Wikipedia

Deaths during the Mahsa Amini protests

(Redirected from Killing of Erfan Zamani)

Deaths during the Mahsa Amini protests refer to those people who were killed due to Iran's nationwide protests of 2022, triggered by the death of 22-year-old Kurdish Iranian Jina Mahsa Amini on September 16, 2022, in a Tehran hospital under suspicious circumstances.[1]

Solidarity demonstration in Melbourne, September 2022

The Guidance Patrol, the religious morality police of Iran's government, arrested Amini for allegedly not wearing the hijab in accordance with government standards. The Law Enforcement Command of the Islamic Republic of Iran stated that she had a heart attack at a police station, collapsed, and fell into a coma before being transferred to a hospital.[2][3] However, eyewitnesses, including women who were detained with Amini, reported that she was severely beaten and that she died as a result of police brutality,[4][5][6] which was denied by the Iranian authorities.[7] The assertions of police brutality, in addition to leaked medical scans,[8] led some observers to believe Amini had a cerebral hemorrhage or stroke due to head injuries received after her arrest.[9]

Documentation

edit
 
A mural commemorating the victims of the Islamic regime in Iran, in Nazareth.

During the protests that followed, many young women and men, including children, were shot or killed in the street or executed in prison without trial, or died as a result of mistreatment and torture. The perpetrators are usually male members of the religious police, the paramilitary Basijis, the Iranian Revolutionary Guards Corps (IRGC) or prison guards.[10] The killings and mistreatments are being carried out systematically on orders from the regime to use ruthless violence to suppress the protests and deter the population from further participation. They are internationally regarded as serious human rights crimes.[11]

Since the beginning of the protests, human rights organizations, news agencies specializing in Iran, quality media, and domestic and foreign Iranian opposition groups have continuously collected testimonies from inside Iran, verified the information as much as possible, and then provided reports on the reliably identified fatalities and essential information about their deaths released. Documentaries on this come from the news agencies IranWire, the Human Rights Activists News Agency (HRANA) and Iran International, Amnesty International, the Hengaw Organization for Human Rights (Hengaw), Iran Human Rights (IHR), the Iran Human Rights Monitor (IHRM) and the National Council of Resistance of Iran (NCRI). Media such as The New York Times, Washington Post, The Guardian, Der Spiegel, Der Tagesspiegel, Die Zeit and others have published many names of victims in the context of their reports on Iran.[12]

Statistics

edit
 
 
Number of protesters killed by province and county.

As of October 5, 2022, HRANA registered 342 civil protest gatherings in all 31 provinces of Iran, including 266 street protests in 105 major cities and 76 student protests in all 69 universities in the country. The police and Basijis used tear gas, rubber and metal bullets and live ammunition to disperse the gatherings, killing hundreds of unarmed people. In the first three weeks, HRANA initially identified 200 fatalities, including 18 children and adolescents, largely through analysis of video footage and testimonies received from Iran.[1]

By the end of October 2022, NCRI announced 280 identified protesters were killed in the protests and put the total death toll at 450 so far,[13][better source needed] similar to IHRM.[14] By November 2, 2022, IHR registered at least 277 people killed in the protests and in custody, including 40 children. IHR is investigating numerous unconfirmed reports of further killings and also expects dozens of executions of those arrested on arbitrary death sentences.[15] As of November 5, 2022, at least 314 people have been killed in protests in Iran, including 47 minors and 38 security forces, according to HRANA and more than 14,000 were arrested.[16] Following a massacre by regime forces in Khash on November 4, 2022, NCRI reported 324 identified fatalities.[17] By December 17, 2022, at least 469 people have been killed. 374 of the deaths were men and 63 of the deaths were children and 32 were women. 39 protesters are also at risk of execution[18]

According to the Iranian government, around 200 people have died during the protest.[19] Human rights activists assume a high number of unreported deaths.[11] A reason for this is that the Iranian regime arbitrarily arrests or kidnaps thousands of people, kills many without a process of law, and instead of handing over their bodies to their relatives, disappears them. Media research and criminal investigations are forbidden under the dictatorship of Iran, and are being done illegally and then associated with great risks and danger for witnesses, investigative journalists, human rights activists and lawyers.[20]

List of victims

edit

The documentation from HRANA (1), IranWire (2), Der Spiegel (3), Amnesty International (4), Iran Human Rights (5) and NCRI (6) regularly includes the names of the fatalities and, where ascertained, their ages and the date, place and cause of death. The following list presents the most important published information in chronological order.

