Wikipedia

Nigel Farage Coutts bank scandal

In June 2023, the private bank Coutts closed the account held by the British politician and broadcaster Nigel Farage, triggering controversy. NatWest, the owner of Coutts, initially claimed that he failed to meet the Coutts eligibility criteria of holding £1,000,000 or more in his account, following the expiry of his mortgage. NatWest instead offered him an account with the retail side of the bank.

Farage in 2018

After Farage went to the press about the closure, it was discovered that Coutts had closed Farage's account as they deemed him to be "at best seen as xenophobic and pandering to racists". Following media attention, the NatWest CEO, Dame Alison Rose, resigned.

Events

edit

In June 2023, the British politician Nigel Farage said that his account with the private bank Coutts was to be closed.[1] He was offered a standard bank account by Coutts' parent group, NatWest, in the closure notice he received.[2] Farage said he was then refused personal and business accounts at seven other UK banks.[1] When pressed by Farage to reveal why, NatWest said that he failed to meet the Coutts eligibility criteria as he did not hold £1,000,000 or more in his account following the expiry of his mortgage.[3]

The story was picked up by the UK press. It was later revealed that Farage's account was closed in part as Coutts felt that his beliefs and values did not align with theirs. In an internal dossier, Coutts wrote that he "is at best seen as xenophobic and pandering to racists" and considered a "disingenuous grifter".[3]

In a front-page story on 20 July, The Daily Telegraph reported that the Coutts CEO, Dame Alison Rose, had dined with Simon Jack, the business editor for BBC News, on the evening before he published an article saying that the decision had been "for commercial reasons". Peter Bone MP and David Jones MP were reported as calling for Rose to resign.[4][5]

Documents disclosed by the bank to Farage following his submission of a subject access request showed that the decision by the bank's Wealth Reputational Risk Committee to close his accounts, according to the 40-page dossier, was in part due to his views being considered incompatible with the bank's "values or purpose". The dossier revealed that Farage was classed as a "lower risk" politically exposed person (PEP).[3] It went to note that the bank considered declassifying Farage as a PEP on their next review in 2022. His status was maintained, however, in 2023, owing to his public profile and reported links to Russia.[3]

Within the document, an update to Farage's notes from 10 March 2023 stated "The relationship has been below commercial criteria for some time and upon review of Nigel's past public profile and connections, the perceived risks for the future weighed against the benefit of retention the decision was taken to exit upon repayment of an existing mortgage."[3] It adds that continuing to do business with him was "not compatible with Coutts given his publicly-stated views" and the decision was "This was not a political decision but one centred around inclusivity and purpose".[6]

Rose was accused of holding ultimate responsibility for the decision to close Farage's accounts.[7] On 25 July, Rose admitted to a "serious error of judgement" in discussing Farage's Coutts accounts with Jack, while the NatWest board said that it retained full confidence in her.[8] Later that day, Rose resigned as CEO of NatWest Group with immediate effect.[9][10]

On 26 July, Farage called on the whole of the NatWest board to resign.[11] On 27 July, the Coutts chief executive Peter Flavel stepped down with immediate effect.[12] Then-UK Prime Minister Rishi Sunak expressed support for Farage in his dispute with the bank.[13]

In October 2023, it was reported that the ICO ruled that Rose twice violated the law,[14] as it upheld two parts of Farage’s complaint concerning the treatment of his personal data,[15] but the ICO later withdrew the comment about Rose, and apologised to her, saying that their ruling related only to NatWest.[16] In the same month, an investigation by lawyers Travers Smith, appointed by NatWest, found that the bank had acted in a "lawful" manner when it closed Farage's account, but had "failed to treat him fairly". The Financial Conduct Authority said that the report by Travers Smith revealed "potential regulatory breaches" by the bank.[17] Farage described the Travers Smith report as a “whitewash”.[18]

Reaction

edit


Criticism has been laid at some media organisations for their coverage. Miqdaad Versi said some outlets have disproportionately focused on Farage's financial affairs while neglecting similar instances involving the de-banking of Muslim organisations and individuals.[19] In 2014, when HSBC closed the account of a number of Muslim organisations in the UK, garnering similar concerns around freedom of speech and religion, HSBC stated decisions to close the accounts were "absolutely not based on race or religion".[20] In 2016, the Co-op Bank closed the bank account of the pro-Palestinian non-governmental organisation Friends of Al-Aqsa, the Palestinian Solidarity Campaign, and approximately 25 other Palestinian-affiliated organisations. The closures were said to have occurred without providing any explanation for the action.[21] At the time the government commented saying it had delegated to banks the role of de-risking their clients for potential suspicious financing or money laundering.[21][22]

Gina Miller, a pro-European Union activist, had a bank account for her political party closed down by Monzo with no explanation. Monzo subsequently stated that it did not provide bank accounts for political parties and that it had approved the account by mistake in the first place. Farage, a political opponent of Miller, called it "plain wrong" for her account to be closed down.[23][24]

British journalist Emily Maitlis criticised the media coverage for "whipping up a populist storm" over the affair, claiming that the incident was a private company making a commercial decision to end a relationship, over political views.[25] She went on to say Farage had somehow turned "utter entitlement into victimhood" given he had been offered a standard account rather than a private banking account, despite meeting the bank's requirements for an account.[26][27]

