Category talk:Biography articles by quality

Jimbo Wales

If the biography of me is consdiered to be A-class, this is a depressing indictment of what it means to be A-class. It is full of original research, speculative statements, trolling absurdities, etc. I consider to be no better than C+, if we are handing out letter grades.--Jimbo Wales 14:48, 14 July 2006 (UTC)

I think A-Class should be used very, very sparingly personally. A-Class is theoretically better than GA and on a par with Featured Articles. The biography article about you wouldn't get the GA badge, nor is it an FA in waiting so that makes it automatically a B at best. It's partly referenced and reasonably detailed so B it is. We don't have a C-class; the next below B is Start which is kind of a turbocharged Stub. I'll change to B and link to this thread. --kingboyk 12:16, 17 August 2006 (UTC)

Actually, I stand corrected - it does have a GA badge! So, let's change it to GA-Class. --kingboyk 12:17, 17 August 2006 (UTC)