People killed by regime officials in protests in Iran since September 16, 2022
Date of death 2022 Name Age Location Circumstances of death Ref.[12]
16 September Mahsa Jina Amini 22 Tehran She was arrested because a headscarf had slipped and was transferred to a hospital after an hour's detention. She died there after three days in a coma, probably as a result of severe blows to the head. A CT scan of it shows a skull fracture, cerebral hemorrhage and bruising.[21] [22]
18 September Fouad Ghadimi ~40 Divandareh Gunshot wound 1, 2, 3,[23]
19 September Hajar Abbasi ~70 Mahabad Gunshot wound 1
Fardin Bakhtiari Sanandaj Gunshot wound 1, 3
Iman Behzadpour Sanandaj 6
Reza Lotfi ~25 Sanandaj Gunshot wound 1, 3,[23]
Aysan Madanpasand Tabriz Beating 1
Fereydoun Mahmoudi 32 Saqqez Gunshot wound 1, 3,
Mohsen Mohammadi 28 Divandareh Gunshot wound 1, 3,[23]
20 September Sasan Bagheri Rezvanshahr Gunshot wound 1, 2
Farjad Darvishi 23 Balo, Urmia Gunshot wound 1, 3,[23]
Zakaria Khial / Khayal 16 Piranshahr Targeted close-range shots and club blows inflicted serious wounds on him, causing him to bleed to death. 1, 3, 4, 5,[24][23]
Erfan Khazaei Zahedan Gunshot wound 1, 2
Farzin Lotfi 35 Rezvan Shahr Gunshot wound 1, 3
Minoo Majidi 62 Kermanshah The mother of three was shot by Basijis. A photo of her youngest daughter with her hair shaved and no hijab at her grave was widely shared on social media.[25] 1, 3,[26][27][23]
Diako Mehrnavaei Bukan 6
Nika Shakarami 16/17 Tehran Standing on top of a dumpster at the head of a student protest downtown, she burned her hijab, was chased by Basijis, disappeared without a trace and was handed over dead to her family nine days later. She allegedly fell from an unoccupied house; however, according to an autopsy, she suffered many broken bones from severe beatings. According to witnesses, she was interrogated by the IRGC and then taken to Evin prison.[28] 1-5,[22][29]
Reza Shahparnia 20 Kermanshah Gunshot wound 1, 3
Abdolsamad Sabeti Zadeh (Shahu Zahie) Zahedan 2
Milad Zare 25 Babol 1, 3,[30]
21 September Matin Abdollahpour 16 Balo, Urmia 3
Fereydoun Ahmadi Saqqez [27]
Roshana Ahmadi Bukan Gunshot wound 1, 6
Mehdi Babr-Nejad Quchan Gunshot wound 1, 6
Amir Hossein Basati 15 Kermanshah Targeted close-range shots with metal balls killed him directly. 1, 4, 5,[24]
Amir Bastami Kermanshah 6
Ghazaleh Chalavi 32/33 Amol Gunshot wound 1, 3,[26]
Abdolfazl Akbari Doust Langroud Gunshot wound 1, 6
Mehdi Mohammad Fallah 33 Amol Gunshot wound 1, 3
Mohammad Farmani Shahr-e-Ray 6
Alireza Fathi Sanfar Gunshot wound 1, 6
Amir Ali Fouladi 16 Eslamabad-e Gharb Gunshot wound 1, 3, 4, 5
Mohsen Geysari 32 Ilam Gunshot wound 1, 3
Mehrdad Ghorbani Zanjan Gunshot wound 1, 6
Milan Haghighi 21 Oshnavieh Gunshot wound 1, 3,[31]
Saeed Iranmensh Kerman 6
Yasin Jamalzadeh ~28 Rezvan Shahr Gunshot wound 1, 3
Erfan Khazaee Shahriar 6
Hannaneh Kia 22 / 23 Nowshahr Gunshot wound 1, 3,[26]
Mohsen Mohammadi Kochsaraei / Kochaksarai Qaem Shahr Gunshot wound 1, 6
Behnam Layeghpour 37 Rasht Targeted close shots in the heart 1, 3,[32]
Sadreddin Litani 27 Oshnavieh Gunshot wound 1, 3
Amir Hossein Mahdavi Rasht 6
Abdollah Mahmoudpour /
Mohammadpour 		16-18 Balo, Urmia He was shot from behind while retreating from a Basij office. 1, 3, 4,[24]
Mohsen Mal Mir Nowshahr Gunshot wound 1, 6
Amin Maroufi / M'arefat 16 Oshnavieh Shot by IRGC 1, 3, 4, 5,[24]
Abdolfazl Mehdipour Babol Gunshot wound 1, 6
Seyyed Abbas Mirmousa / Mir-Mousavi Langroud Gunshot wound 1, 6
Mahsa Mogouei 18 Fulad Shahr Gunshot wound 1, 3
Amir Mehdi Malak Mohammadi Tehran 6
Iman Mohammadi Islamabad-e Gharb / Kermanshah 1, 3
Saeid Mohammadi 21 Islamabad-e-gharb Gunshot wound 1, 3
Seyed Mehdi Mousavi 15-16 Zanjan Was shot from behind and then beaten up. 5,[24]
Seyyed Sina Mousavi Amol Gunshot wound 1, 6
Hadis Najafi 22 / 23 Karaj She had posted dance and music videos on TikTok and was shot dead at a demonstration in Karaj. 1, 3,[22][33]
Mehrab Najafi Zarrin Shahr 6
Mahdi Mousavi Nikou 16 Zanjan Died while being transported to the hospital after being shot in the back and being beaten with clubs to the head and body. 1, 3, 4
Amir Nowrozi 16 Bandar-e Anzali Gunshot wound 1, 3, 4
Arash Pahlavan 27 Machad Gunshot wound 1, 6
Danesh Rahnema 25 Balo, Urmia Gunshot wound 1, 3
Parza Rezadoust 17 Karaj 1, 3
Erfan Rezaei 21 Amol Gunshot wound 1, 3
Ali Mozaffari Salanghouch 17 Quchan Gunshot wound 1, 3
