Chinese classics

(Redirected from Confucian Classics)

The Chinese classics or canonical texts are the works of Chinese literature authored prior to the establishment of the imperial Qin dynasty in 221 BC. Prominent examples include the Four Books and Five Classics in the Neo-Confucian tradition, themselves an abridgment of the Thirteen Classics. The Chinese classics used a form of written Chinese consciously imitated by later authors, now known as Classical Chinese. A common Chinese word for "classic" (; ; jīng) literally means 'warp thread', in reference to the techniques by which works of this period were bound into volumes.[1]

Chinese classics
Traditional Chinese中國古籍
Simplified Chinese中国古籍
Transcriptions
Standard Mandarin
Hanyu PinyinZhōngguó gǔjí

Texts may include shi (, 'histories') zi ( 'master texts'), philosophical treatises usually associated with an individual and later systematized into schools of thought but also including works on agriculture, medicine, mathematics, astronomy, divination, art criticism, and other miscellaneous writings) and ji ( 'literary works') as well as the cultivation of jing, 'essence' in Chinese medicine.

In the Ming and Qing dynasties, the Four Books and Five Classics were the subjects of mandatory study by those Confucian scholars who wished to take the imperial examination and needed to pass them in order to become scholar-officials. Any political discussion was full of references to this background, and one could not become part of the literati—or even a military officer in some periods—without having memorized them. Generally, children first memorized the Chinese characters of the Three Character Classic and Hundred Family Surnames and they then went on to memorize the other classics. The literate elite therefore shared a common culture and set of values.[2]

Qin dynasty

edit

Loss of texts

edit

According to Sima Qian's Records of the Grand Historian, after Qin Shi Huang, the first emperor of China, unified China in 221 BC, his chancellor Li Si suggested suppressing intellectual discourse to unify thought and political opinion. This was alleged to have destroyed philosophical treatises of the Hundred Schools of Thought, with the goal of strengthening the official Qin governing philosophy of Legalism. According to the Shiji, three categories of books were viewed by Li Si to be most dangerous politically. These were poetry, history (especially historical records of other states than Qin), and philosophy. The ancient collection of poetry and historical records contained many stories concerning the ancient virtuous rulers. Li Si believed that if the people were to read these works they were likely to invoke the past and become dissatisfied with the present. The reason for opposing various schools of philosophy was that they advocated political ideas often incompatible with the totalitarian regime.[3]

Modern historians doubt the details of the story, which first appeared more than a century later. Regarding the alleged Qin objective of strengthening Legalism, the traditional account is anachronistic in that Legalism was not yet a defined category of thought during the Qin period,[4] and the "schools of thought" model is no longer considered to be an accurate portrayal of the intellectual history of pre-imperial China.[5][6][7] Michael Nylan observes that despite its mythic significance, the "burning of books and burying of scholars" legend does not bear close scrutiny. Nylan suggests that the reason Han dynasty scholars charged the Qin with destroying the Confucian Five Classics was partly to "slander" the state they defeated and partly because Han scholars misunderstood the nature of the texts, for it was only after the founding of the Han that Sima Qian labeled the Five Classics as Confucian. Nylan also points out that the Qin court appointed classical scholars who were specialists on the Classic of Poetry and the Book of Documents, which meant that these texts would have been exempted, and that the Book of Rites and the Zuo Zhuan did not contain the glorification of defeated feudal states which the First Emperor gave as his reason for destroying them. Nylan further suggests that the story might be based on the fact that the Qin palace was razed in 207 BC and many books were undoubtedly lost at that time.[8] Martin Kern adds that Qin and early Han writings frequently cite the Classics, especially the Documents and the Classic of Poetry, which would not have been possible if they had been burned, as reported.[9]

Western Han dynasty

edit

Five Classics

edit

The Five Classics (五經; Wǔjīng) are five pre-Qin texts that became part of the state-sponsored curriculum during the Western Han dynasty, which adopted Confucianism as its official ideology. It was during this period that the texts first began to be considered together as a set collection, and to be called collectively the "Five Classics".[10] Several of the texts were already prominent by the Warring States period, but the literature culture at the time did not lend itself to clear boundaries between works, so a high degree of variance between individual witnesses of the same title was common, as well as considerable intertextuality and cognate chapters between different titles. Mencius, the leading Confucian scholar of the time, regarded the Spring and Autumn Annals as being equally important as the semi-legendary chronicles of earlier periods.

