The Philadelphia Inquirer wrote that the album "offers old-fashioned rock-and-roll with earnest, even patriotic principles that nonetheless rarely sounds strained or sentimental."[ 6] The Globe and Mail deemed the album "as unpretentious as rock can get while still maintaining its spark."[ 7] The Los Angeles Times noted that, "on paper, the lyrics look a bit corny, but the music and obvious passion lift them."[ 8] The New York Times determined that "the music has a newfound toughness, with clanging guitars and explosive drums."[ 9]
All songs written by Scott Kempner , except "Drug Deal" written by the Del-Lords .
Side one Title 1. "Heaven" 2:58 2. "Love Lies Dying" 5:50 3. "Drug Deal" 3:34 4. "Soldier's Home" 5:34 5. "Saint Jake" 5:23
Side two Title 1. "Dream Come True" 5:00 2. "True Love" 3:46 3. "Everlovin'" 5:41 4. "Against My Will" 4:48 5. "No Waitress No More" 3:07
CD Version Title 1. "Heaven" 3:02 2. "Love Lies Dying" 5:55 3. "Drug Deal" 3:37 4. "Soldier's Home" 5:41 5. "Saint Jake" 5:28 6. "Dream Come True" 5:08 7. "True Love" 3:50 8. "Everlovin'" 5:45 9. "Against My Will" 4:53 10. "No Waitress No More" 3:21 11. "Some Summer" 2:52 12. "Obsessed With Mary" 4:54 13. "Mickey Paid for What Mickey Done" 4:09 14. "St. Jake" 4:48 15. "True Love" 4:06
The Del-Lords
Additional musicians and production
Lenny Castro – percussion
Scott Church – assistant engineering
David Eaton – assistant engineering
Michael Frondelli – engineering , mixing
Neil Geraldo – production, mixing
Dave Hernandez – assistant engineering
George Marino – mastering
Jenine Saccente – photography
Brian Scheuble – assistant engineering
George Tutko – engineering
Mark Wilczak – assistant engineering
^ Robins, Wayne (18 Apr 1986). "A New York Band on Vinyl". Newsday . Weekend. p. 25.
^ Guterman, Jimmy (May 22, 1986). "Records: Johnny Comes Marching Home". Rolling Stone (474): 80.
^ "TrouserPress.com :: Del-Lords" . www.trouserpress.com .
^ Deming, Mark. "Johnny Comes Marching Home" . AllMusic. Retrieved August 7, 2012 .
^ Christgau, Robert. "The Del-Lords: Johnny Comes Marching Home" . Robert Christgau.com. Retrieved August 7, 2012 .
^ Tucker, Ken (12 Mar 1986). "Pop/Rock". The Philadelphia Inquirer . p. D3.
^ Lacey, Liam (20 Mar 1986). "Johnny Comes Marching Home The Del Lords". The Globe and Mail . p. D5.
^ Hochman, Steve (27 Mar 1986). "N.Y.'s Del-Lords: Feeling's Genuine". Calendar. Los Angeles Times . p. 4.
^ Pareles, Jon (28 Mar 1986). "Rock Album of the Week". The New York Times . p. C27.