Politics on the Edge: A Memoir from Within is a political memoir by former Conservative Party politician and host of The Rest Is Politics podcast Rory Stewart.[1] In the United States, the book was published under the title How Not to Be a Politician: A Memoir. In the book, Stewart argues that there has been a decline in political standards in the United Kingdom.[1] The book is critical of former Conservative prime minister Boris Johnson.[2] The book discusses Stewart's 2019 Conservative Party leadership election campaign, and critiques centralized government and argues for Civil Service reform.[1][2]
 2023 cover | |
| Author | Rory Stewart |
|---|---|
| Genre | Memoir |
| Publisher | Jonathan Cape |
Publication date | 15 September 2023 |
| ISBN | 978-1787332713 |
Synopsis
editThe book comprises six parts and twenty-six chapters.[3]: 6 The first part discusses Stewart's work as a governor of an Iraqi province during its occupation and running a non-governmental organization in Kabul and then his work as a Harvard academic on human rights policy and global governance, and his decision to become a Member of Parliament (MP) in the United Kingdom.[3]: 23,28,40 It discusses his election campaign and initial experiences of the British parliament.[3]: 50 The second part discusses Stewart's work as a local member of parliament including his attempts to improve access to broadband in Cumbria and his work on select committees. [3]: 97 “Part three discusses the outcome of the Brexit referendum and the 2017 elections. Stewart observes and analyses the effects on his party and society in general of the expected effects of leaving the European Union.[3]: 145
Part four discusses Stewart's experience with Boris Johnson. Stewart describes his first meeting with Johnson and their similar educational backgrounds and working at the Foreign Office when Johnson was Foreign Secretary.[3]: 311,316 Part five discusses Stewart's role at the Ministry of Justice.[3]: 355 Part six discusses Stewart's role campaigning for Theresa May's Brexit deal,[3]: 449 its rejection by Parliament,[3]: 516 his campaign to become leader of the Conservative Party,[3]: 517 Johnson's victory, and Stewart's ejection from the Conservative Party and decision not to run as an independent candidate for MP.[3]: 603
Critical reception
editReviewing in The Guardian, Luke Harding describes the book as a "brilliant portrait of a nation in decline" and refers to Stewart as a modern James Boswell.[1] Reviewing in the political magazine The House, historian Peter Hennessy calls the book "truly absorbing" and "fascinating".[2] Reviewing in The Scotsman, Joyce McMillan says an exceptional political memoir and a pleasure to read.[4] Reviewing in the Financial Times, Gideon Rachman said the book is likely to become a classic.[5] Writing in The Atlantic, Michael Ignatieff describes the book as a brilliant and unsparing portrait of Stewarts time in politics.[6]
Hennessy says that the book is a study in pain and disillusionment.[2] Harding says that it is hard to disagree with Stewart's conclusions.[1] McMillan feels that, owing to Stewart's distrust of all forms of ideology, he fails to offer a real analysis of the causes of problems. She posits that Tory attacks on "big government" and underfunding have led to a loss of integrity within the state and a growth of corporate interests. While she says that Stewart does not offer solutions, she says he vividly and eloquently sets out problems.[4]
Cherwell reviewed the book positively and reserved especial praise for Stewart himself:
"In a Parliament and more specifically a party filled with hundreds of bleating robots, he is a free intelligence, with a rich appreciation of the arts, nature, history, tradition, and cultures. He is an anachronism, not in the cartoonish sense, but because if he were referred to as a “right honourable gentleman”, it would be a fact rather than an appellation. No other modern politician could say without irony that he believes in love of country, respect for tradition, prudence at home, and restraint abroad, or could give a speech containing the line that 'True courage is not the opposite of cowardice, but the golden mean, between cowardice and foolhardiness.' Had he been born a century and a half earlier, Stewart might have been remembered as one of the great Victorian statesmen, a Prime Minister or a Viceroy, as well as a man of letters."[7]
The book was long-listed for the 2024 Lakeland Book of the Year.[8]
References
edit- ^ a b c d e Harding, Luke (4 September 2023). "Politics on the Edge by Rory Stewart review – blistering insider portrait of a nation in decline". The Guardian. ISSN 0261-3077. Retrieved 28 October 2023.
- ^ a b c d "Ultimately a study in pain: Lord Hennessy reviews 'Politics On the Edge'". Politics Home. 12 September 2023. Retrieved 28 October 2023.
- ^ a b c d e f g h i j k Stewart, Rory (2023). Politics on the Edge: A Memoir from Within. London: Jonathan Cape. ISBN 978-1-4735-8142-5.
- ^ a b McMillan, Joyce. "Stewart, Rory". The Scotsman. Retrieved 28 October 2023.
- ^ Rachman, Gideon (11 September 2023). "Inside the corridors of power — the best new politics books". Financial Times. Retrieved 28 October 2023.
- ^ Ignatieff, Michael (7 September 2023). "Why Would Anyone Become a Politician?". The Atlantic. Retrieved 28 October 2023.
- ^ Akram, Hassan (24 July 2024). "Politics on the Edge by Rory Stewart review - "The prime minister we never had"". Cherwell. Retrieved 28 July 2024.
- ^ "Lakeland Book of the Year". www.cumbriatourism.org. Cumbria Tourism. Archived from the original on 8 May 2024. Retrieved 8 May 2024.