Year
|
Nominated work
|
Award
|
Category
|
Result
|
1992
|
Romper Stomper
|
Seattle International Film Festival
|
Best Actor
|
Won
|
1993
|
Hammers Over the Anvil
|
Won
|
1999
|
The Insider
|
Broadcast Film Critics Association
|
Best Actor
|
Won
|
1999
|
London Film Critics Circle
|
Best Actor
|
Won
|
1999
|
Los Angeles Film Critics Association
|
Best Actor
|
Won
|
1999
|
National Board of Review
|
Best Actor
|
Won
|
1999
|
National Society of Film Critics
|
Best Actor
|
Won
|
1999
|
San Diego Film Critics Society
|
Best Actor
|
Won
|
1999
|
Southeastern Film Critics Association
|
Best Actor
|
Won
|
1999
|
New York Film Critics Circle
|
Best Actor
|
Nominated
|
1999
|
Chicago Film Critics Association
|
Best Actor
|
Nominated
|
1999
|
Las Vegas Film Critics Society
|
Best Actor
|
Nominated
|
1999
|
Online Film Critics Society
|
Best Actor
|
Nominated
|
2000
|
Gladiator
|
Broadcast Film Critics Association
|
Best Actor
|
Won
|
2000
|
Dallas-Fort Worth Film Critics Association
|
Best Actor
|
Won
|
2000
|
London Film Critics Circle
|
Best Actor
|
Won
|
2000
|
San Diego Film Critics Society
|
Best Actor
|
Won
|
2000
|
Las Vegas Film Critics Society
|
Best Actor
|
Nominated
|
2000
|
Online Film Critics Society
|
Best Actor
|
Nominated
|
2001
|
A Beautiful Mind
|
Broadcast Film Critics Association
|
Best Actor
|
Won
|
2001
|
Dallas-Fort Worth Film Critics Association
|
Best Actor
|
Won
|
2001
|
San Diego Film Critics Society
|
Best Actor
|
Won
|
2001
|
Phoenix Film Critics Society
|
Best Actor
|
Won
|
2001
|
Chicago Film Critics Association
|
Best Actor
|
Nominated
|
2001
|
Online Film Critics Society
|
Best Actor
|
Nominated
|
2001
|
Vancouver Film Critics Circle
|
Best Actor
|
Nominated
|
2003
|
Master and Commander: The Far Side of the World
|
Broadcast Film Critics Association
|
Best Actor
|
Nominated
|
2003
|
London Film Critics Circle
|
Best Actor
|
Nominated
|
2005
|
Cinderella Man
|
Broadcast Film Critics Association
|
Best Actor
|
Nominated
|
2005
|
Dallas-Fort Worth Film Critics Association
|
Best Actor
|
Nominated
|
2012
|
Les Misérables
|
Washington D.C. Area Film Critics Association
|
Best Ensemble
|
Won
|
2012
|
Broadcast Film Critics Association
|
Best Acting Ensemble
|
Nominated
|
2012
|
Phoenix Film Critics Society
|
Best Cast
|
Nominated
|
2012
|
San Diego Film Critics Society
|
Best Performance by an Ensemble
|
Nominated
|
2019
|
The Loudest Voice
|
Critics' Choice Television Award
|
Best Actor in a Movie/Miniseries
|
Nominated
|