File talk:Christopher Cox.ogg
Latest comment: 16 years ago by Hassocks5489 in topic Spoken article quality assessment
Spoken article quality assessment
editVersion reviewed: As at 25 July 2008
Technical quality: High/Medium
- Standard introduction and licence details are present and correct.
- Voice is clear and does not suffer from any editing artifacts (such as excessive noise reduction).
- There is background noise, but it is at a constant low level and does not affect the clarity of the voice. Two seconds of slightly louder buzzing at approximately 04:59 (at the line "With U.S. Rep. Barney Frank...").
- Occasional mouse button clicks.
Clarity: High/Medium
- Fairly clear enunciation.
- Pacing is generally good, although longer sentences often have relatively large silent gaps between clauses—especially after commas in the text. A good example is the sentence starting "He was Chairman of the House Committee on Homeland Security..." (03:27), which has a stop-start flow. This does not affect the listener's understanding of the article, though.
- Good use of intonation and emphasis to convey the sense of the text.
Accuracy: High/Medium
- Link to the historical version correctly provided on the upload page.
- All section headings and subheadings are provided correctly.
- Very little hesitation and no mid-narration corrections.
- Some minor variations from the text, none of which compromise the meaning:
- "...leading state-controlled newspaper" read as "...leading state-controlled newspapers".
- "...recommending wholesale modernization" read as "...recommended wholesale modernization".
- "...the only law that was enacted" read as "...the only law that was ever enacted".
- "...fraudulent and extortionate lawsuits" has a choppy edit and is read as "extraordinate lawsuits".
Notes: {{{notes}}}
Help with recording issues can be obtained under "Recording assistance" here.
Information on the assessment procedure can be found on the spoken article assessment page.
Reviewed by: Hassocks5489 (tickets please!) 21:42, 4 August 2008 (UTC)
A good-quality narration which supplements the article well. Many thanks!