Botany (New Zealand electorate)

Botany
Botany
Single-member general constituency for the New Zealand House of Representatives
Formation	2008
Region	Auckland Region
Character	Suburban
Term	3 years
Member for Botany
	; Christopher Luxon ; since 17 October 2020
Party	National
Previous MP	Jami-Lee Ross (Ind)

Botany is a New Zealand parliamentary electorate, returning one Member of Parliament to the New Zealand House of Representatives. It was contested for the first time at the 2008 general election, and won by Pansy Wong for the National Party. Following Wong's resignation in late 2010, a by-election returned Jami-Lee Ross, who was confirmed by the voters in the 2011 general election. Ross left the National Party in October 2018 and became an independent. Ross did not contest the seat at the 2020 general election, and was succeeded by the new National candidate, Christopher Luxon, who became the party's leader in November 2021 and has served as prime minister since November 2023.

Background

The Representation Commission established the electoral district of Botany after the 2006 New Zealand census due to high population growth in and around Auckland. The new electorate resulted from several sweeping changes to the electoral landscape of South Auckland:

The southern end of Port Waikato was lanced and combined with the area around Clevedon township to form Hunua.
The resultant change pulled the Clevedon electorate tighter around the city of Papakura for which the electorate is now named.
In the north, Manukau East was pulled up through Otahuhu into Auckland City, in the process dropping the western suburbs of Flat Bush, East Tāmaki, Dannemora and Botany Downs, which combined with fragments of the Clevedon and Pakuranga electorates to form Botany.

Demographics

Demographically, Botany is older than the rest of New Zealand, with over half of its population aged over 30; It has three times as many Chinese New Zealanders than the national average (33.5 versus 9.2%), and nearly twice as many Pasifika New Zealanders (13 to 7%), which makes Botany a minority-majority electorate. Botany has the highest number of people born overseas of any New Zealand electorate (49% in 2006), the most Buddhists in a New Zealand electorate and the highest number of one-family homes. The average income in the electorate is high, with over half of the electorate's residents earning over $50,000 a year.^{[citation needed]}

A 2005 academic survey assessing the voting behaviour of Asian New Zealanders^[1] showed a strong preference for the Labour Party, with a sizeable proportion prepared to vote for the National Party (47 to 40); it also showed that among Asian New Zealanders, the most important issues were the economy and law and order. This was demonstrated by a large anti-crime march (a crowd of 15,000 was estimated, with a significant number of these being Asian New Zealanders) was held in Auckland (on the streets of Botany) in July 2008 amidst claims of increasing violent crime in New Zealand targeted against its Asian population.^[2] The march's organiser Peter Low used his website to clarify his position, calling for harsher sentencing, victims' rights and zero "criminal rights".^[3]

History

Botany was first created for the 2008 general election, and won by Pansy Wong for the National Party.^{[citation needed]}

Both National and the ACT party stood Chinese New Zealanders as their candidates in 2008; Pansy Wong and Kenneth Wang, respectively. Labour chose Koro Tawa, an Auckland University lecturer. Raymond Huo, a Chinese-speaking lawyer, was initially mooted for the Labour nomination, but eventually chose to stand as a list-only candidate.^[4]^[5]

On 14 December 2010 it was announced that a by-election was to be held on 5 March 2011 due to the resignation of incumbent MP Pansy Wong.^[6] The electorate was won by Jami-Lee Ross from the New Zealand National Party.

In October 2018, Jami-Lee Ross resigned from the National Party and accused party leader Simon Bridges of breaching electoral law. Ross announced his intention to resign from parliament and run as an independent in the resulting by-election,^[7] however he later decided against resigning. Christopher Luxon won the National Party selection in November 2019.^[8]

On 15 September 2020 Ross announced he was no longer intending to contest the electorate, but will instead contest the upcoming election as a list only candidate for his newly formed party, Advance NZ.^[9] Luxon won the seat at the 2020 election as Ross was ejected from Parliament.

