Information wants to be free

"Information wants to be free" is an expression that means either that all people should be able to access information freely, or that information (formulated as an actor) naturally strives to become as freely available among people as possible. It is often used by technology activists to criticize laws that limit transparency and general access to information. People who criticize intellectual property law say the system of such government-granted monopolies conflicts with the development of a public domain of information. The expression is often credited to Stewart Brand, who was recorded saying it at a Hackers Conference in 1984.^[1]

History

The phrase is attributed to Stewart Brand,^[1] who, in the late 1960s, founded the Whole Earth Catalog and argued that technology could be liberating rather than oppressing.^[2] What is considered the earliest recorded occurrence of the expression was at the first Hackers Conference in 1984, although the video recording of the conversation shows that what Brand actually said is slightly different. Brand told Steve Wozniak:

On the one hand you have—the point you’re making Woz—is that information sort of wants to be expensive because it is so valuable—the right information in the right place just changes your life. On the other hand, information almost wants to be free because the costs of getting it out is getting lower and lower all of the time. So you have these two things fighting against each other.^[3]

Brand's conference remarks are transcribed accurately by Joshua Gans^[4] in his research on the quote as used by Steve Levy in his own history of the phrase.^[5]

A later form appears in his The Media Lab: Inventing the Future at MIT:^[6]

Information Wants To Be Free. Information also wants to be expensive. ...That tension will not go away.^[7]

According to historian Adrian Johns, the slogan expresses a view that had already been articulated in the mid-20th century by Norbert Wiener, Michael Polanyi and Arnold Plant, who advocated for the free communication of scientific knowledge, and specifically criticized the patent system.^[8]

Gratis versus libre

The various forms of the original statement are ambiguous: the slogan can be used to argue the benefits of propertied information, of liberated, free, and open information, or of both. It can be taken amorally as an expression of a fact of information-science: once information has passed to a new location outside of the source's control there is no way of ensuring it is not propagated further, and therefore will naturally tend towards a state where that information is widely distributed. Much of its force is due to the anthropomorphic metaphor that imputes desire to information. In 1990 Richard Stallman restated the concept normatively, without the anthropomorphization:

I believe that all generally useful information should be free. By "free" I am not referring to price, but rather to the freedom to copy the information and to adapt it to one's own uses ... When information is generally useful, redistributing it makes humanity wealthier no matter who is distributing and no matter who is receiving.^[9]

Stallman's reformulation incorporates a political stance into Brand's value-neutral observation of social trends.

Cypherpunk

Brand's attribution of will to an abstract human construct (information) has been adopted within a branch of the cypherpunk movement, whose members espouse a particular political viewpoint (anarchism). The construction of the statement takes its meaning beyond the simple judgmental observation, "Information should be free", by acknowledging that the internal force or entelechy of information and knowledge makes it essentially incompatible with notions of proprietary software, copyrights, patents, subscription services, etc. They believe that information is dynamic, ever-growing and evolving and cannot be contained within (any) ideological structure.^{[citation needed]}

According to this philosophy, hackers, crackers, and phreakers are liberators of information which is being held hostage by agents demanding money for its release. Other participants in this network include cypherpunks who educate people to use public-key cryptography to protect the privacy of their messages from corporate or governmental snooping and programmers who write free software and open source code. Still others create Free-Nets allowing users to gain access to computer resources for which they would otherwise need an account. They might also break copyright law by swapping music, movies, or other copyrighted materials over the Internet.^{[citation needed]}

Chelsea Manning is alleged to have said "Information should be free"^[10] to Adrian Lamo when explaining a rationale for US government documents to be released to WikiLeaks. The narrative goes on with Manning wondering if she is a "'hacker', 'cracker', 'hacktivist', 'leaker' or what".^[11]

Literary usage

In the "Fall Revolution" series of science-fiction books, author Ken Macleod riffs and puns on the expression by writing about entities composed of information actually "wanting", as in desiring, freedom and the machinations of several human characters with differing political and ideological agendas, to facilitate or disrupt these entities' quest for freedom.

In the Warcross duology by Marie Lu, the virtual space "The Pirate's Den" sports the slogan.

