Wikipedia

Old age and driving

The correlation between old age and driving has been a notable topic for many years.[1][2] In 2018, there were over 45 million licensed drivers in the United States over the age of 65—a 60% increase from 2000.[3] Driving is said to help older adults stay mobile and independent, but as their age increases the risk of potentially injuring themselves or others significantly increases as well. In 2019, drivers 65 years and older accounted for 8,760 motor vehicle traffic deaths, and 205,691 non-fatal accidents.[4] Due to their physical frailty, older drivers are more likely to be injured in an accident and more likely to die of that injury. When frailty is accounted for and older drivers are compared to younger persons driving the same amount the over-representation disappears.[5] According to the Insurance Institute for Highway Safety, a senior citizen is more likely than a younger driver to be at fault in an accident in which they are involved.[6] The most common violations include: failure to obey traffic signals, unsafe turns and passing, and failure to yield.[7]

Physical strength, mental acuity, and motor function begin to deteriorate as a person ages, but the degree of decline varies from person to person.[8] There is currently no age cutoff preventing an older adult from driving in the United States.[9] Although, there are some voluntary measures a person can utilize to check their driving abilities. According to the Centers for Disease Control and Prevention, precautionary measures include driving in daylight and good weather, planning the route before departing and receiving an eye exam once a year. Despite these measures, often, family members of an elderly person are faced with the responsibility of trying to get them to give up driving. This can be challenging because few senior citizens are voluntarily willing to give up their own car keys.[10]

Most state laws allow senior citizens to continue driving provided they meet the same requirements as younger adults.[11] Some states require persons above a specified age to take certain tests when renewing their licenses, up to and including a road test, or to receive a physician's certificate stating they are medically fit to operate a motor vehicle.[12] Some older adults may be permitted to drive, but with added limitations such as the amount of driving they can do, the hours in which they can drive, or the distance from home they can travel. These restrictions may be placed either by the law or their insurance provider which vary by state.[13]

As the process of aging varies from one person to the next, the age at which an elderly person's ability to safely operate a motor vehicle declines varies between persons. This creates controversy in regulating driving in the elderly. Senior citizens are seen by some as among the safest drivers on the road, as they generally do not speed or take risks, and they are more likely to wear seatbelts.[14] Others believe there should be increased testing to ensure older drivers are capable of safe driving.[1]

The AARP staunchly opposes testing elderly drivers on the basis of age as age discrimination, and argued the decision to retire from driving should be left to the individual.

Senses, physical abilities, and cognition

edit

There are a multitude of conditions that correlate with old age and have negative effects on senses, physical abilities, and driving capabilities.[15]

The following are two senses that are important for safe driving:

  • Vision: With aging, the lens of the eye loses its transparency and becomes cloudy, a condition commonly known as cataracts.[16] This increases the light scattering by the eye's optical system[16] and is associated with causing disability glare and increased risk of being involved in a crash.[17] Other common age related vision conditions that can affect driving performance are glaucoma and macular degeneration. Glaucoma leads to peripheral vision loss and blindness in advanced disease.
  • Hearing: Age-related hearing loss or presbycusis is a common condition in people over the age of 65.[18] Studies have shown that elderly with hearing loss are more likely to be involved in crashes and commit traffic violations.[19] Additionally, older drivers with hearing loss demonstrate worse driving performance in the presence of distractors than those with good hearing[20] and restricted driving mobility.

Physical abilities such as motor skills are important for driving ability:

  • Motor skills: Aging causes decreased physical abilities, such as gross and fine motor skills and reflexes, thereby rendering the driver physically unable to perform at a safe level.[21][22] As age increases, there is a reduction in muscle mass and elasticity, bone mass, central and peripheral nerve fibers.[23] These partly explain why an elderly motorist may drive more slowly.[24]

Cognition is reduced with age and affects driving ability.

