State
Name
Hometown
Age
Talent
Placement
Awards
Notes
Alabama
Anna Stange
Birmingham
Monologue from Mourning Becomes Electra
Non-finalist Talent Award
Arizona
Lynn Freyse
Tucson
Dramatic Reading from The Country Girl
Top 10
Preliminary Lifestyle & Fitness Award
Later starred in the TV series Hazel
Arkansas
Suzanne Scudder
Hot Springs
Vocal
California
Lorna Anderson
Sacramento
Accordion, "Dark Eyes "
3rd runner-up
Canada
Joan May Fitzpatrick
Windsor
Chicago
Bette Lieb
Chicago
Dramatic Monologue from Romeo and Juliet
Colorado
Marilyn Van Derbur
Denver
20
Organ, "Tea for Two " & "Tenderly"
Winner
Connecticut
Susan Lightbown
Fairfield
Vocal, "Wouldn't it be Loverly " from My Fair Lady
Non-finalist Talent Award
Delaware
Kathleen Ann D'Attillio
Wilimington
Piano
District of Columbia
June Cook
Arlington, VA
20
Piano, "Rhapsody in Blue "
Florida
Dorothy Maria Steiner
Boca Raton
Dramatic Reading, "Such is Your Heritage"
4th runner-up
Georgia
Jody Shattuck
Atlanta
20
Vocal & Dance, "Namely You" from Li'l Abner
1st runner-up
Preliminary Lifestyle & Fitness Award
Hawaii
Sandra Lei Lauhiwa Forsythe
Honolulu
Hula
Idaho
Carene Clark
Pocatello
Classical Vocal from Die Fledermaus
Non-finalist Talent Award
Illinois
Jeannie Beacham
Downers Grove
Drama, "The Great Debates"
Indiana
Gloria Rupprecht
Valparaiso
Vocal/Comedy Skit, "My Hero"
Preliminary Talent Award
Iowa
Carol Fleck
Oskaloosa
19
Dance
Kansas
Georgiana Rundle
Axtell
21
Vocal, "Habanera " & "Getting to Know You "
Kentucky
Jane Brock
Liberty
Piano
Non-finalist Talent Award
Louisiana
Beverly Leigh Norman
Shreveport
Vocal, "My Own True Love"
Maine
Carol Ann Bartels
Bath
Drama/Art
Maryland
Nancy Elizabeth Norris
Silver Spring
Dramatic Monologue, "A Letter to my Parents"
Massachusetts
Daly Hirsch
Boston
Drama
Michigan
Valerie Strong
Williamsburg
Piano, "Brazil"
Minnesota
Ardyce Gustafson
St. Paul
Vocal Medley from My Fair Lady
Mississippi
Mary Allen
Yazoo City
Dance & Art Presentation
Missouri
Sara Cooper
Buckner
Charleston Dance
Top 10
Preliminary Talent Award
Daughter of Major League Baseball player, Walker Cooper
Nebraska
Kathleen L. Nielsen
Lincoln
Dance
Non-finalist Talent Award
Later Miss Iowa USA 1959
Nevada
Loni Gravelle
Reno
Piano, "Piano Concerto in A Minor " by Edvard Grieg
Top 10
New Hampshire
Holly Arnel
New London
Drama
New Jersey
Janet Ressler
Union
Vocal
New Mexico
Glynnelle Hubbard
Farmington
19
Dance
Miss Congeniality
New York
Janet Corrigan
Huntington
Vocal, "True Love"
New York City
Astrid Papamichael
New York City
Vocal
North Carolina
Elaine Herndon
Durham
Vocal & Dance
Top 10
Preliminary Lifestyle & Fitness Award
North Dakota
Helen Winje
Minot
Vocal
Ohio
Linda Hattman
Mansfield
Ballet
Oklahoma
Mary Nancy Denner
Alva
Poetry Recitation, "The Ballad of the Harp Weaver" by Edna St. Vincent Millay
2nd runner-up
Oregon
Judith Hansen
Astoria
Classical Vocal, "Mi Chiamano Mimi" from La bohéme
Top 10
Preliminary Talent Award
Pennsylvania
Jennie Rebecca Blatchford
Hollidaysburg
Baton Twirling, "St. Louis Blues" & "The Stars and Stripes Forever "
Preliminary Talent Award
Puerto Rico
Winnie Rodríguez
Rhode Island
Beatrice Turek
Providence
Art Display
South Carolina
Cecilia Colvert
Greenwood
18
Pantomime/Vocal, "C'est si bon " by Eartha Kitt
Mother of Miss South Carolina 1988, Anna Graham Reynolds
South Dakota
Patricia Miller
Mobridge
Vocal
Tennessee
Amanda Lee Whitman
Nashville
Trampoline/Tumbling, "The Third Man Theme "
Performed the first trampoline talent act in the Miss America competition
Texas
Carolyn Calvert
Austin
Monologue from Medea
Utah
Francine Louise Felt
Salt Lake City
Violin
Non-finalist Talent Award
Vermont
Joan Hewitt
Brattleboro
Art Presentation & Original Skit with original music
Non-finalist Talent Award
Virginia
Rebecca Lee Edmunds
Roanoke
Dance
West Virginia
Janice Sickle
Fairmont
Vocal & Dance
Wisconsin
Joan Hentschel
Wauwatosa
18
Interpretive Dance, "3:00 in the Morning"