Health in North Korea

North Korea has a life expectancy of 74 years as of 2022. While North Korea is classified as a low-income country, the structure of North Korea's causes of death (2013) is unlike that of other low-income countries. Rather, causes of death are closer to the worldwide averages, with non-communicable diseases – such as cardiovascular disease – accounting for two-thirds of the total deaths.

Staff at Pyongyang Maternity Hospital (2008)

North Korea claims to provide universal health care with a national medical service and health insurance system. It also claims that health services are offered for free. However, this claim has been contested by North Korean defectors, who assert that patients must in fact pay for health services, that the upper classes have access to a higher standard of healthcare, and that "how much money a patient has determined whether they live or die".

Overview

In 1946, free, but not universal, healthcare was mandated by North Korea's Social Insurance Law. Beginning in the 1950s, North Korea put great emphasis on healthcare. In 1952 basic universal healthcare was started, and between 1955 and 1986, the number of hospitals grew from 285 to 2,401, and the number of clinics from 1,020 to 5,644.

Most hospitals that exist today in the DPRK were built in the 1960s and 1970s. During the rule of Kim Il Sung, effective mandatory health checkups and immunization programs were initiated. The country could support a large corps of doctors due to their low salaries. The number of doctors remains high, though there is a shortage of nurses, meaning that doctors often have to perform routine procedures. The medical infrastructure is fairly effective in preventive medicine, but less so in terms of treating the more demanding conditions. Since 1979, more emphasis has been put on traditional Korean medicine, based on treatment with herbs and acupuncture. A national telemedicine network was launched in 2010 that connects Kim Man-yu Hospital in Pyongyang with 10 provincial medical facilities.

North Korea's healthcare system suffered a steep decline since the 1990s because of natural disasters, economic problems, and food and energy shortages. In 2001, North Korea spent 3% of its gross domestic product (GDP) on health care, but during that same year, many hospitals and clinics in North Korea lacked essential medications, equipment, and running water due to the international sanctions against North Korea. Electricity shortages remain the biggest problem. Even when sophisticated equipment is available, it is useless without electricity. Some facilities have generators available to meet demand during power outages.

In 2020 the construction of a new central Pyongyang hospital started, the Pyongyang General Hospital, in front of the Monument to Party Founding. This is part of a programme of healthcare system improvement.

Health status

Development of life expectancy in North Korea and South Korea

Development of child mortality in North Korea since 1960

In 2010, Amnesty International and the World Health Organization made wildly varying claims on the state of the North Korean healthcare system. Amnesty International, citing interviews with 40 North Korean defectors and foreign healthcare workers, painted a grim picture of the North Korean healthcare system as one with "barely functioning hospitals." It described hospitals that operate without heating or electricity and shortages of medicines and medical equipment. It also challenged the claims that healthcare was free, claiming that according to interviews with defectors healthcare had not been free since the 1990s. The World Health Organization (WHO) criticized the Amnesty International report as outdated and factually inaccurate, describing the healthcare system as "the envy of the developing world" while acknowledging that "challenges remained, including poor infrastructure, a lack of equipment, malnutrition and a shortage of medicines." The World Health Organization claimed that the report was based on a small sample of people who had left North Korea, some as far back as 2001, and did not reflect present conditions, particularly after recent improvements in the system due to a program funded by South Korea and aided by the WHO. Commenting on the reports, a BBC reporter said that UN agencies with aid projects in North Korea are typically reluctant to openly criticize the country for fear of jeopardizing their work there. Special health care is available mainly in cities, where pharmacies are also common. Essential medicines are also well available. There are hospitals attached to factories and mines.

In a 2020 article, a North Korean defector who left the country in 2018 claimed that the healthcare system in North Korea caters to the upper classes, who get free care in the country's best medical facilities, while everyone else must pay for care in substandard hospitals. According to him, healthcare coverage was better during the reign of Kim Il Sung, with free hospital treatment available in the 1970s and 1980s, but patients must now pay doctors for their services and must also pay for the medicine and medical equipment used to treat them due to shortages, writing that "average North Koreans see their lives as left to fate. They no longer expect anything from the government in terms of health care." He described hospitals lacking electricity and heating, doctors conducting surgeries by battery-powered flashlights, and wealthier patients paying for firewood or using self-made heaters by burning wood inside steel plates or a drum to heat their rooms. He claimed that it was not unusual for patients to endure surgery without anesthetic to save money. Describing a personal case where he and his wife needed surgery, he claimed that they had to buy "everything from cotton and dressing to anesthetic (novocaine) and antibiotics (penicillin)", pay the surgeon, and treat the rest of the staff to a meal at a privately-run restaurant. He wrote that "How much money a patient has determines whether they live or die." Commenting on accessibility, he claimed that "only the top 1 percent actually enjoys free healthcare. Maybe 20% can afford to pay a doctor. The rest wouldn't even dare to think of going to visit a doctor."

