The following is a list of University Football Club leading goalkickers in each of their seasons in the Victorian Football League.
| + | Player won Leading Goalkicker Medal in same season | |
| Season | Leading Goalkicker | Goals |
|---|---|---|
| 1908 | Martin Ratz | 25 |
| 1909 | Albert Hartkopf | 19 |
| 1910 | Albert Hartkopf (2) | 30 |
| 1911 | Albert Hartkopf (3) | 19 |
| 1912 | Roy Park | 22 |
| 1913 | Roy Park (2) | 53 |
| 1914 | Roy Park (3) | 36 |
Note: Park also won the VFL's Leading Goalkicker Award in 1913 with 53 goals for the home-and-away season, a remarkable effort considering the team itself scored only 115 goals for the year.