Mohammad Mam Saleh Sardasht 6
Mohammed Reza Savari 14 Hashtgerd / Shahr-e Rey, Tehran 1, 3, 4
Amir Hossein Shams Nowshahr Gunshot wound 1, 6
Pouya Sheida Urmia 6
Morteza Soltanian Esfahan 6
Mohammad Hassan Torkaman 27 Babol Gunshot wound 1, 3
Mehdi Zahedi Urmia 6
Mohammad Zamani 16 Tehran 1, 5
Mohammad Zarei Qrachak / Sanqar Gunshot wound 1, 6
22 September Kanaan Aghaei 18 Karaj Gunshot wound 1, 6
Mehrdad Avazpour Nowshahr Gunshot wound 1, 6
Pedram Azarnoush 16 Dehdasht He was fatally wounded as a spectator by indiscriminate ICRG gunfire into the crowd. 1, 3, 4,[24]
Mehrdad Behnam-Asl Kohgiluyeh, Boyer-Ahmad / Dehdasht 1, 3
Mohammad Reza Eskandari 25 Pakdasht / Alborz 1, 3,[24]
Sasan Ghorbani 31-32 Rezvanshahr Shot while helping a wounded protester, beaten in custody, denied medical attention 1, 3,[32]
Arvin Malamali Golzari Fuladshahr 6
Esmail Heydari Ardabil 6
Javad Heydari 36 Qazvin Gunshot wound 1, 3
Mohammad Hosseinkhah Mazandaran Gunshot wound 1, 6
Yaser Jafari Ilam 1
Rouzbeh Khademi 32 Karaj Gunshot wound 1,
Shirin Alizadeh Khansari 35 Chalus Was killed by an aimed shot in the head. 6,[32][34]
Mehdi Leylazi Karaj Gunshot wound 1
Mohammad Rasoul Momenizadeh Rasht Gunshot wound 1, 6
Mohsen Pazouki Pakdascht / Varamin Gunshot wound 1
Maziar Salmanian / Soleimanian Rasht 1, 3
Mohammad Reza Sarvari 14 Shahr-e Ray Cerebral hemorrhage as a result of a shot in the back of the head. Original cause of death listed as suicide: this was refuted by the release of his burial certificate. 1, 4,[24]
Setareh Tajik 17 Tehran She was beaten with clubs in the face, head and body. Her family was forced to remain silent. 3, 4,[24][35]
Mohammad Amin Takoli Tehran 6
23 September Ehsan Alibazi 16 Shahr-e-Qods 1, 5
Sarina Esmailzadeh 16 Gohardasht in Karaj / Mehrshahr She was beaten to the head with a club. The judiciary claimed that she committed suicide by jumping from the roof of a house. In order to be able to bury the dead woman, her family was not allowed to open the coffin and had to confirm the information given by the authorities under death threats from the IRGC. 1, 4, 5,[22][35][24]
Hamid Fouladvand Pakdascht 2
Alireza Hosseini 26 Tehran Gunshot wound 1
Seyyedeh Ameneh Vahdat Hosseini Karaj 1
Javad Khansari 36 Tehran 1, 6
Hossein Morovati Qrachak Varamin Gunshot wound 1, 6
Hediyeh Naeimani Nowshahr Gunshot wound 1, 6
Pouya (Ali) Ahmadpour Pasikhani 17 Rasht Gunshot wound 1, 5
Ahmad Reza Qoliji Hamedan 6
Parsa Rezadoust 17 Hashtgerd / Alborz Gunshot wound 1, 3, 4, 5
Mohammad Javad Zahedi 16 Sari Targeted head and neck shots 5,[32]
24 September Mehdi Asgari 25 Garmsar Gunshot wound 1, 3, 4
Mehrzad Avazpour Nowshahr 4
Mohammad Hosseinikhah Sari 4
Hossein Ali Kia Kanjouri 23 Nowshahr Gunshot wound 1, 3, 4
Mahmoud Keshvari Karaj 1
Lina Namour Tehran 6
Morteza Nowroozi Langaroud Gunshot wound 1, 3
Reza Saed Tehran 6
Mohammad Hossein Sarvi / Savari-Rad Garmsar / Tehran 1, 3
25 September Mohammad Jameh Bozorg Marlik Karaj Gunshot wound 1
Hamin Foulavand Varamin 1
Nader Kokar Rudsar 6
Siavash Mahmoudi 16 Naziabad, Tehran Headshot 1, 3, 4, 5,[24]
Milad Ostad-Hashem 37 Tehran Milad was shot as he rode a motorbike after taking part in protests in the capital. His parents alleged security forces pressured them to go along with state media reports that he was a Basij member killed by "rioters" and that security forces threatened to kill their two other sons and bury Milad's body secretly in a remote place if they did not co-operate. [36]
26 September Abdolsalam Ghader Galvani / Abdussalam Qadir Galvan 32 Oshnavieh 1, 2
28 September Samad Barginia Piranshahr Gunshot wound 1, 6
Amir Mehdi Farkhipour / Farrokhipour 17 Tehran, Keshavarz Boulevard He was shot with metal bullets and live ammunition. His father had to name a car accident as the cause; otherwise his daughters will be murdered. 1, 3, 4, 5,[24]
Amir Reza Naderzadeh Nowshahr 6
29 September Erfan Nazarbeigi Tehran 1, 2
30 September Esmail Abil Zahedan 2
Ali Agheli (Narui) 28 Zahedan 2, 3
Mukhtar Ahmadi Marivan 2
Lal Mohammad Alizehi Zahedan 2, 3
Abu Bakr Ali-Zehei Zahedan 2, 3
Balal Anshini Zahedan 2, 3
Lal Mohammad Anshini Zahedan 2, 3
Mehdi Anshini Zahedan 2
Musa Anshini Zahedan 2
Ali Aqli (Naroui) Zahedan 2
Suleiman Arab Zahedan 2
Amin Goleh Bacheh Zahedan 2
Amin (Badr al-Uloum Seminary) Zahedan 2
Riassat (Badel) Balouch Zahedan 2
Abdorrahman Balouchi Zahedan 2