Members of Parliament

Key

National Independent

Election	Winner
2008 election		Pansy Wong
2011 by-election		Jami-Lee Ross
2011 election
2014 election
2017 election
2017 election
2020 election		Christopher Luxon
2023 election		Christopher Luxon

List MPs

Members of Parliament elected from party lists in elections where that person also unsuccessfully contested the Botany electorate. Unless otherwise stated, all MPs' terms began and ended at general elections.

Key

Labour ACT

Election	Winner
2020 election		Naisi Chen
2020 election		Damien Smith

Election results

2023 election

2023 general election: Botany^[10]
Notes:		Blue background denotes the winner of the electorate vote. Pink background denotes a candidate elected from their party list. Yellow background denotes an electorate win by a list member, or other incumbent. A Y or N denotes status of any incumbent, win or lose respectively.
Party		Candidate		Votes	%	±%	Party votes	%	±%
	National	Y Christopher Luxon		24,769	66.57	+14.11	22,239	58.74	+21.69
	Labour	Kharag Singh		8,432	22.66	-18.77	7,708	22.27	-25.21
	ACT	Bo Burns		1,959	5.26	+1.85	2,788	7.36	+0.56
	NZ Loyal	John Armstrong		624	1.67	—	280	0.73	—
	Animal Justice	Robert McNeil		428	1.15	—	98	0.25	–
	New Conservative	Dieuwe de Boer		300	0.80	-0.92	86	0.22	-1.44
	Green						2,212	5.84	+2.56
	NZ First						1,136	3.00	+1.57
	Opportunities						439	1.15	+0.33
	Te Pāti Māori						188	0.49	+0.30
	NewZeal						156	0.41	+0.18
	Freedoms NZ						127	0.33	–
	Legalise Cannabis						106	0.28	+0.08
	New Nation						37	0.09	–
	DemocracyNZ						29	0.07	–
	Women's Rights						27	0.07	–
	Leighton Baker Party						12	0.03	–
Informal votes				692			189
Total valid votes				37,204			37,857
	National hold		Majority	16,337	43.91	+33.38

2020 election

2020 general election: Botany^[11]
Notes:		Blue background denotes the winner of the electorate vote. Pink background denotes a candidate elected from their party list. Yellow background denotes an electorate win by a list member, or other incumbent. A Y or N denotes status of any incumbent, win or lose respectively.
Party		Candidate		Votes	%	±%	Party votes	%	±%
	National	Christopher Luxon		19,017	52.46	–9.17	13,970	37.05	−23.78
	Labour	Naisi Chen		15,018	41.43	+16.81	17,900	47.48	+18.30
	ACT	Damien Smith		1,236	3.41	+2.46	2,563	6.80	+6.20
	New Conservative	Dieuwe De Boer		624	1.72	—	624	1.66	+1.40
	Sustainable NZ	Peter Fleming		358	0.99	—	26	0.07	–
	Green						1,236	3.28	+0.89
	NZ First						541	1.43	−3.14
	Opportunities						237	0.63	−0.19
	Advance NZ						159	0.42	–
	TEA						152	0.40	–
	ONE						85	0.23	–
	Legalise Cannabis						76	0.20	+0.05
	Māori Party						70	0.19	−0.37
	Vision NZ						40	0.11	–
	Outdoors						15	0.04	±0.00
	Heartland						5	0.01	–
	Social Credit						4	0.01	±0.00
Informal votes				1,264			261
Total valid votes				36,253			37,703
Turnout				37,964	73.83^[12]	+1.20
	National hold		Majority	3,999	10.53	−26.48

