Draft:Animal representation in Western medieval art

Animal representation in Western medieval art is diverse in its artistic forms and animals depicted, whether real or imaginary. These medieval representations are influenced by Christianity: they are decorative but above all symbolic. In this period, animals can represent Creation, Good and Evil, God and the Devil. They flourished in churches, on stained glass windows, bas-reliefs, or paving stones, the only learning media for the illiterate who made up the majority of medieval society. Animals were sculpted on church capitals and ivory plaques, painted in manuscript illuminations and church frescoes, as well as in goldsmiths’ and silversmiths’ work, seals, tapestries, and stained-glass windows.

Animals in the Middle Ages

The art of the Middle Ages was mainly religious, reflecting the relationship between God and man, created in His image. The animal often appears confronted or dominated by man, but a second current of thought stemming from Saint Paul and Aristotle, which developed from the 12th century onwards, includes animals and man in the same community of living creatures.

During the Christian era, the Church's commitment to eradicating paganism led to a revival of symbolic art. Representations in Romanesque art reflect the weak link between man and animal at the time. The animal becomes an allegory: the dove, for example, represents peace.

God's creature, the animal, helps man to interpret the world, in a symbolic role, particularly represented in bestiaries. From the 13th century onwards, encyclopedias began to appear, partly due to the translation of Aristotle's works. The animal had its place in these inventories, which gradually shed their moralizations, and some developed practical aspects of animal husbandry.

Animals were an active part of life in the Middle Ages, as evidenced by the depictions of the months in books of hours, as well as tales, fables, and satires, such as the novel of Renart, the novel of Fauvel and the fables of Marie de France.

Religion

The Christian story of animals begins with their creation as described in Genesis. In the first Genesis account, God creates the animals as ornaments of the world before creating man and woman in his own image. The fish of the sea and the birds of the air are made on the fifth day, followed by the beasts of the earth on the sixth day. In the second Genesis account, God destinies the animals to help man. Adam names the animals, establishing his superiority.

Literature

When describing fauna, the medieval man attached more importance to allegory and animal symbolism than to observation. Knowledge was passed on through ancient authors. Around the 12th century, the first taxonomy appeared in English bestiaries, distinguishing between quadrupeds, birds, fish, and reptiles. Then, from the 13th century onwards, notions of science and natural history began to develop. Emperor Frederick II wrote a book with the intention to challenge Aristotle, using observation and experimentation to develop his treatise on falconry, De arte venandi cum avibus.

In bestiary descriptions, the distinction between familiar and wild, common and exotic, real and imaginary animals is not taken into account. The very existence of animals, particularly those that appear in the Bible such as dragons and unicorns, was not called into question until much later: Edward Topsell still includes them in his History of Four-Footed Beasts (1607). What's more, certain animals such as the crocodile may have been familiar to ancient authors, seeing as the Physiologus source of bestiaries was written near Alexandria.

The list of animals known in the Middle Ages includes a number of hybrid beings such as mermaids, centaurs, and the Bonnacon, a bull-headed horse with ram's horns. With the presence of numerous chimeras, animal representations can go beyond named species, as on the northern portal of Rouen Cathedral, where over a hundred creatures do not appear to correspond to a known species.

Society

Representations of animals during the Middle Ages are also seen in hunting books, fables, and seals. Medieval seals were the medium on which many of the animals featured in medieval literature found their place. Birds, fish, mammals, and snakes populated these prints, as did the hybrid creatures mentioned above. Among these seals is that of Jean de Franquerue (12th century), which appears to feature a gargoyle, a man's head leaning against a horse's head and legs and an eagle's head, accompanied by a cinquefoil, on a field of crosses. The seal of Philip III of Burgundy also features two lions supporting the Duke's shield. As we can see from these examples, these figures occupy both a second-order and a first-order position on the object. Thus, it is possible to infer that animal iconography was available and widespread in medieval society. In addition to its symbolic function, it also played a role in identity, the seal being man's image, his personal image, the one that extends, emblematizes, and symbolizes him, the one that is both himself and the double of himself.