Abdolrahman Baluchikhah Zahedan 2, 3
Ali Barahouie 14 Zahedan During Friday prayers in Mossala Mosque, he was shot in the neck and chest. 2, 3, 4,[24]
Abdol Samad Barahui (Aidouzehi) Zahedan 2
Ali Akbar Barahui Zahedan 2
Mahmoud Barahui Zahedan 2
Mohammad Barahui Zahedan 2
Zacharie Barahui Zahedan 2
Mustafa Barichi 24 Zahedan 2
(Lal) Mahmoud / Mohammad Brahoui 18 Zahedan 1, 2, 3
Abdulghafoor Dahmarde / Abdol Ghafoor Dehmordeh Zahedan 2
Mansour Dehmardeh Zahedan 2
Musa Doveira Zahedan 2
Mohammad Farough-Rakhsh Zahedan 2, 3
Mohammad Ali Gamshad-Zehei 18 Zahedan 2, 3
Mohammad Amin Gamshad-Zehei 17 Zahedan On the way home from Friday prayers, he was shot in the heart. 2, 3, 4
Mohsen Gamshadzehei Zahedan 2, 3
Vahed Gamshadzehi Zahedan 2
Salahuddin Gamshad-Zehei Zahedan 2, 3
Saeed Gergige Zahedan 2
Aminollah Ghaljaei Zahedan 2, 3
Mohammad Ghaljei Zahedan 2, 3
Matin Ghanbarzehi 13-14 Zahedan 4
Ibrahim Gorgij Zahedan 2, 3
Matine Qanbar Zehi Gorgij Zahedan 2
Amir Mohammad Gumshadzehi Zahedan 2
Ali Akbar Halgheh-Begoosh Zahedan 2, 3
Omran Hassanzehei Zahedan 2, 3
Vahid Hovat / Hout Zahedan 2, 3
Hamid Isa-Zehei Zahedan 2, 3
Azizollah Kabdani Zahedan 2
Nematollah Kabedani / Kubdani Zahedan 2, 3
Azizullah Kubdani Zahedan 2
Sodeys / Sedis Keshani 14 Zahedan After Friday prayers, the police shot him in the head and heart in front of the police station opposite the Grand Mosque. 1, 2, 3, 5
Mirshekar(i) / Mireshkar 2 Zahedan 2, 4, 5
Jalil Mohammad-Zehei Zahedan 2, 3
Abubakr Nahtani Zahedan 2
Musa Nahtani Zahedan 2
Abdol Majid Naroui Zahedan 2
Hamid Narouei Zahedan 2, 3
Hamzeh Narouei Zahedan 2, 3
Mohammad Sediq / Sadigh Narouei Zahedan 2, 3
Younes Narouei Zahedan 2, 3
Abdollah Naroui Zahedan 2
Rafi Naroui 23 Zahedan 2, 3
Hasti Narui Zahedan 6
Musa Dovira Narui 18 Zahedan 2
Abdol Vahid Tohid Nia Zahedan Gunshot wound 1, 2
Abdulghafoor Noor-Barahui Zahedan 2, 3
Javad Pousheh 11/12 Zahedan After Friday prayers in the Mosalla Mosque, he received several shots in the head outside a police station. 1, 3, 4, 5
Aminullah Qoljai Zahedan 2
Mohammad Qoljaei Zahedan 2
Abdolmanan Rakhshani Zahedan 2
Balal Rakhshani Zahedan 2
Jalil Rakhshani Zahedan 2
Mansour Rakhshani Zahedan 2, 3
Mohammad Rakhshani 12 Kawsar in Zahedan He was shot in the head during a police attack on a protest. 3, 4, 5,[24]
Heydar Narui Rashid Zahedan 2
Abdol Majid Rigi Zahedan 2
Behzad Rigi 30 Zahedan 2
Mohammad Rigi Zahedan 2, 3
Gungo Zehi Rigi Zahedan 2
Amir Hossein Mir Kazehi Riggi 19 Zahedan 2, 3
Hamid Reza Saneipour Hamedan Gunshot wound 1, 2
Ahmad (Jamma) Sarani (Alizehi) Zahedan 2
Omid Sarani 12/13 Zahedan In an attack on a protest, police shot him in the chest. 2, 3,[24]
Omid Safarzehi 17 Shirabad in Zahedan Killed by two shots to the neck.
Ahmad Sargolzaei Zahedan 2, 3
Abdolmalek Shahbakhsh Zahedan 2, 3
Abdullah Shahbakhsh Zahedan 2
Ahmad Shahbakhsh Zahedan 2, 3
Danial/Daniel Shahbakhsh 11 Zahedan 2
Farzad Shahbakhsh Zahedan 2, 3
Imran Shahbakhsh Zahedan 2
Majid Shahbakhsh Zahedan 2
Mohiuddin Shahbakhsh Zahedan 2
Omran Shahbakhsh Zahedan 2, 3
Yaser Shahbakhsh Zahedan 2, 3
Abdol Khaleq Shahnavazi Zahedan 2
Amir Hamzeh Shahnavazi Zahedan 2, 3
Mahmoud Shahnavazi Zahedan 2
Mohammad Eghbal (Iqbal) Naebzehei Shahnavazi 16 Zahedan 2, 3
Omar Shahnavazi Zahedan 2, 3
Omid Shahnavazi Zahedan 2
Thamer Shahnavazi Zahedan 2
Yaser Shahouzehi 16 Zahedan After Friday prayers, he was shot in the head outside a police station. 3, 4, 5
Samad Shahuzehei / Abdol Samad Thabitizadeh Zahedan 2, 3
Jaber Shirouzi / Shiroozehi 12 Shirabad in Zahedan Headshot 1, 2, 3, 4
Najm al-Din Tajik Zahedan 2
Najmuddin Tajik Zahedan 2
Abdul Wahid Tohidnia Zahedan 2
Mohammad Reza Adib Toutazehi Zahedan 2, 3
Esmail Hossein Zahi Zahedan 2
Majid Baloch Zehi (Sheh Bakhsh) Zahedan 2
Mohammad Ali Esmail Zehi (Shah Bakhsh) Zahedan 2
Samer (Sami) Hashem Zehie 16 Zahedan He was shot dead outside a police station after Friday prayers; his family was threatened. 1, 2, 3, 4, 5,[24]
Mohammad Eqbal Naib Zehi Zahedan 2, 3
Gholam Nabi Noti Zehi Zahedan 2
Abdol Jalil Qanbar Zehi Zahedan 2
Khalil Qanbar Zehi Zahedan 2
1 October Mokhtar Ahmadi Marivan 2
Ali Bani Assad Ahvaz 2, 6
Khodanour Laje’i Zahedan 2, 6
Ehsan Khan Mohammadi Tehran 2, 6
Pouya Rajab Nia Babol 2
Mehrab Dolat Panah Talesh Gunshot wound 1, 2
2 October Jamal Abdol Naser Mohammad Hasani Barahui Zahedan 2, 6
Saamer Hashemzehie Zahedan 2, 6
Arman Hassanzani /