2017 election

2017 general election: Botany^[13]
Notes:		Blue background denotes the winner of the electorate vote. Pink background denotes a candidate elected from their party list. Yellow background denotes an electorate win by a list member, or other incumbent. A Y or N denotes status of any incumbent, win or lose respectively.
Party		Candidate		Votes	%	±%	Party votes	%	±%
	National	Y Jami-Lee Ross		21,378	61.63	−2.21	21,428	60.83	+1.41
	Labour	Tofik Mamedov		8,539	24.62	+1.72	10,279	29.18	+6.99
	Green	Julie Zhu		2,103	6.06	—	841	2.39	−1.95
	Māori Party	Wetex Kang		1,165	3.36	—	195	0.55	+0.34
	United Future	Damian Light		500	1.44	—	33	0.09	−0.06
	ACT	Sam Singh		330	0.95	—	209	0.59	−1.81
	NZ First						1,612	4.58	−0.84
	Opportunities						288	0.82	—
	Conservative						91	0.26	−4.25
	Legalise Cannabis						54	1.53	+1.26
	People's Party						44	0.12	—
	Outdoors						14	0.04	—
	Mana Party						12	0.03	—
	Internet						9	0.02	—
	Ban 1080						6	0.02	−0.02
	Democrats						2	0.01	—
Informal votes				673			110
Total valid votes				34,688			35,227
Turnout				35,658	72.63^[14]	+0.78
	National hold		Majority	12,839	37.01	−3.93

2014 election

2014 general election: Botany^[15]
Notes:		Blue background denotes the winner of the electorate vote. Pink background denotes a candidate elected from their party list. Yellow background denotes an electorate win by a list member, or other incumbent. A Y or N denotes status of any incumbent, win or lose respectively.
Party		Candidate		Votes	%	±%	Party votes	%	±%
	National	Y Jami-Lee Ross		21,044	63.84	−0.19	20,016	59.42	−1.71
	Labour	Tofik Mamedov		7,549	22.90	−2.45	7,473	22.19	−1.59
	Conservative	Paul Young		3,053	9.26	+1.57	1,519	4.51	+1.83
	Independent	David McCormick		668	2.03	+2.03
	NZ First						1,825	5.42	+1.02
	Green						1,461	4.34	−0.06
	ACT						808	2.40	+0.75
	Internet Mana						204	0.61	+0.36^[a]
	Legalise Cannabis						90	0.27	−0.02
	Māori Party						71	0.21	−0.08
	United Future						49	0.15	−0.17
	Ban 1080						12	0.04	+0.04
	Independent Coalition						9	0.03	+0.03
	Civilian						8	0.02	+0.02
	Focus						6	0.02	+0.02
	Democrats						5	0.01	−0.01
Informal votes				648			128
Total valid votes				32,962			33,684
Turnout				33,812	71.00	+3.25
	National hold		Majority	13,495	40.94	+2.26

2011 election

2011 general election: Botany^[16]
Notes:		Blue background denotes the winner of the electorate vote. Pink background denotes a candidate elected from their party list. Yellow background denotes an electorate win by a list member, or other incumbent. A Y or N denotes status of any incumbent, win or lose respectively.
Party		Candidate		Votes	%	±%	Party votes	%	±%
	National	Y Jami-Lee Ross		17,780	64.03	+7.81	17,749	61.13	-0.11
	Labour	Chao-Fu Wu		7,039	25.35	+4.29	7,111	24.49	-0.69
	Conservative	Paul Young		2,135	7.69	+7.69	777	2.68	+2.68
	ACT	Lyn Murphy		631	2.27	-12.98	478	1.65	-3.19
	United Future	Ram Parkash		185	0.67	-0.72	94	0.32	-0.37
	NZ First						1,278	4.40	+2.26
	Green						1,277	4.40	+2.01
	Legalise Cannabis						85	0.29	+0.10
	Māori Party						84	0.29	-0.02
	Mana						72	0.25	+0.25
	Libertarianz						13	0.04	+0.01
	Alliance						9	0.03	+0.01
	Democrats						7	0.02	+0.02
Informal votes				1,069			238
Total valid votes				27,770			29,034
	National hold		Majority	10,741	38.68	+3.52

Electorate (as at 26 November 2011): 43,204^[17]

2011 by-election

Official results of the 5 March by-election.^[18]