Classic of Poetry
A collection of 305 poems divided into 160 folk songs, 105 festal songs sung at court ceremonies, and 40 hymns and eulogies sung at sacrifices to heroes and ancestral spirits of the royal house.
Book of Documents
A collection of documents and speeches alleged to have been written by rulers and officials of the early Zhou period and before. It is possibly the oldest Chinese narrative, and may date from the 6th century BC. It includes examples of early Chinese prose.
Book of Rites
Describes ancient rites, social forms and court ceremonies. The version studied today is a re-worked version compiled by scholars in the third century BC rather than the original text, which is said to have been edited by Confucius himself.
I Ching
The book contains a divination system comparable to Western geomancy or the West African Ifá system.[citation needed] In Western cultures and modern East Asia, it is still widely used for this purpose.
Spring and Autumn Annals
A historical record of the State of Lu, Confucius's native state, 722–481 BC.

Up to the Western Han, authors would typically list the Classics in the order Poems-Documents-Rituals-Changes-Spring and Autumn. However, from the Eastern Han the default order instead became Changes-Documents-Poems-Rituals-Spring and Autumn.


Han imperial library

edit
 
The Han-era scholar Liu Xiang edited the text of many Chinese classical works such as the Book of Rites, and compiled the Biographies of Exemplary Women.

In 26 BCE, at the command of the emperor, Liu Xiang (77–6 BC[11]) compiled the first catalogue of the imperial library, the Abstracts (別錄; 别录; Bielu), and is the first known editor of the Classic of Mountains and Seas, which was finished by his son.[12] Liu also edited collections of stories and biographies, the Biographies of Exemplary Women.[13] He has long erroneously been credited with compiling the Biographies of the Immortals, a collection of Taoist hagiographies and hymns.[14][better source needed] Liu Xiang was also a poet, being credited with the "Nine Laments" that appears in the Chu Ci.[15]

The works edited and compiled by Liu Xiang include:

This work was continued by his son, Liu Xin, who finally completed the task after his father's death. The transmitted corpus of these classical texts all derives from the versions edited down by Liu Xiang and Liu Xin. Michael Nylan has characterised the scope of the Liu pair's editing as having been so vast that it affects our understanding of China's pre-imperial period to the same degree as the Qin unification does.[29]: 51 

Song dynasty

edit

Four Books

edit
 
Zhu Xi selected the list of four books in the Song dynasty.

The Four Books (四書; Sìshū) are texts illustrating the core value and belief systems in Confucianism. They were selected by Zhu Xi (1130–1200) during the Song dynasty to serve as general introduction to Confucian thought, and they were, in the Ming and Qing dynasties, made the core of the official curriculum for the civil service examinations.[30] They are:

Great Learning
Originally one chapter in the Book of Rites. It consists of a short main text attributed to Confucius and nine commentary chapters by Zengzi, one of the disciples of Confucius. Its importance is illustrated by Zengzi's foreword that this is the gateway of learning. It is significant because it expresses many themes of Chinese philosophy and political thinking, and has therefore been extremely influential both in classical and modern Chinese thought. Government, self-cultivation and investigation of things are linked.
Doctrine of the Mean
Another chapter in Book of Rites, attributed to Confucius's grandson Zisi. The purpose of this small, 33-chapter book is to demonstrate the usefulness of a golden way to gain perfect virtue. It focuses on the Tao that is prescribed by a heavenly mandate not only to the ruler but to everyone. To follow these heavenly instructions by learning and teaching will automatically result in a Confucian virtue of de. Because Heaven has laid down what is the way to perfect virtue, it is not that difficult to follow the steps of the holy rulers of old if one only knows what is the right way.
Analects
Thought to be a compilation of speeches by Confucius and his disciples, as well as the discussions they held.[31] Since Confucius's time, the Analects has heavily influenced the philosophy and moral values of China and later other East Asian countries as well. The imperial examinations, started in the Sui dynasty and eventually abolished with the founding of the Republic of China, emphasized Confucian studies and expected candidates to quote and apply the words of Confucius in their essays.
Mencius
A collection of conversations of the scholar Mencius with kings of his time. In contrast to the sayings of Confucius, which are short and self-contained, the Mencius consists of long dialogues with extensive prose.