Hasan Zaee 		Zahedan 2, 6
Mahmoud Hassanzani /

Hasan Zaee 		Zahedan 2, 6
Morteza Hassanzani / Hasan Zaee Zahedan 2, 6
Zolfaghar Jan Hassanzani / Zolfaqar Hasan Zaee Zahedan 2, 6
Khodanur Lajai Zahedan 2
Salman Maleki 25 Zahedan Gunshot wound 1, 2
Ali Akbar Rabi’i Isfahan 2, 6
Mahuddin Shirouzehi / Maheddin Shiro Zehi Karimabad, Zahedan 2, 6
3 October Mostafa Beriji Zahedan 2, 6
Mohammad Mehrdadi Tehran 2, 6
5 October Nima Shafagh Doust / Nemia Shafiqdoust 16 Salmas / Urmia He died from gunshot wounds from metal bullets aimed at him. His family had to keep this secret and was threatened. 1, 2, 4, 5, 6,[24]
6 October Reza Bonyadi Tehran 2, 6
Emad Heydari 31 Ahvaz Beatings in custody 1, 2, 6
8 October Abolfazi Adinehzadeh / Abdulfazi Adina 16 Mashhad 5,[32]
Daryoush Alizadeh Sanandaj 2, 6
Mohammad Amini Sanandaj 2, 6
Maryam Ghavasi Mashhad 6
Sajjad Jafari Shiraz 6
Ainaz Javaheri Kermanshah 6
Simeh Mahmoudinejad Kerman 6
Peyman Manbari 29 Sanandaj 2, 6
Mohsen Mousavi 30 Tehran 2, 6
Yahya Rahimi 31 Sanandaj Targeted close-up because the driver had honked for the protests 2, 6,[32]
Nagin Salehi Tehran 6
Kamran Shahbazi Tehran 6
Sopher Sharifi Tehran 2, 6
9 October Nadia Arefani Fardis in Karaj Succumbed to serious injuries during a demonstration the previous day 2, 6
Aref Ashouri Rasht, Lakan-Prison 6
Mehrzad Behrouz Rasht, Lakan-Prison 6
Milad Derakhshan Rasht, Lakan-Prison 6
Esmail Dezvar Saqqez 2
Arian Moridi Salas-e Babajani 1, 2
Mohammad Anoush Niya Rasht, Lakan-Prison 6
Mehran Rajabi Rasht, Lakan-Prison 6
Seyyed Ahmad Shokrollahi Isfahan 2, 6
10 October Abolfazl Adinezadeh Mashhad 2, 6
Farzin Farrokhi Saqqez 2, 6
Omid Mahdavi Tehran 2, 6
Elaheh Sa’idi Saqqez 2, 6
12 October Kamal Fegghi / Feqhi Bukan 2, 6
Asra Panahi Jangah 15/16 Ardabil She was beaten to death by Basij because she didn't want to sing along to a propaganda song [35] 2, 6,[37]
Aziz Moradi Sanandaj 2, 6
Sina Naderi 22 Kermanshah 2, 6
Armin Sayadi 18 Kermanshah 2, 6
Mehrgan Zahmatkesh Rasht 2, 6
13 October Negin Abdolmaleki 21 Hamedan 6,[38]
Parisa Asgari Tehran 2
Reza Esmailzadeh Tehran 6
15 October Ali Basaki Tehran 6
Seyyed Farhad Hosseini Tehran, Evin prison Evin prison fire 6
Hossein Jezi Tehran, Evin prison Evin prison fire 2, 6
Hamid Saeed Mozafari Tehran, Evin prison Evin prison fire 2, 6
16 October Hossein Akbarzadeh Tehran, Evin prison Evin prison fire 6
Atika Gaem Magham 17 Tehran [39][better source needed]
17 October Mohammad Abdollahi Ilam 2, 6
Hamed Baji Zehi / Zahi (Brahoui) Zahedan 2, 6
19 October Ali Bani Asadi 20 Ahvaz 2
20 October Ali Jalili Tehran 6
Ramin Karami Kermanshah 2, 6
Until 22 October Abolfazl Bahu Qaimshahr 6
Mehdi Farahani Khorramshahr 6
Seyyed Mohammad Hosseini Saqqez 2, 6
Maisam Jafari 6
Rahim Kalij Qaimshahr 6
Poriya Kayani Shushtar 2, 6
Mohammad Khawajui Dezful 6
Sina Malayeri Arak 2, 6
Farid Maleki Tehran 2, 6
Arnica Kaem Maqami 17 Tehran 6,[40]
Messam Moghadasi Tehran 2, 6
Milad Javidpour Mogoie 6
Ezzatollah Shahbazi Tehran, Evin prison 6
Sarina Shiri Kermanshah 6
23 October Ramin Fatehi Sanandaj 2, 6
Ehsan Khawajui Dezful 6
Nahid Mostafapour Yasouj 6
Mona Naghib 8 Saravan [41][better source needed]
24 October Sadaf Movahedi 17 Tehran 6,[34]
25 October Parisa Bahmani Tehran 6,[42]
Parmis Hamnava 14 Iranshahr 6,[43][better source needed]
Ebrahim Mirzaei 42 Sanandaj 6,[44]
Marzieh Doshman Ziyari Bushehr 6
26 October Behnaz Afshari Tehran, Evin prison Evin prison fire 6
Afshin Asham 28 Qasr-e Shirin [45]
Rasoul Haddadi Zanjan 6
Hadi Haqshenas Isfahan 6
Mohammad Lotfollahi Sanandaj IRGC seriously injured him, transported him to an unknown location and handed him over dead to his family the following day. The dead man had severe neck wounds, possibly from torture. 6,[46][47]
Hamid Reza Malmir Karaj 6
Ismail Mauludi / Esmail Moloudi 35 Mahabad [46][48][45][49]
Amirhossein Rumiani Nazari Tehran 6
Ali Rouzbahani Tehran 6
Sarina Saedi 16/17 Sanandaj She received severe blows to the head and died the following day.[47] 6,[50][51]
Seyed Ali Seiedi Tehran 6
Mohammad Shariati Sanandaj [45]