2011 Botany by-election
Notes: Blue background denotes the winner of the by-election. Pink background denotes a candidate elected from their party list prior to the by-election. Yellow background denotes the winner of the by-election, who was a list MP prior to the by-election. A Y or N denotes status of any incumbent, win or lose respectively.
Party		Candidate	Votes	%	±%
	National	Jami-Lee Ross	8,352	54.25	-1.97
	Labour	Michael Wood	4,380	28.45	+7.39
	New Citizen	Paul Young	1,626	10.56
	ACT	Lyn Murphy	687	4.46	−10.80
	Independent	Penny Bright	128	0.83
	Legalise Cannabis	Leo Biggs	61	0.40
	Independent	Wayne Young	54	0.35
	Join Australia	Robin Caithness	45	0.29
	Pirate	Hussain Al-saady	32	0.21
	Independent	Robert Goh	31	0.20
Informal votes			25	0.16
Total Valid votes			15,396	35.84
	National hold	Majority	3,972	25.76	-9.40

2008 election

2008 general election: Botany^[19]
Notes:		Blue background denotes the winner of the electorate vote. Pink background denotes a candidate elected from their party list. Yellow background denotes an electorate win by a list member, or other incumbent. A Y or N denotes status of any incumbent, win or lose respectively.
Party		Candidate		Votes	%	±%	Party votes	%	±%
	National	Pansy Wong		17,382	56.22		19,355	61.25
	Labour	Koro Tawa		6,510	21.06		7,958	25.18
	ACT	Kenneth Wang		4,717	15.26		1,528	4.84
	Green	Peter Cooper		1,226	3.97		756	2.39
	United Future	Judy Carter		428	1.38		220	0.70
	Progressive	Racheal Cheam		304	0.98		217	0.69
	Kiwi	Simon Kan		212	0.69		125	0.40
	Independent	Raj Subramanian		140	0.45
	NZ First						678	2.15
	Pacific						295	0.93
	Family Party						166	0.53
	Bill and Ben						98	0.31
	Māori Party						98	0.31
	Legalise Cannabis						62	0.20
	Workers Party						13	0.04
	Libertarianz						10	0.03
	Alliance						8	0.03
	RONZ						7	0.02
	RAM						6	0.02
	Democrats						2	0.01
Informal votes				386			131
Total valid votes				30,919			31,602
	National win new seat		Majority	10,872	35.16

Table footnotes

^ 2014 Internet Mana swing is relative to the votes for Mana in 2011; it shared a party list with Internet in the 2014 election.

References

^ "Asian Vote". New Zealand Listener. 20 August 2004.
^ "Huge turnout for anti-crime march". TVNZ News. 5 July 2004.
^ "ASIAN ANTI-CRIME GROUP (AAG) TRUST NEW ZEALAND". Asian Anti-Crime Group Trust. 5 August 2004. Archived from the original on 5 September 2008.
^ Tan, Lincoln (20 June 2008). "Botany a hot Asian battleground". The New Zealand Herald.
^ Blockley, Louise (22 August 2008). "Raymond Huo on Labour list". Te Waha Nui. Archived from the original on 20 July 2011. Retrieved 3 November 2008.
^ Cheng, Derek (14 December 2010). "Pansy Wong resigns as MP". The New Zealand Herald. Retrieved 21 September 2011.
^ Morning Report (17 October 2018). "Jami-Lee Ross vows to fight for Botany seat". RNZ.
^ Wilson, Simon (5 November 2019). "National selects Christopher Luxon as its new candidate for Botany". The New Zealand Herald. Retrieved 5 November 2019.
^ Kirkness, Luke (15 September 2020). "Election 2020: Advance NZ's Jami-Lee Ross abandons attempt to retain Botany seat". The New Zealand Herald. Archived from the original on 19 September 2020.
^ "Botany - Official Result". www.electionresults.govt.nz. Electoral Commission. Retrieved 3 November 2023.
^ "Botany - Official Result". New Zealand Electoral Commission. Retrieved 4 December 2021.
^ "Party Votes and Turnout by Electorate (2020)". Electoral Commission. Retrieved 26 November 2021.
^ New Zealand Electoral Commission. "Botany - Official Result". Electionresults.govt.nz. Retrieved 7 October 2017.
^ "Party Votes and Turnout by Electorate". Electoral Commission. Retrieved 27 January 2018.
^ Electoral Commission (21 January 2016). "Official Count Results – Botany". Retrieved 21 January 2016.
^ "Botany results, 2011".
^ "Enrolment statistics". Electoral Commission. 21 October 2011. Archived from the original on 10 November 2011. Retrieved 28 October 2011.
^ "By-Election Results -- Botany". electionresults.govt.nz. 2011. Archived from the original on 8 March 2011. Retrieved 6 March 2011.
^ Election result: Botany, 2008 Archived 11 December 2008 at the Wayback Machine