Ming dynasty

edit

Thirteen Classics

edit

The official curriculum of the imperial examination system from the Song dynasty onward are the Thirteen Classics. In total, these works total to more than 600,000 characters that must be memorized in order to pass the examination. Moreover, these works are accompanied by extensive commentary and annotation, containing approximately 300 million characters by some estimates.

List of classics

edit

Before 221 BC

edit

It is often difficult or impossible to precisely date pre-Qin works beyond their being "pre-Qin", a period of 1000 years. Information in ancient China was often by oral tradition and passed down from generations before so was rarely written down, so the older the composition of the texts may not be in a chronological order as that which was arranged and presented by their attributed "authors".[32]

The below list is therefore organized in the order which is found in the Siku Quanshu (Complete Library of the Four Treasuries), the encyclopedic collation of the works found in the imperial library of the Qing dynasty under the Qianlong Emperor. The Siku Quanshu classifies all works into 4 top-level branches: the Confucian Classics and their secondary literature; history; philosophy; and poetry. There are sub-categories within each branch, but due to the small number of pre-Qin works in the Classics, History and Poetry branches, the sub-categories are only reproduced for the Philosophy branch.

Classics branch

edit
Title Description
I Ching A manual of divination based on the eight trigrams attributed to the mythical figure Fuxi—by at least the Eastern Zhou, these eight trigrams had been multiplied to create 64 hexagrams.
Book of Documents A collection of documents and speeches allegedly from the Xia, Shang and Western Zhou periods, and even earlier. It contains some of the earliest examples of Chinese prose.
Classic of Poetry Made up of 305 poems divided into 160 folk songs, 74 minor festal songs, traditionally sung at court festivities, 31 major festal songs, sung at more solemn court ceremonies, and 40 hymns and eulogies, sung at sacrifices to gods and ancestral spirits of the royal house. This book is traditionally credited as a compilation edited by Confucius. A standard version, named Maoshi Zhengyi, was compiled in the mid-7th century under the leadership of Kong Yingda.
The Three Rites
Rites of Zhou Conferred the status of a classic in the 12th century, in place of the lost Classic of Music.
Book of Etiquette and Ceremony Describes ancient rites, social forms and court ceremonies.
Classic of Rites Describes social forms, administration, and ceremonial rites.
Spring and Autumn Annals Chronologically the earliest of the annals; comprising about 16,000 characters, it records the events of the state of Lu from 722 to 481 BC, with implied condemnation of usurpations, murder, incest, etc.
Zuo zhuan A different report of the same events as the Spring and Autumn Annals with a few significant differences. It covers a longer period than the Spring and Autumn Annals.
Commentary of Gongyang Another surviving commentary on the same events (see Spring and Autumn Annals).
Commentary of Guliang Another surviving commentary on the same events (see Spring and Autumn Annals).
Classic of Filial Piety A small book giving advice on filial piety; how to behave towards a senior (such as a father, an elder brother, or ruler).
The Four Books
Mencius A book of anecdotes and conversations of Mencius.
Analects A twenty-chapter work of dialogues attributed to Confucius and his disciples; traditionally believed to have been written by Confucius's own circle it is thought to have been set down by later Confucian scholars.
Doctrine of the Mean A chapter from the Book of Rites made into an independent work by Zhu Xi
Great Learning A chapter from the Book of Rites made into an independent work by Zhu Xi
Philology
Erya A dictionary explaining the meaning and interpretation of words in the context of the Confucian Canon.