Signs of impairment

edit

An aging person may have some issues admitting they are no longer fit to take the wheel. It may be difficult to talk with a loved one who has a driving impairment, but it is essential to communicate the importance of safety when operating a motor vehicle.

The following are considered signs that an elderly person's driving may be impaired:[25]

  • Confusion while driving somewhere
  • Having two or more minor accidents in a short period of time
  • Thinking the speed limit is too high
  • Others not feeling comfortable riding in a vehicle with the driver

Aging individuals should be asked the following questions:[26]

  • When driving, do objects such as parked cars or pedestrians catch them by surprise?
  • Do they have difficulty seeing other cars before the driver honks? Do they get honked by other drivers for reasons you don't understand?
  • Do they have limited neck rotation?
  • Are their reflexes slower and reaction time longer than they used to be?
  • Do they ever feel momentarily confused, nervous, or uncomfortable while driving?
  • Has a family member ever suggested that they should stop driving?
  • Do you have a low-contrast sensitivity? For example, do they have trouble seeing a grey car at dusk, a black car at night, or a white car on a snowy roadway?
  • Is your visual acuity on a 20/20 scale below the minimum level required by your state?

Growing concern

edit

The number of older drivers on the road is growing and bound to increase at a more rapid rate, as more baby boomers become seniors.[7] According to an AARP spokeswoman, by 2030 over 78 million boomers will be 65+, and research shows that men will outlive their driving abilities by six years and women by 10.[27]

A 2003 Gallup showed that 89% of Americans were in favor of increased testing requirements of individuals over the age of 65.[28] However, support for a driving age restriction under 70 years old was met with less than 10% support among those surveyed, whereas 64% of respondents believed there should to be no age limits at all.[28]

Approximately 9,000 senior aged drivers died from driving accidents in 2019, and more than 200,000 were treated in the emergency department for driving related injuries.[4] Gallup reported that more Americans believed teenagers pose a greater driving risk than adults over the age of 75.[4] Studies have shown that the highest driving accidents rates are among drivers aged less than 20 and those greater than 65.[29] However, drivers above the age of 85 are 3 times more likely to be in a fatal crash compared to those aged less than 20, and 20 times more likely than drivers aged less than 60.[30]

Becoming a Safer Driver

edit

There are some changes that older drivers can adopt to help some conditions that come with old aging.[31]

  • Physical therapy can help improve strength and flexibility to help elderly individuals who have trouble turning their heads while driving.
  • Eye doctors can prescribe glasses or contact lenses to help with vision related conditions.
    • Older drivers should avoid driving at night if they have trouble seeing in the dark.

Driving rules for older drivers in the United States

edit

The 50 states differ in their laws governing drivers' licenses for older adults:

License Renewal Laws in the United States
State License Renewal Laws for younger adults[32][11] License Renewal Laws for older adults[32][11]
Alabama All licenses are renewed every four years. No additional rules for older drivers.
Alaska

All licenses are renewed every five years.

At age 69, licenses cannot be renewed by mail.
Arizona All licenses expire at age 65 and then renewed every 12 years. At age 70, renewal cannot be done by mail.
Arkansas

All licenses are renewed every four years.

No additional rules for older drivers.
California All licenses are renewed every five years. At age 70, licenses are renewed with in-person examination (written test and eye exam).
Colorado All licenses are renewed every 10 years. At age 70, licenses are renewed with in-person examination (written test and eye exam).
Connecticut

All licenses are renewed every six years.

No additional rules for older drivers.
Delaware

All licenses are renewed every eight years.

No additional rules for older drivers.
District of Columbia All licenses are renewed every eight years. At age 70, licenses must be renewed in person with clearance from a doctor.
Florida All licenses are renewed every eight years. At age 80, licenses are renewed six years with eye exam.
Georgia All licenses are renewed every eight years. At age 59, licenses are renewed every five years and after age 64 an eye exam is required.
Hawaii All licenses are renewed every eight years. At age 72, licenses are renewed every two years.
Idaho All licenses are renewed every eight years. At age 64, licenses are renewed every four years.
Illinois All licenses are renewed every four years. At age 75, license renewal requires a road test and eye exam.