Evolution and influences of animal representations during the Middle Ages

Over the course of the Middle Ages, animal representation evolved from codified imagery derived from multiple influences to naturalistic representation, as illustrated by the life sketches made in the Visconti or Frederick II menagerie, such as Villard de Honnecourt's lion.

Most animal descriptions are based on the Physiologus, an ancient bestiary written in Greek in Alexandria in the 2nd or 3rd century, then translated into Latin in the 4th century. The West was also influenced by the Orient and dragons and griffins were grafted onto Western animals. Familiar animals are represented in particular through scenes of peasant life in 15th-century Books of Hours.

From the 9th century onwards, Muslim aniconism was respected for religious spaces, with rare exceptions, particularly Anatolian mosques. Figurative illustrations can be found in secular works, illuminated manuscripts and ceramic art.

Romanesque art

Romanesque artists draw inspiration from ancient pagan motifs, reinterpreting them according to the current thinking of the time. The meaning becomes religious and moral, sometimes resulting in a modification of ancient forms.

In terms of meaning, the mermaid finds herself associated with lust. She retains her former appearance as a mermaid-bird with wings and talons, an image that Isidore of Seville justifies by saying that “love flies and claws”. At the same time, the mermaid-fish motif appeared, the result of assimilation with tritons. It comes in two forms: single-tailed or bifid.

Cistercian art

An early work of Cistercian art, Étienne Harding's Bible consists of a first volume decorated with gilded initials and a second volume featuring rich illuminations. But with Saint Bernard, an austere art form began to emerge. In 1140, he railed against cloister decorations, in particular, the carved bestiary: “But what do these ridiculous monsters, these horrible beauties and these beautiful horrors mean in your cloisters, where the monks do their reading? What's the point, in these places, of these foul apes, these ferocious lions, these chimerical centaurs, these half-human monsters, these variegated tigers, these soldiers who fight, and these hunters who give horn”.

The Statutes of Cîteaux (1150-1152) proclaim: “We forbid the making of sculptures or paintings in our churches or in other places of the monastery, because while one looks, one often neglects the usefulness of a good meditation and the discipline of religious gravity”. Cistercian art was then characterized by pared-down decorations, possibly featuring stylized vegetation. Gold was banned from manuscripts, and a different color could only be used for initials. Before the Gothic explosion, figuration gradually made a comeback, as in the modillions of Flaran Abbey, the decorations of Silvacane, and the cloister of Valmagne Abbey. Henri Focillon wrote that “the Cistercians expelled from religious art what remained of pomp and mystery”.

Posterity

An early Renaissance painter, Hieronymus Bosch used animals and fantasy creatures in some of his works, particularly in The Garden of Delights. The artist used animals to criticize the society in which he lived.

Animal symbology

Lion, king of the animals

In the Middle Ages, the lion's title as king of the beasts came from both the Bible and Greco-Roman heritage, as evidenced by scriptures, fables, encyclopedias, and bestiaries. The lion is usually identified by its tail and mane, and it is sometimes crowned as king. The lion is associated with medieval royalty through Richard I of England's nickname of Richard the Lionheart.

In the Old Testament, the lion is confronted by man on three occasions: killed with his bare hands by Samson, when a swarm of bees settles in his corpse; struck down by David to protect his father's sheep; and in the scene from Daniel in the lion's den.

Samson's fight against the lion is interpreted as Christ's victory over Satan. It is a scene often depicted in the Middle Ages, for example on church tympanums in bas-relief, carved on capitals, in illuminated manuscripts, or on the enameled altarpiece by Nicolas de Verdun created for Klosterneuburg Abbey. The scene of Samson gathering honey from the mouth of the dead lion appears on the Wiligelm-style carved doorframe of the Abbey of Nonantola, the lion thus becoming a Christ-like symbol.

The scene of David as a young shepherd features either a lion or a bear. The version with the lion appears, for example, on the Begon lantern in the treasury of the Abbey of Conques and is one of the fourteen full-page illustrations in the Psaultier de Paris, a 9th-century Byzantine manuscript.

Daniel in the lion's den, sometimes simply entitled “Daniel among the lions”, is a frequently depicted scene. It appears on a 6th-century Visigoth capital in the church of San Pedro de la Nave, in numerous Romanesque churches, and on the portal of the church of Saint-Trophime in Arles.