History branch

edit
Title Description
Bamboo Annals History of Zhou dynasty excavated from a Wei tomb in the Jin dynasty.
Yi Zhou Shu Similar in style to the Book of Documents
Guoyu A collection of historical records of numerous states recorded the period from the Western Zhou to 453 BC.
Strategies of the Warring States Edited by Liu Xiang.
Yanzi chunqiu Attributed to the statesman Yan Ying, a contemporary of Confucius

Philosophy branch

edit

The philosophical typology of individual pre-imperial texts has in every case been applied retroactively, rather than consciously within the text itself.[4] The categorization of works of these genera has been highly contentious, especially in modern times. Many modern scholars reject the continued usefulness of this model as a heuristic for understanding the shape of the intellectual landscape of the time.[5][6][7]

Title Description
Confucianism (excluding Classics branch)
Kongzi Jiayu Collection of stories about Confucius and his disciples. Authenticity disputed.
Xunzi Attributed to Xun Kuang, an ancient Chinese collection of philosophical writings that makes the distinction between what is born in man and what must be learned through rigorous education.
Seven Military Classics
Six Secret Teachings Attributed to Jiang Ziya
The Art of War Attributed to Sunzi.
Wuzi Attributed to Wu Qi.
The Methods of the Sima Attributed to Sima Rangju.
Wei Liaozi Attributed to Wei Liao.
Three Strategies of Huang Shigong Attributed to Jiang Ziya.
Thirty-Six Stratagems Recently recovered.
Legalism
Guanzi Attributed to Guan Zhong.
Deng Xizi[Chinese script needed] Fragment
The Book of Lord Shang Attributed to Shang Yang.
Han Feizi Attributed to Han Fei.
Shenzi Attributed to Shen Buhai. All but one chapter is lost.
Canon of Laws Attributed to Li Kui.
Medicine
Huangdi Neijing
Nan Jing
Miscellaneous
Yuzi[Chinese script needed] Fragment
Mozi Attributed to Mozi.
Yinwenzi[Chinese script needed] Fragment
Shenzi Attributed to Shen Dao. It originally consisted of ten volumes and forty-two chapters, of which all but seven chapters have been lost.
Heguanzi
Gongsun longzi
Guiguzi
Lüshi Chunqiu An encyclopedia of ancient classics edited by Lü Buwei.
Shizi Attributed to Shi Jiao
Mythology
Classic of Mountains and Seas A compilation of early geography descriptions of animals and myths from various locations around China.[33]
Tale of King Mu, Son of Heaven tells the tale of king mu and his quest for immortality and after receiving it sadness over the death of his lover.
Taoism
Tao Te Ching Attributed to Laozi.
Guan Yinzi[Chinese script needed] Fragment
Liezi Attributed to Lie Yukou.
Zhuangzi Attributed to Zhuang Zhou.
Wenzi

Poetry

edit
Title Description
Chu Ci Aside from the Shi Jing (see Classics branch) the only surviving pre-Qin poetry collection[citation needed]. Attributed to the southern state of Chu, and especially Qu Yuan.

