---|
| Born | November 28, 1951 Toronto, Ontario, Canada |
| Alma mater |
|
| Occupation(s) | Entrepreneur, lecturer, author |
| Known for | The Arrowsmith School (founder) and the Arrowsmith Program (founder and chief director) |
| Website | barbaraarrowsmithyoung |
Early life
editArrowsmith Young was born in Toronto on November 28, 1951, to Jack and Barbara Young. Her father was an electrical engineer who worked for Canadian General Electric. Her mother was a teacher. As a child she had exceptional visual and auditory memory, but it was coupled with several severe deficits in other areas, including dyslexia, dyscalculia, and problems with spatial reasoning, logic, and kinesthetic perception. With the help of her mother she eventually achieved basic literacy and numeracy. However, she struggled throughout elementary and high school.[2]
Education
editDespite her learning difficulties, she graduated with a BA.Sc in child studies from the University of Guelph in 1974. After graduating she worked for two years as the head teacher of the university's laboratory preschool before embarking on a master's degree in applied psychology at the University of Toronto's Ontario Institute for Studies in Education (OISE). She completed her Masters dissertation, A follow up study of a clinical sample, in 1982.[3] It examined the progress of 62 students who had been previously assessed as learning disabled at the OISE's education clinic.[4]
In 1977 she had met Joshua Cohen, a PhD. student at OISE who also had learning disabilities and ran a small clinic for learning disabled children.[2] Cohen introduced her to the work of Alexander Luria. According to Arrowsmith Young, Luria's 1971 book The Man with the Shattered World which documented the recovery under his treatment of the brain-injured soldier Lev Zasetsky was profoundly influential on her, as was the work of Mark Rosenzweig on neuroplasticity.[5] Using the ideas of Luria and Rosenzweig, she began developing a series of exercises in 1978 which she states finally helped to overcome her learning disabilities.
Career
editArrowsmith Young and Cohen married in 1980 and opened the Arrowswmith School for learning disabled children in Toronto that same year. Its curriculum was based on the exercises which Arrowsmith Young had developed for herself and which came to be known as the Arrowsmith Program. She named the school after her paternal grandmother (born Louie May Arrowsmith in 1883), who as a young girl had been one of the pioneer settlers of Creston, British Columbia. The Toronto school gradually expanded and in 1991 she and Cohen opened a second school in Brooklyn, New York. The Toronto branch was wound down and closed. However, the New York school folded a few years later, and in 1994, Arrowsmith Young and Cohen's marriage ended. She returned to Toronto and re-opened the original school. Cohen remained in New York and died there in 2000.[5][2]
The Arrowsmith Program
editThe re-opened Arrowsmith School in Toronto attracted increasing numbers of students and eventually opened other branches. The Arrowsmith Program was also franchised to other private schools and in some public ones as well. In 2012 she published The Woman Who Changed Her Brain, an autobiographical account of how she overcame her own severe learning disabilities combined with 30 case studies of learning disabled children who she says overcame similar problems by using her method.[6][7]
Her method, which was the subject of a 2008 CBC documentary Fixing My Brain, has proved controversial.[8] Psychiatrist Norman Doidge devoted one of the chapters in his book, The Brain That Changes Itself, to Arrowsmith Young and described her approach as "an important discovery".[2] However, the Arrowsmith Program has been criticized by several neuroscientists, psychologists and cognitive scientists, including Anne Castles, Max Coltheart, Pamela Snow, Emma Burrows and Linda Siegel, for basing its claims on anecdotal evidence. They have noted that there have been no peer-reviewed studies published which use randomized controlled trials to evaluate whether it is actually more effective than any other "brain training" programs.[9][10][11][12]
Additionally, other experts, including clinical psychologist and neuropsychologist Tim Hannan,[13] speech pathologist Alison Clarke, and at least one human rights tribunal have made similar concerns, citing lack of evidence and improper tests on the program.[14][15] Clarke even argues the program to be based on pseudoscientific methodology.[16]
Robert Shepard, a clinical psychologist with twenty-five years of private practice, forensic and family health team experience, as well as a critic of Norman Doidge and his work,[17] makes a ten-point argument against the Arrowsmith Program. Explaining each point in short essay format, he argues that these are essential to marketing a product when no evidence exists that it actually works.[18]
References
edit- ^ "Controversial claims get the soft treatment". Media Watch. 2017-03-12. Retrieved 2023-10-11.
- ^ a b c d Doidge, Norman (2008). Chapter 2: "Building Herself a Better Brain", The Brain That Changes Itself: Stories of Personal Triumph from the Frontiers of Brain Science. Penguin. ISBN 978-0141038872
- ^ OCLC 223117936
- ^ University of Guelph. Alumni profile: Barbara Arrowsmith Young Archived 2015-05-29 at the Wayback Machine. Retrieved 4 June 2015.
- ^ a b Arrowsmith Young, Barbara (2012). The Woman Who Changed Her Brain. pp. 7, 16, 139, 161–162, 187–188. Simon and Schuster. ISBN 978-1451607932
- ^ Barmak, Sarah (1 June 2012). "Step by painful step, she built a better brain". The Globe and Mail. Retrieved 4 June 2015.
- ^ Eggertson, Laura (26 May 2012). "The Woman Who Changed Her Brain by Barbara Arrowsmith-Young: Review". Toronto Star. Retrieved 4 June 2015.
- ^ Hill, M. F. (29 December 2008). "Education expert calling her lawyer". Vancouver Sun. Retrieved 31 May 2015.
- ^ Barmak, Sarah (25 January 2013). "Can a controversial learning program transform brains?". The Globe and Mail. Retrieved 4 June 2015.
- ^ Tarica, Elisabeth (18 June 2012). "Brain program heads this way". Sydney Morning Herald. Retrieved 4 June 2015.
- ^ Han, Esther (15 May 2012). "Proof hurdle for 'brain training'". Sydney Morning Herald. Retrieved 9 June 2015.
- ^ Sydney Morning Herald (11 May 2012). "Experts question effectiveness of program". Retrieved 4 June 2015.
- ^ "Experts question Arrowsmith Program for kids with learning difficulties". Patrick Wood. ABC News. 21 March 2017.
- ^ Australian Broadcasting Corporation (13 March 2017). "Media Watch, Episode 6: Controversial claims get the soft treatment"
- ^ "Jobb v Parkland School Division No. 70, 2017 AHRC 3 (CanLII)". Alberta Human Rights Commission (AHRC).
- ^ "Children with learning difficulties need programs based on science, not anecdote and neurobabble". Alison Clarke. The Sydney Morning Herald. 2 September 2015.
- ^ Robert Shepard (Apr 4, 2017). "Would You Trust This Man? Norman Doidge and the Brain's Way of… Fooling You". Medium.
- ^ Robert Shepard (Apr 21, 2017). "10 ways to sell your product even when there's no evidence that it works: The Arrowsmith Program of Cognitive Exercises". Medium.