27 October Ermita Abbasi 20 Karaj [52]
Zaniar Aboubekri / Abu Bakri Mahabad 6,[46][45]
Fereshteh Ahmadi 32 Mahabad When the mother of two tried to protect two young men from attacks by the military, they shot her. 6,[46]
Keyvan Darvishi 18 Sanandaj [53]
Fereydon Faraji Baneh He was hit and killed by IRGC gunfire in the crowd. 6,[46]
Shahou Khezri Mahabad 6,[45][46]
Motalleb Saeed Pirou / Matlab Saeed Peyrow / Peyro Baneh He was hit by shots fired into the crowd by the IRGC.[54] 6,[46]
Mehrshad Shahidi 19 Arak 6,[50][34][55]
Kobra Sheikheh / Sheikh Saqqa Mahabad 6,[46][45]
28 October Dastan Rasul Mohammad Agha Baneh 6,[46]
Masoud Ahmadzadeh Mahabad 6,[46]
Ali Fazeli Amol 6
Kabdani, son of Khodabakhsh 12 Zahedan 6
Adel Kochakzaei Zahedan 6
Farid Koravand Asaluyeh 6
Omid Narouie Zahedan 6
Amir Shahnavazi Zahedan 6
29 October Aref Gholampour Zahedan 6
Saman Qadirpour Tehran 6
Diana Mahmoudi 8 Piranshahr 6
31 October Kumar Daroftadeh 16 Piranshahr Purposefully shot 6,[46][32]
Jafar Qurbani Kamyaran 6
Moulavi Youssef Raisi Lashar 6
Mohammad Saremi Borujerd 6
1 November Mohammad Hossein Faraji Tehran 6
Nasim Sedghi 22 Urmia shot 2, 6
2 November Momen Zand Karimi 18 Sanandaj He was shot dead at a funeral for Hadis Najafi. 6,[56][32]
Milad Khavari Bandar Abbas 6
Morteza Shirmohammadi Shahin Dez 6
3 November Shoaib Darghale Chabahar 6
Mehdi Hazrati Karaj 6
Mehdis Hosseini Amol 6
Mohammadreza Bali Lashak Nowshahr 6
Prasto Mouradkhani Karaj 6
Yaser Naroi Zahedan 6
Mohammad Reza Sarvi Shahr-e Rey 6
Mehran Shekari Karaj 6
Erfan Zamani Lahijan Shot and bled to death because the perpetrators prevented first aid. Police actions prevented a vigil a few days later. 6,[32]
4 November Shahli Bar Khash 6
Sohn von Haj Khoda Murad Brahoi Khash 6
Sadegh Brahui Khash 6
Mohammad Amin Heshmatian Karaj 6
Ali Kurd Kalahori Khash 6
Mobin Mirkazehi Khash 6
Nima Nouri 17 Karaj The teenager was purposefully shot. This gave rise to new protest calls. [57][58]
Kambiz Regi Khash 6
Sohn von Anwar Salahshuran Khash 6
Mohammad Selahshuran Khash 6
Mohammad Shahbakhsh Khash 6
Yunus Shahbakhsh Khash 6
Rahim Dad Shahli Khash 6
Abdul Malik Shahnawazi Kash 6
Azim Mahmoud Zahi Khash 6
Murad Zahi Khash 6
Saeed Sohrab Zehi Khash 6
Yasir Bahadur Zehi Khash 6
5 November Maria Gavasieh Shiraz 6
Pegah Gavasieh Shiraz 6
Nasrin Ghaderi 35 Marivan The Kurdish doctoral student was shot in the head several times during a protest, fell into a coma and died in a hospital. Her family was not allowed to bury her in Marivan. The Secret Service ordered a funeral without anyone present. 6,[59][60][61]
Mozhgan Kadkhodaei Tehran 6
Abbas Louiemi Ahvaz 6
Mohammad Hossein Salari Mahshahr 6
6 November Mohammad Ghaemi Far Asterki Dezful 6
Oveis Shekarze’i Sarbaz 6
7 November Sina Firouzabadi Shiraz 6
Zia Mir Baloch Zehi Saravan 6
8 November Komeil Amir Khanlou Karaj 6
Mohammad Reza (Hessam) Tehran 6
9 November Sepehr Biranvand Khorramabad 6
Alireza Karimi 20 Arak Beaten to death with police batons during student protests 6,[62]
Matin Nasri Sanandaj 6
Faieq Mom Qadri Mahabad 6
Hemin Hamzeh 30 Sardasht Killed by border guards in the village of Boyuran [63]
16 November Kian Pirfalak 9 Izeh [64]
16 November Artin Rahmani Piyani 17 Izeh [65]
16 November Aylar Haghi 23 Tabriz Haghi participated in the anti-government protest that took place in Tabriz on November 16, 2022, as part of the 2022 Iran protests.[66] Government forces began to disperse the demonstration by using violence against the demonstrators. After the intervention of the police, Haghi took refuge in a building to escape the violence.[67] Several officers who were chasing her followed her into the building and shot her in the back of the head, killing her.[68][69][70][71][72] Her body was then thrown from a high-rise building.[73][74][75]
dateless Saeid Iranmanesh Kerman Gunshot wound 1
Omid Safarzahi 17 1, 5
Afshin Shahamat 16 Tehran Gunshot wound 1
Jabir Shirouzahi 12 5
23 November 2023 Milad Zohrevand 21 Hamedan Charge of murdering a member of the Islamic Revolutionary Guard Corps named "Ali Nazari" [76]