After 206 BC

edit

See also

edit

References

edit

Citations

edit
  1. ^ van Voorst, Robert E. (2007). Anthology of World Scriptures. Cengage. p. 140. ISBN 978-0-495-50387-3.
  2. ^ "Confucianism". Encyclopædia Britannica. Retrieved 2023-06-25.
  3. ^ Chan (1972), pp. 105–107.
  4. ^ a b Smith, Kidder (2003). "Sima Tan and the Invention of Daoism, 'Legalism,' et cetera". Journal of Asian Studies. 62 (1). Duke University Press: 129–156. doi:10.2307/3096138. JSTOR 3096138.
  5. ^ a b Csikszentmihalyi & Nylan (2003), pp. 59–99.
  6. ^ a b Meyer (2012), pp. 247–249.
  7. ^ a b Grebnev (2022), pp. 2–3, 254–255.
  8. ^ Nylan (2001), pp. 29–30.
  9. ^ Kern (2010), pp. 111–112.
  10. ^ Nylan, Michael. (Internet Archive Copy) The Five "Confucian" Classics. New Haven: Yale University Press, 2001.
  11. ^ Twitchett & Loewe 1986, p. 192.
  12. ^ E.L. Shaughnessy, Rewriting Early Chinese Texts, pp. 2–3.
  13. ^ Hinsch, Bret (2005). "Reading Lienüzhuan (Biographies of Women) through the life of Liu Xiang". Journal of Asian History. 39 (2). Harrassowitz: 129–157. JSTOR 41933413.
  14. ^ Theobald, Ulrich (24 July 2010), "Liexianzhuan", China Knowledge, Tübingen{{citation}}: CS1 maint: location missing publisher (link).
  15. ^ Hawkes, 280
  16. ^ Riegel 1993, p. 295.
  17. ^ Boltz 1993b, p. 144.
  18. ^ Shaughnessy 1993b, p. 239.
  19. ^ Tsien 1993, p. 1.
  20. ^ Cheng 1993, p. 315.
  21. ^ Loewe 1993b, p. 178.
  22. ^ Thompson 1993, p. 400.
  23. ^ Barrett 1993, p. 299.
  24. ^ Le Blanc 1993, p. 190.
  25. ^ Rickett 1993, p. 246.
  26. ^ Durrant 1993, p. 484.
  27. ^ Knechtges 1993c, p. 443.
  28. ^ Nylan 1993b, p. 155.
  29. ^ Nylan, Michael (2007). ""Empire" in the Classical Era in China (304 BC–AD 316)". Oriens Extremus. 46. Harrassowitz: 48–83. JSTOR 24047664.
  30. ^ Daniel K. Gardner. The Four Books: The Basic Teachings of the Later Confucian Tradition. Indianapolis: Hackett, 2007. ISBN 978-0-872-20826-1.
  31. ^ Hunter, Michael (2017). Confucius Beyond the Analects. Studies in the History of Chinese Texts. Vol. 7. Brill. pp. 4–8. doi:10.1163/9789004339026_002. ISBN 978-9-004-33902-6.
  32. ^ Cambridge History of Ancient China chapter 11
  33. ^ The Classic of Mountains and Seas. Penguin. 2000. ISBN 978-0-140-44719-4.

