Eileen Bransten (December 11, 1942 – April 26, 2022) was an American judge who served in New York's state courts for nearly 25 years, including from 2008 to 2018 in Manhattan's Commercial Division, its specialized business court. She was the daughter of author Ruth McKenney and writer and editor Richard Bransten.
Eileen Bransten | |
|---|---|
| Justice, New York Supreme Court, Manhattan | |
| In office 1996–2018 | |
| Judge, New York Civil Court | |
| In office 1994–1999 | |
| Personal details | |
| Born | December 11, 1942 |
| Died | April 26, 2022 (aged 79) New York |
| Parent(s) | Ruth McKenney, Richard Bransten |
| Education | Hunter College (summa cum laude 1975), Fordham School of Law (1979) |
Early life and education
editBransten was the daughter of author Ruth McKenney and writer and editor Richard Bransten, and the niece of Eileen McKenney (an executive assistant to Walt Disney) and her husband, author Nathaniel West. Bransten was born on December 11, 1942, two years after her aunt and uncle died in an automobile accident. McKenney actively discouraged Bransten from attending college, believing that Bransten could learn all she needed to know by reading books. Bransten ultimately attended Hunter College at age 28, graduating summa cum laude in 1975, and received her law degree from Fordham University Law School in 1979.[1][2][3][4]
Bransten had a wide range of experience before attending college, often involving politics. From 1965 to 1969, she directed research for political campaigns, and in 1967 served as a senior research analyst for the Style and Arrangement Committee of the New York State Constitutional Convention. From 1970 to 1973, she was director of research and public relations for the New York State Senate Minority and also did research and writing for the Criminal Justice Coordinating Council of the New York City Mayor's Office. In 1967 and 1968 she was also a correspondent for the New York Law Journal.[5][6]
Legal career
editFrom 1979 to 1984, Bransten served in the Queens County District Attorney’s Office, and after that was in the private practice of law as a solo practitioner for seven years.[1] In 1992, she became the Principal Court Attorney and Law Secretary to Supreme Court Justice Jacqueline W. Silbermann, who was also Administrative Judge of the Civil Court of the City of New York (the New York Civil Court).[1]
Judicial Service
editIn 1993, Bransten was elected to the New York Civil Court, and began serving in 1994. She was appointed an acting trial level New York State Supreme Court justice in 1996, where she presided over a General Trial and then a Matrimonial Part.[1][7]
In November 1999, Bransten was elected to the New York Supreme Court in Manhattan. She spent seven years presiding over a Medical Malpractice Part within the Supreme Court, from 2001 until 2008.[8][1][9]
In March 2008, Bransten was assigned to the Commercial Division, and served there until her retirement in 2018.[7][9] The New York Supreme Court's Commercial Division is a specialized business court docket within that court, with a jurisdiction limited to disputes of a business and commercial nature. In Manhattan's Commercial Division,[10] the amount in controversy must exceed $500,000 for a case to be heard in that court. Commercial Division judges preside over an assigned case from beginning to end. "The caseload of the Division is ... very demanding, requiring of the court scholarship in commercial law, experience in the management of complex cases, and a wealth of energy."[11][12]
In 2014, Bransten was a founder of Fordham Law School's Institute on Complex Commercial Litigation, which was designed to train Commercial Division and appellate judges on issues related to commercial litigation. Fordham has described Bransten as the institute's "leader and greatest supporter".[13] In 2023, Fordham Law School renamed the institute, the Eileen Bransten Institute on Complex Commercial Litigation.[14][15]
New York Supreme Court Appellate Division justice (and former Commercial Division justice) Saliann Scarpulla once served as Bransten's principal court attorney, and New York Commercial Division justice Jennifer G. Schechter once served as Bransten's law clerk.[14]
Hundreds of Bransten's written legal opinions as a judge have been published.[1] Some of the notable cases over which Bransten presided include: the child custody dispute involving Revlon billionaire Ronald O. Perelman;[2] fraud claims against Countrywide Financial and Bank of America arising out of the mortgage backed securities crisis of the mid-2000s;[16] challenges to largest ever (at the time) arbitration awards involving securities futures;[17] a lawsuit involving Hexion Specialty Chemicals financing of its takeover bid for the Huntsman Corporation;[18] a dispute over the application of a New York State sales tax law on Amazon;[19] a suit by professional golfer Vijay Singh against the PGA Tour;[20] an investor suit against Outcome Health and its principals Rishi Shah and Shradha Agarwal;[21] litigation over the restructuring of paper maker Norske Skogindustrier ASA;[22] and a suit by Norex Petroleum Ltd. against Leonard Blavatnik and Victor Vekselberg over control of a Siberian oil field.[23]
In 2018, Bransten read aloud her 40-page legal opinion, in a case involving art looted by the Nazis, saying, among other things: "'New York is not and shall not become a safe harbour for [art pillaged] during Nazi genocide....'"[24][25]
Personal life after retirement
editBransten and her husband volunteered at the Blessed Sacrament Soup Kitchen for decades.[1] Bransten died in April 2022.[7]
Positions and honors
editBransten held the following positions or received the following honors, among others;
- Fordham Law School renamed its Institute on Complex Commercial Litigation, the Eileen Bransten Institute on Complex Commercial Litigation (2023)[15]
- New York Chief Judge Jonathan Lippman appointed Bransten to serve on the Commercial Division Advisory Council (2013)[1]
- President of the Association of the Supreme Court Justices of the State of New York (2012)[1]
- Co-president of Judges and Lawyers Breast Cancer Alert (2006 to 2008), and member of its Board of Directors[1]
- Presiding Member of the New York State Bar Association's Judicial Section (2008)[1]
- Inducted into the Hunter College Alumni Hall of Fame (2000)[1]
- Member of the New York City Bar Association’s Council on Judicial Administration[1]
- Officer of the New York State Supreme Court Board of Justices[1]
- Member, Board of Directors of Fordham University Law School[1]
References
edit- ^ a b c d e f g h i j k l m n o "Biography of Justice Eileen Bransten, Commercial Division - New York Supreme Court" (PDF).