See also

edit

References

edit
  1. ^ a b main (October 12, 2022). "Woman, life, freedom; Comprehensive report of 20 days of protest across Iran". Hrana. Retrieved November 12, 2022.
  2. ^ "Three killed in protests over Iranian woman Mahsa Amini's death in custody". Canadian Broadcasting Corporation. September 20, 2022. Archived from the original on September 20, 2022. Retrieved September 22, 2022.
  3. ^ "Arrest by hijab police leaves woman comatose". Al-Monitor. September 15, 2022. Archived from the original on September 18, 2022. Retrieved September 22, 2022.
  4. ^ Mehsa Amini's death "due to injury to the skull"; A former IRGC commander informed about the forensic report, BBC News, 29 September 2022
  5. ^ Fazeli, Yaghoub (September 16, 2022). "Iranian woman 'beaten' by police for 'improper hijab' dies after coma: State media". Al Arabiya. Archived from the original on September 16, 2022. Retrieved September 16, 2022.
  6. ^ "IranWire Exclusive: Morality Patrol Beats a Woman into a Coma". Iranwire.com. September 15, 2022. Archived from the original on September 24, 2022. Retrieved September 18, 2022.
  7. ^ "Iranian coroner denies Mahsa Amini died from blows to body". Al Jazeera. Retrieved October 13, 2022.
  8. ^ "Mahsa Amini's medical scans show skull fractures caused by 'severe trauma': Report". Al Arabiya. September 19, 2022. Archived from the original on September 24, 2022. Retrieved September 22, 2022.
  9. ^ Brase, Jörg (September 20, 2022). "Irans Opposition hat vor allem eine Schwäche" [Above all, Iran's opposition has one weakness]. ZDF (in German). Archived from the original on September 24, 2022. Retrieved September 22, 2022.
  10. ^ "Basij death toll highlights Iranian paramilitary group's role in protest crackdown". Middle East Eye. Retrieved November 12, 2022.
  11. ^ a b "Iran: Leaked documents reveal top-level orders to armed forces to 'mercilessly confront' protesters". Amnesty International. September 30, 2022. Retrieved November 12, 2022.
  12. ^ a b Extensive documentation of the fatalities with verified information is available: Nr. 1: Woman, life, freedom; Comprehensive report of 20 days of protest across Iran. en-hrana.org, 12. October 2022. Nr. 2: Omid Shams: Remembering the Victims of #IranProtests2022. Iran Wire, 5. October 2022. Nr. 3: Alexander Epp, Klaas Neumann, Dawood Ohdah, Matthias Stahl: Wie Iran den Protest bekämpft. Die Blutspur des Regimes. Der Spiegel, 23. October 2022 (chargeable). Nr. 4: Iran: Killings of Children during Youthful Anti-Establishment Protests. Amnesty International, 13. October 2022. Nr. 5: 26 children killed by security forces during protests. Iran Human Rights Monitor (IHRM), 13. October 2022. Nr. 6: Iran: PMOI/MEK Publishes Names of Martyrs of the Iranian People’s Nationwide Uprising. People's Mojahedin Organization of Iran (PMOI), 1. October 2022. The numbers 1 to 6 in the evidence column of the list of victims refer to these main documents. The remaining documents are given directly as individual proofs. The spelling of the names follows the first document; where relevant, major discrepancies and additional details from other supporting documents are given.
  13. ^ "Systematic violence and arbitrary killing of women and girls will not stop Iran Protests1". October 31, 2022. Retrieved November 12, 2022.
  14. ^ "Monthly Report October 2022, Iran Human Rights Monitor - Iran HRM". October 31, 2022. Retrieved November 12, 2022.
  15. ^ "Iran Protests: At least 277 Including 40 Children Killed/Protesters Facing Death Penalty Charges". iranhr.net. Retrieved November 12, 2022.
  16. ^ Menschenrechtler teilen mit: Mehr als 300 Tote bei Protesten in Iran. FAZ, 5. November 2022; Proteste gegen die Führung. Bisher mehr als 300 Tote im Iran. ARD Tagesschau.de, 5. November 2022
  17. ^ Aslani, Mostafa (November 4, 2022). "Iran: Protests Continue Despite Khash Massacre – Day 50". Iran News Update. Retrieved November 12, 2022.
  18. ^ "List of 39 Protestors at Risk of Execution and Death Sentences; at Least 469 Protesters Killed". iranhr.net. Retrieved January 4, 2023.
  19. ^ Motamedi, Maziar. "Iran says more than 200 killed in country's continuing unrest". www.aljazeera.com.
  20. ^ Iran: Special Rapporteur calls for effective accountability for deaths in recent protests. OHCHR, 26. October 2022; Corinna Gall: Proteste in Iran: Die neuesten Entwicklungen. NZZ, 29. October 2022
  21. ^ "Mahsa Amini's CT Scan Shows Skull Fractures Caused By Severe Blows". Iran International. September 19, 2022. Retrieved November 12, 2022.
  22. ^ a b c d "Lesen Sie zeit.de mit Werbung oder im PUR-Abo. Sie haben die Wahl". Zeit Online. Retrieved November 12, 2022.
  23. ^ a b c d e f "Iran: Internationaler Untersuchungsmechanismus gegen Straflosigkeit notwendig". www.amnesty.de (in German). Retrieved November 12, 2022.
  24. ^ a b c d e f g h i j k l m n o p q "Amir, Nika, Mohammad: Nicht einmal vor Kindern macht die Grausamkeit des Regimes in Teheran Halt". Der Tagesspiegel Online (in German). ISSN 1865-2263. Retrieved November 12, 2022.
  25. ^ Agencias, Trinidad Deiros Bronte (October 7, 2022). "The faces of repression in Iran". EL PAÍS English Edition. Retrieved November 12, 2022.
  26. ^ a b c "Hadis, Minoo and Ghazaleh: The women victims of Iran's crackdown - Qantara.de". Qantara.de - Dialogue with the Islamic World. Retrieved November 12, 2022.
  27. ^ a b "Hengaw Report No. 5 on the Kurdistan protests, 7 dead and 450 injured". Hengaw (in Kurdish (Arabic script)). September 21, 2022. Retrieved November 12, 2022.
  28. ^ Pourahmadi, Gianluca Mezzofiore, Katie Polglase, Adam (October 27, 2022). "What really happened to Nika Shahkarami? Witnesses to her final hours cast doubt on Iran's story". CNN. Retrieved November 12, 2022.{{cite web}}: CS1 maint: multiple names: authors list (link)
  29. ^ "Nika Shakarami: Tod der Jugendlichen befeuert Proteste in Iran". Der Spiegel (in German). October 4, 2022. ISSN 2195-1349. Retrieved November 12, 2022.
  30. ^ "Iran: Death toll rising in 'alarming' crackdown on protests". Amnesty International UK (Press release). Retrieved November 12, 2022.
  31. ^ "Iran forces kill at least 20, injure 490 in protests across Kurdistan | Kurdistan Human Rights Network". KHRN. October 3, 2022. Retrieved November 12, 2022.
  32. ^ a b c d e f g h i "Shooting to kill, an unretouched image of Iran regime - Iran HRM". November 8, 2022. Retrieved November 12, 2022.
  33. ^ "Iran: Teen protester Nika Shakarami's body stolen, sources say". BBC News. October 4, 2022. Retrieved November 12, 2022.
  34. ^ a b c "Iranische Paramilitärs knüppeln erneut Jugendliche zu Tode". blue News (in German). Retrieved November 12, 2022.
  35. ^ a b c Welle (www.dw.com), Deutsche. "Tödliche Gewalt gegen iranische Schülerinnen | DW | 19.10.2022". Deutsche Welle (in German). Retrieved November 12, 2022.