Sources

edit

Primary sources

edit

Secondary sources

edit
  • Chan, Lois Mai (1972). "The Burning of the Books in China, 213 B.C.". The Journal of Library History. 7 (2): 101–108. ISSN 0022-2259. JSTOR 25540352.
  • Csikszentmihalyi, Mark; Nylan, Michael (2003). "Constructing Lineages and Inventing Traditions Through Exemplary Figures in Early China". T'oung Pao. 89 (1–3). Brill: 59–99. doi:10.1163/156853203322691329. JSTOR 4528923.
  • Fei, Zhangang (2009). "Liu Xiang". Encyclopedia of China. ISBN 978-7-5000-7958-3.
  • Grebnev, Yegor (2022). Mediation of legitimacy in early China: a study of the Yi Zhou shu and the Grand Duke traditions. The Tang Center Series in Early China, Vol. 5. Columbia University Press. pp. 2–3, 254–255. ISBN 9780231555036. LCCN 2021053942.
  • Hawkes, David, ed. (1985). The Songs of the South: An Ancient Chinese Anthology of Poems By Qu Yuan And Other Poets. Penguin. ISBN 978-0-140-44375-2. Retrieved 28 December 2021.
  • Kern, Martin (2010), "Early Chinese Literature: Beginnings through Western Han", in Kang-i Sun Chang; Stephen Owen (eds.), The Cambridge History of Chinese Literature, Cambridge University Press, pp. 1–114, ISBN 9780521855587
  • Twitchett, Denis; Loewe, Michael, eds. (26 December 1986). The Cambridge History of China: Volume 1, The Ch'in and Han Empires, 221 BC-AD 220. Cambridge University Press. ISBN 978-0-521-24327-8. Retrieved 28 December 2021.
  • Loewe, Michael (1993). Early Chinese Texts: A Bibliographical Guide. Society for the Study of Early China. ISBN 978-1-55729-043-4. Retrieved 27 December 2021.
    • Tsien, Tsuen-hsuin (1993). Chan kuo ts'e 戰國策. pp. 1–11.
    • Ch'i-yün Ch'en 陳啟雲 and Margaret Pearson (1993). Ch'ien fu lun 潛夫論. pp. 12–15.
    • Christopher Cullen (1993a). Chiu chang suan shu 九章算術. pp. 16–23.
    • William G. Boltz (1993a). Chou li 周禮. pp. 24–32.
    • Christopher Cullen (1993b). Chou pi suan ching 周髀算經. pp. 33–38.
    • David S. Nivison (1993). Chu shu chi nien 竹書紀年. pp. 39–47.
    • David Hawkes (1993). Ch'u tz'u 楚辭. pp. 48–55.
    • H.D. Roth (1993). Chuang tzu 莊子. pp. 56–66.
    • Anne Cheng 程艾藍 (1993b). Ch'un ch'iu 春秋, Kung yang 公 羊, Ku liang 穀 梁 and Tso chuan 左 傳. pp. 67–76.
    • Steve Davidson; Michael Loewe (1993). Ch'un ch'iu fan lu 春秋繁露. pp. 77–87.
    • John Makeham (1993). Chung lun 中論. pp. 88–93.
    • W. South Coblin (1993). Erh ya 爾雅. pp. 94–99.
    • David R. Knechtges (1993). Fa yen 法言. pp. 100–104.
    • Michael Nylan (1993a). Feng su t'ung i 風俗通義. pp. 105–112.
    • A.F.P. Hulsewé (1993). Han chi 漢記. pp. 113–114.
    • Jean Levi (1993). Han fei tzu 韓非子. pp. 115–124.
    • James R. Hightower (1993). Han shih wai chuan 韓詩外傳. pp. 125–128.
    • A.F.P. Hulsewé (1993). Han shu 漢書. pp. 129–136.
    • David R. Knechtges (1993). Ho kuan tzu 鶡冠子. pp. 137–140.
    • Boltz, William G. (1993b). Hsiao ching 孝經. pp. 141–153.
    • David R. Knechtges (1993). Hsin hsü 新序. pp. 154–157.
    • Timoteus Pokora (1993). Hsin lun 新論. pp. 158–160.
    • Nylan, Michael (1993b). Hsin shu 新書. pp. 161–170.
    • Michael Loewe (1993a). Hsin yü 新語. pp. 171–177.
    • Loewe, Michael (1993b). Hsün tzu 荀子. pp. 178–188.
    • Le Blanc, Charles (1993). Huai nan tzu 淮南子. pp. 189–195.
    • Nathan Sivin (1993). Huang ti nei ching 黃帝內經. pp. 196–215.
    • Edward L. Shaughnessy (1993a). I ching 易經. pp. 216–228.
    • Shaughnessy, Edward L. (1993b). I Chou shu 逸周書. pp. 229–233.
    • William G. Boltz (1993c). I li 儀禮. pp. 234–243.
    • Rickett, W. Allyn (1993). Kuan tzu 管子. pp. 244–251.