At age 81, license renewal occurs every two years.

At age 87, license renewal occurs annually.

Indiana All licenses are renewed every six years. At age 75, licenses are renewed every three years.

At age 85. licenses are renewed every two years.

Iowa All licenses are renewed every five years. At age 70, licenses are renewed every two years.
Kansas All licenses are renewed every six years with eye exam. At age 65, licenses are renewed every four years.
Kentucky

All licenses are renewed every four years.

No additional rules for older drivers.
Louisiana All licenses are renewed every four years. At age 70, licenses must be renewed in-person.
Maine All licenses are renewed every six years. At age 40, a vision test is required for first renewal.

At age 65, licenses are renewed every four years.

Maryland All licenses are renewed every eight years. At age 40, a vision test is required for every renewal.
Massachusetts All licenses are renewed every five years. At age 75, licenses must be renewed in-person with an eye exam or vision screening.
Michigan

All licenses are renewed every four years.

No additional rules for older drivers.
Minnesota

All licenses are renewed every four years.

No additional rules for older drivers.
Mississippi

All licenses are renewed every eight years.

No additional rules for older drivers.
Missouri All licenses are renewed every six years. At age 70, licenses are renewed every three years.
Montana All licenses are renewed every eight years. At age 75, licenses are renewed every four years.
Nebraska All licenses are renewed every five years. At age 72, licenses must be renewed in-person.
Nevada All licenses are renewed every four years. At age 71, licenses must be renewed in-person.
New Hampshire

All licenses are renewed every five years.

No additional rules for older drivers.
New Jersey

All licenses are renewed every four years.

No additional rules for older drivers.
New Mexico All licenses are renewed every four or eight years with a vision test. At age 67, licenses are renewed every four years.

At age 75, licenses are renewed annually.

New York

All licenses are renewed every eight years.

No additional rules for older drivers.
North Carolina All licenses are renewed every eight years. At age 66, licenses are renewed every five years.
North Dakota All licenses are renewed every four years. At age 78, licenses are renewed every six years.
Ohio All licenses are renewed every four years. No additional rules for older drivers.
Oklahoma

All licenses are renewed every four years.

No additional rules for older drivers.
Oregon All licenses are renewed every eight years. At age 50, license renewal requires vision screening.
Pennsylvania

All licenses are renewed every four years.

No additional rules for older drivers.
Rhode Island All licenses are renewed every five years. At age 75, licenses are renewed every two years.
South Carolina All licenses are renewed every ten years. At age 65, licenses are renewed every five years and require a vision test.
South Dakota All licenses are renewed every five years. No additional rules for older drivers.
Tennessee All licenses are renewed every five years. No additional rules for older drivers.
Texas All licenses are renewed every six years. At age 79, licenses must be renewed in-person.

At age 85, licenses are renewed every two years.

Utah All licenses are renewed every five years. At age 65, licenses renewal requires an eye exam.
Vermont All licenses are renewed every four years. No additional rules for older drivers.
Virginia All licenses are renewed every eight years. At age 80, license renewal must occur in person with an eye examination.
Washington All licenses are renewed every five years. At age 65, licenses must be renewed in-person.
West Virginia All licenses are renewed every five years. No additional rules for older drivers.
Wisconsin All licenses are renewed every eight years. No additional rules for older drivers.
Wyoming All licenses are renewed every four years. No additional rules for older drivers.

Effects of giving up driving

edit

The operation of a private vehicle is essential to life in many places, especially to one's independence.[33] After losing their ability to drive, an elderly person may be forced to make major lifestyle changes, often becoming unable to perform activities they once were able to. The following effects have been noted in former drivers.[34]

Health effects

  • Reduced physical mobility and functioning due to decreased exercise and participation in outside activities.
  • Increased risk of developing depression.
  • Increased acceleration of cognitive decline.
  • Increased mortality risk (4-6 times more likely to die as drivers).