External links

Electorate Profile Archived 22 May 2011 at the Wayback Machine Parliamentary Library

[Internet_Mana-16] 2014 Internet Mana swing is relative to the votes for Mana in 2011; it shared a party list with Internet in the 2014 election.

[1] "Asian Vote". New Zealand Listener. 20 August 2004.

[2] "Huge turnout for anti-crime march". TVNZ News. 5 July 2004.

[3] "ASIAN ANTI-CRIME GROUP (AAG) TRUST NEW ZEALAND". Asian Anti-Crime Group Trust. 5 August 2004. Archived from the original on 5 September 2008.

[4] Tan, Lincoln (20 June 2008). "Botany a hot Asian battleground". The New Zealand Herald.

[5] Blockley, Louise (22 August 2008). "Raymond Huo on Labour list". Te Waha Nui. Archived from the original on 20 July 2011. Retrieved 3 November 2008.

[resign-6] Cheng, Derek (14 December 2010). "Pansy Wong resigns as MP". The New Zealand Herald. Retrieved 21 September 2011.

[7] Morning Report (17 October 2018). "Jami-Lee Ross vows to fight for Botany seat". RNZ.

[8] Wilson, Simon (5 November 2019). "National selects Christopher Luxon as its new candidate for Botany". The New Zealand Herald. Retrieved 5 November 2019.

[9] Kirkness, Luke (15 September 2020). "Election 2020: Advance NZ's Jami-Lee Ross abandons attempt to retain Botany seat". The New Zealand Herald. Archived from the original on 19 September 2020.

[election_2023-10] "Botany - Official Result". www.electionresults.govt.nz. Electoral Commission. Retrieved 3 November 2023.

[result2020-11] "Botany - Official Result". New Zealand Electoral Commission. Retrieved 4 December 2021.

[12] "Party Votes and Turnout by Electorate (2020)". Electoral Commission. Retrieved 26 November 2021.

[Botany_2017_election_results-13] New Zealand Electoral Commission. "Botany - Official Result". Electionresults.govt.nz. Retrieved 7 October 2017.

[14] "Party Votes and Turnout by Electorate". Electoral Commission. Retrieved 27 January 2018.

[Botany_2014_election_results-15] Electoral Commission (21 January 2016). "Official Count Results – Botany". Retrieved 21 January 2016.

[Botany_2011_election_results-17] "Botany results, 2011".

[enrolment-18] "Enrolment statistics". Electoral Commission. 21 October 2011. Archived from the original on 10 November 2011. Retrieved 28 October 2011.

[19] "By-Election Results -- Botany". electionresults.govt.nz. 2011. Archived from the original on 8 March 2011. Retrieved 6 March 2011.

[20] Election result: Botany, 2008 Archived 11 December 2008 at the Wayback Machine

[1]

[2]

[3]

[4]

[5]

[6]

[7]

[8]

[9]

[10]

[11]

[12]

[13]

[14]

[15]

[a]

[16]

[17]

[18]

[19]