    • A.C. Graham (1993). Kung sun Lung tzu 公孫龍子. pp. 252–257.
    • R.P. Kramers (1993). K'ung tzu chia yü 孔子家語. pp. 258–262.
    • Chang I-jen; William G. Boltz; Michael Loewe (1993). Kuo yü 國語. pp. 263–268.
    • William G. Boltz (1993). Lao tzu Tao te ching 老子道德經. pp. 269–292.
    • Riegel, Jeffrey K. (1993). Li chi 禮記. pp. 293–297.
    • Barrett, T.H. (1993). Lieh tzu 列子. pp. 298–308.
    • Timoteus Pokora and Michael Loewe (1993). Lun heng 論衡. pp. 309–312.
    • Cheng, Anne (1993). Lun yü 論語. pp. 313–323.
    • Michael Carson and Michael Loewe (1993). Lü shih ch'un ch'iu 呂氏春秋. pp. 324–330.
    • D.C. Lau 劉殿爵 (1993). Meng tzu 孟子. pp. 331–335.
    • A.C. Graham (1993). Mo tzu 墨子. pp. 336–341.
    • Rémi Mathieu (1993). Mu t'ien tzu chuan 穆天子傳. pp. 342–346.
    • Michael Loewe (1993c). Pai hu t'ung 白虎通. pp. 347–356.
    • Riccardo Fracasso (1993). Shan hai ching 山海經. pp. 357–367.
    • Jean Levi (1993). Shang chün shu 商君書. pp. 368–375.
    • Edward L. Shaughnessy (1993c). Shang shu 尚書 (Shu ching 書經). pp. 376–389.
    • Ch'en Ch'i-yün 陳啟雲 (1993). Shen chien 申鑒. pp. 390–393.
    • Herrlee G. Creel (1993). Shen tzu 申子 (Shen Pu-hai 申不害). pp. 394–398.
    • Thompson, P.M. (1993). Shen tzu 慎子 (Shen Tao 慎到). pp. 399–404.
    • A.F.P. Hulsewé (1993). Shih chi 史記. pp. 405–414.
    • Michael Loewe (1993d). Shih ching 詩經. pp. 415–423.
    • Roy Andrew Miller (1993). Shih ming 釋名. pp. 424–428.
    • William G. Boltz (1993d). Shuo wen chieh tzu 說文解字. pp. 429–442.
    • Knechtges, David R. (1993c). Shuo yüan 說苑. pp. 443–445.
    • Krzysztof Gawlikowski and Michael Loewe (1993). Sun tzu ping fa 孫子兵法. pp. 446–455.
    • Jeffrey K. Riegel (1993b). Ta Tai Li chi 大戴禮記. pp. 456–459.
    • Michael Nylan (1993c). T'ai hsüan ching 太玄經. pp. 460–466.
    • Michael Loewe (1993e). Tu tuan 獨斷. pp. 467–470.
    • Hans Bielenstein and Michael Loewe (1993). Tung kuan Han chi 東觀漢記. pp. 471–472.
    • John Lagerwey (1993). Wu Yüeh ch'un ch'iu 吳越春秋. pp. 473–476.
    • Michael Loewe (1993f). Yen t'ieh lun 鹽鐵論. pp. 477–482.
    • Durrant, Stephen W. (1993). Yen tzu ch'un ch'iu 晏子春秋. pp. 483–489.
    • Axel Schuessler and Michael Loewe (1993). Yüeh chüeh shu 越絕書. pp. 490–494.
  • Mair, Victor H.; Steinhardt, Nancy Shatzman; Goldin, Paul R. (31 January 2005). Hawaii Reader in Traditional Chinese Culture. University of Hawaiʻi Press. ISBN 978-0-8248-2785-4. Retrieved 27 December 2021.
  • Meyer, Dirk (2012). Philosophy on Bamboo: Text and the Production of Meaning in Early China. Studies in the History of Chinese Texts, Vol. 2. Brill. pp. 247–249 et passim. ISBN 978-9-004-20808-7.
  • Neininger, Ulrich (1983), "Burying the Scholars Alive: On the Origin of a Confucian Martyrs' Legend", Nation and Mythology", in Eberhard, Wolfram (ed.), East Asian Civilizations. New Attempts at Understanding Traditions vol. 2, pp. 121–136 Online
  • Nylan, Michael (2001). The Five "Confucian" Classics. Yale University Press. ISBN 978-0-300-08185-5. Retrieved 27 December 2021.
  • Petersen, Jens Østergȧrd (January 1995). "Which Books Did the First Emperor of Ch'in Burn? on the Meaning of Pai Chia in Early Chinese Sources". Monumenta Serica. 43 (1): 1–52. doi:10.1080/02549948.1995.11731268.
  • Endymion Wilkinson. Chinese History: A New Manual. (Cambridge, Massachusetts: Harvard University Asia Center, Harvard-Yenching Institute Monograph Series. New Edition; Second, Revised printing March 2013). ISBN 9780674067158 ISBN 0674067150. See esp. pp. 365– 377, Ch. 28, "The Confucian Classics."
edit
in Traditional Chinese
in Simplified Chinese
in Japanese