In the cyberpunk world of post-singularity transhuman culture described by Charles Stross in his books like Accelerando and Singularity Sky, the wish of information to be free is a law of nature.^[12]^[13]

References

^ ^a ^b Wagner, R Polk, Information wants to be free: intellectual property and the mythologies of control (PDF) (essay), University of Pennsylvania, archived from the original (PDF) on 26 December 2010, retrieved 9 December 2010.
^ Baker, Ronald J (8 February 2008), Mind over matter: why intellectual capital is the chief source of wealth, John Wiley & Sons, p. 80, ISBN 9780470198810.
^ "Stewart Brand states information wants to be free". 15 June 2012..
^ Gans, Joshua (25 October 2015). ""Information Wants to be Free": The history of that quote". Digitopoly. Retrieved 21 November 2021.
^ Levy, Steve (11 March 2015). ""Hackers" and "Information Wants to Be Free"". Backchannel. Retrieved 21 November 2021.
^ Brand, Stewart (1987), The Media Lab: Inventing the Future at MIT, Viking Penguin, p. 202, ISBN 0-14-009701-5.
^ Clark, Roger. ""Information Wants to be Free ..."". Retrieved 21 November 2021.
^ Johns, Adrian (2009), Piracy. The Intellectual Property Wars from Gutenberg to Gates, The University of Chicago Press, p. 429, ISBN 978-0-226-40118-8, We still live amid the legacies of these mid-century debates about science and society. We inherit their terms, and the culture of science that shapes our world is the one left to us by them. If we think 'information wants to be free,' then we voice a sentiment championed by Wiener, Polanyi and Plant
^ Denning, Dorothy E (October 1990), "Concerning Hackers Who Break into Computer Systems", Proceedings of the 13th National Computer Security Conference, Washington, DC: Georgetown, pp. 653–64, archived from the original on 22 June 2009, retrieved 8 November 2005.
^ KEVIN POULSEN AND KIM ZETTER (6 October 2013). "'I Can't Believe What I'm Confessing to You': The Wikileaks Chats". Wired.com. Retrieved 24 November 2013.
^ Fishman, Steve (3 July 2011). "How Bradley Manning Became One of the Most Unusual Revolutionaries in American History". New York. Retrieved 4 July 2011.
^ Stross Accelerando (review), Trashotron, 2005, retrieved 23 April 2011.
^ Stross, Charles (1 April 2010), Singularity Sky – A Modest Construct, Heliologue, archived from the original on 21 October 2020, retrieved 23 April 2011.

External links

[R._Polk_Wagner-1] Wagner, R Polk, Information wants to be free: intellectual property and the mythologies of control (PDF) (essay), University of Pennsylvania, archived from the original (PDF) on 26 December 2010, retrieved 9 December 2010.

[Ronald_J._Baker-2] Baker, Ronald J (8 February 2008), Mind over matter: why intellectual capital is the chief source of wealth, John Wiley & Sons, p. 80, ISBN 9780470198810.

[3] "Stewart Brand states information wants to be free". 15 June 2012..

[4] Gans, Joshua (25 October 2015). ""Information Wants to be Free": The history of that quote". Digitopoly. Retrieved 21 November 2021.

[5] Levy, Steve (11 March 2015). ""Hackers" and "Information Wants to Be Free"". Backchannel. Retrieved 21 November 2021.

[6] Brand, Stewart (1987), The Media Lab: Inventing the Future at MIT, Viking Penguin, p. 202, ISBN 0-14-009701-5.

[7] Clark, Roger. ""Information Wants to be Free ..."". Retrieved 21 November 2021.

[8] Johns, Adrian (2009), Piracy. The Intellectual Property Wars from Gutenberg to Gates, The University of Chicago Press, p. 429, ISBN 978-0-226-40118-8, We still live amid the legacies of these mid-century debates about science and society. We inherit their terms, and the culture of science that shapes our world is the one left to us by them. If we think 'information wants to be free,' then we voice a sentiment championed by Wiener, Polanyi and Plant

[denning-9] Denning, Dorothy E (October 1990), "Concerning Hackers Who Break into Computer Systems", Proceedings of the 13th National Computer Security Conference, Washington, DC: Georgetown, pp. 653–64, archived from the original on 22 June 2009, retrieved 8 November 2005.

[10] KEVIN POULSEN AND KIM ZETTER (6 October 2013). "'I Can't Believe What I'm Confessing to You': The Wikileaks Chats". Wired.com. Retrieved 24 November 2013.

[11] Fishman, Steve (3 July 2011). "How Bradley Manning Became One of the Most Unusual Revolutionaries in American History". New York. Retrieved 4 July 2011.

[accelerando-12] Stross Accelerando (review), Trashotron, 2005, retrieved 23 April 2011.

[Singularity_Sky-13] Stross, Charles (1 April 2010), Singularity Sky – A Modest Construct, Heliologue, archived from the original on 21 October 2020, retrieved 23 April 2011.

[1]

[2]

[3]

[4]

[5]

[6]

[7]

[8]

[9]

[10]

[11]

[12]

[13]