The image of the lion can become more negative, as illustrated by Psalm 22, verse 22, “Save me from the lion's mouth”, and we find sculptures of lions devouring men, as on the portal of the Cathedral of Sainte-Marie in Oloron. Another negative connotation is associated with a passage from Peter referring to Satan who roams like a lion seeking prey to devour. Psalm 91, verse 13, “You shall tread on the asp and the basilisk; you shall trample on the young lion and the dragon”, is the origin of the figure of Christ walking on animals, as on the Genoelselderen diptych or the Christ blessing on the portal of Amiens Cathedral.

In the Physiologos, and later in bestiaries, it is asserted that the lion can sleep with its eyes open, which gave the lion a guardian role, embodied by its presence at the entrance to churches and halls, as on the trumeau of the abbey of Saint-Pierre de Moissac. Illuminated manuscripts depict the lion according to the three fundamental characteristics given in the Physiologos: he stands at the top of the mountains, his eyes are open even when he sleeps, and he brings his dead-born cubs back to life after they have spent three days in limbo. This last characteristic associates him with resurrection: he therefore is also interpreted as having a role in protecting men in death and is said to be found at the feet of those who lie dead.

The lion is also depicted through the positive images of Saint Jerome and his lion, and the tetramorph (Saint Mark's lion). The winged lion is highly represented in Venice: it is the city's symbol, and legend has it that the city is responsible for guarding the remains of Saint Mark. The lion is often seen in Catholic churches, representing the strength of the believer in the fight against sin, and in objects such as lion's paw bracelets, episcopal seats carved with the effigy of a lion, candlestick bases, and church portals.

• Daniel dans la fosse aux lions Bois sculpté polychrome, Cathédrale Saint-Sauveur à Bruges, 10th century.
  Daniel dans la fosse aux lions Bois sculpté polychrome, Cathédrale Saint-Sauveur à Bruges, 10th century.
• Les représentations de l'art roman sont toujours effrayantes et étranges. Sculpture de Maître de Cabestany dans la cathédrale de Prato en Italie.
  Les représentations de l'art roman sont toujours effrayantes et étranges. Sculpture de Maître de Cabestany dans la cathédrale de Prato en Italie.
• Les quatre figures du tétramorphe Fresque gothique de l'Abbaye de Viboldone en Italie
  Les quatre figures du tétramorphe Fresque gothique de l'Abbaye de Viboldone en Italie
• Aquamanile en forme de Lion (1250-1300)
  Aquamanile en forme de Lion (1250-1300)

Stag, enemy of the serpent

The stag was reputed to kill snakes, which made it start to be seen as a Christ-like animal. Furthermore, its antlers, which fall and grow back each year, made it become associated with resurrection. During the Middle Ages, deer hunting became seen as the noble hunt, as bear hunting fell into decline.

Bear, the fallen king

The bear was celebrated and venerated in Antiquity and the High Middle Ages, mostly by the Celts and Germanic-Scandinavians: Christian authorities therefore endeavored to combat these animistic cults by changing the symbolism of the bear, which went from being king of the animals to becoming seen as a clumsy, silly, tame beast during the 12th century. This phenomenon took the form of physical combat against the animal and festivals dedicated to it, but also through hagiography and representations. Indeed, hagiography abounds with examples of saints taming bears, such as Saint Blaise, Saint Columban, and Saint Gall. All of them had the function of combating pagan bear cults. At the same time, according to Michel Pastoureau, many medieval theologians drew inspiration from Saint Augustine and Pliny the Elder to paint a diabolical portrait of the bear. Thus associated with the Devil, the bear became his favorite animal or one of his forms. In Christian iconography, the Devil often has the feet, muzzle, and coat of a bear. The bear's hairy appearance and brown color became a sign of diabolical bestiality, and the animal was attributed capital sins.