Social fffects

  • Increased risk of social isolation.
  • Decreased social health (i.e. social engagement, social contacts/support, social satisfaction).
  • Increased admittance to long-term care facilities.

The inability to drive results in increased dependence on caregivers for social and medical transportation.[35] According to the National Aging and Disability Transportation Center, family caregivers spend approximately 5 hours a day arranging or providing transportation for senior family members.[36] [failed verification] This increased caregiver responsibility can conflict with work or other life demands, often resulting in an inability to help seniors.

Where available, some senior citizens may turn to public transportation or paratransit for medical appointments and personal needs.[35] Though individuals can find alternative means of transportation, these alternatives may be more limiting than one's own car.

Senior-friendly transportation

edit

Because giving up driving is viewed by the elderly as a loss of their independence, many may be reluctant to seek out alternative forms of transportation when they are no longer able to drive. The best way for transit providers to meet the transportation needs of most older Americans is to meet the transportation needs of the general adult population. Their needs are similar to other age groups: shopping, getting to work, medical appointments, going to restaurants and visiting friends.[37] Seniors are looking for travel services that provide control, autonomy, and choice.[37] The National Center on Senior Transportation (NCST) states that 83% of older Americans agree that public transit provides easy access to the things that they need in everyday life.[38]

Self-driving cars have also been proposed as an alternative for senior citizens who are unable to drive.[39] However, studies have shown that autonomous vehicles have not gained acceptance among some older adults.[40]

Five A's of Senior-Friendly Transportation

edit

The Beverly Foundation developed these five aspects to greater encompass the necessary requirements to create a senior-friendly transportation alternative:[41][42]

  • Availability: This alone is not the solution to transportation challenges for older adults. Most public and community transportation systems require passengers to get to a transit stop or to the curb in order to use their services, and senior-friendly transportation must be different. The same limitations that make it difficult/impossible for seniors to drive also can make it difficult for them to get to the transit stop or the curb, or even to get on or off a vehicle without assistance.
  • Acceptability: This suggests senior passenger criteria of comfort and convenience of service. Seniors may have higher standards for transportation because they are used to their personal vehicles. Senior-friendly transportation needs to recognize these standards to which it is being measured.
  • Accessibility: Passengers must be able to access the service and the vehicle. The system must take services to the passengers, and offer them assistance and support prior to, during, and following their travel, coined as "door-to-door, door-through-door, and at-the-destination assistance."[42]
  • Adaptability: Calls for the service to meet the assistance needs of older adults. Multi-stop metro and bus rides are more difficult for elderly because they lack flexibility, which is essential for senior-friendly transportation. It needs to be able to accommodate the use of walkers and service animals, also.
  • Affordability: Aims for transportation to be affordable to passengers and to the transportation services. Research shows it can cost between $5000 and $7500 a year to own and operate an automobile.[42] However, when older adults can no longer drive, they rarely convert savings in automobile ownership into funds which they can use for another transportation option. Senior-friendly transportation systems have the job to educate the elderly about alternative options, and help them to understand that these costs are not an additional expense, but a substitute for the cost of a personal automobile.

