Allmusic panned the album, saying: "This is truly a bizarre and disappointing album, combining Rogers' bland adult contemporary versions of traditional Christmas songs with obnoxious numbers sung by children."[2]
| Title | Writer(s) |
|---|
| 1. | "It's Just Not Christmas" | Sandin, Smith-Cochran | 3:09 |
|---|
| 2. | "The Christmas Song" | Torme, Wells | 2:49 |
|---|
| 3. | "My Favorite Things" | Hammerstein, Rodgers | 2:42 |
|---|
| 4. | "White Christmas" | Berlin | 2:57 |
|---|
| 5. | "Let It Snow!" | Cahn, Styne | 2:07 |
|---|
| 6. | "O Come All Ye Faithful" | Oakeley, Wade | 3:16 |
|---|
| 7. | "Hey Little Christmas Tree" | Golden, Hartman, Rogers | 3:04 |
|---|
| 8. | "Merry Christmas" | Golden, Hartman, Rogers | 1:44 |
|---|
| 9. | "Money Isn't What Really Matters" | Golden, Hartman, Rogers | 2:30 |
|---|
| 10. | "Heroes" | Golden, Hartman, Rogers | 2:20 |
|---|
| 11. | "I Wanna Be a Christmas Present" | Golden, Hartman, Rogers | 2:20 |
|---|
| 12. | "The Ballerina Song" | Golden, Hartman, Rogers | 3:50 |
|---|
| 13. | "Help Somebody Find Their Way" | Golden, Hartman, Rogers | 2:20 |
|---|
| 14. | "If I Only Had Your Heart" (duet with Alyssa Bonagura) | Golden, Hartman, Rogers | 3:50 |
|---|
| 15. | "Mister Perfect" | Golden, Hartman, Rogers | 2:35 |
|---|
| 16. | "I Promise You" | Golden, Hartman, Rogers | 3:30 |
|---|
| 17. | "The Toy Shoppe" | Golden, Hartman, Rogers | 3:10 |
|---|
| 18. | "Til the Season Comes Around Again" | Goodrum, Jarvis | 3:53 |
|---|
In 2008, Koch Records reissued the CD under the same title, but with one change; the final track is omitted.