Unicorn

Representations

The first unicorns in medieval bestiaries rarely resembled a white horse, but rather a goat, a sheep, a doe, a dog, a bear, or a snake. They came in a variety of colors, including blue, brown, and ochre, before the white color and twisted shape of the horn became widespread. Often confused with the rhinoceros, descriptions of the two began to merge as early as Pliny the Elder, who described the unicorn as existing in two varieties: one, very discreet, resembling an antelope or a goat with a single horn on the forehead, the other a huge, uncapturable animal with a very tough skin. The generalization of its caprine and equine form and white color is the result of the symbolism and allegories attributed to it.

In the late 12th and early 13th centuries, the unicorn became a popular theme in bestiaries and tapestries in the Christian West, and to a lesser extent in sculptures. Two series of tapestries featuring unicorns can be mentioned here: La Chasse à la licorne and The Lady and the Unicorn.

La Chasse à la licorne is a famous series of seven tapestries executed between 1495 and 1505, depicting a group of noblemen pursuing and capturing a unicorn. This series, probably executed for a French patron (perhaps to mark a large wedding) by the Brussels or Liège workshops, subsequently came into the possession of the La Rochefoucauld family, before being purchased by John D. Rockefeller, who donated it to the Metropolitan Museum of Art, where it remains today.

The Lady and the Unicorn is a series of six tapestries dating from the late 15th century and exhibited at the Musée de Cluny in Paris. In each tapestry, a lion and a unicorn are depicted to the right and left of a lady. Five of these representations illustrate a meaning and the sixth tapestry, on which the formula “Mon seul désir” (My only desire) can be read on a tent, is more debated by specialists.

Symbolism

There are hundreds, if not thousands, of miniatures of unicorns with the same staging inspired by the Physiologos: the beast is seduced by a treacherous virgin and a hunter pierces its flank with a spear. The “capture of the unicorn” seems to stem from the culture of courtly love, linked to respect for women, leisure pursuits, music, and poetry, and all these illustrations are Christian-inspired, the unicorn representing betrayal of Christ, its flank pierced by a spear as in the biblical episode of the Passion of Jesus Christ. According to Francesca Yvonne Caroutch, the unicorn represents the divine beast whose horn captures cosmic energy and impregnates the Virgin Mary in the numerous “Annunciations to the Unicorn ”.

According to the Dictionary of Symbols, works of art depicting two unicorns confronting each other represent a violent inner conflict between the unicorn's two values: virginity and fecundity. From the 15th century onwards, wild men and women became frequent in iconography and the unicorn was associated with wild beasts, sometimes ridden by Silvani, although only a virgin could ride it. This idea that the unicorn can only live apart from men, in a wild state and in a remote forest from which it cannot be torn, in which case it would die of sadness, was taken up by other authors much later, among which Carl Gustav Jung.

Dragon, king of serpents

Issued from Celtic and Asian traditions, the dragon starts appearing in early Christian art. They can be found in Byzantine art, Slav icons, gargoyles, and illuminated manuscripts.

The medieval dragon is depicted as an evil, hideous monster always associated with evil. In Latin, draco means both dragon and serpent; the dragon is linked to the serpent and in particular to the tempter of Genesis, who drove Adam and Eve to taste the forbidden fruit. Medieval encyclopedias therefore classify it as a serpent.

The dragon is depicted in a variety of forms, most often with two clawed legs, a long reptilian tail, and sometimes wings, or even several heads.

In the Apocalypse, Saint Michael and his angels fight the dragon. It is brought down by many saints in battles that symbolize the triumph of Good over Evil, or even the victory of Christianity over paganism. In some versions of Saint George and the Dragon, for example, the saint agrees to kill the monster only if the villagers are baptized. In the legend of Saint Margaret of Antioch, the dragon that swallows the saint and from which she emerges intact thanks to a cross is the Devil. Marthe de Béthanie uses holy water to subdue a dragon, the tarasque, a six-legged dragon which, according to the golden legend, gives its name to the town of Tarascon.

Horse

Horses were part of everyday life in the Middle Ages. It was the attribute of knights and was the subject of a specific vocabulary: palfrey, destrier, or rouncey designate different types of horse for different uses. Legendary horses such as Pegasus have populated tales and legends since Antiquity. In the Middle Ages, chanson de geste heroes rode palfreys or fairy horses such as Bayard to serve courtly love.