See also

edit
edit

References

edit
  1. ^ a b "Should Older Drivers Face Special Restrictions?". pew.org. 15 December 2016. Retrieved 2021-09-13.
  2. ^ "Debate Increases Over Licensing Rules for Elderly Drivers". NBC4 Washington. 13 May 2014. Retrieved 2021-09-13.
  3. ^ "Older Adult Drivers | Motor Vehicle Safety | CDC Injury Center". www.cdc.gov. 2020-12-10. Retrieved 2021-10-02.
  4. ^ a b c "WISQARS (Web-based Injury Statistics Query and Reporting System)|Injury Center|CDC". www.cdc.gov. 2020-07-01. Retrieved 2021-09-11.
  5. ^ Langford J, Methorst R, Hakamies-Blomqvist L. Older drivers do not have a high crash risk — a replication of low mileage bias. Accid. Anal. Prev. 2006; 738: 574-8.
  6. ^ Fitzgerald, Eileen (17 February 2010). "Should we be scared of senior drivers? - NewsTimes". Newstimes. newstimes.com. Retrieved 12 January 2017.
  7. ^ a b "American Medical Association | AMA". 5 July 2023.
  8. ^ Hunter, Sandra K.; Pereira, Hugo M.; Keenan, Kevin G. (2016-10-01). "The aging neuromuscular system and motor performance". Journal of Applied Physiology. 121 (4): 982–995. doi:10.1152/japplphysiol.00475.2016. ISSN 1522-1601. PMC 5142309. PMID 27516536.
  9. ^ "State Traffic Laws". Findlaw. Retrieved 2021-09-13.
  10. ^ "Aging Drivers - Getting Parents to Give Up Their Keys". axcessnews.com. January 7, 2011.
  11. ^ a b c "Elderly Driving Laws By State". Taos Injury Lawyers. 2018-11-29. Retrieved 2021-09-17.
  12. ^ "Driving in UK at the Ripe Age of 70 | Smart Learner Driving School". Archived from the original on 24 February 2015. Retrieved 12 January 2017.
  13. ^ Gursten, Steve. "Elderly Driving Resource Center". Michigan Auto Law. Retrieved 20 December 2016.
  14. ^ "Should we be scared of senior drivers? - NewsTimes". newstimes.com. 17 February 2010. Retrieved 12 January 2017.
  15. ^ Segal, Robert. "Age and Driving - HelpGuide.org". www.helpguide.org. Retrieved 2021-09-11.
  16. ^ a b Martínez‐roda, Joan A.; Vilaseca, Meritxell; Ondategui, Juan C.; Aguirre, Montserrat; Pujol, Jaume (2016-11-01). "Effects of aging on optical quality and visual function". Clinical and Experimental Optometry. 99 (6): 518–525. doi:10.1111/cxo.12369. hdl:2117/89681. ISSN 0816-4622. PMID 27452417. S2CID 41774608.
  17. ^ Owsley, Cynthia (2001-06-01). "Visual Risk Factors for Crash Involvement in Older Drivers With Cataract". Archives of Ophthalmology. 119 (6): 881–887. doi:10.1001/archopht.119.6.881. ISSN 0003-9950. PMID 11405840.
  18. ^ Liu, X. Z.; Yan, D. (2007). "Ageing and hearing loss". The Journal of Pathology. 211 (2): 188–197. doi:10.1002/path.2102. ISSN 1096-9896. PMID 17200945. S2CID 20120166.
  19. ^ Picard, Michel; Girard, Serge André; Courteau, Marilène; Leroux, Tony; Larocque, Richard; Turcotte, Fernand; Lavoie, Michel; Simard, Marc (2008-10-07). "Could Driving Safety be Compromised by Noise Exposure at Work and Noise-Induced Hearing Loss?". Traffic Injury Prevention. 9 (5): 489–499. doi:10.1080/15389580802271478. ISSN 1538-9588. PMID 18836961. S2CID 38333396.
  20. ^ Hickson, Louise; Wood, Joanne; Chaparro, Alex; Lacherez, Philippe; Marszalek, Ralph (2010). "Hearing Impairment Affects Older People's Ability to Drive in the Presence of Distracters". Journal of the American Geriatrics Society. 58 (6): 1097–1103. doi:10.1111/j.1532-5415.2010.02880.x. ISSN 1532-5415. PMID 20936734. S2CID 23986544.