- ^ a b Rothstein, Mervyn (December 21, 2003). "'Sister Eileen' to Daughter, Eileen, a State Judge". New York Times.
- ^ Lippman, Laura (March 15, 2018). "In Praise of Ruth McKenney". New York Times.
- ^ "The Honorable Eileen Bransten Simpson".
- ^ "Eileen Bransten". Ballotpedia. Retrieved 2024-09-03.
- ^ "PUBLICITY POSTS GROW IN ALBANY". New York Times. February 2, 1973.
- ^ a b c Grant, Jason (April 28, 2022). "Former Manhattan Commercial Division Justice Eileen Bransten, Known for Cutting Through Complex Issues, Dies at 79". New York Law Journal. Retrieved 2024-09-03.
- ^ "Eileen C. Bransten, New York State Board of Elections".
- ^ a b "Hon. Eileen Bransten, Biography, New York State Supreme Court Commercial Division". www.pli.edu. Retrieved 2024-09-03.
- ^ "Commercial Division - New York County/Manhattan, New York State Unified Court System".
- ^ "History, Commercial Division - New York Supreme Court, New York State Unified Court System".
- ^ "PART 202. Uniform Civil Rules For The Supreme Court And The County Court | NYCOURTS.GOV". ww2.nycourts.gov. Archived from the original on 2019-03-11. Retrieved 2019-03-02.
- ^ "Join the NY Commercial Division for a Tribute to Hon. Eileen Bransten '79 and Reception". go.activecalendar.com. Retrieved 2024-09-03.
- ^ a b Rizvic, Sejla (2023-11-15). "Judge Eileen Bransten '79 Celebrated for Her Landmark Contributions to the New York State Judiciary". Fordham Law News. Retrieved 2024-09-03.
- ^ a b Degregario, Erin (2023-11-16). "Judicial Center Welcomes Commercial Division Judges for 5th Annual View from Chambers Series". Fordham Law News. Retrieved 2024-09-03.
- ^ "Setback for Bank of America in a Lawsuit Filed by MBIA". New York Times. January 3, 2012.
- ^ Norris, Floyd (August 15, 2002). "Multimillion-Dollar Awards Are Allowed in Futures Case". New York Times.
- ^ "Hexion Granted Quick Trial in Acquisition Suit". November 3, 2008.
- ^ Morgan, Timothy Prickett (January 12, 2009). "New York judge OKs Amazon Tax".
- ^ Mohler, Brendan (June 30, 2014). "Judge Limits Singh's Search In Tour Suit". Golf World. 68 (2).
- ^ "Investors Sue Outcome Health, Alleging Investment Fraud". India-West. December 8, 2017. pp. A18.
- ^ Bakewell, Sally (February 3, 2016). "Norske Skog Extends Blackstone-Backed Debt Swap After Law Suit". Bloomberg.com.
- ^ Dolmetsch, Chris (January 17, 2015). "Norex petroleum wins reinstatement of blavatnik suit". Bloomberg.com.
- ^ "Holocaust act offers hope to claimants in restitution cases". The Art Newspaper. 301: 52. May 2018.
- ^ P.C., Farrell Fritz (2018-05-24). "Action to Recover Amadeo Modigliani Painting Stolen by Nazis Survives Dismissal Due in Part to Alter Ego Finding". New York Commercial Division Practice. Retrieved 2024-09-03.