A study based on interviews with respondent-driven sampled defectors living in South Korea found that 65.4% of respondents paid out-of-pocket for medicines 82% for medical supplies and 75.9% for other items such as "meals or heating when in health facilities."

A 2013 study stated that the largest obstacle to understanding the accurate health status of North Korea is the lack of validity and reliability of its health data.

Life expectancy

North Korea has a life expectancy of 74 years (as of 2022). The 2009 gender breakdown was 72.8 years of life expectancy for females and 64.9 for males.

Period	Life expectancy in Years	Period	Life expectancy in Years
1950–1955	37.6	1985–1990	68.6
1955–1960	49.9	1990–1995	70.0
1960–1965	51.6	1995–2000	63.5
1965–1970	57.2	2000–2005	68.1
1970–1975	61.7	2005–2010	68.4
1975–1980	65.0	2010–2015	70.8
1980–1985	67.1

Source: UN World Population Prospects

Malnutrition

See also: North Korean famine

During the 1990s, North Korea was ravaged by famine, causing the death of between 500,000 and 3,000,000 people. Food shortages are ongoing today, with factors such as bad weather, lack of fertiliser, and a drop in international donation meaning that North Koreans do not have enough to eat. A study of North Koreans in 2008 found that three-quarters of respondents had reduced their food intake. Extreme poverty is also a factor in the hunger faced by North Korean people, with 27% of the population living at or below the absolute poverty line of less than US$1 a day.

These food shortages cause a number of malnutrition diseases. A 2009 UNICEF report found that North Korea was "one of 18 countries with the highest prevalence of stunting (moderate and severe) among children under 5 years old". A survey in 2017 found that less than 20% of North Korean children were stunted, a decrease from 32% in 2009.

Sanitation

A survey conducted in 2017 found that most people had access to a toilet, but that 93% of sanitation facilities were not connected to a sewage system. Rather, the human waste was used as fertilizer on fields, creating the potential health risk of spreading intestinal worms. The survey also found that a quarter of people ingested contaminated drinking water.

Ophthalmology

In 2006, Professor Gerd Auffarth of Heidelberg University Eye Hospital in Germany was permitted to visit the country. He is one of the few Western surgeons to have carried out eye surgery in North Korea. Before he arrived in Pyongyang, he was authorized to do just five surgeries but once he reached the University Hospital, he found that he could do seventeen: one perforating keratoplasty using donor tissue he had brought from Germany, three scleral-fixated secondary IOL implantations, and thirteen phacoemulsification procedures with IOL implants. All the procedures were conducted with topical anesthesia which had been brought with him from Germany. He reported on his experiences in 2011 in a video entitled, Ophthalmology Behind the Iron Curtain: Cataract Surgery in North Korea, saying that the economic conditions have led to improvisations – especially because of the absence of consumable medical devices but he commented that once a visiting surgeon adapts to these unique surroundings, he found that teaching and clinical work could be very effective and satisfying for both surgeon and patient. As a consequence of this visit, in 2007 two young North Korean ophthalmic surgeons were permitted to visit Heidelberg and remain for six months, gaining extensive training in cataract surgery.

Another foreign ophthalmologist to visit North Korea to do surgery is Sanduk Ruit from Nepal. The Nepalese Tilganga Institute of Ophthalmology trains North Korean practitioners of ophthalmology.

Non-communicable diseases

Further information: Smoking in North Korea

Non-communicable diseases (NCD) risk factors in North Korea include high rates of urbanization, an aging society, and high rates of smoking and alcohol consumption amongst men.

Cardiovascular disease as a single disease group is the largest cause of death in North Korea (2013). The three major causes of death in DPR Korea are ischaemic heart disease (13%), lower respiratory infections (11%) and cerebrovascular disease (7%).

Approximately 54.8% of all North Korean adult males smoke an average of fifteen cigarettes per day. Smoking prevalence is slightly higher amongst the urban worker population than the farming population. Amongst men, a high rate of excessive alcohol consumption has been reported, defined by the World Health Organization as consumption of more than one bottle, per sitting, per person (26.3% of males).

The North Korean government has prioritized the prevention of NCDs in their National Strategic Plan for the Prevention and Control of Noncommunicable Diseases 2014-2020 and in 2005 ratified the WHO Framework Convention on Tobacco Control. As of 2022, it prioritized the prevention of diabetes.

