Antenne Brandenburg critic Tina Knop wrote that with Remember Me "Schulte masters the delicate play of quiet tones and large gestures, of power and fragility, of pop catchiness with rock and dance energy."[2] Kai Butterweck from laut.de rated the album three stars out of five and summed the album as "Sheeran pop from Northern Germany." He found that "Schulte ensures that the boundaries between melodic pop music and danceable club sounds are blurred. Thanks to his clear voice and almost accent-free English, nothing here seems forced or fake. Remember Me may not be a case for the music history books. But it's very possible that many of today's chart pop fans will still remember [it] in five or ten years."[1]Stern magazine found that with Remember Me "Schulte doesn't necessarily create a musical monument for himself, but it is at least modern, varied and easy to listen to."[3]
Remember Me debuted at number nine on the German Albums Chart in the week of 6 October 2023.[4] It marked Schulte's first top ten album as well as his highest-charting album yet.[4]