Category talk:Hotels in Dublin (city)

Notes

User Good Ol'factory had added the Category:Hotels in County Dublin to this category. Following his successful petition of Nov 8th, the cat was renamed to Hotels in Dublin. As part of the debate, User Peterkingiron noted "in that case the offending iteme need to be re categorised or move to a Dublin Region category. County Dublin exists as a historical entity only and any categories for it should be merged into those for Dublin Region.". You did not disagree with his viewpoint. That does not mean that you agree with his viewpoint. Still, I would be interested in understanding your rationale for including the County Dublin category as a parent for this category. Laurel Lodged (talk) 21:47, 7 December 2010 (UTC)

The core point is that "any categories for it should be merged into those for Dublin Region". Far from merging with the Dublin Region, you (user Good Ol'factory) went the opposite direction and populated a previously unpopulated category that reports to County Dublin. How was this action consistent with the concensus that emerged on that thread? Is it that you did not consider yourself to be bound by user Peterkingiron's opinion? Laurel Lodged (talk) 14:28, 9 December 2010 (UTC)