Four Faultless Felons is a collection of stories by G. K. Chesterton, comprising four mystery novelettes connected by the theme of persons assumed to be criminals, who are paradoxically not so. The stories originally appeared individually, serialized in Cassell's Magazine and Storyteller.[1]
Published in 1930 in London by Cassell and in New York by Dodd, Mead & Co., it was the final collection of mystery stories that appeared during Chesterton's lifetime.
Plot
editThe Moderate Murderer
editMr. Hume confesses to the attempted murder of Lord Tallboys.
The Honest Quack
editConcerning Dr. Judson and an alleged fraud.
The Ecstatic Thief
editA thief is caught breaking into the Nadaway family safe.
The Loyal Traitor
editPortents of revolution stir in the land of Pavonia.
Critical Reception
editThe novel was critically well-received upon its publication, with praise for Chesterton's wit, unique creative style and profound themes, intermixed with an unusual approach to detective fiction.[2] [3][4][5][6][7][8][9][10]
Critic Ralph Straus in The Sunday Times called it an "exhilarating" book, though not quite Chesterton's best.[11] The Yorkshire Post meanwhile compared the novel to the Father Brown stories, but longed for a similar grounding force in the narrative.[12]
Though the majority of reviews were positive, some criticized the collection. Cecil Roberts found the stories entertaining, though confusing with weak denouements.[13] The Northern Whig and Belfast Post felt let down by plot inconsistencies.[14] Truth claimed the novel bordered on self-parody, as it was similar in style to other Chesterton works but less inventive.[15] Gerald Gould in The Observer provided a negative view, objecting to the "trick" of Chesterton's paradoxical plots.[16]
The novel was reprinted in 1962 by Darwen Finlayson, a "recommended reprint" by The Guardian's Richard West[17]
More recently, scholar Ian Boyd described Four Faultless Felons as a blend of The Club of Queer Trades and The Man Who Was Thursday. Its protagonists were very similar to other Chesterton characters, Boyd observed, "artist-poets whose apparent madness is the true norm of sanity." Political and social issues reflected in the text did not cohere into a clear perspective, and Catholicism and Distributism, major through-lines of Chesterton's thought, were not clearly represented, though the novel's reflection on post-war society was filled with Chesterton's preoccupations at the time. Themes included parables of modern imperialism and social revolution, yet lacked specific calls to action. Boyd considered the work to be extremely well constructed, albeit ultimately without a true thematic unity.[18]
Chesterton expert Dale Ahlquist, on the other hand, found great profundity in the stories, comparing them to Manalive and The Club of Queer Trades. "Lovely little mysteries with a twist...he has sewn an intricate tapestry with the minimum number of stitches."[19]
References
edit- ^ Tibbetts, John C. (2021). The Dark Side of G.K. Chesterton: Gargoyles and Grotesques. McFarland. p. 79.
- ^ "Four Faultless Felons". Country Life. 23 August 1930.
- ^ "The Books You Read". The Graphic. 13 September 1930.
- ^ "Jolly Criminals". Western Morning News and Mercury. 1 September 1930.
- ^ "G. K. C.'s 'Four Faultless Felons'". Evening Sentinel. 28 August 1930.
- ^ "Bogus Crime". Liverpool Post and Mercury. 17 September 1930.
- ^ Straus, Ralph (27 August 1930). "Crimes, Clues and Mr. Chesterton". The Bystander.
- ^ "Notes on New Books". Daily News and Chronicle. 13 June 1930.
- ^ "The Books You Read". The Graphic. 13 September 1930.
- ^ "New Novels". The Times. 22 August 1930.
- ^ Straus, Ralph (24 August 1930). "New Fiction: Mr. Chesterton's 'Crooks'". The Sunday Times.
- ^ "G. K. Chesterton". The Yorkshire Post. 27 August 1930.
- ^ Roberts, Cecil (30 August 1930). "What Mr. Rumpus and Mr. Jumpus have Said and How Much it Matters". The Sphere.
- ^ "The Back of the Moon". Northern Whig and Belfast Post. 30 August 1930.
- ^ "Innocent Crime". Truth. 10 September 1930.
- ^ Gould, Gerald (24 August 1930). "New Novels: The Glooms and the Gleams". The Observer.
- ^ West, Richard (4 May 1962). "Inside Dope". The Guardian.
- ^ Boyd, Ian (1975). The novels of G. K. Chesterton : a study in art and propaganda. Harper & Row. pp. 155–190.
- ^ Ahlquist, Dale. "Lecture 59: Four Faultless Felons". The Society of G. K. Chesterton. Retrieved 16 November 2024.