  36. ^ "Iran security forces and state media cover up protester's death - source". BBC News. November 4, 2022. Retrieved November 12, 2022.
  37. ^ "Iran: 15-jährige Schülerin stirbt nach Schlägen von Sicherheitskräften". Der Spiegel (in German). October 20, 2022. ISSN 2195-1349. Retrieved November 12, 2022.
  38. ^ October 11 as the date of death Kurdish student killed by security forces in Hamadan, Iran: Hengaw. Nalia Radio and Television, 24. October 2022
  39. ^ "Stop systematic killing and torture of children in Iran". October 23, 2022. Retrieved November 12, 2022.
  40. ^ "Nächstes unschuldiges Opfer: Iranische Sittenpolizei schlägt 17-Jährige tot". RTL Online (in German). October 24, 2022. Retrieved November 12, 2022.
  41. ^ "Little Baluch girl victim of arbitrary killing in SE Iran". October 25, 2022. Retrieved November 12, 2022.
  42. ^ "Doctor In Iran Protests Killed By Security Forces". Iran International. October 29, 2022. Retrieved November 12, 2022.
  43. ^ Schoolgirl Killed by Iranian Security Forces. Iran Wire, 31. Oktober 2022; As Iran uprising continues on 46th Day, repressive forces step up their brutality. women.ncr-iran, 31. Oktober 2022
  44. ^ "Confirmed identity of another person killed by government forces". Hengaw (in Kurdish (Arabic script)). October 29, 2022. Retrieved November 12, 2022.
  45. ^ a b c d e f "Iran: UN must act urgently after authorities unlawfully kill eight protesters in less than 24 hours". Amnesty International. October 27, 2022. Retrieved November 12, 2022.
  46. ^ a b c d e f g h i j k "16 Kurdish citizens killed in the protests on the 40th day death anniversary of Zhina (Mahsa) Amini". Hengaw (in Kurdish (Arabic script)). November 2022. Retrieved November 12, 2022.
  47. ^ a b "Iran forces kill three more protesters in Sanandaj, Mahabad | Kurdistan Human Rights Network". KHRN. October 28, 2022. Retrieved November 12, 2022.
  48. ^ "Iran: deaths reported as security forces open fire on protesters in Zahedan". The Guardian. October 28, 2022. Retrieved November 12, 2022.
  49. ^ Memorials for 2 Young Women Killed in Iran Galvanize Protests. NYT, 27 October 2022
  50. ^ a b "Witness Report | Iran | Afghanistan". witness.report. Retrieved November 12, 2022.
  51. ^ "In the Sanandaj uprisings, a 16-year-old girl was killed". Hengaw (in Kurdish (Arabic script)). October 28, 2022. Retrieved November 12, 2022.
  52. ^ Schlomo (October 26, 2022). "Iran: Ermita Abbasi, nouvelle victime du régime". JForum (in French). Retrieved November 12, 2022.
  53. ^ "3 protesters killed by Iranian security forces in Sanandaj". Hengaw (in Kurdish (Arabic script)). October 27, 2022. Retrieved November 12, 2022.
  54. ^ "IRGC forces kill two civilians during protests in Iran's Baneh | Kurdistan Human Rights Network". KHRN. October 28, 2022. Retrieved November 12, 2022.
  55. ^ Bowman, Verity; Vahdat, Ahmed (October 29, 2022). "'Jamie Oliver of Iran' beaten to death after arrest at hijab protests". The Telegraph. ISSN 0307-1235. Retrieved November 12, 2022.
  56. ^ "Iranians defy crackdown as another teen reported killed". France 24. November 3, 2022. Retrieved November 12, 2022.
  57. ^ ikhumanrights.com. "Karaj; The killing of a 17-year-old teenager by the security forces". ikhumanrights.com. Retrieved November 12, 2022.
  58. ^ "Protests Death Toll Rises To 304; Tehran Youths Call For More Demos". Iran International. November 5, 2022. Retrieved November 12, 2022.
  59. ^ "Iran: Sicherheitskräfte schießen erneut auf Demonstranten". Der Spiegel (in German). November 6, 2022. ISSN 2195-1349. Retrieved November 12, 2022.
  60. ^ "Iran: Fresh protests erupt after death of Kurdish student – DW – 11/06/2022". Deutsche Welle. Retrieved November 12, 2022.
  61. ^ "Enraged By Killing Of PhD Student Kurds Clash With Iran's Police". Iran International. November 6, 2022. Retrieved November 12, 2022.
  62. ^ "20-year-old Kurdish student in Arak killed with batons by Iranian government forces". Hengaw (in Kurdish (Arabic script)). November 11, 2022. Retrieved November 12, 2022.
  63. ^ "Hemin Hamzeh". kurdistanhumanrights. Retrieved November 14, 2022.
  64. ^ "The killing of a 9-year-old boy further ignites Iran's anti-government protests". washingtonpost. Retrieved November 20, 2022.
  65. ^ "Iran protests: Two boys shot dead by security forces, family sources say". BBC News. November 17, 2022. Retrieved January 1, 2024.
  66. ^ Ciddi, Behzad; Cavanşir, Lalə; Cabbarlı, Ramin; Bozkurt, Türkan. Iran: Updates on the Human Rights Report on the Azerbaijani Turks in Iran (PDF). etekyazi.com. p. 14. Archived (PDF) from the original on June 11, 2023. Retrieved December 27, 2023.
  67. ^ "Təbrizdə öyrənci fəal Aylar Həqqi məmurlar tərəfindən öldürülüb". aznews.tv. November 17, 2022. Archived from the original on December 28, 2023. Retrieved December 28, 2023.
  68. ^ Халип, Ирина (November 25, 2022). "Волосы. Три покушения, изгнание, 10 миллионов подписчиков и "Тайная свобода" — история Масих Алинеджад, одной из лидеров иранских протестов". Новая газета Европа. Archived from the original on October 29, 2023. Retrieved December 29, 2023.
  69. ^ "Təbrizdə gənc Aylar Həqqi öldürüldü". Qafqazinfo (in Azerbaijani). November 19, 2022. Archived from the original on December 27, 2023. Retrieved December 27, 2023.
  70. ^ "ح مله نیروهای امنیتی به مراسم خاکسپاری آیلار حقی در تبریز؛ پلیس علت مرگ او را هم سقوط از بلندی اعلام کرد - BBC News فارسی". November 18, 2022. Archived from the original on November 18, 2022. Retrieved December 28, 2023.{{cite web}}: CS1 maint: unfit URL (link)
  71. ^ فردا, رادیو (November 18, 2022). "آیلار حقی با "شلیک مستقیم به پشت سرش توسط نیروهای حکومتی" کشته شد". رادیو فردا (in Persian). Archived from the original on November 18, 2022. Retrieved December 28, 2023.
  72. ^ Dehkordi, Maryam (February 24, 2023). ""They Shot Me, Sister:" The Women Victims Of Iran Protest Crackdown". iranwire.com. Archived from the original on November 3, 2023. Retrieved December 29, 2023.
  73. ^ "Qatilə çevrilən Tehran hakimiyyəti: Arzuları gözündə qalan gənc Ayların ölümü - ŞƏRH + FOTO". Oxu.Az (in Azerbaijani). November 19, 2022. Archived from the original on December 28, 2023. Retrieved December 28, 2023.
  74. ^ "خشم از کشتن کیان پیرفلک؛ معترضان "خانه خمینی" را آتش زدند - BBC Persian". BBC News فارسی (in Persian). Archived from the original on November 18, 2022. Retrieved December 28, 2023.
  75. ^ Cole, Brendan (November 18, 2022). "Who Is Aylar Haghi? Medical student killed during protests in Iran". Newsweek. Archived from the original on October 23, 2023. Retrieved December 29, 2023.
  76. ^ "Iran secretly executes man over 2022 anti-government protests - sources". BBC. November 23, 2023. Retrieved April 19, 2024.
edit
Retrieved from "https://en.wikipedia.org/w/index.php?title=Deaths_during_the_Mahsa_Amini_protests&oldid=1249087616"