Oral health

A dental clinic at Pyongyang Maternity Hospital (photo taken from South Korean hospital website)

In the past, North Koreans had few problems with dental health because their diet included little sugar. Since the 2000s, sugar has been introduced to diets in the form of confectionery and sweet snacks, especially in urban areas. Toothpaste is not regularly used.

Infectious diseases

In 2003, infectious diseases, such as tuberculosis, malaria, and hepatitis B, were described as endemic to North Korea. An estimated 4.5% of North Koreans had hepatitis B in 2003.

In 2009, the flu pandemic in Asia affected the country.

Further information: 2009 flu pandemic in Asia

In 2010, Amnesty International reported that North Korea was experiencing a tuberculosis epidemic, with 5% of the population infected with the disease. It attributed this to the "overall deterioration in health and nutrition status of the population as well as the rundown of the public health services".

In 2010, infections that cause pneumonia and diarrhea were reported to be the leading causes of child death. In 2009, one-third of the school-age children in North Korea were assessed as having diseases caused by intestinal parasites.

Coronavirus outbreak

Main article: COVID-19 pandemic in North Korea

In 2020, North Korea was one of the first countries to close borders and take other measures due to the COVID-19 pandemic. On 12 May 2022, North Korea announced its first case.

HIV/AIDS

The DPRK government has always maintained that North Korea is completely free of AIDS. According to UNAIDS, less than 0.2% of North Korea's adult population were HIV-positive in 2006. In 2018, WHO's North Korean office said there were no reported HIV positive cases in the country.

A study in 2002 found both men and women were reasonably educated about HIV/AIDS. More than two-thirds knew about ways to avoid HIV/AIDS, and there were only few misconceptions about the disease. However, according to the UN Population Fund in 2001, even hospital staff occasionally had limited awareness. Travel across the border to China has been seen as a risk factor.

In 2011, North Korea spent $1,000,000 on HIV prevention, with similar figures for previous years. The same year, North Korea received $75,000 of international aid for combatting HIV/AIDS. There are testing points and clinics, but no antiretroviral therapy was reportedly available in 2006.

North Korea has punitive laws concerning certain populations at risk of HIV/AIDS. According to UNAIDS, such laws can stigmatize those affected by HIV/AIDS and hinder their treatment. North Korea criminalizes the sex trade. Some drug-related crimes are capital offenses. On the other hand, drug users are not subjected to compulsory detention. Same-sex relations between consenting adult males are not illegal. North Korea deports visitors upon discovery of HIV-positive status.

In 2019, American journal Science has reported the country has higher numbers of HIV than expected, with a total number of 8362 people with HIV in the country.

Traditional Korean medicine

According to the Korean Medical Association, more than 80 percent of primary care in North Korea relies on traditional Korean medicine. The association suggests the promotion of traditional medicine is the result of poor pharmaceutical production. North Korean law both requires and emphasizes that Western medicine must be combined with traditional Korean medicine. Article 31 of the North Korean Medical Law stipulates that medical institutions must use acupuncture and traditional Korean medicine to treat patients. Other aspects of the law also emphasize developing both traditional and modern medicine, which is reflected in most North Korean medical journals.

See also

• Disability in North Korea
• Basic Medicine

References

Works cited

• "Country Profile: North Korea" (PDF). Library of Congress – Federal Research Division. July 2007. Retrieved 4 July 2009.
• Global Report : UNAIDS Report on the Global AIDS Epidemic 2012 (PDF). UNAIDS. 2012. ISBN 978-92-9173-592-1. Retrieved 7 December 2015.
• Lankov, Andrei (2015). The Real North Korea: Life and Politics in the Failed Stalinist Utopia. Oxford: Oxford University Press. ISBN 978-0-19-939003-8.
• Toimela, Markku; Aalto, Kaj (2017). Salakahvilla Pohjois-Koreassa: Markku Toimelan jännittävä tie Pohjois-Korean luottomieheksi (in Finnish). Jyväskylä: Docendo. ISBN 978-952-291-369-2.

Further reading

• Kim Jong-il (22 July 1992). Some Problems Arising in Improving Public Health (PDF). Pyongyang: Foreign Languages Publishing House.

External links

• WHO DPR Korea
• WHO DPR Korea profile
• WHO Country Cooperation Strategy Democratic People's Republic of Korea (Archived 9 October 2013 at the Wayback Machine)
• The Public Health Law of the Democratic People's Republic of Korea: Adopted at the Fourth Session of the Sixth Supreme People's Assembly of the Democratic People's Republic of Korea 3 April, 1980 (PDF). Archived from the original (PDF) on 24 September 2016.