References

edit
  1. ^ a b O'Dwyer, Ellen (29 June 2023). "What we know about Nigel Farage's claim he has been shut out of his bank accounts". inews.co.uk. Retrieved 30 June 2023.
  2. ^ "Nigel Farage says set to lose Coutts account, offered NatWest one instead". Reuters. 2023-07-05. Retrieved 2023-08-02.
  3. ^ a b c d e "Key points from Coutts' dossier on Nigel Farage". Sky News. Retrieved 2023-08-02.
  4. ^ Gordon Rayner, Daniel Martin, Louisa Clarence-Smith, "NatWest boss under pressure over Farage bank scandal", The Daily Telegraph, page 1, 20 July 2023, accessed 20 July 2023
  5. ^ Gordon Rayner, "Bank chief Dame Alison sat next to BBC journalist night before he tweeted claim about Nigel Farage", The Daily Telegraph, 19 July 2023, accessed 20 July 2023 (subscription required)
  6. ^ "Nigel Farage: Coutts document 'shows bank account shut over my views'". BBC News. 2023-07-18. Retrieved 2023-08-02.
  7. ^ Johnston, Neil (2023-07-18). "Dame Alison Rose: the bank boss who steered Coutts' diversity drive". The Telegraph. ISSN 0307-1235. Retrieved 2023-07-19.
  8. ^ "NatWest boss 'made serious error of judgement' in discussing Farage bank accounts with BBC reporter". Sky News. Retrieved 25 July 2023.
  9. ^ "NatWest boss steps down with immediate effect over Nigel Farage bank account leak". Sky News. Retrieved 26 July 2023.
  10. ^ Issac, Anna; Makortoff, Kalyeena (3 July 2023). "NatWest boss Alison Rose resigns over Nigel Farage Coutts account row". The Guardian. Retrieved 25 July 2023.
  11. ^ "Nigel Farage says more NatWest bosses must go in Coutts row". BBC News.
  12. ^ Taafe-Maguire, Sarah (27 July 2023). "Coutts chief executive stands down over Nigel Farage banking row". Sky News. Retrieved 27 July 2023.
  13. ^ Alex Wickham. Bloomberg reporter. (28 July 2023). "Sunak Gambles With Lurch to Right as UK Moderates Flee to Labour". Yahoo News website Retrieved 31 July 2023.
  14. ^ Tom Witherow; Ben Martin (25 October 2023). "NatWest's Alison Rose broke data law in Nigel Farage fiasco". The Times. Retrieved 26 October 2023. The former chief of NatWest twice breached data protection laws
  15. ^ Makortoff, Kalyeena (25 October 2023). "Ex-NatWest chief breached Nigel Farage's privacy, watchdog rules". theguardian.com. Guardian. Retrieved 26 October 2023.
  16. ^ Makortoff, Kalyeena (6 November 2023). "ICO apologises to ex-NatWest chief over claim she broke privacy law on Farage". theguardian.com. Guardian. Retrieved 6 November 2023.
  17. ^ Makortoff, Kalyeena (27 October 2023). "NatWest decision to close Nigel Farage's bank accounts was lawful, says report". theguardian.com. Guardian. Retrieved 29 October 2023.
  18. ^ Race, Michael (10 November 2023). "Ex-NatWest boss Alison Rose loses out on £7.6m after Nigel Farage row". bbc.co.uk. BBC. Retrieved 12 November 2023.
  19. ^ Versi, Miqdaad (2023-07-28). "Where were Nigel Farage and his defenders when Muslim bank accounts were shut down?". The Guardian. ISSN 0261-3077. Retrieved 2023-08-02.
  20. ^ "HSBC closes some Muslim groups' accounts". BBC News. 2014-07-30. Retrieved 2023-08-02.
  21. ^ a b "Co-op Bank has shut down accounts belonging to Palestinian NGOs". The Independent. 2016-01-11. Retrieved 2023-08-02.
  22. ^ "Diane Abbott has said the Tories are 'failing to hold bankers to account' for severing ties with Islamic charities". The Independent. 2016-01-08. Retrieved 2023-08-02.
  23. ^ Eardley, Nick (28 July 2023). "Gina Miller's political party bank account to be closed". BBC News. Retrieved 13 August 2023.
  24. ^ Mitchell, Archie (28 July 2023). "Anti-Brexit campaigner calls for investigation into banks after Monzo account closed". The Independent. Retrieved 13 August 2023.
  25. ^ @TheNewsAgents (July 26, 2023). ""The power of the populist is, somehow, to turn utter entitlement into victimhood." @maitlis on Nigel Farage using his Coutts bank account closure to provoke a culture war. Coming to @GlobalPlayer" (Tweet). Retrieved 2023-08-02 – via Twitter.
  26. ^ Lough, Catherine (2023-07-27). "Nigel Farage playing victim in NatWest row, says Emily Maitlis". The Telegraph. ISSN 0307-1235. Retrieved 2023-08-02.
  27. ^ "Nigel Farage: BBC apologises to Farage over account closure story". BBC News. 2023-07-24. Retrieved 2023-08-02.
Retrieved from "https://en.wikipedia.org/w/index.php?title=Nigel_Farage_Coutts_bank_scandal&oldid=1257174881"