Category talk:Sheep wool
Latest comment: 7 years ago by Eddaido in topic Categorisation
 | This category was nominated for deletion, renaming, or merging with another category on 2011 February 19. The result of the discussion was keep. |
Categorisation
editWool is a natural fibre. All the items which feed into this category are related to the Wool Industry or Woolgrowing industry and should be so categorised and as a group by itself should be linked here
EXCEPT:
edit- Owling (legal term) because it is wool trade
- Karakul sheep and Merino because they are sheep breeds
And EXCEPT
editbecause they are not creating wool or dealing in "raw" wool
they describe some of the uses for wool or promote the use consumption of wool
- Burying in Woollen Acts
- Knitting
- Lantana (fabric)
- Lopi
- Maryland Sheep and Wool Festival
- National Wool Museum
- New York State Sheep and Wool Festival
- S number (wool)
- Sheep to shawl
- Shepherd's Harvest Festival
- Wool insulation
Those that belong in the category Wool Industry
edit- Blade shearing
- Bradford system
- The Golden Fleece (painting)
- Golden Shears
- Kemp (wool)
- Lambswool
- Organic wool
- Sheep Research Center (Mannavanur)
- Sheep shearer
- Sheep shearing
- Staple (wool)
- Wool classing
Eddaido (talk) 05:55, 8 August 2017 (UTC)
- @Eddaido: I'm alright with the above presuming that you intend to move a number of "EXCEPT" articles from this category to Category:Wool or Category:Wool industry.
- Hmmm. The listing above is to explain to you why the topics listed above, currently in Sheep Wool, do not fit directly into Sheep Wool.
- By the way you should be aware that category content changes continuously, e.g. because new articles are being written. So the above lists will soon be outdated and the main thing is that it should be intuitively clear to editors what does and doesn't belong in the category, by choosing a smart category name.
- Goes without saying. It also presumes those editors know a little of that which they so categorise
- I don't think "Sheep wool" is clear enough as a category name and "Sheep shearing" may be a better choice.
- This last comment is so extraordinary it seems to be beyond my understanding, please explain more so I might have another try to grasp it.
- Responded with interpolations above. Eddaido (talk) 05:40, 13 August 2017 (UTC)