  21. ^ Belsky, J. (2006). Experiencing the Lifespan. Worth Publishers. p. 436. ISBN 9780716751304. Retrieved 12 January 2017.
  22. ^ Burns, A.; Dening, T.; Lawlor, B. (2001). Clinical Guidelines in Old Age Psychiatry. Taylor & Francis. ISBN 9781841840291. Retrieved 12 January 2017.
  23. ^ Stelmach, George E.; Nahom, Ariella (1992-02-01). "Cognitive-Motor Abilities of the Elderly Driver". Human Factors. 34 (1): 53–65. doi:10.1177/001872089203400107. ISSN 0018-7208. PMID 1577503. S2CID 9810959.
  24. ^ Posner, R.A. (1997). Aging and Old Age. University of Chicago Press. p. 124. ISBN 9780226675688. Retrieved 12 January 2017.
  25. ^ "Should we be scared of senior drivers? - NewsTimes". newstimes.com. 17 February 2010. Retrieved 12 January 2017.
  26. ^ "AARP® Official Site - Join & Explore the Benefits".
  27. ^ "Caregiving, Assisted Living, Caregiver Help and Advice - AARP". aarp.org. Retrieved 12 January 2017.
  28. ^ a b "Support Is Widespread for Regular Testing of Elderly Drivers". Gallup.com. 2003-07-25. Retrieved 2021-09-18.
  29. ^ Pitta, Leonardo Santos Rocha; Quintas, Juliana Lima; Trindade, Isabela Oliveira Azevedo; Belchior, Patrícia; Gameiro, Keli da Silva Duarte; Gomes, Ciro Martins; Nóbrega, Otávio Toledo; Camargos, Einstein Francisco (2021-07-01). "Older drivers are at increased risk of fatal crash involvement: Results of a systematic review and meta-analysis". Archives of Gerontology and Geriatrics. 95: 104414. doi:10.1016/j.archger.2021.104414. ISSN 0167-4943. PMID 33845418. S2CID 233221530.
  30. ^ Tefft, Brian C. (2008-01-01). "Risks older drivers pose to themselves and to other road users". Journal of Safety Research. 39 (6): 577–582. doi:10.1016/j.jsr.2008.10.002. ISSN 0022-4375. PMID 19064042. S2CID 23151377.
  31. ^ "Older Drivers". National Institute on Aging. Retrieved 2021-09-17.
  32. ^ a b "State by State Look at Driving Rules for Older Drivers". Claims Journal. 2012-09-19. Retrieved 2021-09-17.
  33. ^ "Should we be scared of senior drivers? - NewsTimes". newstimes.com. 17 February 2010. Retrieved 12 January 2017.
  34. ^ "Driving Cessation and Health Outcomes in Older Adults". AAA Foundation. 2015-07-01. Retrieved 2021-09-18.
  35. ^ a b "Transportation Services for Seniors and the Disabled". AARP. Retrieved 2021-09-18.
  36. ^ "Older Adults & Transportation". National Aging and Disability Transportation Center. Retrieved 2021-09-18.
  37. ^ a b "Senior toolkit and best practices transportation" (PDF). Archived from the original (PDF) on 2011-06-09. Retrieved 2012-12-08.
  38. ^ "APTA a partner in older driver awareness week". Metro Magazine. 2009-12-16. Retrieved 29 July 2024.
  39. ^ Halsey, Ashley (2017-11-23). "Driverless cars promise far greater mobility for the elderly and people with disabilities". Washington Post. Retrieved 29 July 2024.
  40. ^ Siegfried, Alexa (2021-04-29). "Older Adult Willingness to Use Fully Autonomous Vehicle (FAV) Ride Sharing". Geriatrics.
  41. ^ "A Report on STPs in America" (PDF). Archived from the original (PDF) on 2013-02-18. Retrieved 2012-12-08.
  42. ^ a b c "The 5 A's of Senior-Friendly Transportation" (PDF). Archived from the original (PDF) on 2013-10-13.
Retrieved from "https://en.wikipedia.org/w/index.php?title=Old_age_and_driving&oldid=1256608678"