These are the songs that reached number one in the USA on the Top 60 Best Sellers chart (expanded to 75 on June 21, 1958, and 100 on September 13, 1958) in 1958 as published by Cash Box magazine.
| † | Indicates best-performing single of 1958 |
| Issue date | Song | Artist |
|---|---|---|
| January 4 | At the Hop | Danny & the Juniors |
| January 11 | ||
| January 18 | ||
| January 25 | ||
| February 1 | ||
| February 8 | The Stroll | The Diamonds |
| February 15 | ||
| February 22 | Get a Job | The Silhouettes |
| March 1 | Don't | Elvis Presley |
| March 8 | Get a Job | The Silhouettes |
| March 15 | Tequila | The Champs |
| March 22 | ||
| March 29 | ||
| April 5 | ||
| April 12 | ||
| April 19 | He's Got The Whole World (In His Hands) | Laurie London |
| April 26 | ||
| May 3 | Twilight Time | The Platters |
| May 10 | Witch Doctor | David Seville |
| May 17 | All I Have to Do Is Dream | The Everly Brothers |
| May 24 | ||
| May 31 | ||
| June 7 | ||
| June 14 | The Purple People Eater | Sheb Wooley |
| June 21 | ||
| June 28 | ||
| July 5 | ||
| July 12 | ||
| July 19 | Yakety Yak | The Coasters |
| July 26 | Patricia | Perez Prado & Orchestra |
| August 2 | ||
| August 9 | ||
| August 16 | ||
| August 23 | Nel Blu Dipinto Di Blu (Volare) † | Domenico Modugno, Dean Martin |
| August 30 | ||
| September 6 | ||
| September 13 | ||
| September 20 | ||
| September 27 | ||
| October 4 | It's All in the Game | Tommy Edwards |
| October 11 | ||
| October 18 | ||
| October 25 | ||
| November 1 | ||
| November 8 | Topsy Part 2 | Cozy Cole |
| November 15 | It's Only Make Believe | Conway Twitty |
| November 22 | Tom Dooley | The Kingston Trio |
| November 29 | ||
| December 6 | ||
| December 13 | To Know Him Is to Love Him | The Teddy Bears |
| December 20 | The Chipmunk Song | Chipmunks with David Seville |
| December 27 |